8 ms·
Success determined by ability to speak, ability to write, and quality of ideas
- Aisen8010 4y agoQuantity of luck has a bigger role to achieve success.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Kelm 4y agoFair, unfortunately this is not something one can substantially improve upon ;)
- caseysoftware 4y agoBut you can. The catch phrase for this is "increasing your luck surface area" There are all kinds of possibilities and opportunities in front of us every day. We're "lucky" when we can a) identify them and b) take advantage of them. There are lots of strategies for this ranging from the simple (learn more) to the complex (networking, the people kind) and everything can give you additional perspective, opportunities, etc, etc to make you "lucky." As you're successful with a few, you can build momentum, reputation, etc to grow your "luck"
- photochemsyn 4y agoI just finished reading this biography of the physicist Enrico Fermi, "The Pope of Physics" and while he was obviously very talented from a young age, there were a lot of points in his career from Italy to the United States where luck played a critical role. He was lucky that he was taken under the wing of a senior academic early on, well before he became famous or did any really significant work. That figure ensured that he and several other young physicists got academic appointments (when others tried equally hard to block those appointments, and put their favored proteges in those slots). He was also lucky that he was able to escape fascist Italy with his Jewish wife, and emigrate to the United States. However, it also kind of backs up the thesis here, as Fermi apparently worked very hard to lose his Italian accent once in America, as a means of more effectively communicating with the locals. He then became the leader of the Chicago reactor project, then an all-around consultant for the Los Alamos Manhattan Project.
- dasil003 4y agoThis is such an impotent and sour-grapes refrain that someone always has to blurt out in any thread about “success”. Of course luck plays a huge role in success just as it does for all asymmetric outcomes in a chaotic environment. Just ask any formerly living thing over the last billion years about its fortunes. Shit happens, you can’t control it. However focusing on what you can’t control is to nullify your competitive advantage as a human: your brain. There’s a reason they say “luck favors the prepared mind”. Stop feeling sorry for yourself and play the hand you were dealt.
- jjj123 4y agoBut we can control societal factors that cause success to be inequitably distributed. Through worker organization, redistribution of wealth, etc. It’s just that individuals that have benefited from this false meritocracy have a vested interest in the rest of us “hustling” at the individual level instead of banding together to change the system for everyone.
- robertlagrant 4y ago"Luck playing a part" is not the same as a false meritocracy.
- DarylZero 4y agoIt wasn't claimed to be.
- theonemind 4y agoI don't think it follows that he feels sorry for himself. This bias in human thought could use correcting for several reasons. It runs a bit like the "just world" fallacy. On one side, you have things like the Republican party, where millions vote against their own interests on the basis of a delusion of control. Then you have the general lack of social safety nets in America, because of the just-world fallacy that people get what they deserve. Then, you have people like Jeff Bezos who credit themselves with deserving their wealth and lead companies with delivery drivers peeing in bottles not to get fired. As a species, focusing on our competitive advantage has brought us to 100 seconds to midnight on the Doomsday clock: https://thebulletin.org/doomsday-clock/current-time/ https://thebulletin.org/doomsday-clock/current-time/ .
- dontcare007 4y ago"Chance favors the prepared mind" - one of my favorite quotes. The point being, chances come your way every day, and you need to be prepared to grab them.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoThe sentiment may lose its power if factors like inequality and racism make the chances available wildly different for disadvantaged subsets of society. Hearing such quotes may be to them insult to injury if coming from well born or huge outliers (that got 1/million lucky). Even the most disadvantaged should still prepare themselves. And ideally get extra help, without pretense, from those who never had to face their precarious circumstances.
- hprotagonist 4y ago…film at eleven.
- smitty1e 4y ago...tomorrow, denunciations based upon centuries-old events and ethnic origins.
- Xeoncross 4y agoI've noticed that good sounding ideas communicated well often win the team vote even if they are the wrong solution. Sometimes you don't realize the rest of the equation (or other side of the argument) until later.
- ChildOfChaos 4y agoI think in a corporate enviroment, most organisations are too large and all you really have to do is sound like you know what you are doing hence the ability to speak and ability to write. A lot of the higher up, management types are so far removed from the ground work, that is all they see. You could be doing excellent work but they won’t see that if you can’t communicate your ideas to them or your busy doing the actual work, they will just see the end result and if a team was working on it, the people in the team that get the most credit are the louder, more visible ones.
- hunglee2 4y agoSo, ask yourself: How much does my audience already know about my topic? If you can tailor what you say specifically to your listeners, you'll maximize your impact. Donald Trump proves at least some of this thesis. Understand your audience and just trigger them = translates directly into political power in representative democracy
- smitty1e 4y agoDJT hardly has any monopoly here.
- hunglee2 4y agoindeed not. A good exemplar though, as he is an extreme case.
- sumedh 4y agobut he became the most powerful man in the world because of that skill.
- eurasiantiger 4y agoIt’s pretty well established that it was more due to Russian social media engineering. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_interference_in_the_2016_United_States_elections https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_interference_in_the_...
- sumedh 4y agoBoth sides used Russian interference, Trump was still able to win.
- smitty1e 4y agoWe're now finding out just how valid any of those accusations may have been => https://redstate.com/bonchie/2022/05/28/durham-delivers-a-smoking-gun-on-hillary-paying-sussmann-to-take-disinformation-to-the-fbi-n571593 https://redstate.com/bonchie/2022/05/28/durham-delivers-a-sm...
- tjpnz 4y agoNot trying to rubbish the article but I've seen all manner of fuckery perpetrated by sadistic individuals to climb their way up the corporate ladder. Those who have been most successful in such environments absolutely have the first, but the last two are orders of magnitude less important and can easily be stolen from others when in a bind. If you've nailed the speaking you can walk into a room and spout complete BS for an hour and be applauded for it.
- davidivadavid 4y agoOf course that only works as long as you're surrounded by people who clap for BS.
- gumby 4y agoI knew Patrick well and he was as far from a sadistic individual as one could imagine. Yes, there are many dysfunctional organizations, but even if you work on a road crew, being able to speak clearly and have good ideas will help. You may not speak the same way a prof might speak at a faculty meeting, but people you’re speaking with should be able to understand what you’re talking about.
- buscoquadnary 4y agoSuccess meaning being high up on the corporate ladder and making lots of money. Success not meaning doing work that makes a difference, helping others, achieving contentment, or having a balanced meaningful life. Not that the stated qualities don't help you with accomplishing the seocnd as being able to communicate appropriately is a powerful tool, but I've found the person on my engineering team that does the most actual work right now is the quiet guy who isn't trying to lead the team, doesn't spend a lot of time talking in meetings, and just diligently chips away at whatever he has been assigned. His quality of work is high, his output consistent and his stress and complaining seem lower. Meanwhile as a loud "senior engineer" I have to spend all day trapped in meetings and arguing with people and get to spend very little time doing what I enjoy, spending more of my time fighting the "process". I am more "successful" but I wish I was him.
- kirse 4y agoI have to spend all day trapped in meetings and arguing with people and get to spend very little time doing what I enjoy The only "have to" in life is death. I've been in situations like you describe as a lead, choose another role or choose a better story for yourself. Lead positions are hard for the very reasons you describe, they don't offer the immediate dopamine hit of typing code into your IDE or lining up commits throughout the day. It does take an extra degree of learned faith to understand your impact on the team. As the saying goes "manage it or it will manage you." Do you block off 1hr on your calendar every day to do things you want/enjoy like coding or skill improvement?
- kodah 4y agoLead positions don't have to be that way. As a lead, it's important to find org structure and management personalities that not only enable leaders but also give them direct domains of authority. A lot of the time when I've read about people disattisfied in leadership positions and the general toxicity around them, it's because the structure and culture remove authority from engineers, proxy it through non-engineers, and create an environment of "leadership through influence", which is absolute junk.
- watmough 4y agoI'm happy to believe that the article captures part of success. However, communication is a two-way process, and the following have been important to me in my career journey: * Understanding when to listen instead of talking, * Asking open-ended questions that provide opportunity for other viewpoints, * Empathizing with others', including understanding their expectations. I guess the older I've gotten, the more value i've gained from just listening.
- rootsudo 4y agoIt makes you wonder how "held" back people that suffer from suttering, autism spectrum and dyslexia (to name a few) are held back in day to day life. Where most of life really falls under communication.
- makecheck 4y ago“…in that order” is the full quote, and omitting that from the title really changes the point. Ultimately if you don’t work on the first two, it isn’t enough to have the third. Persuasion is really important because you’re usually not working in a vacuum.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AlbertCory 4y agoI was all prepared to dismiss this as yet another bunch of Toastmasters BS ("use hand gestures!"). I consider myself a decent public speaker (whether anyone else does is another matter :) But you can find me on YouTube.) But his points for speaking well... 1. Ask: How much does my audience know? 2. Get excited. 3. Slow down. ... are not terrible, unless you're going to pretend to be excited by the latest team outing to the Laser Tag place. Mine are things that I think Winston would have approved of, and they're not particularly designed to help you climb the corporate ladder. They're for technical people like us, and definitely not about spewing BS. Learn your topic inside and out, including all audience questions you can think of. Don't worry about your FORM at all; just the content. Remember when you're up there: 1. You know the stuff. 2. They don't. 3. You want them to know it.
- ree-san 4y agoI looked you up. I’m excited to read Inventing The Future, I’d actually been googling recently to see if I could find something similar.
- AlbertCory 4y agoThank you, ree-san. Enjoy! New book about the 80s coming very soon.
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y agoThose who read Inc magazine for career tips already are on the hard path.
- throwaway0asd 4y agoI see developers ignore this guidance all the time. They can’t write or articulate their concerns clearly. They are willing to argue their concerns during meetings but it feels like time wasting posturing for self-serving grand standing. Don’t waste peoples time with your stumbling bullshit. Be great then be done. The end. Strong communication is a pillar of an effective organization, a competent work culture. Other pillars include strong leadership, a clear vision, and quality controls.
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y agoSure, maybe...but at the end of the day I watch Biden and I think to myself: That's just a job like any other, and it was a boring journey to get there as well. The lost art of amateur craftmanship of every skill is the way to go. It's when you are an amateur that you make the most progress on a time unit basis. And then you switch craft often once you reach a plateu ranging from social, engineering, music, poetry, leadership etc.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- notjustanymike 4y agoAt our company we're bringing in a professor of non-fiction to teach a workshop on personal narrative ahead of annual reviews this year. Not everyone grew up with the same education or language, and this is a good way to even out those imbalances.
- wallfacer120 4y agoHuge if true.
- LegitShady 4y agoThe people I've seen perform best on corporate ladders always seem to have borderline sociopathic tendencies.
- stereoradonc 4y agoinsert Steve Jobs reference works "all the time" to convince readers about these phoney corporate laced narratives. Success depends on a combination of hard work, circumstances, choices and random probabilities. Perceptible success, on the other hand, is completely different ("fake it till you make it" syndrome). As for the fancy "ivy leagues" - those professors are mandated to make it sound good to address the marketable skills. I am sure there are many others who don't get featured here (or get the PR they want).
- RickJWagner 4y agoA nice, common sense article. There's lots of wisdom here.
- rajnathani 4y agoI would narrow it down to: (1) Empathy (2) Having a great world-view by (a) reading a lot of industry news, and (b) traveling (3) Ability to write/communicate well (this is mentioned in the article)
- rajnathani 4y agoAlso (2)(c) Job/Volunteering experiences / other experiences (4) Resourcefulness / Creativity