3 ms·
If enough people actually cared about this, then you’d have people marching on the capitol, like after a certain president was not re-elected. If people haven’
by Aeolun 4y ago
If enough people actually cared about this, then you’d have people marching on the capitol, like after a certain president was not re-elected.
If people haven’t gotten motivated enough after literally decades of this shit, I find it really hard to blame the law.
- School-Cotton 4y ago> If enough people actually cared about this, then you’d have people marching on the capitol, like after a certain president was not re-elected. People do care, and they do protest and march, and like most protests anywhere it does not change anything. Sorry but you seem to have a very naive view of the effectiveness of protests. By the way, the pro-Trump protests didn’t achieve anything either (other than furthering the US’s slide into bitter ultra-partisan division and total erosion of trust in institutions). Notably, they did not successfully enable Trump to remain president. So what is your point?
- LoveGracePeace 4y ago
- chrischen 4y agoThat amendment was written back when a gun was more powerful than words or information, and when gun ownership was more prevalent and necessary. In our modern day information, speech, and and privacy are the guns that ensure rights are not stomped on. It’s no longer the wild wild west. To think that rules written hundreds of years ago never need to be changed is spitting in the face of our founders who realized that the process of amendments are necessary because things change. The irony is that people are defending the second amendment by claiming it cannot be amended.
- alar44 4y ago
- chrischen 4y agoI don’t understand your rebuttal?
- hunterb123 4y ago
- chrischen 4y agoBy the time the KGB come knocking at your door it’s already over. What we need is an amendment guaranteeing our right to encryption and privacy, so that the KGB won’t even know which door to knock on. Back then your arms were pretty well matched against the government. Today, not so much. Civilians and their small arms are no match for the KGB or modern US military. If we really wanted a way to check the physical power of the US military we’d need a bit more than some semi automatic rifles. They are literally in their current form just play things for the wealthy who don’t want to give up their gun hobby, and liabilities for the rest of civilian society due to the criminally insane.
- jdr23bc 4y agoJanuary 6th is somewhere in the neighbourhood of the kind of scenario your referencing. Ubiquitous guns change the equation for all kinds of theoretical events. They may be a boon in the "armed populous saves country from corrupt gov't" case, and a curse in another case. Were a more extreme version of Jan 6th to occur in the future, adding civilian firearms into the mix may not be a good thing.
- hunterb123 4y agoCivilians chose not to bring guns to that protest. The only person shot was an unarmed civilian. Even so, guns have been involved in protests before without a problem.
- rswail 4y agoThe only person shot was an unarmed terrorist that, after repeated warnings not to proceed, while attempting to break through a barrier that was keeping a mob away from elected representatives, broke through that barrier. I think it shows remarkable restraint by the security and protection officers that more people weren't shot on January 6th. And it is untrue that "civilians" "chose" not to bring guns. There were numerous people that had preparations to be armed and were actively working to that end. They are currently being tried for sedition.
- hunterb123 4y ago> after repeated warnings not to proceed Untrue, there was no warning. Crowd was let in (there is security footage of this), funneled to a location, and a killzone was setup without their knowledge. The antifa person filming the death was the only person hurling threats in that specific interaction. Both hands of the civilian shot were visible when climbing through the window. Officer could have arrested when she made it through. I guess we're for shooting on sight now. > I think it shows remarkable restraint by the security and protection officers that more people weren't shot on January 6th. Yes let's praise cops for not killing more unarmed civilians than they did, very high bar! > there were numerous people that had preparations to be armed and were actively working to that end. What a long way to say they didn't bring guns to the event. Any CCW holder has preparations to be armed. > sedition Point to a case, noone is being tried for sedition, only trespassing.
- bruce511 4y agoAh yes, the hypothetical dictator defense. Nothing that said dictator would need support from the military (which has demonstrated it is not necessarily keen to go that route), how well will your "well armed" people fare against well trained soldiers with, um, "tanks" (using tanks here as a catchall for all their weapons.)?
- jcbrand 4y agoGoat herders with AK-47s did pretty well in Afghanistan and basically defeated the US military after 20 years. A highly motivated and armed insurgency is almost impossible to control, even if you have superior fire-power.
- hunterb123 4y agoAh yes, the "the gov. is too powerful so what's the point of fighting tyranny" talking point. The tank premise is almost as stupid as Biden's nukes / jets threat against the American people. A country is not going to carpet bomb, send tanks in, or nuke its own people / land. It takes a lot of brainwashing to get your soldiers to do that to their own people and direct force like that will lead to instant revolts. What is much more likely is a KGB like secret police that goes around black bagging people, etc. You're much less likely to be able to do that when you know the civilian population has more guns than your secret police.
- curiousgal 4y ago> If enough people actually cared about this, then you’d have people marching on the capitol, like after a certain president was not re-elected. THANK YOU! Say what you will about those supporters but the fact they went that far to support something they believed in (albeit dumb honestly) is admirable. Meanwhile the people with actual good values are just sharing senators' edgy tweets thinking that makes a difference.
- mrguyorama 4y ago
- mulmen 4y agoThere's nothing admirable about the January 6th attackers. Do you also admire the 9/11 hijackers? How about the gunman in this most recent school shooting? These are all "true believers". Most people exist in the expansive middle ground between regurgitating Tweets and insurrection.
- rswail 4y agoThey have and they do. If you recall, there were marches and protests across the US after the Parkland school shooting. However, there are 50+ Senators, disproportionally representing low population, rural states, that are beholden to the NRA and its illegal funding and mis/dis-information campaigns. There are Senators today suggesting that schools be turned into prison-like places (Cruz with his "one door in and out" nonsense), that others are suggesting arming teachers, while ignoring the fact that the school protection officer and local law enforcement engaged the murderer in this school shooting but failed to apprehend or stop him and the SWAT team took 40 minutes to engage the murderer and eliminate the threat. People have been marching and protesting and demonstrating continuously and yet there is a specific party, the Republicans, and specific lobby groups, that have stopped any change.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tomp 4y ago> However, there are 50+ Senators, disproportionally representing low population, rural states, that are beholden to the NRA and its illegal funding and mis/dis-information campaigns. Well, there's the political interpretation (NRA lobbying) and the factual interpretation as well: "low population rural states" i.e. where guns are used for hunting & self-defence (low population but also huge, so low density, so the nearest police/neighbours are so far away you can't always rely on their help)