5 ms·
If you are distressed by anything external, the pain is not due to the thing itself, but to your estimate of it; and this you have the power to revoke at any mo
by AlbertCory 4y ago
If you are distressed by anything external, the pain is not due to the thing itself, but to your estimate of it; and this you have the power to revoke at any moment.
― Marcus Aurelius, Meditations
- bowsamic 4y agoI prefer the Buddha's simile of two arrows: the first arrow of the actual pain is not avoidable, but the second arrow is something we inflict upon ourselves in response to the pain. Marcus here makes it sound like we can totally avoid pain, but actually we can't, that first arrow will always hit and we shouldn't pretend like there isn't pain. The second arrow is what we have control over: our own personal response to the pain, seeing it as bad or good, wanting it to be gone.
- danaris 4y agoMaybe by "external", Marcus was being quite literal: that first arrow is inside your body when it causes you pain. Until it physically contacts you, it doesn't hurt you. (I'm mostly being facetious.)
- thunkshift1 4y agoThats right, advice from a goddamn emperor on how the downtrodden should not feel downtrodden
- daedalus_f 4y agoMarcus Aurelius writings that are collected together in the Meditations were never intended to be published, they were his thoughts and advice for himself.
- refurb 4y agoOk, does that mean the writing aren’t useful? No
- kodah 4y agoKind of a weird take. Marcus Aurelius' life, although that of an emperor, was filled with a lot of strife that he used philosophy to deal with. His stoic philosophies come from his early life, which saw the death of his father, and adoption by a series of people he didn't know, all the way to the death of both of his sons. Marcus did achieve the title of emperor, but dismissing him because of his accomplishments, especially when stoicism was a key and integral part of his life along the way, is odd.
- mjburgess 4y agoSay, there are two types of people: (1) a person who mostly experiences challenges at or just above their ability to solve them (2) a person who mostly experiences challenges way above their ability to solve them (even plausibly so) Stoicism, political conservatism, rugged individualists, etc. are just those in camp-1 unaware there's a camp-2. (Likewise, social radicals are in camp-2, saying of 1, they're privileged as if that isnt desirable!. So both sides are superstitious about the other).
- kodah 4y agoFor much of Marcus' life he wasn't able to solve things though. In fact, that's what much of his philosophy talks about, and his (fairly open) history. Much of stoicism is focused around dealing with things you can't change, which also makes this take very odd.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThis isn't my experience at all. I think the main difference is disagreement on what constitutes a solvable problem and the value of trying.
- DarylZero 4y agoThat's not remotely true. Political conservatism and social radicalism demonstrably don't correlate with personal experience in that way: children adopt the beliefs of their parents (and/or peers). Hence "champagne socialists" and "temporarily embarrassed millionaires."
- meowkit 4y agoIf you mischaracterize this as “advice for the downtrodden” then sure your snark makes sense. Except it isn’t that. Its the internal monologue of a roman emperor dealing with the extreme stresses of his life and his role in the world.
- Delk 4y agoPeople kind of throw it around as if it were applicable advice for others, too. It's a good remark that it's effectively the emperor's diary instead, though. I didn't know that.
- 1123581321 4y agoThat’s not a problem. Others find The Meditations applicable to their own lives because they contain honest self-advice. Some observe others finding the writing self-applicable, so they recommend it to people who haven’t read it yet.
- DigiDigiorno 4y agoYou made the incorrect assumption either that having the "power to revoke" means the necessity to exercise that power, and/or that revoking feelings means inaction on all events leading to them. The advice says nothing about how the downtrodden should act about their situation of downtroddeness. Focusing and making assumptions on the unfairness of the statement is a bit of victim mentality. In fact, your statement reminds me of an article I read somewhere. I think it was titled "Feeling like a victim is a perfectly disastrous way to go through life"
- Majestic121 4y agoIt could be quote from Epictetus, who had a similar philosophy and lived his life as a slave, made lame by his master breaking his leg, before becoming a philosophy teacher.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoThese dudes also had a (to most contemporary people) deeply weird metaphysics that brought them to these understandings and allowed them to share them despite extreme differences in their lives. Unless you also believe that the entire universe including yourself is a single sentient being and every event is perfectly predetermined, you're gonna find some contradictions here. It's not really a unified coherent practical philosophy when separated from that cosmology. Individual parts of it can still be individually valuable of course, but other parts truly are just an emperor telling people to deal with it. A more western-digestible analogy would be believing in the resurrection of christ without believing in his divinity. You could still get useful advice from the sermons but it stops being a coherent foundation of belief for your role in the world.
- codemonkey-zeta 4y agoStoicism, Daoism, Buddhism, all the Hindu religions stemming from advaita vedanta, heck even proto Indo Europeans all have very similar monistic metaphysics, I don't think it's weird at all. Different names for the same thing: - logos - Dao - Brahman - Wralda > It's not really a unified coherent practical philosophy when separated from that cosmology. I absolutely agree with this, and I'd say anyone who wants to take Stoicism seriously should adapt a similar metaphysical perspective. I'd also say that anyone who already understands one of the above religions already has the ability to readily understand the others, at least compared to the standard Westerner.
- goodpoint 4y agoIt irks me how stoic philosophy quotes are constantly taken out of context and bent into rugged individualism: "soldier on, be tough".
- codemonkey-zeta 4y agoNo bending required. Marcus literally says you are a soldier who must perform his duty over and over again.
- goodpoint 4y ago> taken out of context My point exactly.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoCan you clarify?
- cafard 4y agoLord Byron wrote in one of his letters that he was a Stoic until a toothache convinced him of the reality of pain.