2 ms·
The larger scientific community is still waiting for the QC folks to actually do something interesting. From what I can tell, QC is still stuck in the position
by dekhn 4y ago
The larger scientific community is still waiting for the QC folks to actually do something interesting. From what I can tell, QC is still stuck in the position of claiming they've achieved supremacy, but cannot demonstrate any important problem which cannot be solved on conventional computers, that can be done on QC.
Some folks trot out various projects to "optimize logistics" using QC (Volkswagen), but if you look at the problems they want to solve, we already have classical solvers that reach effective optimality in reasonable times. It's not like QC is somehow going to magically find a route that can do the kessel run in 9 parsecs (whatever the hell that means).
Even following many of the most promising teams, I don't really see a path which will lead to that. My conclusion is that nobody truly has a plan for a marketable QC for the foreseeable future- and instead, these are basically just "science-by-press-release" from the academic and industrial communities.
Really a shame since it seems like there's a lot of other useful applications that material scientists and quantum reserachers could be working on.
- ksaj 4y agoI don't really disagree, but to be fair, there are more than a few limitations that need to overcome before the killer app can even be considered. We have enough hints to know we're in the right direction. A lot of the recent Quantum articles I've seen have been specifically about getting past those hurdles. A big one, for example, is developing qubits that are stable for a long enough duration to finish a computation and evaluation. Some advances have looked at different lasers. Some have discovered interesting/new magnetic effects that were previously unknown. Some are working with single(ish) molecule layers of various metals and other elements. And so on. And that's all just to tackle one specific hurdle. So I don't really see any reason for shame. Nobody is expecting to see anything truly revolutionary from a quantum computer yet. But without all the inputs and attention given to the intermediate results, we'd never get there either.