5 ms·
> It should be legally required Do you really want that level of government control over everything? I think that this is something "the market" should fix. Or
by dotancohen 4y ago
> It should be legally required
Do you really want that level of government control over everything? I think that this is something "the market" should fix. Or, a soldering iron.
- paskozdilar 4y ago> Do you really want that level of government control over everything? Absolutely not. But I also don't want that level of company control over everything. I think "government punishing companies" is a much better alternative to "companies punishing people". > Or, a soldering iron. In this case, the wireless card could be just detached physically. But what happens when e.g. device requires network access to work, but also has some malicious feature? What if the malicious feature is baked in the hardware, e.g. DRM? Do we just pull out an electron microscope and a disassembler?
- baq 4y agothe market is smart (or dumb, depending on point of view). it won't price in externalities unless forced to. that's why we need regulations and enforcement in a free market environment - to make sure (raise probability) the price is fair to everyone, not just to manufacturers or just to consumers. it isn't possible to have a free market without regulation (anarcho-capitalists believe otherwise until the first time they get shafted.)
- dotancohen 4y ago> price in externalities At what point should governments start pricing in exeternalities? Is the price of air pollution and global warming yet priced into the cost of gasoline?
- thfuran 4y agoNo it isn't, and that's a problem. Externalities would ideally always be priced in, though it's not practical to achieve that.
- strogonoff 4y agoFree market doesn’t work well in presence of information asymmetry and behaviors exploiting it. Since we cannot fundamentally eliminate exploitative behavior just yet, seeing as the world is full of suffering and people grow up with all sorts of psychological trauma and cannot help trying to secure themselves at the expense of others, the biggest antagonist of the market that we can tackle is information asymmetry. In some countries, you can bet that every mention of a regulation intended to tackle a specific instance of information asymmetry abuse (often enabled by advances in technology) will be accompanied by concerns about “government control over everything” and that “the market should fix it”. Unfortunately, that agenda mostly helps the exploitative behavior. If we don’t do our best to keep the market working by compensating for information asymmetry, command economy will eat it.
- dotancohen 4y ago> we cannot fundamentally eliminate exploitative behavior just yet Under what conditions will we ever be able to fundamentally eliminate exploitative behavior? This really sounds like an argument against capitalism in general.
- bheadmaster 4y ago> This really sounds like an argument against capitalism in general. Are you saying that exploitative behavior is exclusive to capitalism? If so, would you elaborate how do other economic systems avoid exploitative behavior - i.e. what makes capitalism so much worse?
- dotancohen 4y agoI'm not an economist, I really know little about other economic systems. I'm certainly not advocating for any specific economic system, I just took note of your conclusion. Your advocacy for a controlled market demonstrates a far better understanding of the topic than I have.
- bheadmaster 4y ago
- Dylan16807 4y ago"that level" is mandating a toggle? Hell yes I want "that level" of control. A very narrow but important one.