4 ms·
> I had one person start crying they put so much pressure on themselves, I had to take a two week break from interviewing after that. This is a sign that the h
by lapcat 4y ago
> I had one person start crying they put so much pressure on themselves, I had to take a two week break from interviewing after that.
This is a sign that the hiring process is broken. It's not testing skill level, it's testing anxiety level.
- native_samples 4y agoThe second sentence may be true but the former isn't. People who break down and cry in interviews are rare but if they do it, they are best avoided and it was good that the interview revealed this. You cannot have that happening on the job but if they can't handle being asked to program something whilst up against a time limit or being watched, they're going to have breakdowns in other situations too.
- lapcat 4y agoI've written at length about this before, so I'll just give a link instead of repeating the whole screed, but it's a misconception to equate interview anxiety with job anxiety. They're distinct and not necessarily correlated. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31377459 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31377459
- sitkack 4y agoThanks for taking the time to write that. I agree. Interviewing is a horrible crap shoot and would say even cruel by construction.
- native_samples 4y agoIt's obviously unpopular, but the brutal reality is that the vast majority of candidates don't panic during interviews and can in fact demonstrate their skills when asked. I've done lots of interviewing and you aren't going to convince me or anyone else actually that breakdowns in an interview are completely irrelevant, especially when all you've been asked to do is demonstrate that you're actually qualified. It's also frankly a bit insulting to people who learned to control their emotions and work under pressure to expect that this behaviour be ignored in others who never learned to do it.
- weatherlite 4y ago> the brutal reality is that the vast majority of candidates don't panic during interviews and can in fact demonstrate their skills For a given job most candidates actually don't get hired, often because they are not a good fit but many times because they are too nervous to think straight.
- native_samples 4y agoI've done hundreds of interviews and that is only very rarely a problem. Normally candidates aren't nervous, but just can't program. They don't have the knowledge, they're flummoxed by basic errors from their compiler/interpreter even when they got to pick what language they used, they're asked to write something (anything) in a language they advertise knowing on their CV and then admit they don't actually know it, etc.
- lapcat 4y ago> Normally candidates aren't nervous, but just can't program. How do you know their level of nervousness? You can't read minds.
- lapcat 4y ago> the vast majority of candidates don't panic during interviews and can in fact demonstrate their skills when asked Is this actually true? It's been widely and frequently claimed over the years that "199 out of 200 applicants for every programming job can't write code at all. I repeat: they can't write any code whatsoever." https://blog.codinghorror.com/why-cant-programmers-program/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/why-cant-programmers-program/ > frankly a bit insulting to people who learned to control their emotions It's frankly a bit ignorant of human psychology to think that people can just "learn" to control their emotions. We're humans, not robots. Yes, you could go to a professional therapist, if you have both the time and money; it could take a lot of both. But if many people have to go to a therapist for the sole purpose of dealing with audition-style coding interviews, then maybe there's something seriously wrong with audition-style coding interviews. It's already bizarre that candidates with many years of experience in the field have to study intensely for job interviews. > and work under pressure I explained at length in the link from my previous comment that working under pressure is entirely different from interview pressure.