15 ms·
Tesla’s ‘phantom braking’ problem is getting worse
- TrevorJ 4y agoHow much better than a human driver does a self-driving system need to be before we as a society will accept fully autonomous vehicles? That seems like the key question which we are spending very little effort trying to understand. Until we have a national conversation about this, I suspect self-driving will be an intractable problem.
- kube-system 4y agoA human driver is no longer the null hypothesis they have to beat. Most vehicles in the US are now sold with collision avoidance systems. The alternative to an autonomous vehicle is a vehicle with the combined efforts of humans + automated systems. Also, until there's a SAE level 5 vehicle in existence, we're comparing different sample sets. The situations humans crash most often in are many of the same situations where current autonomous vehicles simply won't operate at all. We may see these sample sets get even more skewed as we partially automate driving in levels 3 and 4. Because humans will have to drive in the more demanding scenarios where automated systems refuse to do so.
- TrevorJ 4y agoWhat I'm 'driving at' (hehe) here is that there's a lot of daylight between what the math says, and what people are likely to accept. We are, for better or worse, somewhat comfortable with the fact that a human driven semi truck will occasionally wipe out a minivan. It's not clear to me at all that we as a society are, or will ever be comfortable with a computer-operated semi-truck doing the same. No amount of "Well, the number say this truck is statistically safer when driven by a computer..." will move the needle on that, IMO.
- kube-system 4y agoWell, there are different failure modes that we care about too. People think about first-party losses much differently than third-party losses. And, people currently take actions to mitigate those losses. Preventable crashes can be avoidable, by avoiding the situations in which humans engage in dangerous behavior. And the factor of control is why people are more comfortable with that failure mode, than a failure mode which may be more unpredictable. For instance: If I'm worried about killing my child in a first-party drunk driving crash, the average crash rate is irrelevant, because I can decrease the risk to zero by not drinking and driving. If I'm worried about third-party risk of a drunk driving crash, I can greatly mitigate that risk by choosing when and where I drive with my child in the car. > No amount of "Well, the number say this truck is statistically safer when driven by a computer..." will move the needle on that And I think the reason for that is that people subconsciously understand that the people who would be interested in (or financially capable of) purchasing an autonomous vehicle for the safety features are the same people who have lower accident rates than average.
- Brendinooo 4y agoNah, I think it’s more that people like to be in control. Planes are safer than cars, but plenty of people are afraid of flying. Maybe there’s something psychological about going hundreds of miles per hour thousands of feet in the air, but what I usually hear as the reason is that people don’t like that they’re not in control of the systems. (Also that media plays up plane crashes, but that would almost certainly be true of autonomous crashes as well.)
- kube-system 4y agoThat's what I meant by > the factor of control is why people are more comfortable with that failure mode, than a failure mode which may be more unpredictable. There are situations in which control mitigates risk, and there are situations in which it doesn't. While the average crash rate is relevant to public health, it's really irrelevant to someone who is dead.
- CoastalCoder 4y ago> Until we have a national conversation about this, I suspect self-driving will be an intractable problem. I hate to be a pessimist, but I'm not sure "national conversations" are all that useful in the U.S. Consider the "national conversation" leading up to Obamacare. NPR (at least) reported on the known pros/cons of various national healthcare systems around the world. AFAIK some of them were simply better than what we had, regardless of whether one looked at them through a conservative or liberal lens. And yet we still ended up with a system that was only marginally better IMHO.
- beebmam 4y agoFor the ACA, whether it's better for you or worse for you depends on what income bracket you're in, whether you have preexisting conditions, and what kind of health care your job previously offered. Whether it's better or worse for the country is a complicated question that I don't have an answer to, and no one does. Because it's a nuanced answer, if you're being serious about quantifying "better". Unfortunately most people, across both political factions in the US, would rather adhere to their ideologies than think critically about things in this era.
- TrevorJ 4y agoI think it's easy to be biased towards agreeing with your point here because failures are much more visible in this realm than the successes. There's a whole host of things that we've 'worked out' on a national level. Schools, National Parks, Interstate Highway Systems, Fire Departments. All these things either didn't exist, or took hugely different forms only a couple generations ago, and now they are almost entirely accepted in their present form. We just don't think much about it now because this stuff is so accepted, even though at one point it was a whole big complicated thing that needed to get worked out and agreed on.
- robonerd 4y agoBeating the national average never should have been seen as the finish line. The average is dragged down into the gutter by a minority of drivers who choose to engage in very poor behavior, like driving drunk, speeding, making unnecessary trips at night and bad weather, street racing, etc. By simply avoiding these few behaviors, it's easy to put yourself well above the average. (inb4 "everybody thinks they're better than the average"; most people who think this are correct. Bad driving doesn't have a normal distribution.) If you want to impose self-driving on everybody, it should be at least as good as the best drivers. It would be a grave injustice to force it on the best drivers if it can't match their performance. As for the bar to pass for simply allowing, not mandating, self driving: I think they should first exceed the skill of a student driver. If they can't then they don't belong on the road without supervision, just like a student driver.
- dkarl 4y ago> If you want to impose self-driving on everybody, it should be at least as good as the best drivers. I would gladly have self-driving imposed on me if it were also imposed on drunks, teenagers, and the elderly. Sounds like a great trade-off.
- kube-system 4y agoYou can see this in actuarial data that the IIHS posts. Often, cars that perform comparably in crash tests have wildly different real world loss rates. The difference is likely explainable by differences in driver behavior. For example, look at any car also sold under a hybrid trim model, the hybrid almost always has lower rates of injury. For an identical chassis. Or, consider the brands that have good crash test rating, but target subprime buyers.... in comparison to brands that have similar crash performance but target higher incomes and/or higher credit profiles. Nissan and Kia vehicles often have good crash test ratings, but they consistently have bad real-world crash data. https://www.iihs.org/ratings/insurance-losses-by-make-and-model https://www.iihs.org/ratings/insurance-losses-by-make-and-mo...
- alphabettsy 4y agoI noticed the same thing. It seems pretty reasonable that the kind of person who drives a 350hp Volvo hybrid wagon is most often not the same kind of person who drives a 350hp Mustang.
- polytely 4y agoIt also isn't a problem that's binary, I think we could very easily end up in a situation where the AI is a better driver 99% of the time but will occasionally cause an easily preventable accident. Who will be liable once your self-driving car runs over a kid because it mistook them for road markings? I have the feeling that people are going to be more OK with explainable human accidents than unexplainable AI accidents.
- TrevorJ 4y agoI agree with this 100%. To compound this issue is the fact that when I, as a person, make a mistake on the road, the problem space is limited to me. When a self driving car makes a mistake, every other vehicle on the road running that software/hardware is implicated as well. Imagine having to decide if all humans should have their license suspended until root cause analysis can be completed every single time a human is involved in a car crash. That is the problem we will need to grapple with when it comes to self driving cars.
- kodah 4y agoPersonally, I'm kind of done having "national conversations", I don't think having all these fruitful perspectives has really driven us anywhere but mad. The people at the NHTSA need to be non-appointed SME's that heavily prioritize safety and balance efficiency and innovation below the safety threshold. The government then needs to respect them as an institution that protects people within its domain (drivers and pedestrians) and they need to either guide, force, or destroy violators.
- r00fus 4y agoI don't think real L4+ self-driving will be feasible until we change how the roads are designed to support such vehicles. Having clear indicators and markings that are maintained properly will not only help L4 but also L2 and even human drivers. So yes, it would require a standards-based solution - and that's where government involvement is essential.
- Robotbeat 4y agoA grade-separated (ie tunnel) system for autonomous vehicles would be one such method. Government can certainly assist in this, but industry is usually better at coming up with better standards which the government can then deploy
- jowday 4y agoRequiring dedicated infrastructure eliminates the point of self driving cars - you might as well just build public transit infrastructure. On top of that, this won’t eliminate any of the real edge cases - humans and other cars will still violate these rules and drive or walk across these roads, at which point the AV will still need to know how to handle this novelty. These are the main reasons AV companies don’t consider approaches like this.
- r00fus 4y agoNothing of what I said indicates dedicated infrastructure. In fact, I don't think that would work (as you say why not I'm thinking more like expanding priority bus-lanes (if you have visited regions outside the US these are common) and ensuring there are markers that are abundantly clear for everyone and more usable for self-driving vehicles.
- jowday 4y agoI mean I’d count adding lane markers as building infrastructure - and the same caveat of people disobeying them applies. Not to mention you wouldn’t be able to add dedicated lanes outside of main thoroughfares and highways.
- paxys 4y agoThe problem with this approach is that the average human driver includes teenagers, very old people who shouldn't be driving, drunk drivers, distracted drivers, speeders, reckless drivers and lots more categories whose accident risk is a LOT higher than the baseline. As someone who doesn't fall into any of these, I wouldn't accept a self driving system that's merely better than average, it has to be better than ME.
- jowday 4y agoThis is something that robotaxi companies have already spent a ton of time figuring out - there are a ton of different metrics the cars have to hit before they remove the driver (as companies have done in Phoenix, San Francisco, Miami, and Austin). There are already robotaxis on the road right now.
- jjav 4y ago> How much better than a human driver does a self-driving system need to be before we as a society will accept fully autonomous vehicles? If you watch the many selfdriving videos online, it is clear the current state is worse than a drunken teenager on their first week with a license.
- colordrops 4y agoThis is probably happening a lot more than the number of reports mentioned in the article indicates. It happens to me every other day in my Model 3. It's also not binary - sometimes it slows down more quickly than other times, or stops too suddenly when a car is stopped in front of you. Seems real easy to get rear-ended. I've only got autopilot, not FSD. It's very conservative. It always considers someone to be in front of you even if they've mostly moved out of your lane into the next lane, or they swerve slightly into your lane. I suspect the engineers erred on the side of being rear-ended rather than rear-ending cars in front.
- throwaway0a5e 4y ago>Seems real easy to get rear-ended. Which, in this age of cheap ubiquitous dash-cams, isn't nearly as likely to be the "inconvenient waste of time but zero financial risk" deal it used to be Edit: Since apparently this needs explaining, insurers will consider evidence and happily doll out blame to a party that does something dumb in proportion to their fault (with slight variations per differences in law from state to state). The fact that said dumbness results in the back of your car getting hit with the front of another only matters in the base case in which no other reliable information about the situation is available. In the case of a car that just stops in the roadway with no reason to do so some of the blame is likely to land on the driver thereof. Insurers are well aware that the rules of the road are built around redundant requirements so that crashes don't happen when one party can't or won't hold up their end. Infantile "but the other guy is responsible for.." arguments don't tend to hold much water with them when there's evidence (video or otherwise) that in the events that lead up to the accident your hand was no more forced than the other guy's were because both drivers are still bound by whatever the default responsibility to operate their vehicles in a safe manner is (wording varies by state).
- antiframe 4y agoI don't understand what you mean. You seem to be implying that if a driver rear-ends you he can use his dash-cam to show you were at fault? Most places I've driven it is the following car's responsibility to maintain a safe distance which includes being able to stop if the car you are following suddenly stops. Yes, brake checking is a thing and could complicate any civil suit, but mechanical (now software) failure wouldn't be that.
- sane_stats_ 4y agoAn anecdote in a sea of data - My 2022 Model 3 had a pretty serious phantom braking problem until 2 or 3 software releases ago. Now it seems to be entirely resolved in my use case. For context, I drive 200-400 miles a week, 95% of which using autopilot on divided highways and well-marked two or four lane roads.
- standyro 4y agoSeems like radar equipped cars had less issues and they've finally worked out some of the kinks with the vision only system.
- LegitShady 4y agohe says he has a 2022 which is radar free.
- ahahahahah 4y agoUser1: I have model 3 w/o radar and it had bad phantom breaking until a recent release. User2: seems like the cars without radar were really bad, but that they are finally getting it fixed. You: he said he has a car without radar Everyone: wtf
- LegitShady 4y ago>until 2 or 3 software releases ago. Now it seems to be entirely resolved user's comment disagrees with the title, says phantom breaking is resolved. You: "It's worse on radar free models" them: "It's entirely resolved"
- ec109685 4y agoMy radar Tesla was awful for a few releases in November too.
- jra101 4y agoThis happens to me just using the adaptive cruise control, no Autopilot or FSD enabled and it's super annoying. Can happen on a completely empty road driving in a straight line.
- outworlder 4y agoThat's... appalling. My 2019 Leaf has absolutely zero problems maintaining distance with adaptive cruise control, using the ancient technology formerly known as radar. It can somehow even see stationary vehicles, something I thought wasn't feasible.
- robonerd 4y ago>It can somehow even see stationary vehicles, something I thought wasn't feasible. Radar seeing stationary objects is trivial, it sees them just like it sees any other. The trick is seeing only the stationary objects which are actually relevant; e.g. not seeing a street sign suspended above the road, or a tree next to the road, but only the stationary objects in the path of the car. The radar configuration that Tesla use[s/d] apparently has awful angular resolution, making this differentiation difficult if not impossible. But this isn't inherent to all radar technology; some radars can have good angular resolution. For instance with SAR or ISAR, you can produce high resolution 2d images. But I don't know what kind of radar systems your Leaf has.
- judge2020 4y agoDoesn't it also have to handle things like windy roads and steep angle changes when going uphill? it seems you need both vision and radar to confirm things, eg: - when on level ground approaching a steep hill, the radar might not know if the object directly in front of the car is just a continuation of the road or not - when approaching a sharp curve in the road, is the object directly in front of the car actually in its path, or is it just on the side of the road
- paxys 4y agoYeah, never had a problem with my Hyundai as well. It also does lane keep assist perfectly on the highway using just the front cameras.
- rvz 4y agoOh dear. Much worse than I expected by unexpected breaking; and FSD (Fools Self Driving) is involved in these problems, once again putting the lives of the driver and others at risk on the road. > Tesla has drawn scrutiny from safety advocates and regulators for its willingness to allow its customers to test what is essentially an unfinished version of a software product that Musk has long promised will lead to fully autonomous vehicles on the road. Now here's a similar recent scenario with 'blockchain'. Suppose an unfinished 'beta' blockchain with multi-billions at stake going down or gets hacked and the price falls, is the excuse 'it's beta software', 'sorry you lost your savings'? Hence if many users of FSD beta are putting their lives at risk or getting themselves killed over faulty safety-critical software, is the excuse also going to be 'It's beta software'? 'Sorry you lost your life, you knew the risks!' It really sounds like a way to push all blame on to the driver rather than the developer, despite little to no protections to the users and screams more tighter regulations to rid of that public 'beta' responsibility with software that has an incredible amount of risks.
- robonerd 4y agoI'd like to know when "beta test" entered the layman lexicon and came to be an accepted justification for a product under-performing expectations. Google's ngram viewer suggests usage of the term in literature began around 1980, but that doesn't really capture the use and perception of the word by consumers.
- mberning 4y agoMost of the “driver aids” available today have the competency of a drunk or highly inexperienced driver. Just maintaining lane is a problem for all the systems I have had the opportunity to try. They are easily flummoxed by worn or moved lane lines (like you would see in a construction area). I view it as a definite upgrade over traditional cruise control, but it’s so far away from self driving it’s laughable to even think about.
- a-dub 4y agoi recently rented a late model rav4 and described the experience of radar cruise (on an admittedly challenging road) to be "like having a drunk lead-footed teenager at the wheel." lots of overaggressive acceleration and deceleration, with all too frequent state changes. personally i'd rather just have regular cruise and something that will drive the car competently at low speeds in heavy congestion.
- smt88 4y agoI currently drive a 2021 Rav4 Prime and it's not like that at all. The adaptive cruise control is smooth and never makes mistakes. Lane assistance is helpful but not as close to flawless, mostly due to poorly marked lanes.
- a-dub 4y agowas it on flat roads or more challenging terrain? it was apparent that it was a very simple system that did not attempt to do any estimation beyond what was immediately visible to the sensors. so if there was a change in the pitch of the road, it would immediately react as the sensors became occluded and then regained their field of view. maybe in situations that challenging, it should complain and force manual control. rav4 primes look like awesome vehicles by the way... if i were going to get a late model green vehicle, it would definitely be on my shortlist.
- smt88 4y ago> so if there was a change in the pitch of the road, it would immediately react as the sensors became occluded and then regained their field of view I've used it on miles of interstate in the mountains, but that's never a problem because interstates don't change pitch that rapidly (by design). You must be using it on a very different roads than I do. I only use it on large, US interstates.
- standyro 4y agoI rarely have this issue, but I have a 2019 Model 3 with radar and Autopilot (not full self driving) ~ although I was admittedly extremely slow to upgrade to the latest v11 software and have experienced it more recently. Seems to be a major problem with cars that shipped in the past year or two without radar. Seems like a blunder that Tesla made not to include radar because of the parts shortage, that they're struggling to solve with software only based on cameras/vision.
- indus 4y agoI think Elon needs to open source the braking flowchart…
- metadat 4y agoMollusk not likely to give it up, unfortunately.
- urgentmessage 4y ago
- Alexss 4y agoOr autocorrect...
- colejohnson66 4y agoI doubt it. "Mollusk" is a term Johnny Depp used in a text to refer to him.[0] I could easily see it being used by detractors. [0]: https://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2022/05/26/mollusk-amber-heard/ https://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2022/05/26/mollusk-amber-heard/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- malsanton 4y agoi think gp was referencing the hypocrisy in Musk’s demands to open source Twitter’s recommendation algorithm
- TheRealNGenius 4y agothey did a piss poor job of making a reference then
- leesec 4y agoIs it possible that there's just more people driving Tesla's than when they initially reported this
- qwertox 4y agoHow do they deal with insects hitting the glass covering the cameras? Also if multiple cameras get blurred because of insect dirt in front of them?
- jayd16 4y agoIf something obstructs the camera, autopilot will signal as such and disengage. I assume there's _some_ overlap in camera coverage but it won't work if they're disabled. Also won't work if there's too much glare.
- analog31 4y agoOn my Subaru if the sensors are blocked, for instance with ice, it disables the controls.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoIt tells you if that happens, you get a "camera obscured" message, so you can stop and clean it. It doesn't actually happen very often, the aerodynamics are quite good at diverting crud from the cameras. (The front-facing cameras are behind the wipers, so you can at least clean those ones while driving.)
- tristanb 4y agoI have two teslas and this is a non issue. The rare time it's happened it's a slow down, not a jerk. It just seems like FUD
- misiti3780 4y agoI concur it used to be a problem, but I have driven 4K miles since march and have no had a single phantom break in a vision only car.
- poutine 4y agoAgreed. This used to be a big problem late last year for me (2021 M3 FSD). But I can't remember the last time it happened.
- plutonorm 4y ago
- qsdf38100 4y agoTesla is a scam, Elon is a fraud. It’s just obvious if you’re not a Musk fanatic. Wake up. I’d be more worried for the IQ of Tesla fanboys.
- jstream67 4y agoyeah gotta agree. I suspect it is software version dependent - the most negative comments here always seem to be from folks who don't own teslas - whereas people who do seem to be mostly saying that the issue is getting better not worse. Tesla topics seem worse than political topics on HN for triggering blind rage
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThey should give drivers a simple way to notify Tesla exactly when phantom breaking happens. E.g. use the mic and when Tesla users say ‘Tesla phantom’ it would send the flagged data to a central repository to train against. Regardless of your feelings towards Tesla, we need someone to figure out safe self driving before the effort is halted and humanity has to wait a century before a new generation tries again (like with nuclear tech today).
- Teever 4y ago> we need someone to figure out safe self driving before the effort is halted and humanity has to wait a century before a new generation tries again (like with nuclear tech today). That's quite the leap. A far more reasonable statement would be 'we need someone like Ralph Nader to spearhead initiatives to regulate self driving cars to prevent the disasters we saw in automobile safety in the 1950s-1960s.'
- jMyles 4y agoNo disrespect to Ralph Nader, but cars claim about the same number of lives (more in most years) than they did then. Sure, many _many_ lives are saved by seatbelts, but car-centric inner-cities combined with the psychology of invincibility for the people inside the vehicle are a recipe for dead kids in city blocks, and it's an absolute blood bath out there. Sure, there are fewer deaths per capita, and fewer deaths per mile traveled, but the chances of a fatality occurring at a given intersection haven't budged except in places where car-centric infra has been removed or scaled back.
- spacemark 4y agoI'm confused. Are you saying Nader didn't do any good thus regulation is a fool's errand?
- jMyles 4y agoI'm saying Nader did some good, but that regulation hasn't caused cars to stop being the most deadly threat people face in life before they age into the heart disease bracket. Or perhaps more to the point for the autonomous vehicle discussion: that no amount of hacking on the concept (which I fully support, and think is amazing and important work!), whether prompted by regulation or not, is likely to finally end the era of petro-carnage. For that, we need to stop using our tax dollars to build cities (and other roads) that are for cars first and people last.
- jari_mustonen 4y agoLast sentence of the article: > Tesla did not reply to a request for comment, nor has it since 2019 when it dissolved its PR department.
- qayxc 4y agoBoosts confidence in the company if the only way to get any comment is the social media account of the guy who also tries (tried?) to buy said social media.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoI have a "legacy" Model X which still has the radar fitted. For now, autopilot still uses the radar on these models, and I get little or no phantom breaking. Probably only once a month, or less, and I drive on autopilot most days. I fear the update that disables my radar. (And actually I'm planning to replace the Model X this year for something other than a Tesla, because of the awful service experience.)
- silax 4y ago2022 Model Y with FSD. I use Autopilot 50+ miles a day, and use it 98% of the way on trips from San Diego to SF. It infrequently phantom brakes, and more often brakes hard and late and sometimes people think I'm brake-checking them. It also is annoying slow to recover back to cruise speed from a slow down. Also if you're in the right lane when the two right lanes merge- it is totally unreliable, I've been sandwiched between an 18-wheeler and the gutter. But that said, once you learn the quirks it is extremely predictable and robust. I have used it on snowy mountain roads in Tahoe, a sandstorm at Salton Sea, and thousands of highway miles. If you have the minimum distance set to 2 or 3 car lengths, you should not be complaining about late and hard braking- that's the setting you chose. The phantom braking is annoying but infrequent, and you can quickly override it with an accelerator tap. My suggestion to Tesla would just be to have a debug button where you can report and elevate the past 10 seconds of driving.
- chinathrow 4y ago> It infrequently phantom brakes, and more often brakes hard and late and sometimes people think I'm brake-checking them. And you're still using this car? Why exactly?
- dylan604 4y agoBecause the rest of us are just crash test dummies. Nothing to see here, carry on.
- 0des 4y agoClout, social signaling
- nathanaldensr 4y agoAverage people are acceptable sacrifices on the altar of technology worship.
- itsoktocry 4y ago>My suggestion to Tesla would just be to have a debug button where you can report and elevate the past 10 seconds of driving. Wait, do you think that Tesla are actually obtaining all driver video and manually adjusting the model based on reports like this? I've seen a lot of fanatics with no technology background claim this, but I'm...skeptical to say the least.
- lesgobrandon 4y ago
- formerkrogemp 4y agoAll of these issues with Tesla cars and the stock still trades at 100x earnings. What dumb shit will old Musky Elon do to tank the stock price next I wonder? Is the halo of being the face of all the SpaceX and Tesla engineers' work going to fade away? Probably not. On an unrelated note, just a friendly reminder that the Chevy Bolt is only $26k with 250 miles of range. How much is the most affordable phantom braking, Full-Self-Driving-driver-should-always-pay-attention, pedestrian-squishing Tesla again? Model 3 Rear-Wheel Drive: $44,990 to $46,990. Huh.
- qsdf38100 4y agoYes but, "Tesla". If it’s named after the best inventor the world has ever known, and it’s been guaranteed to be 1 year from Full Self Driving For Real by Elon The Great himself, it has to be true right? All those stupid car makers can’t keep up with so much bullshit, I mean, ground breaking innovation.
- Lightbody 4y agoI don't have AutoPilot: I have a 2013 Model S with zero smarts, not even parking sensors. Every few months, while pulling out of a parking spot, my car will just SLAM on the breaks violently, sometimes when I'm in reverse and sometimes when I'm inching forward. Even at low speeds it's super unsettling.
- bool3max 4y agoWhy or how people deem "phantom braking" to be even remotely acceptable is completely beyond me. You are putting your life in the hands of a multi-ton steel box with a mind of (seemingly) its own and it "phantom braking" at highway speeds does not alarm you? In a normal world all of those cars would be immediately recalled.
- TremendousJudge 4y agoAs with everything, a tragedy must happen before something is done. I'm not condoning this behavior, but that's the way things are -- I'd be surprised if the opposite happened, and preventive action was taken. It took decades for mass adoption of simple security devices such as seat belts and third brake lights.
- mgarfias 4y ago2021 MYP w/o FSD. Happens often. Usually related to a corner while on cruise control, but can reliabily make it happen cresting a local hill. Have also had it happen while passing a flat deck trailer on the interstate a few weeks ago.
- ra7 4y agoI've completely stopped using Autopilot whenever there is a vehicle behind me (unless it's a highway traffic jam and I'm going <25 mph) because of phantom braking. I only use it when it's completely empty, which of course doesn't happen very often. It's just too unpredictable and I have no interest to be dangerous to others because I want to play with some tech.
- alphabettsy 4y agoLast week I had a Model 3 cross an intersection in front of me causing me to slam on the brakes to avoid hitting it broadside. It was stopped at the stop sign, I did not have one, and it went anyway. I have no idea if the driver was in control or it was FSD Beta. Couldn’t help but wonder if there should be a way for other drivers to report bad behavior by self-driving vehicles. I don’t see how it could be implemented or how it would work though.
- tibbydudeza 4y ago"once you learn the quirks" I had to laugh at this statement - imagine if I had to tell to a patient that he had to learn the quirks of his defib - so it "might" randomly just restart your heart at inopportune times but just hold on while it happens :).
- darkteflon 4y agoMy parents-in-law own a late-model VW. It’s not my car, but I drive it regularly when we visit. Despite limited use, in the last year or so I’ve had 3 phantom braking incidents - one with my son in the car that almost resulted in an actual collision with another vehicle. I hate this car so much. I cannot believe that VW thinks this junk technology is a good idea and I will never, ever buy a VW.
- eternityforest 4y agoI still don't understand why this is a hard problem. You can make radars and lidars cheap. You can confirm radar findings with an ultrasound. If the global priority was safety at all costs, a lot of this stuff could probably be solved with deterministic algorithms, and some mandatory changes to manual cars(Like an unsafe distance warning radar).
- Rygian 4y agoRadar is basically false positives everywhere. Ultrasound is few meters deep max. Lidar is a clunky wart that no modern production car carries at the moment, afaik.
- irrational 4y agoI’m sure laying off 10% of their workforce will expediate fixing this problem.
- rapphil 4y agoSomeone is using recursion in the code again