3 ms·
The problem in the end comes down to the fine line Canada always straddles due to the proverbial "sleeping with the elephant" (see quote from Trudeau Sr.) The
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
The problem in the end comes down to the fine line Canada always straddles due to the proverbial "sleeping with the elephant" (see quote from Trudeau Sr.)
The fear being that if Canada deregulates fully and opens critical sectors like telecomms etc. to full competition we will completely lose these industries to US (or Chinese, etc.) interests.
And yet at the same time domestic regulation is continually captured by predatorial internal interests.
Canada has always been this way, and it's frustrating as hell. Almost every industry has a caste of "goold old boys" who seek to prevent competition by capturing regulatory agencies.
Many times many participants all went to private school together @ Upper Canada College, etc. Or sit/sat on boards together.
You could say "ok, disband the regulation and let them compete" but many times that just leads to the total collapse of certain domestic industries because they simply can't compete with US capital.
- voisin 4y ago> You could say "ok, disband the regulation and let them compete" but many times that just leads to the total collapse of certain domestic industries because they simply can't compete with US capital. What’s wrong with this if it leads to lower costs for consumers and better service?
- xav0989 4y agoCanada wants to maintain a domestic industry, in part to not be held to the whims of another country's governing body. When the people that control your information flow, your food production, etc. are not within your jurisdiction, you're effectively at the mercy of both them and the government of their country.
- voisin 4y ago> in part to not be held to the whims of another country's governing body. Just because the industry is foreign doesn’t mean it isn’t subject to local regulation and oversight.
- loudthing 4y ago... and largely, when American companies set up shop in Canada, they create a wholly owned subsidiary that is a Canadian company. I.e. McDonald's Canada and General Motors Canada are separate entities from their parent organizations. Fun fact posted here before: The McDonald's locations that were recently shuttered in Russia were specifically founded by McDonald's Canada.
- michael1999 4y agoThe only thing Canadian about Rogers is the dividends. None of the technologies they operate are Canadian.
- marcosdumay 4y agoLocal industry can't compete because the costs are too high, so the government acts by protecting the local industry and increasing costs everywhere. Welcome to the protectionism vicious cycle.
- bregma 4y agoThere is more to domestic policy than being able to go to the foreign-owned big-box store in your foreign-made sweats to buy foreign-made underwear that is 5 cents cheaper. Especially if that savings is only used to pay for the higher cost of internet infrastructure owned by a handful of oligarchs and used to distribute foreign-made content consumed in your sweats while quaffing beer made by foreign-owned cartels and eating popcorn grown by foreign-subsidized farmers.
- 52-6F-62 4y agoIt's not so great for people who don't see themselves only as consumers of a service. It's not a simple linear change.
- jamal-kumar 4y agoThis is a correct point of view. It's just plain old localized oligarchy.
- FredPret 4y agoWe should do two things: 1. Pick a couple of industries and specialize in them 2. Deregulate everything This way, we can compete as a small country without getting screwed as consumers across the board. I think Sweden followed this model with cars and something else.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ttul 4y ago> The fear being that if Canada deregulates fully and opens critical sectors like telecomms etc. to full competition we will completely lose these industries to US (or Chinese, etc.) interests. I have never understood the reluctance of successive governments to allow foreign competition in our telecom markets. Telus, Shaw, Bell, and Rogers are all widely held public companies. They answer to global shareholders. Yet, I can accept the argument writ large that some degree of sovereign relatedness for significant industries is sensible in a world where many foreign companies receive illicit government support for strategic reasons. The best solution to bring down prices while protecting corporate sovereignty is a state-owned provincial provider. Mobile prices in Saskatchewan are significantly lower because of SaskTel. At times, yes, even a boring state-owned telecom is a good thing. Rogers/Telus/etc resist this notion, yet prices are evidentially a great deal cheaper in that province. IMHO, the feds should create a fund to help provinces and municipalities build their own public broadband and mobile infrastructure, with the stated aim of competing with big-telecom.
- amscanne 4y agoI suspect that for every well-run public corporation, there are a dozen that are bloated and wasteful, and should have died long ago. SaskTel seems like one of the good ones, but it’s not that way because it’s a public corporation. This doesn’t happen because people involved are less competent, it’s just that if they make some bad decisions or have some bad luck, they won’t be forced to answer to reality by the market by e.g. running out of money or being beaten by competition. Public corporations are too easy to keep going by continuing to fund through state coffers; to shut them down suggests that leaders made a mistake, so instead we throw good money after bad. It may not have been a mistake to attempt a public option, however even good ideas can fail for lots of reasons, and incentives just make it too hard to fail when it should. To me the LCBO is the shining example of this: any reasonable analysis that compares with private competition for alcohol sales (e.g. Alberta, BC) would find Ontario has much worse store coverage, worse selection and lower net revenue per unit of alcohol .. yet, no politician would dare visit such an idea, since it suggests government (and its leaders) and ineffective. The best thing would be to do a Yozma-style funding program. The government offers to match investment and provides clear buy-out terms for successful cases. If you lower the downside risk, you’ll get the competition you want in the space.