7 ms·
I'm Bangladeshi, rather than Indian, so I'm watching this from the sidelines. That being said, I'm of the opinion that activists suck up all the oxygen when it
by rayiner 4y ago
I'm Bangladeshi, rather than Indian, so I'm watching this from the sidelines. That being said, I'm of the opinion that activists suck up all the oxygen when it comes to discussions of race in the U.S. A Pew poll a few years ago noted that 90% of Indian Americans think discrimination against Indian Americans in America is a "minor problem" or "no problem at all": https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2013/09/16/miss-america-pageant-puts-indian-americans-in-the-spotlight https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2013/09/16/miss-americ.... But the 10% that think it's a big problem get the biggest platforms.
In reality, it's probably impossible to understand how big or small a problem caste discrimination really is in context. The folks who don't face any negative experiences mostly aren't going to pipe up.
- kajecounterhack 4y ago> the 10% that think it's a big problem get the biggest platforms. Don't you think this might have something to do with the representation of low caste Indians in the US, and that they have to be their own advocates? Minorities have to make disproportional noise to get issues that affect them to be heard to the same degree as others. That's just how it is, otherwise our systems would always only advocate for the majority and every single minority would group would be systemically disadvantaged.
- newsclues 4y ago
- jamiek88 4y agoThis is not engaging seriously with OP, the argument or indeed this forum.
- kajecounterhack 4y agoWay to paint with a broad brush. So every climate activist is a bitter loser? Would you consider Martin Luther King Jr. to be a bitter loser?
- thghtihadanacct 4y ago...and how is it we americans accept low/minority caste indians ( i am guessing we are talking about citizens from India as opposed to indigenous)? I am in tech on the west coast and wouldnt know the difference. From my perspective Indian migrants from india are indian. I know no castes. This is subjugation they have brought with them and I am not privy or party to. I also have no ability to fight or side with it since I DO NOT see it ... cuz I have no idea. I think to side with your point ... the vocal extremists have the mic.
- baruch 4y agoFrom what I read so far the discrimination is not wasps but rather by other Indians. So no one is saying you are discriminating one care or another but that such discrimination exists even if you don't see it.
- thghtihadanacct 4y agoI hear ya ... and I am not excusing it since im blinded and immune to it. I am saying tho, that it also isnt enforced here anymore than sharia law or the jewish or other hindu/religious law. It will never hold up in court. I feel strongly (im always open to being wrong) that part of coming here (USoA) is freeing yourself of those burdens (we got our own problems that you gotta deal with now). I dont burden myself with that knowledge as I find it useless. If someone drags it here with them they need to understand its their baggage.
- baruch 4y agoI have no beef in this, I'm not living in the US and not Indian or south Asian. The thing that is the issue, again from the little I read, is that such discrimination is brought by other Indians on the Dalit and it's most defyingly bit something they want imported. I didn't figure or yet what is wanted and how but it's not like this is sintering you can blame them for.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nostrademons 4y agoThere's a collectivist, political, external-locus-of-control assumption to your point. Not everybody thinks of the world in those terms. A lot of minorities are too busy making money to worry about representation or group rights. You can make a lot of noise, or you can spend that time developing skills and a track record that will get people to pay you a lot of money. A lot of industries are based on the idea of "I don't care if people think they're superior to me as long as they pay me." The savvier ones even exploit this: "I'll get people to think they're superior to others because they pay me" (see: Apple, Rolls Royce, DeBeers, BMW, Louis Vitton, and every other luxury brand). American society is uniquely suited to this sort of mercenary economic climbing, because it brings together lots of people who have no knowledge of each others' previous social hierarchies anyway.
- kajecounterhack 4y ago> A lot of minorities are too busy making money to worry about representation or group rights. You can make a lot of noise, or you can spend that time developing skills and a track record that will get people to pay you a lot of money. Por que no los dos? This is such a tired take -- how is activism at odds with getting good at what you do and working hard? You can absolutely do both. In fact, some of the most helpful activists are folks who made it and give a helping hand to others (e.g. successful black businessmen teaching other black folks to be successful businessmen; successful women in tech helping other women to succeed in tech). You do realize that this very "capitalism as the great equalizer" take ignores that being underrepresented / disadvantaged also very negatively affects one's economic prospects. Say I'm a woman -- looking at that rare woman in tech who's overcome many sexist hurdles / gotten lucky enough to make it to the top, are you telling me I should be cool with my odds being shittier? White folks already love yelling about affirmative action because it lowers your already-low odds so very slightly when it comes to Ivy League college admittance. But you'll tell minorities "shut up just work hard activism is stupid" in the same breath. > There's a collectivist, political, external-locus-of-control assumption to your point. First of all, minorities ARE collectives even if we don't all contribute equally to our collective causes. And representation is political because policy shapes how we are treated and what our lives look like. A democracy by design favors the majority, so minorities need to be politically convincing that their needs are important too. It's okay to work hard at this, it's okay to want the world to be more meritocratic. Frederick Douglass could have lived as a free black person and had a much better life than other black folks in the US. There were other free blacks who did less for the collective. Instead, he gave a crap about activism, and used his education and ability to make a difference. Wasn't that great? Plenty of white folks running plantations at the time were inconvenienced by this guy saying black folks should be free and that slavery is bad, and I'm sure they said "you're free why do you give a damn." But some people do give a damn about the people around them and the world they hand to their progeny. Not every activist is their minority's Frederick Douglass, but you can certainly be a point along that spectrum of activist, in accordance with your ability and concern. Saying that minorities should be "too busy making money" to give a crap about how their children will be treated is some hot garbage. > American society is uniquely suited to this sort of mercenary economic climbing, because it brings together lots of people who have no knowledge of each others' previous social hierarchies anyway. Guess I won't convince you of the many glass/bamboo/whatever the fuck ceilings that exist, but it seems obvious that people are _absolutely_ bringing knowledge of previous social hierarchies. Talk to some {black folks, women} in tech and see what kind of bullshit they have to put up with that you don't have to. How many female founder stories can you find that talk about counterparts assuming something due to their gender? You simply cannot escape social prejudice and hierarchy (oh wait, you can, if you're a white male! maybe this is why you're confused).
- rayiner 4y agoMy point is more about the notion that the activists represent the views of the minority group. With respect to Indians, you have two levels: Indians as minorities with respect to Americans, and lower castes as minorities with respect to other Indians. At the first level, the Indians who say there’s lots of discrimination against Indians—the folks getting Apu cancelled—get a lot of air time, but aren’t representative. My point is that the same thing may apply to low caste Indians too. The views of this Dalit activist may or may reflect the experience of low caste Indian Americans.
- kelnos 4y ago> My point is more about the notion that the activists represent the views of the minority group. But aren't often those the people who need that sort of representation the most? Even if 90%[0] of Indians aren't discriminated against, the 10% who suffer discrimination absolutely deserve representation and redress. [0] Apparently 90% of Indian immigrants in the US are high-caste, so funny how that statistic might seem to line up. This of course makes sense, since low-caste people are probably less likely to be able to obtain the education and financial resources necessary to move to a different country.
- rayiner 4y ago> But aren't often those the people who need that sort of representation the most? When you engage in activism on behalf of $GROUP you’re affecting the relationship of everyone in the group with the larger society.
- kajecounterhack 4y agoWorking as intended. Consider PETA vs the Humane Society. One is hated, the other is not. Does PETA not have a right to exist? Their distasteful antics didn't change the relationship between me and the Humane Society though they both advocate for animal welfare. On the other hand, if you are successful at being convincing (and loud enough) for a minority community you can achieve a lot of good! LGBTQ+ activists have made the lives of young non-binary folks so much better in just the last 30 years: they are a minority, but they were loud and convincing that "maybe we should treat people equally (e.g. right to marry) even if their sexual proclivities are different from our own!" Groups that really change the shape of society ultimately have to be loud if they're underrepresented, and make a lot of people uncomfortable. Frederick Douglass was a free black man, which was rare for the time. He used his very minority voice to make a racket that helped propel centuries of social change for the better. Would you prefer he didn't succeed / couldn't have a platform? It's still up to loud minority communities to actually be convincing, after all. All the hate campaigning like those "god hates fags" stuff won't ever get anywhere because it's not convincing to most people.
- mkr-hn 4y agoI would be interested to see a caste breakdown of that poll, and a more recent poll. Nine years is an eternity in tech. One specific to tech workers would help too.
- rfrey 4y agoAccording to Wikipedia, 1.5% of Indian immigrants to the USA are Dalit. 90% are the high castes. That is interesting coincidence to your quoted statistic of 90% thinking this is a minor problem or no problem at all.
- derevaunseraun 4y agothat might be because some Dalits choose not to identify as such, could be a bit more
- paxys 4y agoIs it really surprising that the poor and marginalized section of society in India isn't the one getting fancy degrees and immigrating to the USA for tech jobs?
- pcthrowaway 4y agoI'd argue that if a higher-than-reported percentage of Indian immigrants are Dalit, that supports the idea that there's a problem.
- javajosh 4y agoHow is that information gleened? I can't imagine immigration asking "what caste are you?"
- bgdam 4y agoIn a lot of cases you don't need to ask "what caste are you", you just need to ask "what's your name". For a vast majority of Indians their last name gives away their caste.
- crooked-v 4y agoCastes come with plenty of cultural baggage, and the metaphorical 'secret handshakes' shared by people of higher castes can be used to suss out those of a lower caste even if the person of interest is trying to hide their background.
- 4y ago
- honkler 4y ago> 90% of Indian Americans think discrimination against Indian Americans in America is a "minor problem" Ofcourse they would. They are mostly those whose parents (or themselves) were privileged enough to make it to the US.
- throwawayricha 4y agoThose days are long gone. Now, anyone can come to US. Some states in India (Telangana) give you money to study abroad, knowing fully well that those kids emigrate.
- rajup 4y ago> Ofcourse they would. They are mostly those whose parents (or themselves) were privileged enough to make it to the US. I keep seeing this thrown around, but I am yet to see anyone respond exactly what form this "privilege" takes as it pertains to caste. The Indian constitution was co-written by a very forward thinking Dalit and affirmative action for lower castes is literally written into the Indian constitution. The only "privilege" I know of is that only upper castes can conduct priestly duties etc (at least used to), but I mean cmon that's just clutching at straws...
- kajecounterhack 4y agoPrivilege is the concept that being born into your social standing, race, gender, etc may confer subtle (and not-so-subtle) benefits. Affirmative action does not solve discrimination toward Dalits, it's one of many reactions & mitigations to it. Even if you have affirmative action, if you feel like you're going to work or school in a hostile environment, this is a disadvantage to you. Psychological safety is one example of a privilege (e.g. women in silicon valley have inherently less psychological safety than men in the workplace because there are more men, and enough of them make unwanted advances with high enough frequency to force them to think about it). Dalits have to deal with the stress of potentially being treated differently on the basis of their caste. Even if laws say "you can't discriminate," that doesn't change the interactions they have to have. And even if only a small number (let's say 1%) of people are discriminatory, but you go to a school with 300 people, you're now dealing with 3 folks who you're very uncomfortable around and may bully or hurt you. That's still going to suck. Privilege is not having to think about any of that. Another example is being gay. You might say "well if you're gay and you live in SF, you are worry free!" But at work, school, or even at the grocery store there could be people who harbor discriminatory feelings and even unconcious biases against you, and it can affect how they treat you. If you're straight, you're lucky (privileged) not to have to deal with that. You also are lucky (privileged) that you can visit Alabama without fearing for your life. I mean, unless you're a straight black man and you encounter police in Alabama. Again, your expectations given that situation are a matter of privilege. The reason folks harp on privilege so much is that privileged folks often say stuff like "X doesn't happen to me or in my proximity, so it doesn't happen ever." But the only way to know it _really_ doesn't happen is to exist as someone who lacks those privileges and to see what that's like. Since we can't do that, everyone argues about the validity of minority folks sharing their personal experiences. There are also levels to it, as with anything. Within minority groups, there can be folks who have more relative privilege (e.g. black men vs black women, or dalits vs brahmins, or dark skinned vs light skinned black folks). Most people have some privileges relative to other people, so it's good for us to all understand what those things are when we interact with one another. We already do some amount of this very naturally (e.g. unless you're an asshole, you probably won't tell your poor friend to just buy better clothes if you know they are less privileged than you, and you might not expect your female friend to walk to your place through the city at night).
- cmeacham98 4y agoThis is super misleading/wrong. First of all, that poll is about discrimination against Indian-Americans (presumably based on race or ethnicity), while TFA is about caste-based discrimination. Secondly, the option below "major problem" in that poll is "minor problem", there is no in-between. In other words, 90% or Indian-Americans think it isn't a major problem, but over half do think there is a problem. Most importantly, polling opinions about this is the worst method of determining if discrimination exists. A better method would look at objective measures like salary/job/hiring rate/layoff rate/etc of lower-caste Indians compared to Indians as a whole.
- thghtihadanacct 4y agowhats TFA? edit --> ... thank you all for the info ... i guess i learned today?
- seoaeu 4y agoThe "Fine" Article
- djbusby 4y agoThe Fantastic Article
- javajosh 4y agoA poor substitute for "OP" - original poster.
- panda88888 4y agoEveryone’s being so diplomatic :) … it’s The Fxxxing Article…
- thghtihadanacct 4y agoahhh, gotcha. that really went over my head
- 4y ago
- fastaguy88 4y agoIf it turns out that 90% of (you name the group) are not discriminated against, but 10% are, does that mean that we should ignore that discrimination? Almost by definition, minorities are the generally the ones who are discriminated against. This the discrimination problem -- if you are not in the minority, it is much more difficult to appreciate how common it is.
- kelnos 4y agoThis is the thing I find super weird about a lot of the comments in this thread. In the vast majority of cases, it's the majority discriminating against the minority, often a very small minority. (Which makes sense; I mean, most minority groups don't have the clout to discriminate against members of the majority. Sure, it happens [c.f. apartheid in South Africa], but it's not the common case.) And yet somehow that makes it not worthy of awareness and fixing? It's a very odd argument to make.
- belltaco 4y agoBecause the stats have been completely misinterpreted in the thread by all the commenters. Kind of like the work visa vs green card legal requirements mass confusion on HN(and all the other tech forums) whenever H1B is discussed. No one is making that "odd argument". rayiner's comment about 90% of Indian-Americans not thinking discrimination is a big problem is about perceived racism from non-Indian Americans. If you read the link it's about racist Twitter posts about an Indian American by what looks like white folks. No mention of caste. Nothing about internal casteism in the Indian community. I say this as a HN'er but sorry HN can be just dumb sometimes.
- usrn 4y agoThe political commentary on HN makes way more sense when you realize probably half the posters are Indian.
- rayiner 4y ago> If it turns out that 90% of (you name the group) are not discriminated against, but 10% are, does that mean that we should ignore that discrimination? At the very least, it might mean you don’t bring in an activist that antagonizes members of the majority group, as was allegedly the case here. Activism undertaken on behalf of a minority group affects the relationship between that minority group and society as a whole. All members of the group have a stake in the overall relationship between the group and other groups.
- quantified 4y agoAcross the whole USA, discrimination against any minority isn't a problem for the majority who aren't that minority. So what kind of platform should that minority not get?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway879080 4y ago
- gumby 4y ago> A Pew poll a few years ago noted that 90% of Indian Americans think discrimination against Indian Americans in America is a "minor problem" or "no problem at all" It’s all relative. My mum (in her 80s) is, as they say, “quite fair”. She’s lived in Boston for decades and when I was visiting a couple of weeks ago I could see she was still subject to the usual Boston racism. But I noticed it was mostly older people — ppl my age (50s) or younger were a lot better, and not just because they don’t notice older people. I got a lot of appearance genes from my white dad so this issue doesn’t come up for me. Where I live in Palo Alto the kids I interact with don’t appear to care at all and seem to mix pretty indiscriminately, which is great.
- rayiner 4y agoWhat is “the usual Boston racism?”
- gumby 4y agoHave you ever lived there? (I went to high school in Boston and university in Cambridge). Of all the places I've lived in the USA (Massachusetts, NY, Texas, California) Massachusetts was by far the most overtly unashamedly racist, with certain Boston neighborhoods particularly bad. I was just visiting a few weeks ago and a couple of my friends told me "it's not as bad as it used to be" but when I asked, admitted it hadn't improved that much from the late 70s/early 80s that we remembered. Just a casual example: my mum entered her retirement home with some groceries, using her own electronic key, and was told "deliveries are to be made through the service entrance." This to a woman who has been living there for years and whom the "diversity board" keeps trying to recruit (as it's always been 100% white people). This attitude is deeply rooted. Remember, though Massachusetts was famously abolitionist, its immense wealth started out from funding slave voyages and slave mortgages. And of course the Bay Colony was founded by a shipload of notoriously intolerant people.