10 ms·
‘Mind blowing’ ancient settlements uncovered in the Amazon
- roughly 4y ago1491 by Michael Mann is a must read for anyone even vaguely interested in the Americas before European arrival. It’s a fantastic book that will change how you think about indigenous cultures in the Americas and make this kind of thing seem a lot less surprising.
- bleachedsleet 4y agoWould also recommend the follow up, 1493 for a comparison of how Columbus altered these cultures. Excellent books.
- aerovistae 4y agoI think you mean Charles Mann :) Michael Mann is a director of heist movies.
- mistrial9 4y agoalso this guy -- http://www.met.psu.edu/people/mem45 http://www.met.psu.edu/people/mem45
- roughly 4y agoWhoops, yes, Charles Mann. Too late for an edit or delete; guess that typo's just gonna live there now. Although Michael Mann's filmography is pretty good, too.
- h2odragon 4y agohey you were in the right general neighborhood. "that dude that wrote the book about the thing" is as far as I usually get. "you know, the cover was blue"
- bee_rider 4y agoAnyone who has encountered a potato or corn (maize) should know that the Americas had superior agricultural technology to Europe. Metallurgy and mechanics just leave more obvious artifacts.
- ghotli 4y agoI read this in my late teenage years. I can safely say it had a great impact on me and how I view the world. It was especially jarring as I was still in high school and the narrative I was being taught / had been taught was quite... well it left out a lot of things.
- seibelj 4y agoAncient peoples and societies were very advanced. We constantly find earlier and earlier evidence of advanced behavior and technology because they were using it. People 10k years ago are physiologically the same as us, and human nature does not change, so it isn't surprising that many wanted to live in dense communities, just as we do. The major difference is imagining that you have no knowledge of science. As humans desire control, your brain immediately assumes that gods cause everything, and then to get more control society starts believing they can influence and appease the gods through various rituals, which then develop into organized religion. The total integration of religion with every facet of life is alien to most of us, and certainly to nearly everyone on Hacker News, which is the biggest barrier to imagining yourself living back then. Otherwise, people fell in love, had children, desired to achieve, were constantly striving and innovating, and all of the same types of people and desires that we have today, leading to kings, wars, commerce, and so on.
- humbleMouse 4y agoHow can you state they had no knowledge of science? How do you think they built things like pyramids and countless other mega structures that are exactly aligned with the solar system?
- neaden 4y agoI think this goes to a question of what we mean when we say science. If someone has knowledge of where all the stars are and their movements, but thinks of those stars as gods and believes that their movements affect sickness on Earth, is that science, religion, or some combination?
- rurp 4y agoI don't think it's possible to develop the ability to predict astronomical events without a lot of work analogous to modern science. Sure it was probably couched in some spiritual terms that we wouldn't recognize, but it's probably not all that different to how people will view our modern science in thousands of years.
- 4y ago
- ch4s3 4y agoThese causeway and mound settlement structures have been known for quite awhile, the new thing here seems to be the discovery of a more complex city like settlement. It's seems like cities and complex states probably weren't necessary to build the causeways as evidenced by Poverty Point and the mound building peoples of Ohio and the later Mississippian/Cahokia. However, given the geography in that part of the Amazon basin, these mounds and causeways were probably necessary FOR cities to develop. The other piece is this quote: > By the 20th century, archaeologists had yet to confirm the rumours, and argued that the Amazon’s nutrient-poor soil was inadequate for supporting large-scale agriculture, and that it would have prevented tropical civilizations I think it's worth noting that a number of large settlements north of the Rio Grande managed to grow quite large with limited or no agriculture. Particularly where fish were plentiful, farming wasn't taken up even when contemporaneous neighboring groups farmed. Similar to Kosher or Halal, not farming seemed to be a matter of cultural or religious preference/edict among some pre-Columbian indigenous peoples.
- ellopoppit 4y ago>> By the 20th century, archaeologists had yet to confirm the rumours, and argued that the Amazon’s nutrient-poor soil was inadequate for supporting large-scale agriculture Those archaelogists were also ignorant of Terra Preta https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terra_preta https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terra_preta
- ch4s3 4y agoYeah, the next half of the paragraph I quoted mentions that. I'm not sure if the range of Terra Preta extends all the way to the site in question, but it may. Either way it seems like some amount of soil improvement was happening on all of the mounds I've read about in the region.
- et-al 4y agoPrevious discussion with link to actual paper: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31511047 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31511047
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoInteresting. I have a question though. It notes in the article that “ Amazon’s nutrient-poor soil was inadequate”. How can the soil be so deficient in a forest where there is constant death and decay? Or is it because the trees don’t shed their leaves seasonally? I would have imagined that a place so rich in biodiversity had rich soil.
- detaro 4y agoDead matter decays quickly (due to hot&wet climate) on the surface instead of settling into the ground and decaying there. And rich ecosystem also grows fast, picking up any nutrients immediately. And high rainfall etc means nutrients would be washed out quickly. These three things mean that soil in tropical rainforests isn't nutrient-rich, because the nutrients are constantly reused everywhere else.
- Razengan 4y agoThat logic doesn’t make sense: “This person isn’t rich because he keeps spending millions.” If the soil wasn’t “rich” how did it become such a forest in the first place? Maybe reword it as “forests are not suitable for farmland”.
- axus 4y agoIf you're always spending money (soil), there's nothing left for someone else (the farmer) to steal.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- minsc_and_boo 4y agoIt's rich because of the insane cash flows going through the soil. Clear out the rainforest for traditional agri and you've lost your insane income.
- codefreeordie 4y agoAt one time in the past, it was richer. But the forest ecosystem was too stable, causing it to continue to grow until it had consumed all of the resources, leaving the soil poor. But the forest remains, and remains almost maximally stable, so any time that anything dies, freeing up resources, they're almost immediately taken back up by the system and converted into more forest.
- zwilliamson 4y agoI would be curious to hear author and researcher Graham Hancock’s take on this. His theories on human history based upon archeological evidence are very interesting. He predicted old new kingdoms were yet to be discovered in Amazon basin. Fingerprints of the Gods was one of his good reads
- bee_rider 4y agoIs he a well regarded expert on this kind of stuff? I've never heard of him, just -- title in the format "<Noun> of the <Dramatic Noun>" tend to set off little alarm bells in my head.
- rfwhyte 4y agoNo, Graham Hancock is an anti-science charlatan. No actual archaeologists take him remotely seriously.
- mistrial9 4y agodescribing people who publish original thought as "anti-something-important derogatory-name" sets off alarm bells for me. Is conformity really that precious? are public writings so black-and-white ?
- nobody9999 4y ago> describing people who publish original thought as "anti-something-important derogatory-name" sets off alarm bells for me. Is conformity really that precious? are public writings so black-and-white ? In that case, I recommend you check out Erich von Danniken[0], Giorgio Tsoukalos[1] and Charles Dawson[2]. They have some original thoughts that have been wildly popular. Or are you saying that if something is "popular" that it's "conformity" and should be rejected for being conformist? If it's generally accepted (as bible dogma in the middle ages was), then it must be a false flag designed to hoodwink the masses into accepting false information, because no amount of consensus is enough. amirite? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erich_von_D%C3%A4niken https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erich_von_D%C3%A4niken [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giorgio_A._Tsoukalos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giorgio_A._Tsoukalos [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Dawson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Dawson
- motohagiography 4y agoRaises the question of what about our present beliefs and thinking should change as a consequence of discovering advanced civilizations that have risen and fallen not only independent of "us," but of our ability to have ever precived the possibility of their existence. Makes me want to write a sci-fi story about predicting the reflection of coherent radio signals from distant planets that originated on earth hundreds or thousands of years ago, and the ML model that filters for candidate signals, as though it were more plausible that old civilizations discovered radio before they were wiped out than another advanced civilization inhabit nearby solar systems. Starts with capturing reflections of 1930s broadcasts, but then the method scales by applying it to further objects that reflect ones from further back in time.
- edgyquant 4y agoThis is a hard subject to discuss because there’s a ton of fud and unintellectual nonsense (e.g. people who want hyperborea or Atlantis to have been real industrial civilizations.) There probably wasn’t some industrial level civilization as we know it. But there’s 200,000 years of human history and the there was another ~20ky period like ours 120,000 years ago in between ice ages. Humans migrated across the old world at this time and they likely had societies we’ll never know about. I try to envision ways they could have achieved cool tech but primitive. So maybe there was no industrial civilization but maybe some mystic religious society devised some way to do computation (if we really wanted to we can build do computation with water and irrigation) and learned a ton about the universe. My hot take is we do man a disservice by saying civilization began with writing. There were certainly societies that learned lots of truths about the universe and passed them on via memes and superstitions.
- acegopher 4y agoI've often wondered... what is the most advanced civilization (human or not) that could have existed some number of years back and not left evidence, or the evidence was destroyed through natural processes, or the evidence would remain in places we can't/haven't discovered? Conversely, at each known stage of human civilization, how long will it be before evidence of that civilization becomes unknowable through future archaeology?
- steeleyespan 4y agoI find I get insights about the future by peering into the past, especially when it comes to slaying my enemies.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stakkur 4y agoGreat, but they’re not ‘ancient’, at least by common definitions of what ancient means. They’re relatively recent, historically speaking.
- yesenadam 4y agoThe article says "starting about 1,500 years ago, ancient Amazonians built and lived in densely populated centres". From a quick google, ancient most commonly is defined to mean, until about 500AD or before the fall of Rome (476). But that's in a European history context. It seems that ancient in the context of the Americas is usually applied to anything pre-1492.
- stakkur 4y agoUnderneath all this is a recent phenomenon to recast Central/South American civilizations as 'ancient' and 'comparable' to other non-American civilizations. A lot of this is normal, on the level kind of research, but there's a significant amount of breathless hyperbole about it too. You can usually identify the latter by the language it uses. This article does a lot of that ("Mind blowing!" "Challenges archeaological dogma!" "Mysterious"!), and it repeats something that's very suspect, even amongst conservative historians--it dates civilization in the area to "10,000 years old". Also, much of what's in these kinds of articles is not new, but simply repackaged content.
- yesenadam 4y agoMaybe I was too obscure or something - there's no sign in your reply that you heard my point: that, contrary to what you said, it seems 500AD is "‘ancient’, at least by common definitions of what ancient means."
- stakkur 4y agoMaybe you thought I was trying to respond to your point, instead of adding more information of my own.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoEach time remains of an ancient city are uncovered, I wonder the same thing: is the estimation of size of the city correct? They include all the settlement remains. But perhaps it was serial - that is, new places were built as old ones decayed? They were often mud brick. Perhaps it wasn't 1000 people, but 100 moving 10 times etc.
- iostream24 4y agoWe speak of evidence for having had writing systems, but it’s worth noting that we preselect for mineral-based writing systems. Paper/papyrus/neet-weavings tend to rot if made from organic matter. We certainly find marked sticks where preservation of organic matter is possible, I.e. frozen crag falling victims. The article references these jungle cities to have disappeared around 1400ce, and I wonder what this estimate is based upon and if it’s not 1500ce instead, as disease could be the culprit…
- pvg 4y agoDiscussed yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31511047 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31511047
- ozten 4y agoThe Dawn of Everything - A new history of humanity by David Graeber and David Wengrow is a fascinating book that challenges the dominant western narrative and re-examines the archeological record giving credit to the contributions and achievements of ingenious peoples.