13 ms·
East German Doping Victims Die 10 to 12 Years Earlier (2018)
- mpol 4y agoOriginal discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17529815 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17529815
- TheGigaChad 4y ago[dead]
- raverbashing 4y agoInteresting tidbits > On average, victims of East German doping die 10 to 12 years earlier than the rest of the population. And here's another alarming statistic: A victim of East German doping falls ill 2.7 times as often, and for psychological illnesses, we have calculated a factor of 3.2. That's fair enough > Against this background, calls to legalize performance-enhancing drugs are naïve and irresponsible. Maybe, but this is a bit of a non-sequitur. Especially as the drugs were given unwillingly and with no consideration to individual conditions (and in excess doses) It was more of an experiment than anything else.
- dav_Oz 4y agoYes. One could easily argue the other way. >The magnitude in East Germany was likely unique. Unbeknownst to them, the athletes were given heavy anabolic steroids along with sex and growth hormones, often in extremely high doses. For many of the victims, the consequences have been dramatic, some of which are only appearing now, decades later. The other thing which is missing in that rather myopic conversation is that after their careers are over most competitive athletes in general have a hard time adjusting to a more "mundane" life which is understandable given that they were training since their childhood to be the best in their respective sport. Money to some extent can bridge that gap but in most sports there isn't much money to be made in the first place. Now give this into the mix of the accumulated harm to the body - at that level you are taking that willingly into account - and some insane overdosing to somehow sustain the damage in a system with unchecked incentives (ideological view), you now have a very clear signal. In classic bodybuilding where historically virtually all half-openly use/experiment with all kinds of PEDs, one can observe that with time and experience the dosings of e.g. TRT and GH are being finely titrated now. Additionaly because of the more open culture around that topic there is a solid understanding (in the more professional community at least) about the benefits and potential side effects. Another more serious issue are the effects of extreme weight cutting but I'll leave it at that.
- raverbashing 4y ago> Another more serious issue are the effects of extreme weight cutting but I'll leave it at that. Agree. That is one serious elephant in the room.
- atchoo 4y ago> there is a solid understanding (in the more professional community at least) Hmm. I don't know about that. There has been a spate of recent deaths of professional bodybuilders in their 30s and 40s despite more knowledge and health checks. The problem with PEDs in competitive sports is that in many cases, higher doses mean more results. It pushes competitors and coaches out of what might be safe usage into high risk. Although use is admitted in bodybuilding, the vast doses and number of compounds is something most lie / downplay with only a few whistleblowers sharing real world usage. > Another more serious issue are the effects of extreme weight cutting Also a PED issue. Some of the Shelby Starne's stacks used in recent deaths of female bodybuilders are insane. Stacking 3 different diuretics, multiple types of stimulant... my god. They looked like they were designed to give people heart attacks.
- zemvpferreira 4y agoYou have a good take on this. Matter of fact is we have very little data on the role of anabolics on mortality/longevity. What we do have on pro-level dosages is almost completely negative. We can say with some confidence that a small TRT dosage would be beneficial for almost all seniors. But small means really small, just enough to bring their hormones up to par with an average 50 year old body. Anything above that has non-negligible risks for any population and I hope no one will use PEDs with the assumption that they'll never pay a health price for it. I wish it were different but it is what it is.
- dav_Oz 4y agoYes, you might be on the right track here 'cause I honestly lack a well founded overview over the scene as a whole. So I correct myself: From the things I've selectively listen to or read about [0] they at least are more knowledgeable about their "stuff" or more open to share their experiences as compared to other competitive athletes. If they act accordingly (on average) is up to a thorough analysis which I've not encountered so far. I can imagine as with other performance driven activities there is certainly a lot of potential for reckless abuse given the highly competitive nature. [0]https://moreplatesmoredates.com/anabolic-steroid-family-tree/ https://moreplatesmoredates.com/anabolic-steroid-family-tree...
- nradov 4y agoMost performance-enhancing drugs are already legal for prescription use, and in some circumstances can even be used by competitive athletes with an approved therapeutic use exception. But there's really nothing to be gained by allowing every athlete to use such drugs. https://youtu.be/jAdG-iTilWU https://youtu.be/jAdG-iTilWU
- isaacfrond 4y agoWebpage archive: https://archive.ph/SlmHD https://archive.ph/SlmHD
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y ago> On average, victims of East German doping die 10 to 12 years earlier than the rest of the population. While the comparison with the general population is interesting, I would also like to see a comparison with Olympic athletes in general. To be an Olympics athlete, even without doping, you have to be an outlier physically. In addition, even without doping, there is an intensive training regimen and specialized diet. There is also ultra competitive environment and high stress of competing in front of the whole world and knowing that a fraction of a second may be all the difference between glory winning the gold medal and the obscurity of 4th place. Finally, there is the whiplash where for a few weeks you are the center of attention and then when the Olympics are over, are more or less forgotten, even if you did win the gold. This environment is pretty likely to have physical and psychological consequences, even apart from the doping, and it would be interesting to see what they are in comparison to doping.
- pessimizer 4y ago
- treeman79 4y agoI’m going to get blasted for this. But the various chronic illness support forums I follow have a lot of trans people with tons of serious issues.
- klyrs 4y agoSounds like sampling bias to me.
- postalrat 4y agoShould it be ignored until it's confirmed to be sampling bias?
- wolverine876 4y agoYes, given the likely outcome of raising the issue, including more discrimination against and negative rumors about trans people. Or rather, no, like most things, it should be ignored until it's confirmed to have data. That is, things are not (true until fault is found), things are (non-true until factual support is provided).
- postalrat 4y agoIf everyone is ignoring it then who is going to bother confirming it?
- mftrhu 4y agoIt should be ignored until sampling bias is found to be unlikely. Vague suspicions based on anecdotal experience with chronic illness forums are worthless.
- 4y ago
- jotm 4y agoI thought that's common knowledge? The lifespan decrease from effective steroids, I mean. When making the decision voluntarily, you trade years of life for better quality of life. Which is a tradeoff many people would accept.
- cafard 4y agoBetter quality of life for yourself, or for the GDR sports administration?
- cgh 4y agoThere’s little evidence that modest courses of anabolic steroids lead to shortened lifespans. Millions of men are on legally-prescribed steroids right now, although we call it “trt”. The East Germans were in relatively unique circumstances, likely comparable or even beyond modern professional bodybuilding dosages, which are in turn way beyond what any professional athlete would take. From the article: “Freyberger: The magnitude in East Germany was likely unique. Unbeknownst to them, the athletes were given heavy anabolic steroids along with sex and growth hormones, often in extremely high doses. For many of the victims, the consequences have been dramatic, some of which are only appearing now, decades later.”
- wolverine876 4y ago> When making the decision voluntarily, you trade years of life for better quality of life. If you are well-informed about the decision. Most are not, and realistically will not understand the costs and benefits. That's why we don't let companies sell dangrous things freely. > Which is a tradeoff many people would accept. I'm not sure what that means. What tradeoff would many accept? It depends on the benefit and the cost. Of course people would take eliminating excruciating chronic back pain at the cost of losing a day of life, but they would not take eliminating hangnails at the cost of losing 10 years. I'm sure you know that; my point is, what are you actually saying?
- StevePerkins 4y agoI'm very surprised that you're being downvoted here, or lead on frivolous logical goose chases by replies. Everyone... just make-believe that we're talking about recreational drugs. Rather than a class of drugs that you and your social cohort do NOT take to get high, or to self-medicate your self-diagnosed mental health disorders. Perhaps that thought experiment will help?
- mensetmanusman 4y agoI grew up watching Mutant League cartoons: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutant_League https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutant_League It probably altered my view on doping. Because so much money is involved in sports, I think we should legalize it even knowing that it has these health effects. People volunteering to test performance enhancement will improve our understanding of human biology. If everyone knows they kill you, people will search for versions that do not over time and will be able to weigh risk/reward.
- a4isms 4y agoIt's not "people volunteering" to test performance enhancing drugs in sport any more than it's "people volunteering" to test the effects of concussion on the brain in contact sports. It's a perverse set of incentives designed to exploit the underclass into becoming celebrity gladiators for the entertainment of the masses. It is a free choice and so on, but let's not pretend it is a randomized sample of humans in a double-blind study conducted with ethical oversight.
- rowanG077 4y agoI just looked up the demographic of professional atheletes: https://www.zippia.com/professional-athlete-jobs/demographics/ https://www.zippia.com/professional-athlete-jobs/demographic... The amount of college graduates is SIGNIFICANTLY higher for them then the average US population. You can't really make the argument that they are an exploited underclass when they are one of the best paid and educated in the country.
- knbknb 4y agoThe East German staff (team directors and doctors) probably didn't really know which dosis of Doping Medication was the right one for the performance enhancing treatments. The substances were newly discovered, and in the 1970s/80 nobody on Earth has ever used that human growth hormone on children or young adults. So, I guess the medical staff simply, systematically, tried a whole range of concentrations on their athletes. Those who then performed best in training were promoted to the Olympic team. Those who received too little were removed from the national team. And those who received too high concentrations? They had their adolescent bodies messed up, but were simply neglected afterwards. A very cynical program indeed.
- onetokeoverthe 4y ago
- 0des 4y agoHGH has been used for much longer than you give it credit for to address a myriad of growth issues. What the difference is now we have lab derived recombinant HGH rather than that of the cadavers they used to be extracted from. LAGH is rather new, and Im excited to see where it goes and how it affects treatments of those who want to minimize the frequency of administering it.