7 ms·
When I worked at Qualcomm a while ago the company had two major business lines. One of them was developing and selling a line of mobile chipsets (Snapdragon) to
by paxys 4y ago
When I worked at Qualcomm a while ago the company had two major business lines. One of them was developing and selling a line of mobile chipsets (Snapdragon) to a lot of the major players in the market, for which they employed thousands of top engineers and researchers. The other was licensing their CDMA patents to all of the players in the market, and this org was run entirely by lawyers. The second business made significantly more money than the first.
- ljhsiung 4y agoDisclaimer: current employee. Purely personal opinion. I'm curious how long ago this was? I can't find any time period where QTL (the licensing division) made more than QCT (the Snapdragon et. al division). Still, I think your statement's sentiment is the consensus-- that overall, Qualcomm is/has been the "Oracle of hardware" that milks the licensing cow. Let's look at Q2 '22, Q2 '19, Q2 '16, Q2 '13. I choose 3-year gaps for no particular reason, simply how I personally view company timelines and how long it might take to "steer a ship", e.g. if the CEO wants to change its public perception, it might take a few years. I also choose Q2 simply because Q2 was the most recent quarter. Relatively arbitrary, but still sensible data points when talking about Qualcomm's recent history. Noteworthy also, is that Q2 '22 is about the 1 year anniversary of when the new CEO was instantiated. ($mil) | - QCT - | - QTL -- | QTL % of tot rev -------------------------------------------- Q2 '13 | $3,916 | $2,057 | 33.6% -------------------------------------------- Q2 '16 | $3,337 | $2,135 | 38.5% -------------------------------------------- Q2 '19 | $3,722 | $1,122 | 22.9% -------------------------------------------- Q2 '22 | $9,548 | $1,580 | 16.5% Licensing revenue has actually been flat or on the decline recently. Even in business outlooks, Qualcomm usually directly says "our goal is to maintain QTL" while heavily expanding on QCT, somewhat implying an attempt to cast off this "ran by lawyers" reputation. Time will tell, I suppose. [1] https://d1io3yog0oux5.cloudfront.net/_ef937ef9314613934ed1233f1498098e/qualcomm/db/773/6117/file/Q2_13_ER_Final.pdf https://d1io3yog0oux5.cloudfront.net/_ef937ef9314613934ed123... [2] https://d1io3yog0oux5.cloudfront.net/_ef937ef9314613934ed1233f1498098e/qualcomm/db/773/6130/file/FY_2016_2nd_Quarter_Earnings_Release.pdf https://d1io3yog0oux5.cloudfront.net/_ef937ef9314613934ed123... [3] https://d1io3yog0oux5.cloudfront.net/_ef937ef9314613934ed1233f1498098e/qualcomm/db/773/6142/file/FY+2019+2nd+Quarter+Earnings+Release.pdf https://d1io3yog0oux5.cloudfront.net/_ef937ef9314613934ed123... [4] https://d1io3yog0oux5.cloudfront.net/_ef937ef9314613934ed1233f1498098e/qualcomm/db/773/7114/file/FY+2022+2nd+Quarter+Earnings+Release.pdf https://d1io3yog0oux5.cloudfront.net/_ef937ef9314613934ed123...
- JOnAgain 4y agoI'm guessing the licensing is much more profitable. Especially if, accounting-wise, all the costs of developing the the patents is attributed to the chip division.
- ljhsiung 4y agoThat would make sense. You touch on an interesting point-- that the chips themselves might be somewhat of a loss-leader to just get them out the door, where the licenses *on those chips* are the real money maker. While that might make OP's original statement ("a long time ago... made more money") true, these days it is no longer true. QTL in Q2 '13 had $1800mil EBT with 88% of revenue contributing to earnings. EIGHTY EIGHT PERCENT. Holy cow. QCT in that same year had $600mil EBT with 17%. For comparison, QTL in Q2 '22 had $1540mil EBT with 74% of revenue contributing to earnings. QCT in that same year had $3340mil EBT with 35%. I guess really you can only squeeze so much before the market gets annoyed. Given these numbers, I can't see how QCT would be a loss-leader. Why else would the margins on them be increasing, and margins on QTL be decreasing? My point is, I believe things aren't as lawyer-y as before. The Qualcomm of today focuses a lot more on its QCT division. Licensing is still obviously there, and will always be an incredibly nice moat, but it's not the suffocating "shakedown" it might have been 10 years ago.
- beembeem 4y agoYes, last I checked QTL's revenue was much lower yet profit higher than QCT.
- kappi 4y agoLooking at Q2 is misleading. QTL revenue has increased from 4.591B in 2019 to 6.320B in 2021. https://investor.qualcomm.com/segments/qtl https://investor.qualcomm.com/segments/qtl. Qualcomm is heavily represented in lot of industry standards. Every "if condition" is patented and counted as part of any standards. Standards group decisions are highly political and not completely based on technical merits. With Qualcommm political power, they are able to include many of their proposals in standards which end up getting them royalty.
- chasil 4y agoThe funny thing is that CDMA was a Russian invention, and was first implemented in a mobile phone in 1957. "In the Soviet Union (USSR), the first work devoted to this subject was published in 1935 by Dmitry Ageev... The technology of CDMA was used in 1957, when the young military radio engineer Leonid Kupriyanovich in Moscow made an experimental model of a wearable automatic mobile phone, called LK-1 by him, with a base station." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cdma https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cdma
- chroem- 4y agoAnd yet the technology was reserved exclusively for the Soviet political elite and never saw use with regular citizens.
- cbozeman 4y agoWhat I'm about to say I know will sound glib, or... something... but I don't know what else to say, or even how else to say it, but after learning this, why do I want to say something along the lines of, "Communists are too stupid to make money and this kinda proves it."
- rpmisms 4y agoCommunism is an ideology that requires/promotes an incredibly naive worldview. In order for it to function properly, everyone must act in good faith, which is obviously impossible. Once the communism is established, the expectation is to believe everyone is acting in good faith, which is even more naive. Hence your observation.
- colordrops 4y agoCapitalism is only marginally less naive. It assumes that markets behave in a way that optimizes for the public good and that regulatory mechanisms will be independent and without conflict of interest with regards to the corporations themselves. Both extremely naive.
- zugi 4y ago> The other was licensing their CDMA patents to all of the players in the market, and this org was run entirely by lawyers. The U.S. Constitution empowers Congress to issue patents "to promote progress in science and the useful arts." It's not supposed to be all about full employment for lawyers. When patents inhibit progress rather than promote it, they need to be cut short. Resolving this through antitrust seems like a patch - fixing a problem caused by bad government policies and too many lawyers by adding more government policies and lawyers.
- daniel-cussen 4y agoAren't those lawyers frequently patent lawyers, meaning often are engineers themselves? Electrical Engineering in particular, that's the hottest undergrad degree to then become a patent lawyer.