25 ms·
Has the ‘great resignation’ hit academia?
- AlexanderDhoore 4y agoCan anyone show me statistical evidence that this "great resignation" is anything more than a story made up by the media?
- idiotsecant 4y agoThe plural of anecdote is not data, but my employer has definitely felt this. In the last year they've lost approximately 25% of empoyees (who were very long-term, not temps and young people only) to retirement and job moves, which is extremely high compared to baseline.
- p1esk 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Resignation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Resignation
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fullshark 4y agoHere's some data: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CIVPART https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CIVPART I'm not gonna claim anything here but do agree what firms / business are mostly complaining about is key employees changing jobs more so than leaving the workforce entirely.
- ghaff 4y agoIn professional circles, maybe you see some people retiring sooner than they would otherwise would have. Don't know. I haven't really seen that myself though. [ADDED: That's not really true in healthcare. I had two primary care doctors retire on me over the course of a year.] Certainly I've seen a fair bit of motion among fairly senior employees between companies but I don't know how it compares to the baseline. What anecdotally is the case is that there are a lot of staffing issues for service sector jobs.
- pojzon 4y ago> In professional circles, maybe you see some people retiring sooner than they would otherwise would have. Mother was working as a teacher for over 40 years. A real teacher by calling. Kids loved her, always got the most flowers and chocolades etc. Unfortunately she had to retire prematurely because the work conditions became terrible. Goverment wants you to do more and more for the same pay. On top of that ppl quit and you have to fill in for them too. Slowly the situation will resemble retail sector. Healthcare and Education are the two sections we should NEVER be cheap on. Unfortunately our rulers dont see that.
- mcshicks 4y agoAmerica spends more per Capita than any other nation. https://www.statista.com/statistics/236541/per-capita-health-expenditure-by-country/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/236541/per-capita-health...
- vkou 4y agoSports stadiums and elite coaches, and doctors' third summer homes don't pay for themselves.
- stereoradonc 4y agoIt is primarily to keep the populace "under-educated" to keep them on the "universal basic income" and remove all motivation to "work".
- nh23423fefe 4y agoMaybe you should put forward an affirmative argument of non-existence or continuity with the past, etc. Otherwise, you are just asserting formless skepticism -- with no evidence.
- JasonFruit 4y agoSkepticism is appropriate when there's no evidence, in general. No opinion on this matter.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- NikolaNovak 4y agoHmm; I think of it more as the null hypothesis - it is the alternative/proposed hypothesis that would need evidence in my mind. I.e. my daily necessary-for-sanity assumption is that 10 million gazillion things are pretty much the same today as yesterday; if a headline/claim is "This thing has changed/Occurred!", that is what needs evidence in order for claim to be relevant/substantiated/interesting.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoOr just google it.
- mcnamaratw 4y agoDo you have any evidence of this?
- fennecfoxen 4y agoThe BLS's records of the labor force participation rate alone are pretty intense. https://www.bls.gov/charts/employment-situation/civilian-labor-force-participation-rate.htm https://www.bls.gov/charts/employment-situation/civilian-lab...
- somenameforme 4y agoGraphs with zoomed in Y axes make eyeballing often misleading. Consider the data: 2000-2016: -4.3% LFPR 2016-2020: +1% LFPR Current: 0.2% below what we were in September 2015 (while currently in a sharply increasing trend) The graph is eye popping, but the numbers themselves don't seem particularly exceptional.
- jldugger 4y agoI mean, we celebrate when GDP growth rates hit 3 percent, and here we show a 4 percent decline in the workforce that generates that GDP so I don't think it's that misleading, perhaps as a lucky coincidence. Travelling 7 years in time is a rather huge deal. Really, where this chart is misleading is that there are likely different cohorts. If stratified by decade of birth I would expect boomers to be most of the difference, and maybe even millenials offsetting it. And if so, there are at least two great resignation stories to tell: 1. Boomers resigning, as long predicted. in the 2008 crisis everyone expected them to retire but that didn't really happen. maybe happened this time 2. The rest of us resigning one job to start another, filling the vacancies created by story #1, and creating its own cycle of job hopping for salary bumps.
- ghaff 4y ago>Boomers resigning, as long predicted. Changes are probably at the margins but those can still be significant in the aggregate. There are obviously many people (of all generations) that can't afford to just pack it. But there are also a lot of Boomers, among others, who--thanks in part to a long bull market--don't have to keep working and there are a lot of reasons to imagine why now might be as good a time as any to wind down full-time employment.
- dominotw 4y agogreat musical chairs
- DebtDeflation 4y agoI think this is closer to the truth. People are changing jobs, changing careers, going back to school, etc. more frequently. But I don't buy the narrative that people are just dropping out and living the van life or whatever. At least not in significant numbers.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoIt's the result of moronic short-sighted managers and HR departments that would rather pay replacements 50% more than the existing employee than to give the existing employee the 25% pay bump necessary to keep them.
- stonemetal12 4y agoTo add a little color to the bare link already posted: Back in 2000 the Department of Labor started tracking the number of people quitting their job. The number has bounced between 1.5 and 2.5 percent during that time. The number recently went up to 3 percent, and is staying high. From that it appears "something" is happening. Given the lack of historical data it is impossible to tell if it is normal variability or something interesting. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Resignation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Resignation
- jxidjhdhdhdhfhf 4y agoIt doesn't even really make sense as a concept. People resign from their jobs and then what? Maybe a small extra portion of the elderly retire early and a small portion become stay at home parents. The rest find new jobs.
- babypuncher 4y agoThe "Great Resignation" name is fearmongering, meant to make people think something bad is happening. Unemployment is at rock bottom; people aren't quitting, they are moving to new jobs. That is just the free market at work. Yet for some reason the "free market ooh rah" people seem the most upset about it.
- fundad 4y agoI think so many layoffs happened in 2020, and there haven’t been as many layoffs since. Resignations look huge in comparison.
- anonymousDan 4y agoIn the UK at least there is huge discontent about the recent pension cuts. The salaries already suck (especially in a technical field such as CS), but a 40% cut to pensions as a reward for the efforts put in to handle COVID is just too much.
- pjc50 4y agoYeah, I'd expect anyone who can get out of the field to do so in the UK; the pensions fiasco is the opposite of a staff retention effort, and in general the profession suffers from a lack of respect.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 4y agoMy understanding, as well, is that as much as the tenure track situation in NA is on the disastrous side of bleak, the European and specifically UK tenure track (or equivalent) situation is almost worse. I know you pointed out salaries, but the vast majority of junior academics are not interested in chasing higher salaries. They are there for their research and the opportunities to pursue that research.
- udp 4y agoThe salaries suck but this is the UK. If you’re in the correct social class to be an academic you should have your own independent means, and use your academic salary as nothing more than rent for the townhouse you’re staying in while away from your country estate. /s (Somehow this is both sarcasm and the literal situation of people I know.)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- _Wintermute 4y agoI'm in academia in London at the moment and this really struck true. All the senior staff bought their houses for pennies 30 years ago which are now worth millions, and don't seem to understand why the more junior staff are so worked up about salaries. Rent is 50% of our pay cheque and any house within an hours commute is 10x annual salary.
- mikewarot 4y agoHere in the US, I expect a lot of K-12 teachers to be leaving the field. The additional demands created by Covid were the last straw for many. Their employment contracts are such that they have to give months of notice, so I expect all to be quiet until August, then panic everywhere as slots can't be filled.
- gnicholas 4y agoWhy wouldn't you have expected them to leave last summer? I have a couple friends here in CA who did.
- dhosek 4y agoI'm guessing the hope that the 2021–22 school year would be better.
- bakuninsbart 4y agoNot sure if this is the same across the pond, but here in Germany this rings true. Most covid restrictions are gone, but a lot of teachers have burnout or similar problems, and some quit already during covid. This means the teachers left need to pick up the work of these colleagues, and schools and ministries are slow at taking on new teachers. At the same time, there seems to be a huge problem with the "covid generation" of teenagers, in that a lot of them a) don't want to put in the work and b) don't understand how school-work with physical presence really works. There is now a 2 year gap in physical education for high schoolers, during one of the most important times of their education. I also see this now with the new Bachelor students in my department, professors are really confused by complaints like "this was only said during lecture, how should I know".
- blululu 4y ago(Public School) Teacher pay is largely structured to encourage retention. The salary is pretty lousy if you only do it for 2 years, but if you stick around for 40 years it is a well paying job in most States. The pay increases for seniority and the compounding interest of pensions add up to a very good salary. There is also the other problem that a lot of states require an education degree to teach in public schools which is somewhat specialized. A lot of mid-career educators that I have spoken with find that their skills don't really qualify them for a lot of jobs and becoming a private school teacher typically means a pay cut.
- muaytimbo 4y agoI'm surprised it took them so long to get fed up, reaching the mid-career level. I realized doing my PhD that all of academia is a toxic house of cards built on cheap grad student labor, foreign student tuition and grant beggary, and the false promise to students of at least an interesting (if not particularly well-paid) career. If it took you until mid-career to realize this . . . you weren't observant and I don't really feel that sorry that you were asleep for so long.
- ska 4y agoA bit over-egged, but there is not denying there are a raft of problems in academia. On the other hand, observant or not, it's still (nearly ) the only game in town for some sorts of things that people want to do. Some people pursue that for a long time hoping things will shake out ok for them... as it does very much for some.
- seydor 4y agoSome of these things can be done by anyone yet academia gatekeeps the academic creds for itself. E.g. anyone can do machine learning research, but you can't publish in a journal without being affiliated to a university
- freyr 4y agoThat’s not true at all. Papers come from industry all the time. I know of independent researchers who make up an LLC name and use that as their affiliation. Most people who publish in journals are affiliated with academia simply because that’s where the vast majority of basic research happens.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoUniversities are in trouble. I know of three that are unable to hire for senior and middle positions. They've been advertising for months. Here (UK), Brexit is partly to blame, along with post Cov19 fatigue, and aging population with many retiring. As I've said in other comments, the main problem is that academia has become hideously corrupted by "professional management" values leading to de-skilling as good people leave.
- krastanov 4y agoWhat does "senior and middle positions" mean? Are you talking about something that has the potential to be a tenured position, non-tenured academic positions, or non-academic positions?
- nonrandomstring 4y agoBy senior I mean "senior or associate professors and lecturers" like myself, and by middle I mean postdoc full lecturers with at least 5-10 years. I don't know what to say about the word "tenured" because it's meaning seems very different in the UK than it is used in USA. In the US I get the idea people think "tenure" makes you impossible fire. Yet here I know of two full professors with over 20 years service, scores of publications and teaching awards in their pockets who were "let go" (forced quit). I know many more who are planning to quit, and there seems a dearth of replacements to step into their shoes.
- pmyteh 4y agoWhere are you based?
- nonrandomstring 4y agoInstitutions? I'm actually really lucky in that I teach internationally at multiple institutions, university and non-university. What's useful and interesting is it gives me a broad taste of politics (as well as a way to stay out of the melee). That's why I'm quite confident in saying generally "universities are in trouble". I've seen it over time and geography. Not all places of higher learning are. Some private and state entities are thriving. What is killing the universities, in my opinion, is they're caught in a no-mans-land, as neither fully state entities, nor private concerns.
- joshgroban 4y agoThis is actually really scary. As American universities become less powerful I shudder to think of what kind of radical politics and cultural narratives will sweep the nation.
- sydthrowaway 4y agoOr China will take over advanced manufacturing.
- nikanj 4y agoTurns out making increasingly complex things was a better strategy than making increasingly complex financial instruments
- daenz 4y ago
- Clubber 4y agoAre you being serious or sarcastic?
- adamsmith143 4y agoIsn't this exactly the opposite of the current state? That the overwhelming power of Universities in the US is what spreads cultural and political movements? I think you could argue that the entire Woke enterprise is centered on Universities particularly elite ones.
- themitigating 4y agoCan you argue that is the source and/or the majority of the people? Maybe the views of a small number of academics have been amplified by those who have opposite political views and a dedicated audience
- adamsmith143 4y ago
- kd913 4y agoAt some point, this nonsense has to stop. Both in the UK and the US. 1) Student loan plans (especially in the UK) are gonna cripple the economy and are vastly unsustainable. Especially given the ridiculous payback terms that change on a whim every year, and vastly unsustainable interest rates. People aren't earning enough to pay them back either. 2) Grants are being used as a negotiation tactic, with EU horizon funding being held hostage by the NI protocol negotiations. 3) There looks to be a sharp drop off of Chinese student inflows post-covid. 4) We are hitting a bump where we will soon see the population curve drop, and a dramatically reduced number of people attending Uni. 5) As much as people decry the pension changes, I have seen the values given to senior professors and academics. They are vastly unsustainable. 6) University appears to be hitting a weird point of serving too many functions. It props up real-estate, loads millennials/gen-X with debt, acts as a adult school, and provides critical research. A lot of these functions should frankly be split up for different purposes. Don't even get me started in regards to the current ridiculous scheme used to train junior doctors and nurses. 7) Given we have had 2 years of at home lecturing, at what point does the value of this come into question? Professors barely learning how to use a laptop are not worth 3x an open university degree. 8) At some point someone is gonna realize that the paper generated by some of these institutions is not gonna help in a rapidly shrinking junior job market. The nature of which appears to be rapidly changing. 9) Current Universities work on vastly exploiting their phd students, supervisors, postgrads and teaching assistants at close to minimum wage. People are gonna realize this isn't worth it, especially with rapid CoL rises.
- Espressosaurus 4y ago> 7) Given we have had 2 years of at home lecturing, at what point does the value of this come into question? Professors barely learning how to use a laptop are not worth 3x an open university degree. Two years of home lecturing that by all accounts has resulted in close to two years of lost progress if my observation of teachers complaining about ill-prepared students is anything to go by.
- bee_rider 4y agoI think I noticed more divergence in the level of preparation (although, didn't try to quantify it -- grad student here, limited responsibility/scope/ability to make change, so just informal observations). It makes sense -- with at-home instruction there's less of an opportunity to just passively check in with students, remote lectures are easier to ignore, and it is easier to cheat on tests when they are remote (so, unprepared students can get through more easily). In particular -- it was a real struggle to get my first year college students to do any group work (an opportunity they'd usually jump at, because 50% responsibility, right?). If this actually is the case, it is a really unfortunate outcome. I'm opposed to getting kids sick/exposing them to "mystery long-term health consequences." But setting them up for academic regression is also no good. All in all, 0/10 pandemic, would not pandemic again. Not sure there could have been a positive outcome. Not sure what the least-bad option could have been. I wish we'd done more, though. I think we may have failed. I wish we'd tried some really out there strategies. A pet idea I wanted to suggest was having the students on campus and organizing them by major into units -- so, your dorm/floor (depending on the size of the building) is all your-major students and it forms a unit. Call it the Harry Potter strategy. You can socialize normally with each other, maybe classrooms are assigned to a given unit. Maybe a grad student is assigned to (live with?) the unit (hard, though, grad students have their own lives going on and I guess they wouldn't want to restrict themselves enough to safely interact in person with the students -- I don't think I could). Lectures could be broadcast to the unit, with some local representative for the instructor. No interactions between units, but at least the students would have some peers to interact with. But I don't anyone would have been brave enough take responsibility for this sort of thing safety-wise (I certainly wouldn't), and I don't know that I'd trust the average school to work out all the details. But if it worked out, it could have been really something! Actually, I guess we're far along enough to see if anywhere tried that out, and if so, if it worked out.
- stanford_labrat 4y agoNot sure I count as mid career yet(graduated 2018, starting PhD 2022) but I can certainly echo the sentiment. I work in life sciences academia and if it were not for me leaving for school I 100% would be swapping to industry. I’m even quitting a bit earlier than anticipated because I’m fed up. I’ve been getting a lot more recruitment outreach this spring, some good some bad. The biggest thing is that they’re offering sometimes up to 2x my salary. My institution already compensates much higher than most schools (I make 70k, most research techs make like 30k-40k) so this was quite striking. Also hours are better, etc. A better barometer perhaps would be the postdocs I know, the majority of which are not bothering to pursue academia. Only 2 that I’m aware of landed tenure track faculty jobs. I personally have no plans to stay in academia unless I somehow land a tenure track faculty position at a R1 university which might as well be like winning the lottery. I’ll stick to industry or leverage my training to go into patent law/science policy/biotech investing.
- yCombLinks 4y agoA standard career is about 40 years, so mid career is about 20 years in
- qmmmur 4y agoI’m a post doc now and it’s as far as I’m tolerating to go. The system is and I personally can have a much better life just not being in it. M
- quantum_magpie 4y agoMid-career would be associate professor or equivalent in non-teaching institution, where you begin to establish your own group, and have your own doctoral fellows. A postdoc/research associate would be early career researcher, where you still are a member of a research group, but might have bachelor's and master's students under your supervision.
- rr808 4y agoBaby boomers retiring is going to hit most faculty very hard. Not sure if it means new opportunities for the younger staff or just the whole department will fall apart.
- RandomWorker 4y agoI left academia for a software company, not midway my career but at the early start. The decision is easy when you have mouths to feed, wages don’t keep up, and I can earn double my salary doing the fun part of my work (ML+optimization+data/energy modelling in civil engineering space) literally the next day. I was working with all kinds of companies to help them get started with this kind of work. Instead of sending my students I just leapt and it’s been a tremendous experience. If I return I will be a better professor, however not publishing for a couple of years may kill that dream. Right now, it’s a great feeling not to have to worry about food and I can actually focus more on doing my job better. I feel bad about leaving my group, but they can find someone more hungry than me that wants it more.
- samvher 4y agoWhat you mention as “the fun part” does sound pretty interesting. Sounds like you’re contracting/consulting? Any advice on finding assignments in the field? (For someone with a DS + non-civil engineering background)
- dagw 4y agoI worked in civil engineering up until 6 month ago and every civil engineering company I know is desperate to hire people that know ML/simulation/modeling etc. Civil Engineering is seen as a deeply unsexy field compared to other tech industries and they're having a hard time recruiting.
- dc-programmer 4y agoAre non-PE’s treated as first class citizens? Also is there room for developers to grow in an engineering firm. It sounds interesting in a concrete way (pun intended), but it seems similar to working for a research university in that you are viewed as more of a laborer as mentioned in a recent post
- dagw 4y agoIt's getting a lot better on all those fronts, but there is still work to be done. When I started we where much more seen as support and assistants that could occasionally be called on help out the Real Engineers on the Real Projects. When I left my last company, there was an actual Data Science department with its own projects, management structure and place in the org chart. I was a Senior Specialist Engineer in Data Science when I left with exactly the same 'rank' and pay grade as any other Senior Specialist Engineer. The biggest problem was that the higher ups in the organisation still had a very fuzzy idea on how/when/why to actually deploy ML/data science etc. in projects, but at least they where aware of this shortcoming and working to address it. You are going to have to 'sell' yourself and your skills and spend time convincing people that you bring real bottom line value to projects, and there is still scepticism among the old guard that data science can bring anything of value that you will have to overcome. On the plus side I found lots of opportunities to get involved in all kinds of varying projects from crowd simulation to using ML to create predictive geotechnical models. Since no one really knows the best way to use these new tools within civil engineering I found a lot of room for doing essentially R&D. I also found that civil engineers seem to have a much more sane view on work-life balance compared to software engineers and so the work hours and levels of work where much more reasonable than I've seen in many software companies. The flip side to this is that the pay is on the whole lower compared to software companies.
- etempleton 4y agoA few things have happend recently: 1. Covid was hard on education from kindergarten through college. Systems and processes that were already stressed to the max became overloaded and everyone was asked to do more and sometimes take a pay cut or have reduced benefits while doing so. 2. Society stopped valuing education as much. While once educators traded lower pay for the prestige of being a professor they can’t really say it is a worthy trade anymore as a vocal minority do not value education at all. 3. Faculty no longer run colleges/ universities. Once faculty ran everything, but as regulations have tightened and colleges started getting sued for any number of things professional administrators started being required because the jobs got bigger. In theory this has created less work for faculty, but they now feel disconnected and impotent.
- robwwilliams 4y agoPerfect set of comments! Thanks.
- sai_c 4y ago"2. Society stopped valuing education as much. While once educators traded lower pay for the prestige of being a professor they can’t really say it is a worthy trade anymore as a vocal minority do not value education at all." I can totally see why that is the case. Raised in a classical worker family and observing how my peers from childhood are doing, I can imagine where this is coming from. Most of them were also raised as workers kids (i.e. both parents working in mindless jobs in a factory and earning barely enough to raise the kids), but some had the chance to go earn a BS or MS. Yet, they are financially struggling for severals reasons. Also, they have a hard time explaining to their parents why they can't afford a house, vacation, a new car and all the things their parents never had, but wanted their kids to have. So all the reasons their parents fought to get them a good education are nullified. I know getting a good education is of value in and of itself, but the reality is, that most parents want a good education for their kids because they want them to be financially successful, not for humanistic reasons (remember who attended universities in their beginning and why, it was aristocrats with a lot of time and money). So to play the devil's advocate, what value has this education, if my kids still struggle in life, just they way I am? And why should I have "high esteem" for the people teaching, if what they offer has so little practical value?
- icelancer 4y agoI am going the other way, humorously enough. I know a few people who are, too - people who made their mark in the "private" sector, made enough money via their own small business / startup / MANGA job, and are pursuing a graduate-level degree lazily over a half-decade with ideas of teaching part-time for fun. Surely doesn't help people who want to make actual money doing the job, but it doesn't seem like that's realistic for 90% of people anyway.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoMy niece left academia for Draper Labs, where she has had a very productive career. Done far more for society than she would have, at a school. Instead of struggling for grants for her basic and applied research, often finding herself unfunded for a term or year unexpectedly, she's funded liberally and makes quick progress on important issues. Never looked back. Something is broken in Academia.
- fundad 4y agoIs she making weapons?
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoCures
- fundad 4y agoGreat
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoHere she is! https://www.worcestermag.com/story/lifestyle/2021/01/13/last-call-jenna-balestrini-wpi-grad-treating-cancer/6616904002/ https://www.worcestermag.com/story/lifestyle/2021/01/13/last...
- inglor_cz 4y agoAltos Labs, the billionaires' longevity moonshot, seems to be able to recruit from the academia very efficiently with three promises: good money, no unnecessary paperwork and the ability to choose your research topics freely, without a "publish or perish" sword of Damocles hanging over your head.
- pvaldes 4y agoYep, in most cases is as simple as that
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoYears ago i had an option to start an academic carreer (after finishing my studies), and the basic situation back then was publish-or-parish for titles and etting your own EU/locally funded projects/grants and doing most of the stuff yourself, while being limited a lot by paycheck (you're still a public employee) and promotions to tenured positions, because basically, the person there had to die, since it was impossible to remove them, and almost none of them retired voulontarily... So I said "nope".
- nieksand 4y agoI've heard that publish-or-parish is a challenge for all theologians.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoSadly, you'd need someone way above a theologian to fix touchscreen typing with disabled autocorrect :)
- rednerrus 4y agoHow is this possible? Hasn't academia been cranking out more academics than they've needed for the past 40 years?
- lvl102 4y agoIt’s difficult for me to feel bad for these institutions. They jacked up tuitions and caused an entire generation of people to carry lifetime of crippling debt.
- JoeJonathan 4y agoIt's not like universities are just lining their pockets. I'm a humanities professor at a small liberal arts college with a high tuition, and we struggle to pay professors fair wages (when compared to peer institutions, which doesn't even account for differences in cost of living, and we're in an HCOL city). I do not fully understand the economics of higher education—they're complex and often opaque—but a few things to keep in mind: 1. Tuition seems absurd, but very few students pay the sticker price. At my institution, average cost after aid is 39% of average cost before aid, and less than some of the private K-12 schools in this city. 2. "These institutions" are not a monolith. See above—especially when it comes to prestigious schools, many students aren't paying close to sticker price. 3. Families and students expect much more from colleges than they did a few decades ago, both in terms of facilities and staffing. I don't know if anyone's done a study of student wellness center staff sizes, but I wouldn't be surprised if they doubled over the past two years. 4. The sciences (and things like conservatories) are particularly expensive because of equipment/lab costs. Someone has to pay for all this. I think more should come from the corporate America (not sure how), which benefits greatly from these programs, but I'd venture to guess most comes from tuition and government grants.
- lvl102 4y agoHere’s my counter argument: public high schools do it for far less. Outside of maybe 40 research institutes in the US, the rest offer about the same education as a good public high school. It’s really not unheard of to hear college grads say they got better education at their high schools vs college. Secondly, these schools are TAX EXEMPT. They use endowments to basically buy buildings all the time. A great example of this is NYU. Really a mediocre school but happens to be the biggest real estate player in one of the most expensive markets in the world.
- cwmoreiras 4y ago
- meling 4y agoProf. from Norway here. While it sounds like the situation in the US and UK is worse than our own, I’m seriously considering moving to industry after 20 years in academia. Mainly fed up by ever growing admin, and stupid financial oversight regulations, and the general workload… and many other things that isn’t wise to complain about publicly.
- jdshaffer 4y agoAssociate Professor from Japan... and I can relate completely. Love teaching, love my students, but get totally burnt out on admin, committees, "extra" duties and the like. Makes moving to another field look very tempting at times.
- muldoc 4y agoNon-academic. Can you list some examples of what you mean by admin?
- meling 4y agoI could probably list ten examples, but I will limit myself to two easy (or not) to explain examples. 1. To take my research group to dinner, e.g., if a visitor comes to town, requires that I submit a form with about ten fields. We have to name all attendees, date and time of dinner. When the form is submitted, some admin will call the restaurant to organize that the bill is sent to the university. But before all this, I have to call the restaurant to make a reservation. (One time I forgot this and it caused a lot of confusion… I thought the whole idea was to get approval before booking.) Then if the admin approve, it goes to my department head who also has to approve. Actually, before the whole process I have to get an informal approval from my HoD. All this requires a lot of careful planning with all attendees and so forth… it may not sound so bad, but I didn’t mention that the admins require that we submit the form at least five work days in advance to be guaranteed processing in time for the dinner… that’s a lot of hassle pre-dinner… compared to the previous approach; ask HoD if ok, go to dinner, pay with CC, submit receipt and get reimbursed. (Sorry the explanation became more complicated than necessary because I couldn’t remember the ordering of the steps off the top of my head… goes without saying — we spend a lot less funds on dinners after this system was introduced, which is why I keep forgetting the steps…) 2. Our travel reimbursement system is based on the infamous SAP platform… last time I traveled I spent four hours filling the form. We need to provide loads of unnecessary details. And every minor change to a form field requires a save to the database, which typically takes about a second or two in the best case. The system is broken. They keep hiring more admins that are supposed to help. The result is more admin tasks being pushed down to the faculty…
- upupandup 4y agoFor someone with decades experience in software industry, is it possible to take on part-time teaching positions in universities? Is it worth the balance? Seems kinda cool to teach students and come up with course materials.
- culopatin 4y agoYou’ll find that many will want a PhD for you to teach an if else regardless of your experience and will pay you 20k for part time.
- upupandup 4y agoyeah this is a major blocker for me, not the money (Although it would help if they pay more) but the social credit required AND the competition. all in all I am not fond of the academia industry and the hierarchy.
- culopatin 4y agoIdk how much competition there is. I can’t imagine having a PhD and choosing to teach intro to programming for 40k full time unless I have nothing better to do.
- MikeTheGreat 4y agoYes! Absolutely! In fact, any college will be thrilled that you're interested. Owing to several factors it's very, very difficult to find people who have a software engineering background and are looking to teach. Please do look at part-time ("adjunct") positions at any universities, colleges, and community colleges near you!
- t_mann 4y agoDefinitely consider it! Financially, you'll barely break even in the beginning after accounting for commuting and how much work it is to set up a course initially, but emotionally it's very rewarding. As a nice perk, sometimes students (usually the smartest ones) will ask you if you have projects for them to dig deeper, so you've got a great talent pool at your hand.
- 13415 4y agoI'll leave for sure, but for other reasons than in CS. In CS people leave because they get better salaries and have better job prospects outside academia. In my area, people leave because of lack of career prospects, almost no tenure-track positions, favoritism and corruption. But the decisive reason for me is that our small & poor European country has switched to the new "Pan S" for open science publications. This may seem like a good idea at first, isn't it great that every publication for a funding authority needs to be open access? Well, the problem is that in my area there are at most two good and free open access journals. At most. Every top journal is run by traditional publishers, and funding authorities have explicitly stated they will discourage and limit payment of open access fees. Ironically, the better the journal, the higher the open access fees, and the less it is possible to get funding for them. As nice as open access sounds in theory, in practice this new "Plan S" policy will mean that bullshitters who game the system and shouldn't even be in academia will win big time and can spit out one crappy publication after another. I've met people in my profession who literally said "Who cares if its false? It's another publication in your CV!" The difference between fringe journals and the top journals is unbelievably high in my discipline, people used to even count bad publications negatively, and a few publications in top journals used to give you a tenure-track position. To give you an idea of the difference, the former have acceptance rates of about 100%, the latter have acceptance rates of less than 5%. Now the top journals won't even count any longer at all in evaluations by our funding authority. There is so much crap published nowadays, they should limit the allowed number of publications/year; instead they are going for the opposite, a large number of publications in fringe and even self-published open access journals. Some of my colleagues are already literally starting their own journals. I admit that there are many disciplines where open access works better, but not in mine. Maybe "Plan S" will have great and noble effects in 20-30 years from now, but for the generation in-between it's a complete disaster for anyone interested in quality. For me that's the decisive reason to leave.
- anonymousDan 4y agoWhat is your discipline and country? That sounds like some ridiculously narrow minded thinking on the part of the funders.
- hintymad 4y agoThe number of administrative staff in universities has been increasing faster that that of faculty. I was wondering if this is the culprit of run-away cost of universities and the culprit of general stagnation of faculty salary.
- robwwilliams 4y agoYes, great book about just this: 1. Benjamin Ginsberg: The Fall of the Faculty. The Rise of the All-Administrative University and Why it Matters. 2. Harry R. Lewis: Excellence without Soul: How a Great University Forgot Education.
- peterhalburt33 4y agoI would also mention David Graeber’s excellent “Bullshit Jobs”
- etempleton 4y agoThe real reason, if you want to get to the core of it, is two-fold: Regulation and changing consumer expectation driven by cheap loans. Colleges and universities prior to perhaps the 90s weren't all that concerned about the student experience, health resources, quality of the dorms, dining, fitness center, etc, etc, etc. Regulation and accreditation has become more stringent because some for-profit schools have scammed people out of money. Regulation has caused a bunch of positions to be created to make sure that the University is in compliance at all times. Falling out of compliance can cause the university to be sued or lose accreditation. The risk of either is so massive it could close a small college or university so it makes sense to spend as much money as required to mitigate the risk. Cheap loans have changed consumer behavior in the same way low interest rate loans increase the cost of housing. Consumers are willing to spend more to go to the best. But how is a student to determine which school is best? It is impossible to really compare education beyond the general prestige of the university, so how do schools differentiate themselves among similarly ranked schools? New buildings; more and better services; better dorms; better website / marketing materials; better events and activities for students. A good example of this is the student fitness center. Almost every school now has a massive world-class fitness center, not for student athletes, just for students to workout and play rec sports. These are buildings that cost hundreds of millions of dollars. Great, don't build one you say. Pass that savings on to the students. That is fine, but students will, without fail, choose the school with the giant fitness center. And it can't just be a nice fitness center, it has to be on-par or better than what other schools have. Schools that are closing their doors are the ones that have left themselves open to risk (compliance, cybersecurity, accessibility, etc) or have not kept up with the arms race for amenities.
- seydor 4y agonothing else actively promotes and engages with minorities as the academia does. If these people can't make it in that environment, i doubt they can make it in open competition. On of the 'good' things of academia being turned to a paperpushing administration exercise is that it's easy (albeit boring) to do that kind of job at any level.
- tpmx 4y agoLol, no.
- huitzitziltzin 4y agoFor me personally yes it has. I’m leaving my academic position for industry this year. (Technically I’m “on leave” for a year but I am not going to come back barring something insane happening.) For anyone else in my shoes considering the move, I will say that while money isn’t everything I am going to very nearly quadruple my salary by going into industry. I know I’ll have a boss and more boring meetings than I have now, but I am not convinced that I’m going to work more hours.
- timwaagh 4y agowith the emphasis on diversity these institutions have its not unsurprising they have a harder time hiring the people most suitable to this kind of work.
- cyrksoft 4y agoI'm surprised how very few departments within most universities actually make money. If you had a company where most products lost money you would stop producing them. Universities have a lot of departments and degrees that bleed money. I don't understand how anybody thinks that you can have good wages like this. I worked as an Econ professor and visiting academic in top Business Schools in Latin America and the East Coast (USA), and I can tell you that Business Schools make A LOT of money. They charge whatever they want and people (in most cases, their employers) pay them. In many cases Business Schools can amount up to 40/50% of the universities' revenue. That is also why business professors are paid a lot more. I personally know people at London Business School making more than £ 200,000 a year. Salaries at INSEAD are very similar as well. Of course, salaries at top US Business Schools are even higher. My point is that you cannot run a business where one or two products make money and the remaining 90% bleed it. That is, if you want to run it as a business and attract talent and pay nice wages. If you want to run universities as some type of public good, then good luck. Pay everybody the same and offer as many degrees as you'd like. Good luck hiring competent people...
- j7ake 4y agoIsn’t VC funds structured such a way that one or two startups make it while 90 percent fail? University outputs seem to be comparable in this sense. The patent for Gatorade alone has brought in probably 100 million to U of Florida.
- cyrksoft 4y agoThat might be the case. But universities are not startups. In one of the universities I worked at they had a four-year long History undergraduate degree. Between 5 and 10 students chose it each year (the entire university has around 5,000 students, give or take). That means that there are around 30 students combined. For these 30 students, there were more than 40 full time academics! There are more professors than students. All this is possible because they had 2,000 undergraduate business students, and 1,000 business postgraduate students paying 3x or 4x what a History student paid in tuition fees. I know this might be an extreme case, but it is not that rare. You cannot run a sustainable business like that. Of course History professors made a lot less than their business counterparts, and they complained a lot.
- cudgy 4y ago“increasing right-wing hostility towards academics” is listed as a reason for academics leaving. Is this true? Isn’t the power structure in a academics dominated by individuals that lean left? Most of the stories I have read regard academics being driven out by woke staff and students.
- fundad 4y agoThe right-wing hostility comes from the State govts at state schools or Fox News shitheads that send their audiences after an author of some book they want banned. Also there was a Trump executive order that threatened ALL govt funding to any org that commits a thought crime and that will return as soon as Republicans win the WH
- hydrok9 4y agoIt drove me out before I even got there! (pre-masters)
- stillbourne 4y agoWorkers in universities are broadly divided into two categories. Academics, which are usually under the direction of the Provost, and Administration, which is just a bucket for everyone else. From my experience people in the academics side are treated in a completely different manner than administration. If the great resignation were to hit academia it would probably happen on the administration side as those personnel of treated like garbage, underpaid and understaffed, and shit on by every person with a Dr. in front of their name. When I was working at Regis as a software developer they wouldn't pay me more than $65k/year when the going rate was $85k for a Jr. After 5 years as a software dev there I jumped ship and got a dev job with a Sr. title for $120k. They've never been able to replace me with a better dev because no one will work for those kind of poverty wages in Denver.