6 ms·
Executive narcissism affects knowledge transfer among business units
- h2odragon 4y agoExpressed less formally: https://everything2.com/title/SNAFU+Principle https://everything2.com/title/SNAFU+Principle
- TulliusCicero 4y agoThis is cool, but it's about bottom-up communication, whereas the article is about lateral transfer between orgs.
- jcranberry 4y agoHow did they identify narcissistic executives?
- AdamH12113 4y ago...their mouths were moving?
- Psyladine 4y ago>Using a two-wave, multisource survey design and collecting primary data from 118 business units of a headhunting company in China >>The data that support the findings of this study are available on request from the corresponding author. The data are not publicly available due to privacy or ethical restrictions. hoo-boy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- crabbygrabby 4y agoThe day someone proposes solutions to the dynamics of people in the work place will be a good day. I've run simulations of subject matter similar to this. The complexity is brutal, and so far I've come up dry in actionable work topologies, all of them are vulnerable to certain types of jerks...
- incone123 4y agoCould you link to anything you've published or could recommend? Sounds interesting even if you don't have anything actionable.
- crabbygrabby 4y agoIt's all unpublished unfortunately. I don't work in this field, I just started doing it because I have had such a rough ride in industry and needed to work on some kind of plan for setting up a company that wasn't riddled with the toxic stuff I've experienced. Maybe I'll share some code at some point.
- zmgsabst 4y agoI’ll second the request you write a blog post. Your simulations sound fascinating.
- eternalban 4y agoSet up a protocol to identify misbehaving agents and get rid of them. Also guessing that your model does not include an affinity factor. "Certain types of jerks" are attracted to certain types of organizations. I'm reaching here but maybe some old HP hands can chime in - what sort of people did the original HP attract? I'm guessing like attracts like. "HP's founders were very remarkable people at all levels, starting with Bill and Dave." https://hpmemoryproject.org/timeline/stories/Bill&DaveStory170812.pdf https://hpmemoryproject.org/timeline/stories/Bill&DaveStory1... Possibly the fish rots from the head? Model that.
- nradov 4y agoThe jerks will identify flaws in your protocol and exploit them to get rid of their rivals. This is an area where only intelligent human judgment can work (and even that doesn't always work). Any type of strict protocol that could be modeled and simulated in software is doomed to failure and a waste of time.
- 4y ago
- photochemsyn 4y agoSome discussion here: https://www.psychreg.org/executive-narcissism-inhibits-inter-unit-knowledge-transfer/ https://www.psychreg.org/executive-narcissism-inhibits-inter... > Dr Liu offered two theories as to why narcissism stands in the way of knowledge transfer: One, narcissistic unit heads may strongly believe that they have a superior knowledge stock, compared to executives in other units, and understand their unit’s problems better – leading them to believe others’ knowledge is less valuable. The second theory is that these executives may believe that knowledge transfer may diminish their sense of superiority and uniqueness, leading them to decline to receive external knowledge in an attempt to preserve their image. If you're worried you might have narcissitic tendencies, don't worry too much: a real narcissist would never entertain such a notion.
- fsckboy 4y agoIf you're worried you might have narcissitic tendencies, don't worry too much: a real narcissist would never entertain such a notion. this is literally not true, research indicates narcissists know they are narcissistic https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/beautiful-minds/201103/do-narcissists-know-they-are-narcissists https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/beautiful-minds/2011... http://www.simine.com/docs/Carlson_et_al_JPSP_2011a.pdf http://www.simine.com/docs/Carlson_et_al_JPSP_2011a.pdf
- eftychis 4y agoBut they are not worried about it -- usually at least.
- wolverine876 4y agoNarcissists are typically extremely worried, though they won't admit it, probably not to themselves. They are people who feel extremely vulnerable and insist that everything around them cannot threaten that vulnerability. Their kids, for example, have to make them feel like the perfect parent. Not a happy way to live, for them or the people around them.
- lowkey_ 4y ago
- upupandup 4y agoOff-topic but: How do software engineers become a c-suite executive in a non-startup environment? Does it require an MBA from a reputable school?
- watwut 4y agoYou seek transfer to management roles and take on leadership roles.
- ETHisso2017 4y agoNot necessarily an MBA, but it requires (in descending order of importance): 1. A willingness to spend more time & effort solving people problems rather than technical problems 2. A comfort with making decisions with a much lower degree of understanding of the facts than an engineer typically would 3. A knack for rallying lots and lots of people in the face of tough situations (bad quarters, customer escalations, cross-functional dysfunction) 4. A talent for public speaking and presentations
- nradov 4y agoIt also helps to get some experience working in a non-engineering role to broaden your perspective. An MBA isn't essential but can be helpful in teaching at least the basics of finance, accounting, law, marketing, and communications so that you can have productive discussions with those colleagues.
- upupandup 4y agoI have all of those, when do I start ? >.<
- astrange 4y agoIt helps to be unusually tall.
- thenerdhead 4y agoI hate this mentality. Not disclosing knowledge because it's your leverage. Or not leveraging the knowledge internally because you're "too important" to learn from your people. Leaders typically demonstrate narcissistic traits to some extent. Whether that's ambition or incentive driven. Almost to the point of a SNAFU / FUBAR situation when a leader with these traits are backed into a corner or didn't get their way so they aren't willing to comply.
- boringg 4y agoCounter thought here. Isn't there a risk of divulging and sharing information and then said narcissistic executives can scoop up that information and leverage up the chain of command? It's similar to the tragedy of the commons but around knowledge and power. It's also a zero sum mentality.
- thenerdhead 4y agoYeah for sure. Especially the "leaders" who need aces in their sleeves to perform. Those who lay everything out on the table have nothing to lose. They have enough self-respect to not have to stoop to that level. But the world is full of both these types at this level.
- temp8964 4y agoEven it is true, the practical usage of this finding is limited. First, I don't think you can measure candidates' "narcissism". Second, if a narcissist executive gets hired, it might because he/she has other advantages over other less-narcissist candidates.
- DFHippie 4y ago> if a narcissist executive gets hired, it might because he/she has other advantages over other less-narcissist candidates If not they'll still claim they do.
- giardini 4y agoSounds like an old topic, "capitalism", which has has a deep history and has been studied extensively. Using the term "executive narcissism" provides an excuse to exhume old (stolen) arguments and present them as new academic fodder to the great unwashed masses.
- jenkstom 4y agoI can't read the actual article, but the summary implies a distinct lack of understanding of a Narcissistic Personality Disorder. The issue is more that the NPD lives in a fantasy world and compulsively must "prove" that they are better than everyone, or more specifically the compulsively try to break others down. It's completely about power and the ability to trigger negative and traumatizing emotions in others.
- padde 4y agoI think this paper was actually written by a narcissistic bot.
- mikkergp 4y agoI often wonder, do 'good people' make better executives than 'bad people'? Extending on that, I think there's a lot published on how to have more empathy and all these ways to be a good person and manager, but is that as good on the numbers in a purely cutthroat capitalistic game? I would think this may be more/less true the higher up you go.