13 ms·
Sick of Windows but can't afford a Mac? The cynic's guide to desktop Linux
- iLoveOncall 4y agoI honestly cannot believe that a person that uses both Windows and Mac frequently in 2022 would choose Mac if they had to choose a single platform. Not even a developer. MacOS is a masterclass in bad design and lackluster features. I always considered buying a Mac but was always hesitant to change. Once I got one for work I swore to never ever spend a dime on a Mac. People that will disagree haven't used Windows in years.
- bzzzt 4y agoOne mans lackluster features is another mans streamlined interface. MacOS at least goes out of your way most of the time. Windows interrupts you regularly for stuff that's not important to whatever you're doing. Combined with third-party applications that are noisy as heck to make sure you don't forget you bought/installed them (especially AV scanners, but it seems like every app wants a place in your system tray and has it's own updater and wants your attention when it updates). But if Windows does what you need and doesn't cause you friction just use it instead of crapping on macOS.
- Lapsa 4y agonot like my opinion matters much, but I feel that Apple's stuff was great in year 2010. not so much nowadays. I don't know what would be a reason to favor macOS over Linux
- landmass 4y agoWhen it it runs, Linux is great, but when something breaks fixing it can be labor intensive. When something on Mac stops working a call to Mac support will usually fix it in a couple of hours. That said, I agree with your 2010 estimate of Mac software peaking in 2010. Mac laptop hardware is still better than Linux laptop hardware. As someone who's considering my first Linux laptop, I need to balance the inconveniences of Linux hardware now with the likely fact I can probably use that laptop significantly longer than current Mac. Somebody has to pay for all those convenient Mac support folks.
- hollandheese 4y ago>Mac laptop hardware is still better than Linux laptop hardware. As someone who's considering my first Linux laptop, I need to balance the inconveniences of Linux hardware now with the likely fact I can probably use that laptop significantly longer than current Mac. Somebody has to pay for all those convenient Mac support folks. The funny thing about that is that it's only with the Apple Silicon Macs that's true. The 2016-2020 Intel MacBooks were a garbage fire.
- kaba0 4y agoThe goddamn last intel MacBook Pro manages to legit burn my hand if I don’t use a program that forces the vents on.. Like sure, I do hate the sound of a vent but when I am actively using a laptop for writing or something and it is scorching hot then please choose the annoying noise over boiling my skin. Though I feel these things are more like Apple assuming that an intel proc is the same as an M1 that hardly heats up.
- iLoveOncall 4y ago> Windows interrupts you regularly for stuff that's not important to whatever you're doing. It has literally never happened to me. However it happens weekly on Mac, where I will lose the focus of my window and be prompted for an update.
- dmitriid 4y ago> where I will lose the focus of my window and be prompted for an update. That you can disable in System Preferences. On Windows Home, for example, updates cannot be disabled, and the OS will install them even if this means ruining everything you're doing.
- cassianoleal 4y agomacOS updates are notified using the native notification subsystem. It's inobtrusive and definitely does not take the focus away from app windows.
- arprocter 4y agoI discovered recently you can set notifications on macOS to 'do not disturb' System Preferences -> Notifications -> Do Not Disturb I set Turn On Do Not Disturb 'from 12:01AM to 11:59PM'
- bmitc 4y ago> One mans lackluster features is another mans streamlined interface. MacOS at least goes out of your way most of the time. That is really just not true. I don't even think one could consider it an opinion. Irregardless of what Windows does, macOS constantly gets in your way. Try to rename iTunes, because that's the only way to keep it from opening every time you connect your non-Apple Bluetooth headphones (there's a convoluted procedure to do so). Try to control the brightness or volume of an external monitor. You cannot. Even the monitor itself isn't as good as it is on Windows due to poor resolution and text handling on macOS, and a Macbook Pro with a discrete video card struggles to drive the monitor. External mice and keyboards are touch and go with macOS and reset settings nearly on a daily basis for me. Developer tools, such as asdf or others installed from Homebrew are incredibly finicky and often require workarounds depending on whatever macOS version you're on and whatever thing it decided to break. (For example, it's actually easier to get Erlang's observer running on WSL on Windows with the GUI interface than it is on macOS, which requires all sorts of hacks in Homebrew.) I don't know why Apple doesn't get the same hate as Windows, because my Macbook Pro constantly installs stuff all on its own. I get pinged by several apps to update through their own update mechanism on macOS.
- choko 4y agoThe auto-launching of itunes when I get off a call using my Bluetooth headset is super annoying! If it weren't for the CLI Mac would be worthless for development. The only reason I have one is for work, and only because I'm not allowed to use my own hardware (which would be a laptop with debian).
- bmitc 4y agoYou can get rid of iTunes launching by renaming it. If I recall correctly, there are a bunch of possible workarounds but that's the one that definitely works if you don't care about iTunes. But it required getting IT approval for upgraded permissions and then a whole reboot into safe mode and change the name procedure using some setting or shell command (something like that). I think it was like two or three reboots to change the name of the iTunes application, but I don't recall the exact procedure. My CLI do you mean the Unix-like underlying system (like through Terminal, zsh, bash, etc.)? I enjoy WSL on Windows more because it's actually Linux and usually just works. The only trouble I have there sometimes is network related activities, as is usual for VM-like setups.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>Windows interrupts you regularly for stuff that's not important to whatever you're doing. Really not my current experience and I use W10 daily at work and W11 at home. Not saying it's a good OS, just saying that your statement is plain wrong. If certain (third party) apps are annoying then you can control notifications through the focus assist setting just like with any mobile OS.
- phendrenad2 4y agoExactly. The only "interruptions" I get on my Windows machine are from my AV, and the lower-right-corner popup alerts don't steal focus from my current window.
- 10x-dev 4y agoBased on this one comment, I think you should learn to disambiguate between facts and your subjective opinion. We all have our preferences, obviously, but to assert that MacOS UI is 'a masterclass in bad design and lackluster features' is a grandiose exaggeration stated as fact.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoI'm pretty sure the finder lacking basic features such as cut-paste or copying the path to the current folder is a fact. The finder alone would be enough to justify my statement, but it's just a small part of the numerous issues of MacOS. The dock leaving empty space on 50% of the width of your monitor is also a fact. Or having to run a weird command in the CLI to add an empty space as separator in the dock. Or having no "Apply to all displays" when changing background images on monitors. That's just 30 seconds out of the top of my head.
- lproven 4y agoTry to bear in mind that while there is nothing wrong with wanting what you want, others may not share your desires. I've been using Macs since 1988 and I've never wanted your point 1, 3, or 4, and my dock doesn't take 50% of the width of the screen, it takes about 5% of it because it's on the side where it belongs and where it was on NeXTstep. So none of this has ever applied to me, and TBH, I can't even imagine it applying to me.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoDid you miss the part where I say that you shouldn't bother commenting if you aren't using Windows frequently? You just don't know how bad you have it, that's it. But sure, MacOS is great, go back to installing a 3rd party software to snap windows xD
- kcartlidge 4y ago(I use Windows 10 and MacOS on M1 daily, Linux Mint almost as often) Linux wins for dev and loses for apps. Windows wins for apps and loses for dev. Mac is second-best at both which is why I prefer it. That said, I'd love to be running production-ready Mint on my M1 Air. Edit: I forgot to say, and it's the reason I responded to you in the first place, that I agree. It's really sad that something like Rectangle has to exist just to get decent window handling.
- unsupp0rted 4y agoIf millions of professionals are doing a thing a certain way, either they're all wrong and crazy or there's something I'm missing. It's a Chesterton's Fence situation: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Chesterton's_fence http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Chesterton's_fence
- iLoveOncall 4y agoIt's not. The reasoning behind the popularity of MacOS is very well understood: marketing.
- unsupp0rted 4y agoIf it were marketing, then I could leave MacOS for Windows or Linux. I cannot (without making my work harder for no net gain).
- dmitriid 4y agoWhat amazes me is that people who pride themselves on being smart when faced with Apple always resort to the laziest and most stupid of explanations for Apple's popularity: "marketing". While marketing does play a bog role, it is still rooted in the reality: Apple makes good products (that are often leagues better than the competition in several areas), and as a whole the experience of using Apple products is better for a significant number of people.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoWhat amazes me is that Mac fanatics never have any factual argument as to why it would be better than Windows. All I hear are attributes that are supposed to be better (spoiler, they're not), but always without a single concrete example.
- dmitriid 4y ago> What amazes me is that Mac fanatics never have any factual argument First, stop calling people fanatics. And then, and only then, you will hear all the factual arguments.
- ttGpN5Nde3pK 4y ago> Once I got one for work I swore to never ever spend a dime on a Mac +9999999. I wish they'd just sell hardware and keep the OS.
- tootie 4y agoI literally only choose Mac because I'm a developer. Why? Because it is physically impossible to build and test iOS apps or run Safari without one. So long as a huge percentage of our users are on iPhone, we are obligated via Apple's relentless vertical integration to buy macs.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoSo, you don't CHOOSE Mac. You have to use it. That's different and it joins my point. Nobody would choose Mac.
- bmitc 4y agoI fully agree. Other than Preview, there's absolutely nothing about macOS that I miss when I'm not using it, and I used to be a so-called "Mac" person. It's just a collection of compromises between a high-level OS and a Linux-like and a desktop OS and iOS. It is a massive pain, even with Homebrew, to get a development environment that just works and continues to just work. Every macOS update is a game of Russian roulette. On Windows, my development environment is seamless. With WSL, I get an actual Linux distribution. And to be honest, Windows just has a lot less friction than macOS these days. You don't have to jump through all sorts of hoops to actually use your computer. One example of the inanity of macOS and Apple is that in using an external monitor, macOS or the Macbook Pro is incapable of adjusting the brightness and even volume (!) of the external monitor. It's not that the keys don't work. It's that you just simply cannot do it even from the OS. It's absolutely insane people consider Apple the more simple solution. And oh yea, basically every day, my mouse and keyboard settings change or reset or stop working. The exact same setup works flawlessly with my home Windows 11 PC. I setup things, and they stay that way. Updates do not break my computer or reset settings. Applications work. And Windows 11, for whatever reason, does not hog as much RAM as macOS does.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoAs a dev, if I had to choose a single platform it would never be Windows. It’s fine as the OS that I use to play games or occasionally poke at a hobby project in Visual Studio (full fat version, not VS Code) with, but the moment I start trying to use it for actual work it starts driving me insane. It has just as many papercuts as desktop Linux does, just in different places and with far less flexibility to fix any of them. Like yeah, Linux has some legit annoyances but at least I could fix them either by installing a different package or writing something of my own if it’s bothering me badly enough. I certainly wouldn’t choose Windows over macOS. Among macOS, Windows, and Linux, easily Windows is the one that gets booted out. > People that will disagree haven't used Windows in years. Nah, I have a Ryzen 5950X/3080ti tower running Windows 11 (and formerly 10). It gets used at least every other day. I’m plenty familiar with Windows, and it still drives me crazy when using it for anything more than a fancy game console.
- Jcowell 4y agoI have a L shaped setup. My Windows with two monitors on one side, my M1 Mac Mini with an Ultra-wide and mini monitor on the other. I prefer my Mac for Developing every time. It’s a far faster workflow , the trackpad feels amazing, and the ability add my iPad as a third monitor or a side screen via Universal Control is undefeated. I have the Touch ID Keyboard making sign in seamless (and that’s if my Apple Watch doesn’t unlock if first). Everything is fast, smooth, and if I move away from the screen but want to keep looking at what I’m doing (like reading documentation) I can take my iPad and use either Handoff or iCloud tabs to keep it going. If I deviate from my iPad or go somewhere new and want to continue that process, I can airdrop the page to my Mac or use the aforementioned features to do the same. This isn’t even touching document previewing in files but just pressing the spacebar , opening any PDF file in Preview, viewing my synced Notes, calendar, and Mail in the native apps and be assured they’ll show up on my other Apple Devices . All of these things add up to a calm seamless workflow when I develop or do anything on my Mac. All without having to download a single thing. On windows I have to rely on third party services to replicate the same. Added friction that I just don’t have to deal With Mac . It just works (for me). The only edge my windows has over my Mac is gaming (which isn’t an issue for me issue that’s what having a windows machine is for and I prefer having a dedicated machine for that) and windows snapping that I solved using Magnet from the App Store that ensures it’s sandboxes and not collecting data per the App Privacy Page.
- Bright_Machine 4y agoI thought I was the only crazy person who hated Mac OS. Finder is the worst file manager I've ever used. Mac's notification UX is a fucking mess. Not to mention users cannot uninstall pre-installed bloatwares. User account to download from app store? Why the hell should I give an email address and phone number to download apps and SDKs for developement? Also let's not forget that Mac OS sends hash of the application to mothership each time you start it. Unless it sends the hash and verifies it you cannot open the app. I really doubt if it is my computer. Excluding system apps from the VPN? No, thanks.
- leephillips 4y agoI’ve installed Debian on several different kinds of servers and personal computers and it’s been great. The political drama doesn’t affect me. The versions with nonfree drivers, it’s true, are not linked from the Debian website, but there is no problem in finding them. Software versions are not too old, and if I need a more recent release of a program that what’s in the package manager, so far I’ve had no problem finding a binary or compiling it—plus many projects have their own apt repositories, so you can integrate them into the package manager. Before that I used Ubuntu, and find Debian to be a better experience. Especially lately: no need to know what a Snap is, or worry about what weird innovation the Ubuntu people are going to try next to compromise my privacy or security.
- timbit42 4y agoLinux Mint is also a great option that uses dpkg/apt. Not issues with non-free drivers and also no SNAPs. I also previously used Xubuntu and Kubuntu but now have Debian on my desktop and Linux Mint on my laptop and media center, and my wife's and parent's PCs.
- Nursie 4y agoEqually though, you can use snaps if you want to, as I do on my Debian workstation for a few pieces like IntelliJ. Debian's amazing. I've been using it on and off for more that 25 years now. I've used it on x86/amd64, ARM, Sparc and even S390. I've tried Ubuntu, I've worked with various flavours of RH and SLES. But I keep coming back to Debian.
- jagger27 4y agoUbuntu shouldn't be recommended anymore. Flatpak won. Snap is a disaster. If you ask me, Fedora is the new Ubuntu.
- izoow 4y agoAs much as I dislike the direction Ubuntu has been going, the one thing still keeping me on it is the font rendering. I've tried all sorts of font configs and even Ubuntu patches to various packages but never managed to achieve the same result. Font rendering has improved in other distros in recent years, but at least to my eyes Ubuntu still somehow does it better.
- jitl 4y agoLast time I ran Fedora, the update schedule killed my system a few times. I was on a ski trip and wanted to play a movie on the cabin TV, but Fedora did an update and now launching X crashes. Something something, kernel version. Very sad. Has the 6 month release cycle gotten more stable?
- jagger27 4y agoWayland has been the default for several years now, so yes I'd say whatever X-related pain (I can relate) has been eased since then. I'm no Linux-on-the-desktop evangelist however, and still rely on a Mac for work use. My personal desktop runs Fedora currently, where I can afford to tinker. It's getting there.
- 4y ago
- erwan577 4y agoIf Mac are so expensive why are hackintoshes still out of favor ?
- meibo 4y agoThey fall apart at every occasion/update and you're missing out on most of the Apple ecosystem bonus/online infrastructure, which is a big part of why people buy Apple products. They're also naturally stuck on Intel CPUs and the hardware choice is very limiting.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoAs someone who used to maintain a hackintosh, you can get them to work with iCloud, iMessage, Airdrop, Continuity, etc but you need to set the Mac-faking bits in your bootloader (probably OpenCore) correctly, and you might need to select for particular models of wifi/Bluetooth cards. Not particularly straightforward but plenty doable. From what I can see, the popularity of hackintoshing has dropped steeply with the introduction of M-series macs. The biggest driver of hackintoshing was Apple not selling compelling hardware, and that’s mostly been solved.
- mirntyfirty 4y agoI think nowadays they are close to impossible to put together and the article is directed towards the general public.
- jitl 4y agoThey’re delicate, and the ARM situation is probably going to end whatever practicality is left.
- paol 4y ago> It is a truth universally acknowledged that all operating systems suck. This could be engraved in stone. I know the title isn't really serious, but not being able to afford a Mac is not a good reason to use Linux. Use what you want/need/feel comfortable in, otherwise the experience will be miserable.
- raesene9 4y agoWell it has been immortalised in song https://youtu.be/YRlPTbKHIPQ https://youtu.be/YRlPTbKHIPQ
- paol 4y agoWell that was a blast from the past! Both the voice and the sketch seemed familiar, turns out that guy used to be part of Three Dead Trolls in a Baggie. I still have mp3s of their sketches stashed away somewhere. Edit: a classic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1LLTsSnGWMI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1LLTsSnGWMI
- hvs 4y agoSo, your suggestion if you can't afford a Mac is to... buy a Mac?
- pc86 4y agoI think it was probably more that cost alone is not enough reason to choose Linux, and if you can't afford a Mac it's unlikely you actually need the Mac for any Mac-specific purpose.
- lproven 4y agoUsed Macs are a thing. Old ones can be quite cheap. I still run a 2009 MacBook Pro (for my partner) and a 2011 Mac Mini. Both max out at 10.13 but they work 100% fine, run the latest browsers etc., and do all we need.
- wazoox 4y agoFrankly, I have a Mac too and I don't like it much. I keep it for the ability to run some pieces of proprietary software like Cubase and Garmin Express and similar tools to keep my gear updated, but OTOH I really dislike the overall software experience. If only it wasn't so painful to dual-boot linux on it, it would probably live running Linux 99% of the time (but when I need to flash some gizmo or import some proprietary music files).
- throw93232 4y agoMacbook air is like $1000. People can afford it. Problem is shitty hardware. SSD soldered to motherboard, bad cooling, no touchscreen, broken keyboard, no way to replace battery...
- meibo 4y ago$1000 is a lot of money for a lot of people, including me - I could afford it for sure, but yes - absolutely 0 upgradeability and repairability, even on the more expensive models, makes me never want to spend any of my own money on their products. I think Framework is going the right way here and their prices are extremely competitive when you compare them with the higher-tier macbooks, especially if you need more storage or RAM. They don't have anything that competes with the $1k Air, which is also sort of crippled by storage and RAM in the $1k configuration, but I'd guess that's a matter of time.
- ufo 4y agoIn Brazil where I'm from a Macbook Air costs about ~8x the average monthly income. It's out of reach for most people.
- anta40 4y agoI just checked local marketplaces (I'm in Jakarta, BTW): Macbook Air M1 13" 16 GB 256 GB (the minimum configuration for us, mobile devs) is around $1400. Sure not cheap, but on the otherside lots of us have monthly income > $1000, especially if you are a senior or team lead on unicorn startups. So... still manageable.
- durnygbur 4y ago> Macbook air is like $1000. People can afford it. Bought Macbook Air in 2019 directly from Apple website. Paid extra for miserable 256GB SSD and 16 RAM. Over EUR 1800 in total, its current resell value is EUR 700. Apple customer service doesn't exist in the EU country where I'm located. Now when I even think of buying Apple product I hear subconscious voice "you will be violated financially".
- thetinguy 4y ago
- jitl 4y agoI think my ideal Linux OS is probably Ubuntu/CentOS + something like macOS’s .app bundle file format for distributing end-user applications. When running personal Linux, I want things to generally “just work”, which means staying away from the distro package managers on Debian/Redhat derivatives. Given enough “hobby time” I manage to twist my base system’s packages into pretzels and/or break workflow critical software by noodling around. Back in the day I inflicted a lot of pain on myself trying to get newer Apache running on older Debian or similar. Third-party package repos, PPAs, or installing from source are all false prophets that eventually swamp the system in strangeness. At least for server software, Docker solves this problem completely and totally. As long as your kernel is new and you have plenty of disk space, it’s trivial to run anything so long as it doesn’t need to integrate with the host OS for a good experience. Docker turned my hobby home server experience from “periodic distress” into “years of smooth sailing”. No matter how weird the server, I can bottle it inside a Docker container. This works because server software integration relies on a few primitives - sockets, boring files, env vars - and coupling is loose. The same cannot be said for the “Docker for GUIs” stuff like Flatpack/AppImage/Snap, at least the last time I tried Linux on Desktop. I had issues with theme mismatch, weird fonts, broken clipboard, media hotkey problems, etc etc last time I tried Ubuntu & Fedora with these tools. Sure it’s better than running X clients in a docker container, but there were still many issues. Snap on Ubuntu was also slow - how come the calculator snap is slower than a calculator Docker? The issue is there’s tons of wild plumbing needed for GUI apps. Gconf (which is a windows registry clone?), dbus, something something Wayland, arbitrary sandboxing, .desktop files, whatever’s responsible for sound on the host… oy. I look at systems like Nix or Guix with admiration — they offer an interesting tradeoff, but fundamentally represent a better version of a distro package manager. You can install software from the OS repo without worrying about internal conflicts… but now you’re using a weird system that’s much more difficult for software to understand. Also, I need to learn a new programming language (or whatever Nix is) to use it. Maybe one day I’ll go back to school or retire and I’ll have enough free time for this to sound fun. I want to download apps as zip files from an upstream, unzip, and double click to run. Copy apps between systems with drag and drop. Never worry about incompatible versions of dynamic libraries. And my apps should use my system theme and respect my font and DPI settings, and have access to whichever files I want to work on. In short I want the ROX desktop dream, but for all Linux apps. http://rox.sourceforge.net/desktop/about_rox.html http://rox.sourceforge.net/desktop/about_rox.html
- nix23 4y agoTerrible article with lot's of errors: >So it bought CentOS, then killed it, as it did with CoreOS https://www.centos.org/ https://www.centos.org/ <- The recommended linux by Cern https://getfedora.org/en/coreos?stream=stable https://getfedora.org/en/coreos?stream=stable <- Oh sorry it's now Fedora CoreOS >SUSE Linux Enterprise – which is to say it has a painfully slow release cycle. 1 year is painfull? >"Tumbleweed", has a rolling release model, which means the exciting potential of breaking changes every single day. No, that's why tumbleweed is not exactly a rolling distribution but a snapshot to snapshot rolling distro.
- sascha_sl 4y agoDid you really miss RedHat killing CentOS 8? The support was supposed to last to 2029 if I remember correctly. It was cut to end of 2021. Stream is a different product for a different audience. And CoreOS from the company CoreOS is actually dead. Fedora CoreOS is built from scratch. It's very similar to Fedora IoT (runs rpm-ostree, podman, ignition), but it downstreams to RHCOS, which you only get with OpenShift. Neither resemble CoreOS. The biggest fork of real CoreOS is Flatcar Linux. Also, Leap minor upgrades do not come with upstream version bumps, so in a sense, yes, the release cycle of Leap and SLES is 3-4 years. RHEL 8 and RHEL 8.1 are not different releases either.
- lproven 4y ago[Article author here] Thanks for that. Genuinely. :-)
- nix23 4y ago>Did you really miss RedHat killing CentOS 8 It's not death it's just "stream" now, and Centos7 is still without stream >Fedora CoreOS is built from scratch. Yes and? It's not death, you don't want to support different software for the same goal, flannel, docker etc. >the release cycle of Leap and SLES is 3-4 years Not true Leap15.3 = SLES15sp3. RHEL has the ~same kernel for every dot release, that's not the case with SLES SP's. Every SP has a new/different kernel and new software. You can do that "partially" with modules on RHEL, but just certain packages are in modules. You can't compare SLES SP's and RHEL dot-releases.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y ago"Ubuntu is an ancient African word that means I can't configure Debian.*" I did chuckle, because I am still learning that ( Devuan is in my VM now, but it is something of an uphill battle so far ). I just installed PopOS over my Ubuntu media PC and have not looked back. Yes, it is Ubuntu derivative and it has annoying moments, but it does get a lot right. I keep recommending it to my social circle, when they complain about their Windows.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- severak_cz 4y agoThey missed Elementary OS - Linux distro designed to look like open source/bootleg version of Mac.
- hollandheese 4y agoA Bootleg of Mac OS X 10.6-10.9. Thank god, they're not bootlegging the 10.10-10.15 look and especially not the 11/12 look.
- lproven 4y agoHi. Article author here. No, I didn't. Also, if you wish, you can read my review of Elementary from a few months ago: https://www.theregister.com/2021/12/21/elementary_os_61/ https://www.theregister.com/2021/12/21/elementary_os_61/ To counter your points: • I tried to pick 10 of the most widely-used distros. I do not think Elementary would make that list. • I don't think it has any more than a trivial cosmetic resemblance to macOS. • While I admire the coherence of its design, I found its usability and customizability notably poor, and its UI rather annoying.
- senectus1 4y agoI dont understand how you could have a cynics guide and not include Gentoo. Gentoo is the distro for people that dont believe ANY distro is properly compiled for their particular hardware. Gentoo users spend hours/days/weeks compiling and recompiling kernels and applications so they they might squeeze and extra millisecond or two of performance from their PC. Its pure cynical masochism for the consumer market.
- lproven 4y agoIs it in the top 10 most widely used distros? I don't think so. That's why it falls under my #0: niche distros.
- lsofzz 4y agoI have two macs. And, yes, I surely I can afford many more of it. But, whether you own a mac or not, once you start using Linux (and it takes patience to do so _effectively_), I can guarantee that you _will_ never want to use anything else. - Linux user for the past 22 years (for the most part been so much fulfilling).
- saturn_vk 4y agoI have a similar experience. Had a Mac from my previous job. I insisted on a Linux laptop when I switched because I just couldn't use macos as effectively as my personal Linux laptop. I didn't find the hardware all that special either
- phendrenad2 4y agoI spent the time to learn to use Linux effectively, and I still want to use something else.
- lsofzz 4y ago> I spent the time to learn to use Linux effectively, and I still want to use something else. It does take time to be effective. I like to emphasise that learning to be effective at Linux is not a sprint - it's a marathon.
- phendrenad2 4y agoYes, I ran that marathon, a 10+ year long marathon, and I still prefer other things to Linux.
- mark_l_watson 4y agoThat was a strange article: skip it and just read the discussion thread here. I downloaded Slackware over a 2400 baud modem, so I was early on the Linux train. Now, I occasionally use my System76 laptop. My workhorse is using VPSs with mosh or ssh and tmux. A wonderful Linux experience. Either my M1 MacBook Pro or my very nice and very inexpensive little Lenovo Chromebook suffices to reach various VPSs. Since there is a lot of talk about macOS in this thread, I will add that I would like to get off of the Apple platform, but my digital lifestyle based on my Apple Watch (so I can avoid having to have my iPhone with me when I leave home), supplemented with two sizes of iPad Pros and an iPhone when I need a camera serves me well. I have thought of dropping all of this and going back to just using a small Android phone and a high quality Chromebook (to access those VPSs) - there just seems to be too much “Apple ceremony” in my life.
- lproven 4y agoWhat was strange about it? I wrote it; I'd genuinely like to know.
- mark_l_watson 4y agoHello Liam, sorry to sound judgmental. I was expecting a short list of recommendations or more positive, to go along with the list of things wrong with current distributions. I enjoyed it up to the point when I realized there wouldn’t be any recommendations. That said, the subtitle “ A reasonable list of the least bad distros” accurately represents what the article is about. Again, I didn’t intend to be insulting, so I apologize for that.
- lproven 4y agoThank you for the apology. There are already a thousand articles out there with short lists of recommendations. There is absolutely zero point in adding another one. The title (as you said that is all you read) attempted to make it clear. This is a cynical perspective. It is not a list of recommendations. It is the reverse of that. It is a list of what's wrong with them all. It is not a list of least-bad distros either. It is a list of the most popular mainstream distros and tries to summarise, briefly, what is wrong with them. Because all distros have stuff wrong with them. All OSes have stuff wrong with them. There is no value in pointing out what's good; a million fanboys love doing that. What value I hoped to add was pointing out what bad, in a balanced way, by even-handedly saying what's bad with all of the big contenders. The Reg is not primarily an American site. I am not American, and I don't live there, or work for an American company. In my limited understanding of American culture, bare criticism is discouraged. Thus the concept of the "shit sandwich" where the critic attempts to sweeten the deal by wrapping it in praise. I see no real value in this. I did not want to do that. I wanted to say what's wrong with them all, as simple, boiled-down summaries of failings are much rarer and harder to find. This is something which I rather expected might bemuse American readers, but I do not see that as a problem. It's an opportunity for growth for them. :-D I suggest that you read the whole thing, and as a general rule -- not an attack -- I advise not commenting or seeking to comment if you haven't read all of something.
- simonblack 4y agoI discovered the other day that I've been using Linux Mint (MATE) for over 10 years. In other words, that's a good plug for the old saying "If it ain't broke, don't fix it."