4 ms·
I do not understand the purpose of AWS style cloud platforms. What's wrong with Hetzner or Contabo? What is the advantage of paying 270€ per month for a 60GB RA
by imtringued 4y ago
I do not understand the purpose of AWS style cloud platforms. What's wrong with Hetzner or Contabo? What is the advantage of paying 270€ per month for a 60GB RAM instance with 8 cores if you can get the same instance on Contabo for 27€?
It really feels like these cloud platforms are following the Microtransaction model of mobile games.
- jstummbillig 4y agoScalability and in code provisioning
- seydor 4y agowhich for most people is, the aspiration that they might need scalability
- oblio 4y agoOr just the peace of mind of being able to fully recreate infrastructure easily, if need be. Code, you know, version control, diffs, CI/CD pipelines, inherent live "documentation" (up to a point, of course you won't know the "why", but you'll know most of the "how" and "what", git offering the "who").
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tluyben2 4y agoBut at what price… I have said it here many times, but I am a nobody so I can repeat it; one of my weekend side businesses is optimising overall performance for companies. They contact me with something like ‘I am paying 50k$/mo for aws and out app still goes down with traffic’. The case I did today one month ago was doing 10k/mo on aws and that jumps up mentally with traffic. This is a SaaS site and startup and they are bootstrapped. I moved all over to docker compose and then to a $10/mo vps; it didn’t crash and burn and now they make profit. This is not apples to apples; they made a complete shitshow on aws and in their code and their db (on rds). So I fixed some things and moved it over. On aws this improved setup would still be 10x or more expensive. It is very visible that most startup owners never saw a crisis now; this took me 12 hours… so that’s about 2k$ cost for me for a $9990 saving per month.
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoHow much of the cost discrepancy was due to issues inherent with AWS, versus extremely poor engineering on the part of the startup? As a trivial example, I too can rack up a massive cloud bill by provisioning a 128 core VM for a web app that only sees a few thousand hits per day. But the massive bill isn’t the fault of the cloud provider; it’s the fault of my own bad engineering choices.
- tluyben2 4y agoYes, I agree, hence I said not apples to apples, but like said, the same exact vps costs over 10x as much on aws. That’s not good. I encounter 10-10000x higher bills on aws ; most 0s are self inflicted but the last few 0s I don’t think you can erase in the same way with aws vs a good vps provider.
- echelon 4y agoIs Hetzner 10x cheaper on GPU costs too? I recently discovered our logging was costing $3,000/mo at GCP. For freaking logs.
- emj 4y agoWe pay more, what we pay for is making it easily available to a lot more people than before. That is actually cheap for what you get, but if you do not get anything extra besides a text dump it's expensive
- oblio 4y agoWhat kind of volume of logs were you generating, too? And was there some sort of processing thing running on those logs? You'd have to pay for that compute.
- echelon 4y agoLots of logspam volume that I'm immediately going to tamp down. But it's also got me thinking I'm going to buy a bunch of GPUs this month and stand up our own ML compute cluster. We'll still run CRUD in the cloud, but I'm getting sick of paying for cloud GPUs. The GKE / GPU interface leaves tons of spare compute on the table anyway.
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoThe advantage is rapid burst scaling. Some businesses have workloads that only require a handful of small servers for most of the year, but for short periods of time require hundreds or even thousands of servers to process sudden workload bursts. Some examples: * e-commerce sites around holidays; ticketing sites right before popular events * internet fora that get sudden influxes of traffic (e.g. Reddit) * scientific computing projects that occasionally require huge batch jobs using (hundreds of) thousands of cores [0] You are correct that for the majority of businesses, whose workload requirements minimally and predictably fluctuate, cloud providers are a rip off. But for the few use cases actually requiring massive transient scaling, there is no viable alternative. [0] https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/gcp/220000-cores-and-counting-mit-math-professor-breaks-record-for-largest-ever-compute-engine-job https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/gcp/220000-cores-and-...
- mkl95 4y agoGet away with bad code and gargantuan queries for 2-3 years by scaling vertically. Blame your monolith and the engineers that built it when scaling vertically can't mitigate tech debt anymore, and rearchitect to microservices to "fix it". Collect tax deductions and executive bonuses in the process (the journey is more important than the destination)
- 8organicbits 4y agoThe finances work out in a couple ways. First, developers are expensive so productivity improvements on the cloud saves money and speeds delivery. Managed services (storage, queue, email, database) can have great productivity gains. This is also faster delivery or smaller team sizes. Why hire a sysadmin, db admin, etc when AWS has managed services that remove (or reduce) the need for those roles. Keep your headcount low and move fast. The math is different for different companies, workloads, etc.
- cube2222 4y agoIf all you need is Virtual Machines, stay with such a cheaper platform, that's not what you're getting AWS (or the other big ones) for. You get them for the myriad of other managed services they provide, which let you build stuff that would otherwise take months, in days. The catalogue of AWS services is probably over 200 already, EC2 is just one of them. Building on a cloud like that is much more "gluing together legos using Terraform and some code" than the alternative. Configuring and maintaining open source solutions is a lot of work. Building everything yourself is too. I prefer to pay for AWS instead.
- ByteJockey 4y ago> What is the advantage of paying 270€ per month for a 60GB RAM instance with 8 cores if you can get the same instance on Contabo for 27€? For some random raw EC2 server? Zilch. Zero. EC2 isn't really worth it by itself. But EC2 isn't the only thing AWS has. Devs are pretty expensive. If you just need to run some random code in the cloud, futzing with a server somewhere for a couple hours making sure it's compliant with all of the enterprise standards costs many hundreds of dollars in dev pay. Lambda just works, and has a free tier. Setting up a proper queuing system is annoying and takes a few hours to do right. That's another couple hundred dollars. SQS is reasonably good and you can have that dev go do other things instead. These things start to add up fast, and when you do everything yourself, you start to end up with thousands of dollars per month in maintenance costs. You can absolutely do that with AWS as well, but the goal is usually to just let AWS take care of that and have your employees do something that's actually valuable to the business (usually implementing proprietary business logic, which neither AWS nor Hetzner will do for you).
- xboxnolifes 4y agoYou honestly can't think AWS is just EC2, right?