4 ms·
It seems like the basic trick here is setting boundaries. It’s broader than EA, but some formulations of EA (and utilitarianism in general) seem to advocate for
by skybrian 4y ago
It seems like the basic trick here is setting boundaries. It’s broader than EA, but some formulations of EA (and utilitarianism in general) seem to advocate for not setting boundaries; consider Pete Singer’s drowning child thought experiment and how he advocates for treating everyone in the world as having an equal claim on your time and money.
I think that practically speaking, setting boundaries is important and a philosophy that doesn’t take that into account is a bad philosophy. Real world organizations set boundaries all the time; that’s what budgeting is.
But boundaries still seem philosophically suspect due to their arbitrariness: why give 10%, say, and not some other number? Does someone have a philosophical answer for people struggling with this?
- berrytj 4y agothe characteristics of evolved human brains make not setting boundaries suboptimal. it's the same reason you "pace yourself" when running a race. better hardware would enable a more aggressive approach but we have to work with what we've got.
- manwe150 4y agoMy counter-argument question is: why would sending 10% of your income to the other side of the world be a better use of that money than giving your dinner server a 10% higher tip (or other arbitrary numbers)? Both improve the quality of someone else life. Both reduce your own spending power by equal amounts. But money also isn't some static thing that disappears when you spend it. Is is a medium for representing the continuous exchange of work (net of losses due to taxes). This is what "The Wealth of Nations" and others around the time of Adam Smith started to teach, creating the modern field of economics, and the basis for describing capitalism. The article here seemed to mention being comfortable with the number being what was important, perhaps more so than the exact value of the number, or its arbitrariness? Perhaps then the only losing move is not to play? So, even savings are good, since you are giving someone else access to your money, but completely removing yourself from society as a miser or hermit is expected to be a negative for society, since you are depriving others of your talents.
- hiq 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism#Cost-effectiveness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism#Cost-effect...
- skybrian 4y agoThe cost to yourself is the same. However, the benefit to others varies drastically. I think EA is on firmer ground when the boundary has already been set. Let's say you have $10,000 that you've already decided goes to charity. (Suppose it's in a donor-advised fund.) What is the best way to spend it? EA says that it matters how you spend it, that you should try do at least as good job at this as you do choosing an investment when you invest your savings, that it's a hard problem, and that there should be charity advisers to help you make a good decision.
- ineedasername 4y ago>net of losses due to taxes It doesn't stop working then. It's still spent on things that put people to work.
- mcculley 4y agoIt is not a zero-sum game. Some money spent on labor adds more jobs than others. For example, if I employ people building a road to nowhere, I have only employed the builders. If I build a road that is needed, more economic opportunities are unlocked.
- imtringued 4y agoThe assumption of EA is that you strive for extra income to donate it. If we simply assume that you only maximize income for your own well being then spending your money will also improve the wellbeing of others. The only thing that wouldn't improve it is to keep money in your bank account, forcing other people to wait for you to spend it.
- pjscott 4y agoThe reason for 10% is because (a) tithing isn't that hard on most people's finances and (b) it's a nice round number, memetically strong and aesthetically satisfying. Sure, it's arbitrary -- but it's arbitrary in a way that was designed to appeal to as many people as possible without making them feel like they have a moral obligation to make arbitrarily large sacrifices. That's it. There's no broader philosophical reason for why 10% is Objectively Correct. This is driven entirely by practicality. (If we had twelve fingers, the number would probably be 12%.)
- skybrian 4y agoYes, I'm well aware. I agree that it's arbitrary, and it doesn't bother me much. The problem is that this argument doesn't seem likely to succeed if you're talking to someone who is especially interested in philosophical or moral consistency. The arbitrariness of the boundary will bother them.
- a1369209993 4y ago> (If we had twelve fingers, the number would probably be 12%.) Actually, it would be 8.33̅% - ie 10/100 in base 12, or 12/144.
- pjscott 4y agoAh, of course. Thank you, kind emissary from Twelve-Fingered Alternate Earth.
- a1369209993 4y agoActually, I use hexadecimal (or occasionally 6, 60, or 5040 for the factors) - for me it would be 10% => 6.25% (1/10 => 1/16).
- Aicy 4y agoNot quite because if we had 12 fingers we would most likely use base 12.
- Imnimo 4y agoIt sort of seems like if you have to set hand-wavy boundaries to avoid making EA unworkable, maybe it's not that sound of a philosophy after all.
- skybrian 4y agoI think it's a broader question than that. What moral philosophies set boundaries? How do they justify them? Can you live with that? So here's a clear boundary: thou shalt not kill. But do you think the Ukrainians fighting the invasion by killing Russians are wrong? There seem to be boundaries in all moral philosophies, some more arbitrary than others.