7 ms·
In my ever-cynical view, I imagine in most cases manufacturers don't, themselves, especially care about the data from their devices. I see various other motivat
by somenameforme 4y ago
In my ever-cynical view, I imagine in most cases manufacturers don't, themselves, especially care about the data from their devices. I see various other motivations:
1) Price increases. It's "smart". Pay us more.
2) Planned obsolescence. You have numerous new points of failure in your product + make repairing vastly more difficult.
3) Monetize collected data by selling it to interested parties. The data quality, or lack thereof, is a secondary concern.
- s3p 4y ago> Monetize collected data by selling it to interested parties. then they do care about the data, just not the quality of that data. But the fact they are collecting data is definitely of importance or they would not be collecting and selling it.
- mirntyfirty 4y agoI’d just want to know who on earth would want such data and what insights could be gained from it. It can be challenging to build models with tons of really good data.
- IshKebab 4y agoI've worked in a big consumer electronics company and 2. is just a conspiracy theory. Nobody wants their products to be unreliable or difficult to repair. They want them to be cheap to manufacture and unlikely to fail during the warranty period. Everything else stems from that. Your other two points are broadly correct though. Also data collection is helpful for seeing how customers use products, which genuinely does influence development.
- alpaca128 4y ago> Nobody wants their products to be unreliable or difficult to repair. Hard to believe when a printer manufacturer moves a commonly failing part from cartridges to the printer itself, then makes it impossible to repair that specific part without taking apart the whole thing and buying a replacement part for 160 bucks. > Also data collection is helpful for seeing how customers use products, which genuinely does influence development. I'll start calling it helpful once it actually improves product quality and usability.
- bornfreddy 4y agoThey didn't say it improves the product though, just that it influences development. The incentives of producers are not aligned with consumers' wishes.
- mjburgess 4y agoWell calling it "planned" adds a conspiratorial element, maybe there's a better word. The effect comes from many sources. When the engineering science is new, tech tends to be way overbuilt because the creators don't know what tolerances are. There's also the ratio of product cost to disposable income of the users. And to their wish for devices over time. In any case, the natural tendency of a profit-optimizing system of competition is to throw away values (eg., repairability) that consumers at-purchase dont value. In this case, no biz is going to spend extra to include long-life features at a loss to competitors who don't. The remedy here is regulation, which is the mechanism which sets a floor on competition: since consumers at-purchase are at an extreme informational disadvantage, the gov. should require all biz to build in long-life features given consumers do want them, long after purchase. It's not a conspiracy, more of a market failure. The market doesnt produce optimal outcomes in cases where these extreme information asymmetries are built in, ie., by the time the product is around for 10yr to be reivewed, it's retired. There isn't a way of getting that information to the consumer.
- mojzu 4y agoPerhaps incentivised is the better word? Improving tolerances and repairability so that products last beyond the common 1-2 year warranty periods costs time and money, and potentially means that customers aren't buying newer versions of those products or paying for first party repairs. I'd imagine that many engineers who actually design/build the products would like to make these things more durable and repairable, but are more often then not told to cut costs to improve margins/work on new feature X or product Y, etc.
- spacexsucks 4y agoYeah. Only caring for warranty period Is planned obsolescence
- callmeal 4y ago>I've worked in a big consumer electronics company and 2. is just a conspiracy theory. Nobody wants their products to be unreliable or difficult to repair. Really now? https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-great-lightbulb-conspiracy https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-great-lightbulb-conspiracy https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-story-behind-the-story-behind-the-great-lightbulb-conspiracy https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-story-behind-the-story-behind-...
- IshKebab 4y agoThat's literally the one time it actually happened. Please find a single other example.
- barbazoo 4y ago> Also data collection is helpful for seeing how customers use products, which genuinely does influence development. "So they opened the fridge and 15 seconds later closed it again, they might have taken something out, interesting."
- Fiahil 4y agohttps://clickclickclick.click https://clickclickclick.click
- barbazoo 4y agoThat's creepy as hell
- robotnikman 4y agoI just spent time trying to get all the achievements on there
- IshKebab 4y agoI can see you've never designed anything! I can think of plenty of things I'd want to monitor on a fridge if I was a fridge designer. What temperature do they set the fridge to? Do they ever change it? How often do they deice the freezer? Do they use the ice maker / filtered water thing / whatever? How often? How long do they leave the door open normally? What are the temperature / power consumption profiles over time? That's before we even get to any of the smart features (I have no clue what they are).
- barbazoo 4y agoI've designed some things :) Sure you're right there is plenty to monitor and collect, it's just not very useful for the majority of people I'd imagine, unless you like other people to tell you when to buy something.
- Spooky23 4y agoIf repairability isn’t a design goal, it won’t be easy to repair. Ease of assembly is often in opposition to ease of repair. Reliability engineering optimizes failure rates during warranty and extended warranty periods. Why would they optimize repairability? It not in their interest. The defective Apple MacBooks are great example of this effect. Politically powerful design guy prioritizes design over everything else. Keyboard technology is defective and un-repairable. Result: Billion of dollars of warranty claims. Was that a conspiracy? No. Just the result of poor priorities, resulting in a bad outcome.
- throwaway1777 4y agoThe warranty period can be made shorter. It’s like 1 year on many appliances now
- InCityDreams 4y agoTwo years in Europe. Not sure/ don't care about the uk, though.
- angelaguilera 4y ago
- neuralRiot 4y agoI’ve said it so many times. High quality electronic products that last forever are the items that everyone wants but nobody buys.
- asfodelsu 4y agoAnd unlikely to fail during the warranty period. But Ideally, stop working 1 week after warranty ends.
- goodpoint 4y ago> In my ever-cynical view Nothing cynical there: you are simply correct. There's overwhelming evidence that companies profit from selling user's data, engage in planned obsolescence and deploy numerous tricks to disrupt the second hand market.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y ago> There's overwhelming evidence I mean, this has been going on for at least 97 years if you include light bulbs: “The cartel lowered operational costs and worked to standardize the life expectancy of light bulbs at 1,000 hours (down from 2,500 hours), and raised prices without fear of competition, in what has been described as a "classic example of planned obsolescence". The cartel tested their bulbs and fined manufacturers for bulbs that lasted more than 1,000 hours.” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoebus_cartel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoebus_cartel
- coryrc 4y agoIt literally saved customers money to buy the bulbs with lower lifetime because they are so much more efficient. Shortly before incandescents were phased out, I saw markings on packaging like "this bulb uses $10.81 in electricity over its lifetime" on a 40 cent bulb. They could have standardized on a power efficiency metric, but there's an intrinsic inverse relationship of efficiency versus lifetime for tungsten filaments. Back in the day companies did not try to eat every tiny bit of consumer surplus, so this cartel was a win-win situation.
- goodpoint 4y agoThe cartel was never meant to benefit customers and that's why it was kept secret. Historical evidence is pretty clear on this.
- userbinator 4y agoNow that we have LEDs, which were marketed to last "forever" when they were introduced, but clearly don't; and running LEDs at lower specific power actually helps efficiency, but they don't. Phoebus being about efficiency was merely a coincidence.