5 ms·
Yes, but a person can write a paper just as well in Wordperfect 5 as the latest Google Doc or Office365 Word. How many millions of dev-hours have been expended
by SoftTalker 4y ago
Yes, but a person can write a paper just as well in Wordperfect 5 as the latest Google Doc or Office365 Word. How many millions of dev-hours have been expended on stuff that fundamentally doesn't do anything new?
Edit: saying they don't do anything new isn't right. They do, especially with regards to collaboration. What I really mean is that they don't make the essential task -- the actual writing -- much easier. That's still human/mental work. Once you have come up with the words, putting the words into a document is the easy part.
- KronisLV 4y ago> Saying they don't do anything new isn't right. Perhaps it's possible that some people simply don't see the benefit of the newly added functionality, because they don't really use it? For example, personally I'd be served perfectly well with something like LibreOffice, so from my point of view, all of these new solutions do not indeed do much new (that I'd benefit from) and sometimes do things worse (cloud based platform with all the drawbacks that come with it vs local software in open formats). That's not to say that the point that you're making wouldn't be important, quite on the contrary - and even if the software doesn't do anything new, even in those cases one can make an argument for refinement being a worthy pursuit (as long as it's not a useless rewrite). Perhaps text editing isn't the best example, given how different people's expectations can be in that regard.
- wolverine876 4y ago> a person can write a paper just as well in Wordperfect 5 as the latest Google Doc or Office365 Word That seems hard to believe; try printing, or formatting. It's like saying 'a person can fly just as well in a 1930s biplane or a current 737.' Sure, they both fly. On the other hand, am I more productive in 2022 Emacs than I would be in 1985 Emacs?
- dredmorbius 4y agoAs Robert Gordon notes in his The Rise and Fall of American Growht, an air traveller in 1936 headed from New York to Chicago, could have made the trip in 3h 55m gate-to-gate, vs. 2h 35m today. But in 1936, arrival at the airport need only be 10 minutes prior to departure, gates were immediately next to the terminal entrance, and taxis or a chauffeured Cadillac limousine were 5 minutes from the gate --- the latter cost $10.50 in 2014 prices. The 2014 traveller must arrive an hour prior to departure, it takes 20 minutes merely to get off the plane on average (from the middle of the plane) on arrival, and 5--10 minutes to get to the taxi line. The net trip is only 20 minutes shorter than in 1936, despite the faster in-flight leg. Much more of that time is spent standing, waiting, or walking. Robert J. Gordon, The Rise and Fall of American Growth (2015), pp. 396-7.
- wolverine876 4y agoGood points. Still, there are imperfections in the argument: safety, availability (very few could afford that flight in 1936, if I understand correctly), range (NY to LA or London would be entirely different, etc.).
- dredmorbius 4y agoThe range question was addressed by 1960. Costs fell markedly from 1930 -- 1970. Far less so since. It's popular to point to how much airline ticket prices have fallen since dregulation (under Democratic president Carter) in 1979, without also noting that 1979 was a local price peak driven by the Iranian oil embargo of the same year. Safety has increased, of course. That's largely been a continuous function from the first days of flight ... with a curious exception in the first decade of the 2000s, where passenger deaths/mile fell markedly. (Also in Gordon's book.)
- wolverine876 4y ago> Safety has increased, of course. Come to think of it, security too. Hijackings weren't unusual news items in the 1970s; now, it's hard to remember the last one. And that partly explains the slower airport experience today (which is really due to nobody investing in the resources to speed it up). > It's popular to point to how much airline ticket prices have fallen since dregulation (under Democratic president Carter) in 1979, without also noting that 1979 was a local price peak driven by the Iranian oil embargo of the same year. A lot of those narratives are similar if one takes even a cursory look at the facts. As an aside (and IIRC), per the autobiography of former Fed chair Alan Greenspan, who was not a Democrat (and was a follower of Ayn Rand) and served in various roles under many presidents including Carter, deregulation began under Carter.
- dredmorbius 4y agoYou're largely right. Early air travel externalised numerous costs, and those have been internalised. "Big Sky" air traffic policy was proved nonviable over the Grand Canyon (1956) and Park Slope (1960). Bombings and hijackings of the 1960s and 1970s lead to increased departure-gate screenings. Those increased further after 2001. Noise complaints lead to use of quieter high-bypass turbofan engines (with their own MAX failure modes). Increased fuel costs in the 1970s also prompted higher-efficiency engines (again, high-bypass turbofans serve this role), as well as curtailment or cancellation of planned commercial supersonic transports. Gordon also discusses similar apparent retrograde trends in automobiles. Here again I see formerly externalised costs (emissions, safety, handling, noise) being internalised and included in purchase costs. Electrification is a similar trend.
- humanrebar 4y agoCollaborative editing is an essential task in my job. Go back twenty years and folks were emailing copies of copies of drafts back and forth. Today, two authors use two keyboards and two screens and just type. That's very different.
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoThe vast majority of the world is still doing the emailing back and forth method.
- jdauriemma 4y agoSource?
- chii 4y agoSo if their productivity isn't growing, it might be because those people aren't taking advantage of productivity multiplying software. But there's no question that the collaboration capabilities of these software increases productivity.
- listenallyall 4y agoMore likely, multiple people got in a small room together and wrote it all out. Faster, less hassle, better collaboration and idea generation.
- musicale 4y ago> write a paper just as well in Wordperfect 5 as the latest Google Doc or Office365 Word Google docs and Overleaf have dramatically improved my collaborative writing workflow. Long-distance collaboration is also drastically cheaper and easier than it used to be.