5 ms·
When people talk about conductors and what they do, it's almost always "what do they do in the concert?" They'll say, disparagingly, "hey, the musicians know ho
by AlbertCory 4y ago
When people talk about conductors and what they do, it's almost always "what do they do in the concert?" They'll say, disparagingly, "hey, the musicians know how to keep time."
Not quite true, but anyway, what that ignores is that they give the orchestra (and chorus, which was where I was) directions in rehearsal, and the eye and hand gestures during the concert are references to that.
So in rehearsal they stop and point to the horns and say "I want you to crescendo / decrescendo here" and have them do it until good. The horns mark it in their scores.
Then in the concert, the conductor just points, and the horns see the pencil marks on their scores and do it.
- zwieback 4y agoDefinitely true in the (school) orchestras I played in. However, a friend who plays in a orchestra where they bring in high-end soloists told me that they don't really rehearse together more than an hour or two. In those cases I imagine the conductor has to do a bit more to coordinate in real time. Maybe a little glaring when the trumpets play too loud or something.
- FredPret 4y agoI played in a pro orchestra once. We had one practice. The conductor is critical. Sheet music is open to interpretation to an extent - what shade of emotion are you trying to convey; how should the different instruments blend together; how loud is fortissimo for this piece; how fast is fast; at what frequency should we tune, etc, etc. The conductor brings this vision about.
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoThe musicians can't easily keep time. Not because they're bad at their jobs, but because sound travels so slowly there's an appreciable delay between the different sections of the orchestra. (50 ms for a smaller hall, up to 100 ms for a giant Mahlerian monster orchestra in a large space.) Those are not small delays. The speed of light is slightly faster, so having someone at the front indicating time keeps everything together. The pointing and gesticulating aren't limited to prepared rehearsal notes. Rehearsal notes certainly happen, but apart from keeping time, the conductor's job is to define the mood and emotional valence, moment to moment. This may be somewhat improvised, within limits. Orchestras typically play somewhat behind the indicated beat because it allows for more expression. There's also a lot of business-related admin - dealing with absences, holding auditions for new members, contributing to program scheduling, reading and possibly writing feedback notes to/from various interested parties, and so on. Every once in a while a smaller orchestra will try to manage without a conductor. While the results are usually workable - professional musicians are very good at their jobs - they're not great.
- ksaj 4y agoLikewise, the vast majority of orchestral music is not done to a regular tick. The phrasing can be very different between different conductors, as they all speed up / slow down / etc. to the conductor's individual interpretation of the piece. So the conductor is also a visual time keeper.
- sushisource 4y agoI'm not sure ~1million times faster is "slightly", lol
- marcosdumay 4y agoWell, it's an absolute version of it. 50ms is "slightly faster".
- myself248 4y agoMy favorite demonstration of this effect is this moment of Queen during Live Aid at Wembley Stadium: https://youtu.be/TkFHYODzRTs?t=1094 https://youtu.be/TkFHYODzRTs?t=1094 Everyone in the audience is clapping in time with the beat, _as it reaches them_, and you can see the speed of sound as the beat propagates out through the crowd. I often use this to illustrate yet another reason that CPUs went multi-core: When propagation across the chip takes longer than your clock speed, you have to reduce the distances somehow. A bunch of small stages in the same acreage would have a much easier time each clapping "together enough".
- AlbertCory 4y agoVery good points. In the chorus, we were always told to watch the conductor, or else we'd always be late. Amusing factoid: once I was in the audience at a musical theater production, and I could see TV monitors up high on the walls in the house, facing the stage. I couldn't see what was on them, but I'm pretty sure it was the conductor. So those folks have to be able to see the conductor, too.
- pvarangot 4y agoYeah looking at the drummer or the bass guitar also helps keep time because of this. Also Zoom music is impossible because of this. AFAIK most bands that play on stage at fast tempos and are not improvising have a synced click going to everyone's IEMs together with their chosen mix of what's coming into the console. That makes musicians able to perform without looking at each other.
- analog31 4y agoIndeed, it just makes sense to have roughly the same conditions for performance as for rehearsal. But, having played conducted music (double bass), there's another reason. What seems like a fine tuned machine on stage conceals a lot of chaos, and the orchestra may be barely hanging on by a thread. For one thing, at any performance, probably 5 to 15 % of the musicians are substitutes, due to a variety of circumstances. For some commercial gigs, 100%. Those subs rarely attend more than one or two rehearsals, and sometimes none if it's an emergency. Of course there's a cadre of musicians who specialize in that kind of work. I do it but in typically in a jazz setting. Still, I've experienced looking at some hastily e-mailed PDF's of bass parts, a day before a performance, and saying to myself: "I'm screwed unless the conductor gets me through this."
- AlbertCory 4y agoIn fact, I'm friends with a French Horn player, who's subbed with almost every orchestra in the Bay Area. I'm pretty sure he doesn't get a rehearsal.
- cperciva 4y agoIt depends on the rep. You're playing Don Juan? No problem, know it like the back of my hand, just tell me when to show up and I'll watch for the tempo changes in all the usual places. We're doing Boheme? No way I'm doing that without a dress rehearsal. Every opera singer screws things up in their own special way and I need to know what to expect. We're doing anything by Stravinsky? I'll take every rehearsal I can get.
- AlbertCory 4y agoCool, I'll have to ask him next time I see him.
- JasonFruit 4y agoExcept, real talk, we only know the parts of Don Juan that show up on auditions. The rest we sorta fake.
- cecilpl2 4y agoA great comment on a great video I found a while back: https://old.reddit.com/r/nextfuckinglevel/comments/ofw6en/world_famous_conductor_shows_student_how_to/h4g4y5c/?context=1 https://old.reddit.com/r/nextfuckinglevel/comments/ofw6en/wo... > You have to have the ability to physically manifest your vision of what the music sounds like in your head using just your body, in a way that is so clear and concise that anyone watching immediately knows what you mean. You also have to be able to elicit immediate gut responses from people without them realizing it, like a dog trainer giving a command.
- legohead 4y agoThey are your leader, your guide. Without the conductor you are all just a bunch of people playing music independently. That's how it felt for me anyway. You can play without a conductor. In high school, he had us play Samuel Barber's Adagio for Strings without him, because it's such an emotional piece. He wanted us to play off each other, not him. That's the only piece I remember from high school orchestra...
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 4y agoWhen someone asks what a conductor does during the concert, I show them this clip https://youtu.be/uEwMTxbpbrA https://youtu.be/uEwMTxbpbrA
- Stratoscope 4y agoThat is truly grace under pressure. Great composers and conductors also know to play to the strengths of their soloists. As shown here with Nora the Piano Cat: http://catcerto.com/ http://catcerto.com/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zeoT66v4EHg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zeoT66v4EHg
- dotancohen 4y agoAmazing how she continued with a different instrument. That would be like swapping my Matias Ergo Pro for a Logitech Squishboard and keep right on typing with no typos.
- gabereiser 4y agoI came on here to say just that, they are cue’s. They are movements to a rehearsal part that has been drilled into them time and time again until they got it right. I often think it’s funny that we critique what a conductor does with our eyes and miss the entire point of what he’s doing. It’s not our eyes that should be critical, it’s our ears. I play music as well. Eye contact can be a form of communication when other forms are “busy”. When I look to the other musicians on stage and give them TheLook@ they follow, on cue, in time, to the look. It’s also completely natural for both the cue person and the recipient. It’s deeper than our conscious brain. I find it fascinating.
- AlbertCory 4y agoMr. Bean shows how a real conductor does it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xzkm-kbx2T4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xzkm-kbx2T4
- zerr 4y agoCan these be encoded in the score itself? If no, maybe we should improve the score encoding?
- junon 4y agoYes, crescendo looks like a < stretched horizontally based on the length of time that the rise should happen, decrescendo is >. There are musical symbols for pretty much every common (and uncommon) instruction, and any gaps are typically filled in with textual notes. However, conductors are tasked at interpreting the piece, which sometimes they might want a different sound, or perhaps the orchestra has trouble adhering to a tricky bit of notation. Any number of reasons will result in extra added notes jotted down in the scores directly. Given that sheet music is often pre-printed or otherwise very difficult to edit, this is the next best thing.
- mb7733 4y agoNot every interpretation of a piece is the same.
- AlbertCory 4y agoEvery good musician brings a pencil to rehearsal. In Stanford Symphonic Chorus, Steve Sano began every new piece giving us a set of pencil marks to make in our scores. Nearly always, for a phrase that ends with a quarter note, we'd be told to replace that with an eighth note and an eighth rest. This is his choice, not the composer's.