3 ms·
Is there really no way to monitise an audience with ads without collecting their personal info? That seems more of a problem than GDPR exposing that underlying
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
Is there really no way to monitise an audience with ads without collecting their personal info?
That seems more of a problem than GDPR exposing that underlying issue.
edit: seems like Google have a non-personalised ad option, but it still uses cookies:
> A Non-Personalized Ads solution (Ad Manager Help Center, AdSense Help Center) allows you to present EEA and UK users with a choice between personalized ads and non-personalized ads (or to choose to serve only non-personalized ads to all users in the EEA and the UK). Non-Personalized Ads only use contextual information, including coarse general (city-level) location.
Although these ads don’t use cookies for ads personalization, they do use cookies to allow for frequency capping, aggregated ad reporting, and to combat fraud and abuse. Consent is therefore required to use cookies for those purposes from users in countries to which the ePrivacy Directive’s cookie provisions apply.
- muro 4y agoThere is a reason why personalised ads are everywhere. They save advertisers money and bring higher revenues to sites hosting them.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoYeah, there's also a reason our polluted rivers used to catch fire and children worked in mines, both those things were cheaper/more profitable to the decision maker too. But have we forced every non abusive advertising platform out of business as a result of tolerating this abuse for so long?
- Jensson 4y agoA non abusive advertising platform wouldn't be subjected to GDPR problems, this should make it easier for them to compete and thrive not harder. When it was legal to just collect all data about users from everywhere and sell it etc then it was impossible for good actors to compete. What we see today is that all those bad actors who profited from all those bad actions are complaining and having problems, that is a good thing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- solarkraft 4y ago> Is there really no way to monetise an audience with ads without collecting their personal info? There sure is: Contextual ads. DuckDuckGo does it, various documentation sites do it (https://www.ethicalads.io/ https://www.ethicalads.io/), a dutch broadcaster does it (https://archive.ph/Zk4Pv https://archive.ph/Zk4Pv). It's how newspapers used to work and TV channels still do, as well as YouTube sponsorships (and probably many more). It improves the UX over personalized ads because a) you don't have to invade your users' privacy (including asking them for permission to do it, obviously) and b) the ad is actually relevant to the context the user is thinking about, instead of something completely unrelated from some other part of their life (or, more often than not, something completely random).
- macinjosh 4y agoContextual ads have their own set of problems for advertisers though. Think of a blog post writing about someone's traumatic experiences with pregnancy and miscarriages and the algo decides to put an ad for newborn clothes next to it. Ouch...
- WA 4y agoAs a website owner, you probably can provide a bunch of stop words or block domains you don't want to have advertising from.
- solarkraft 4y agoThat can happen with personalized ads. One point of contextual ads is actually letting you control what is shown besides your content/what context you want your ad to be shown in. Besides ... most current ads are distasteful regardless of context.
- makomk 4y agoNot unless you're a NYT-level big player, and even those don't seem terribly keen on the idea. The fundamental problem is that advertisers want to know that their ads are being shown to actual people who are actually interested in what they're selling rather than bots run by fraudsters with fake websites full of fake traffic, which means tracking and attributing clickthrough, and that alone is enough to count as personally identifiable information for the purposes of laws like the GDPR. Contextual ads and not tracking users in order to select the ads doesn't solve this issue, it just reduces the profitability of advertising.