5 ms·
First step, if you get a demand like that, file a police report. Extortion, and attempted extortion, are crimes. You can also file with the FBI online, which w
by Animats 4y ago
First step, if you get a demand like that, file a police report. Extortion, and attempted extortion, are crimes. You can also file with the FBI online, which will at least result in your complaint being accumulated with other similar complaints. Not much may happen, but now it's on record.
Now you have paperwork establishing a crime.
If you're willing to spend legal fees, talk to a lawyer. You can potentially sue the extortionist as an unknown "John Doe", and Google as collaborating with the extortionist to extract money from you.
Google is in a touchy position here, because they really did cooperate with an extortionist to extract money.
Google can claim the cooperation was unwitting, but that can fall apart if an ongoing pattern of similar behavior can be shown, and if Google can be shown to have been negligent in determining whether takedown requests were valid.
This is routine in fleet auto accidents. Uber gets this all the time. They want to pass the buck to the driver, but they have to be able to identify the driver to do that. So they are very helpful about identifying the driver.
Because this arises from a criminal offense, Google's terms of service may be irrelevant. You cannot contract away liability for a crime.
So there's stuff you can do. This sort of thing usually settles out of court. But when you file a lawsuit, you're dealing with people well above the level of the customer service staff. Talk to a lawyer. Might even be able to find one willing to take this on a contingency fee basis.
This is an area where Google might not want extensive pre-trial discovery looking into exactly what level of cooperation they provide extortionists. If someone is extorting small dollar amounts, they're doing this more than once.
- hyperpape 4y agoThis sounds interesting, but are you aware of anyone who has used this strategy with a major social network/content distribution platform and had success? Reading, I wonder if it's the sort of thing where Google’s lawyers could brush you off because companies that large are effectively immune.
- duxup 4y agoI’m wondering the same. Is this just a legal hypothetical that is nice to believe it would work? Has anyone actually done this/ been successful? How much did it cost?
- jelled 4y agoLarge companies definitely aren't immune from litigation over stuff like this. I sent Google a demand letter for breach of contract for wrongfully terminating my Adsense account. In the letter I gave them 30 days to restore my account and pay the money they had wrongfully withheld. On the 30th day the account was restored and the money was paid. Though I wrote the letter myself, I'd imagine anyone similarly situated could hire an attorney who practices contract law to write a similar letter for relatively low cost.
- throwaway2037 4y agoWow, great story. Please write a blog post about this and share on HN. It would be great to have template letters. Then people can fill, print, and post!
- jelled 4y agoI wrote up a couple blog posts as it was happening. Here's the most recent one. https://benbjurstrom.com/youtube-remonetized https://benbjurstrom.com/youtube-remonetized
- jelled 4y agoRegarding the template letter idea, I would advise anyone thinking of doing this to consult with an attorney. The facts and applicable law may be different in your situation and the letter will undoubtably carry more weight if it's backed the the threat of actual litigation.
- PaywallBuster 4y agoInterested! Could you please share why did they close the account and what argument did you make to have them open it back? I have the same issue for another Google service
- jelled 4y agoThe reason given was "Our specialists have found that your account is related to an account that was disabled for violations of AdSense policies." Since it was impossible for there to be such a relation I argued that under the terms of service governing the Adsense program my account was at all times in good standing and that by withholding payment Google had breached the agreement.
- namelessoracle 4y agoLarge companies are actually more vulnerable in some ways, because they have stuff that can be taken away from them if they dont listen to you. Judges HATE being ignored, and every judge in the nation will have the back of the judge who takes action for being ignored. The advantage the company has it that they can drag things out for years and most people cant fight that battle with them. But smart companies will still respond, billable hours spent to fight it may often cost more than just doing what the customer asks. Using the adsense example, cost to do that all that was for sure way less than actually challenging someone over the issue. Demand letter means at least the legal intern is reading what you said at Google. Which is an improvement over nobody reading it.
- sbassi 4y agoI think the FBI has a threshold amount to get involved. It wont move a finger for $50.
- lisper 4y agoYou’re missing the point. You don’t file the report in order to get the FBI to investigate. That obviously won’t happen. You file in order to establish a record of an allegation of a crime.
- duxup 4y agoThen what? You have “a record”. What does that get you?
- marcosdumay 4y agoThen you go after Google as a coactor on the crime. As the OP's next paragraph says.
- duxup 4y agoYou sue google? This plan actually works?
- safety1st 4y agoCredible legal threats are arguably the MOST effective way to get a big corporation to do what you want, the main disadvantage being that the corporation will be disinclined towards doing business with you afterwards since they can no longer farm you passively for revenue. (If there is a long term relationship based on trust this will usually kill it forever.) There are many steps on the path to filing a lawsuit and actually going to court. For Google these steps are all fantastically expensive. So if a credible threat exists, what usually happens is the case gets escalated to someone in the middle of the chain of command who has broad authority and a mandate to settle the matter as quickly and inexpensively as possible. If that includes giving you whatever you want, so be it. They wouldn't have gotten to Google size if they were willing to die on every hill that came along.
- jbritton 4y agoI also wonder if this could apply to robocalls and phone companies.