4 ms·
I think you’re talking past each other a bit. The demand you’re talking about in the SF Bay Area is not necessarily driven by ‘butts in seats’ (aka actual peop
by lazide 4y ago
I think you’re talking past each other a bit.
The demand you’re talking about in the SF Bay Area is not necessarily driven by ‘butts in seats’ (aka actual people needing a roof and willing to pay a concrete price for it), but also by the cheap money narrative the FED has been feeding for a very long time. Which is what they are referring to in their post as having changed.
- zamfi 4y agoI don’t think we are talking past each other. There is absolutely a housing supply crisis in the Bay Area that is not reflected in the national stats. I’m not sure why so many people believe that housing prices in high-demand markets are dominated by things like interest rates — there is certainly an effect, sure — but by far the predmoinant reason a 2br house on a small lot with a small yard costs $2m+ in Palo Alto is that there are thousands if not tens of thousands of well-off workers for nearby tech companies who would like to live there, there is not enough housing to go around, and $2m is the market clearing price. The idea that the “demand” is being “driven” by some “cheap money narrative” is missing the forest for the trees. Low interest rates might be why that house is $2m and not $1.8m. But the narrative is definitely not the reason the median home price across the Bay Area is many multiples higher than the national average of $350k. That’s pure supply and demand.
- adam_arthur 4y agoFirstly, I'm talking nationally. Secondly, the Bay Area is one of the markets subject to some of the more severe headwinds if remote work becomes the new normal, for the reasons you stated. SF population declined ~7% over the past two years. https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/San-Francisco-population-decline-us-census-data-17203868.php https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/San-Francisco-populat... The concept of being forced to live in a hyper local area for work may be a thing of the past, which doesn't bode well for employment driven locales. NYC being another example. Bay area is one of the last places in the country I'd want to own a home right now
- vostok 4y agoDensity still has huge benefits unrelated to work. I don't know much about SF as I haven't lived there as an adult, but New York is an incredible place to live for lifestyle reasons too. It has great food, a very high concentration of smart and highly educated people, great museums, great performance arts, etc. It's also an incredibly walkable city, which is rare in the US. Hands down it would be my choice of city if I was a remote worker.
- adam_arthur 4y agoPrice is defined on the margin. Lack of forced demand from local workers will drive prices down, unless the leisure aspect of the locale outweighs the work aspect. It's subject to debate which locales would stand to net gain/lose from WFH, but I'd pick NYC as a net loser. You gain some who enjoy the city life and amenities, but you lose more to lower COL locales. Price will always be a factor weighed alongside amenities, even if one area is objectively nicer from an amenities perspective
- lazide 4y agoSF only has one thing going for it really - weather. Everything else pales compared to NYC.
- davidgay 4y ago> SF only has one thing going for it really - weather. This is far from an universal view - I live there (well, East Bay) and I think the weather isn't that great: too cold in summer, no nice evenings, never nice to hang out by the water. And I like cold winters as a contrast. October to December are nicer though.
- lazide 4y agoCompared to NYC?
- confidantlake 4y agoSF has better hills.
- lazide 4y ago‘Demand’ includes availability of funds by potential buyers (and what they consider expensive) which is directly influenced by stock prices (which have seen major drops this year), and by interest rates. The amount that can be loaned/supported by a given income, and hence a lot of underwriting standards, are based indirectly on the cost to service the loan relative to the income the person has. The lower the interest rate; the bigger the loan someone can get if they shop around for the same income and assets. This isn’t perfectly linear, as principal payments vs interest payments have different ratios based on interest rates, but it very much applies.
- zamfi 4y agoYes of course demand is influenced by all these things. But it’s driven by people moving to a location and wanting to buy homes. The market clearing price is also driven by these things. But let’s be clear: the primary driver of sky-high prices in the Bay Area is (1) people moving here, getting well-paying tech jobs, and wanting to buy housing, and (2) not nearly enough new construction to meet that demand.
- lazide 4y agoIf the fed continues on it’s current course, I guess we’ll find out over the next few years huh?
- zamfi 4y agoI wish -- but I suspect we won't, sadly, because many factors are at play, including the move to remote work for many, many tech companies. If we see both higher interest rates and dramatic drops in demand, then everyone will be able to spin their own story out of it.
- lazide 4y agoEh, the demand shifted to more rural areas with the remote work shift, so nation wide the trend didn’t change much. See the Case-Schiller index [https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CSUSHPINSA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CSUSHPINSA] Changes in interest rates will be quite visible there, unless millions of people get ‘snapped’ and their houses remain intact anyway.
- imtringued 4y agoLow interest rates only amplify existing demand letting people borrow more principal for the same monthly payment but people are still competing over who can afford the highest monthly payment.