8 ms·
Monkeypox outbreaks: 4 key questions researchers have
- hammock 4y agoQuestions I have for researchers: Is this a new strain or one of the two known strains? Are we witnessing greater human-to-human transmission than previously known? What is the fatality rate so far of this outbreak?
- simonh 4y agoThe article has you covered on the first question. >The most important insight they have gained so far is that each of the sequences closely resembles that of a monkeypox strain found in western Africa. The wikipedia article for the current outbreak gives 0 deaths so far. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_monkeypox_outbreak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_monkeypox_outbreak
- radicaldreamer 4y ago>Is this a new strain or one of the two known strains? It's been confirmed that the current outbreak is the same as a 2018 outbreak of the West African clade. >Are we witnessing greater human-to-human transmission than previously known? This is the million $ question... it's been speculated that this outbreak originated due to some kind of (very) close contact event with dozens of people in Europe and continues to spread because of the long incubation period for monkeypox. >What is the fatality rate so far of this outbreak? None, so far (but it's still early).
- hh3k0 4y agoI am not a researcher but I can answer one of your questions: it is the less-lethal strain (west African clade) but it appears that 94 nucleotide and 51 amino acid changes have occured since our sequencing of the closest strain in 2018. (That is apparently a lot by DNA virus standards, as a friend of mine who happens to be a molecularbiologist has told me.)
- mensetmanusman 4y agoOne interest aspect of these various outbreaks is that we now recognize that there are a lot more negative externalities to air travel that are not being priced in. 80% of the world has never flown, 1% of frequent fliers account for half the pollution/emissions, and the global wealthy/elite are the vast majority of fliers. The fact that air travel accelerates transmission rates of novel diseases from remote parts of the world mean that these new diseases are a manifestation of harm done by the wealthy to the poor. These tragedies of the common can only be solved by coordinating efforts, but the geopolitical situation means that is impossible for now…
- mongol 4y agoWell air travel between Russia and the west has decreased so there is that..
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- simonh 4y agoIt's also heavily impacted travel more broadly because Russia was a popular low cost route from Europe to East Asia
- oxfordmale 4y agoThis is not necessarily true. During the Spanish conquest of South America many indigenous died. It shows diseases travel equally well by boat. Maybe flight accelerates transmission, however, grounding all airplanes is not going to stop it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- User23 4y agoThis is why ships had quarantine flags. It wasn’t a perfect system, but that combined with ocean crossing being longer than the incubation period of many diseases meant they were a far less efficient disease vector. The same result could be achieved with an enforced (men with guns, not polite suggestion) 14 day quarantine of all air travelers, flight time included. But the jet set have too much political power and prefer to spread disease.
- alecco 4y ago
- _Microft 4y agoSubmissions can end up on the frontpage with less than five votes if they only happen early enough after submitting.
- alecco 4y agoIt was 12 votes in 36 minutes when I spotted it at the top. That's not exactly a lot.
- _Microft 4y agoBut that's a lot? You can check new submissions [0] here and have a look for yourself how most of them fare. The second most upvotes in that time that I just saw there were 4. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/newest https://news.ycombinator.com/newest Edit: OK, now the California-climate-power-outage submission has taken off with 19 votes in just over 40 minutes.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoSaturday mornings are slow for submissions. Look at the competition, number two is more than 2 hours old.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y agoIt is for hn.
- dagw 4y agoThe number 3 story on my front page right now has 8 votes.
- jstanley 4y agoI think that is normal. I've noticed posts get on the front page with as few as 4 upvotes, if they come in a short enough period of time. Most posts on /newest don't get any votes at all.
- daliz 4y ago[flagged]
- laputan_machine 4y agoWhat "truth" are you talking about, specifically?
- daliz 4y agoThe one where countries/states without vaccines had a way better outcome in terms of infections and deaths.
- turtledove 4y agoWhat the fuck are you talking about? The data shows the opposite: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1109011/coronavirus-covid19-death-rates-us-by-state/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1109011/coronavirus-covi... Note the states with the highest death rates had lower vaccine uptake.
- daliz 4y agoSweden. No masks, lowest vaccine uptake in Europe. Result: best outcome in Europe.
- turtledove 4y agoGermany, Switzerland, Ireland, the Netherlands, Denmark and several other European countries had lower mortality rates than Sweden. https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/data/mortality https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/data/mortality
- daliz 4y agoCountries with mandatory vaccines had the worst mortality.
- dopylitty 4y agoFor folks who want actual expert thoughts on the recent Monkeypox cases instead of self appointed Twitter expert opinions check out the This Week in Virology podcast. They covered it at the start of episode 902[0] and had a dedicated clinical episode with an infectious disease doc[1] 0: https://www.microbe.tv/twiv/twiv-902/ https://www.microbe.tv/twiv/twiv-902/ 1: https://www.microbe.tv/twiv/twiv-special-monkeypox/ https://www.microbe.tv/twiv/twiv-special-monkeypox/
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoIt is possible that monkeypox, like CoVID, can be asymptomatic in healthier individuals. But now that we’ve gone through Covid we have a lot of less healthy people and these people present with symptomatic disease.
- turtledove 4y agoThe tracker I've been watching shows pretty explosive growth over the past week. https://bnonews.com/monkeypox/ https://bnonews.com/monkeypox/
- wheelerof4te 4y agoThe total population of top 3 countries only is 118200000. That's a hundred and eighteen million two hundred thousand people. Total number of cases in all countries as of now sits at 448. I don't think that can be called "a pretty explosive growth" by any means. Stop spreading the media scare.
- turtledove 4y agoIt was 7 people last week. 7 -> 450 is a big jump up. Until r values stabilize, it's reasonable to keep an eye on it.
- hannxc 4y ago[dead]
- HL33tibCe7 4y agoSomething interesting I’ve observed a lot (on Twitter, so take it with a grain of salt) is an attitude of “monkeypox isn’t exclusively a gay disease, and associating it with gay people is homophobic”. I’ve even seen people criticising government health departments for warning gay men about the epidemic. But the current spread _does_ appear to be, from what I’ve heard, almost exclusively amongst men who have sex with men. It’s not homophobic to state that, if that’s what’s actually happening. In fact, it’s important to inform people at risk so they can take suitable precautions.
- refurb 4y agoApparently we're not allowed to say obesity is a health risk either, so I'm not surprised about the monkeypox issue. Apparently science needs to take a back seat to social justice now.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoIt is but the risk here is that this may be bad information: there’s no reason to believe it can only spread among gay men, or that it will continue to do so. And simultaneously it may be spreading elsewhere but we’re only seeing a subset of the infections because the gay community has been alerted and is looking. So if you do too much messaging about this, you’re potentially going to give people bad information. Not to mention that the last time we had a major outbreak of a “gay men’s disease” it led to some terrifically bad and discriminatory outcomes that were bad for patients and broad public health at the same time. (And no matter how much you might think the US has learned from that episode, plenty of countries still discriminate in law.)
- nieve 4y agoIn fact some of the cases documented so far haven't been men who have sex with men and it's not uncommon in Africa, so encouraging people to believe they're safe if they're not MSM is potentially damaging. It's much like HIV in this case, the number of heterosexuals infected with that is much higher than most straight people want to believe.
- photochemsyn 4y agoWaiting to hear what the gain-of-function research advocates are going to say about this (they've rather gone silent since Sars-CoV2 spread around the world). Should we be using CRISPR to modify different sections of the monkeypox genome to see if we can create as many different variants as possible so we can identify those that rapidly jump from human to human? The argument is, then we would know what to look for if we found it, because we'd have a better idea of which specific regions of the genome are involved in transmissibility... Specious reasoning at best. The more likely result would be that a laboratory worker would get infected with such a highly-transmissible modified monkeypox, leave the lab, spread it into their local community, and from there modern transportation technology (planes, trains, automobiles, etc.) would ensure rapid spread around the world. This is not a conspiracy theory, just a rational risk assessment (and is now the most likely theory of the origin of Covid-19, like it or not). Here's the latest scientific research on monkeypox as of 2020, from researchers based in Africa, it's up on sci-hub.se for those who want to read it, and is also a good overview: Alakunle, E., Moens, U., Nchinda, G., & Okeke, M. I. (2020). Monkeypox Virus in Nigeria: Infection Biology, Epidemiology, and Evolution. Viruses, 12(11), 1257. Respiratory droplets and contact with body fluids, contaminated patient’s environment or items, skin lesion of an infected person have been found to be associated with inter-human transmission. Congo Basin clade (Central Africa clade) is reported to be more virulent than West Africa clade and thereby contributes more to inter-human transmission. The West Africa clade is apparently the one involved in this outbreak.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoI don’t have any dog in this fight, but one of the points made in this article is that we don’t really understand the Monkeypox genome well enough to know which mutations might lead to greater spread or virulence. So when a new cluster pops up we can’t tell if it’s spreading due to a mutation or if it will have a greater IFR than we expect from past outbreaks. I’m not saying GoF is the right solution to this, given the risks. But it is probably one way to gather this sort of data.
- photochemsyn 4y agoThe counterpoint to that argument is that there very well could be hundreds of artificially induced mutations that could give rise to extremely virulent or extremely transmissible strains, and yet that's not proof that such mutations would be at all likely to arise under natural conditions in the wild.
- aaron695 4y ago
- tamaharbor 4y ago