5 ms·
Could youtube-dlp and YouTube Vanced now be hosted on.. YouTube? I wonder how long it'd take for Google to crack down on the system abuse. Is it really abuse
by metadat 4y ago
Could youtube-dlp and YouTube Vanced now be hosted on.. YouTube?
I wonder how long it'd take for Google to crack down on the system abuse.
Is it really abuse if the videos are viewable / playable? Presumably the ToS either already forbids covert channel encoding or soon will.
- throwaway0a5e 4y ago>Is it really abuse if the videos are viewable / playable? Presumably the ToS either already forbids covert channel encoding or soon will. If creators start encoding their source and material into their content Google would probably be fine with that because it gives them data but also gives them context for that data. Edit: I meant like "director's commentary" and "notes about production" type stuff like you used to see added to DVDs back in the day. Not "using youtube as my personal file storage". Why is this such an unpopular opinion?
- baud147258 4y ago> If creators start encoding their source material into their files Google would probably be fine with that it'd depends, as I don't think people using YT to store files would watch a lot of adds
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoIf creators use it like the appendix in a book I can see people watching ads on their way to it.
- jklinger410 4y ago> If creators start encoding their source material into their files Google would probably be fine with that Not true at all, lol. Google has a paid file storage solution. YouTube is for streaming video and that's the activity they expect on that platform. I couldn't imagine any service designed for one format would "probably be fine" with users encoding other files inside of that format.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoI think the parent comment is limiting themselves to the embedding of metadata specific to the containing file. It would be like adding a single frame, but would potentially give useful information to Google. In those limited circumstances I think the parent is correct.
- sevenf0ur 4y agoProbably breaks TOS under video spam
- throwaway92394 4y agoJust gotta add some good 'ol steganography
- javajosh 4y agoThis brings up an interesting question: what is the upper-bound of hidden data density using video steganography? E.g. how much extra data can you add before noticeable degradation? It's interesting because it requires both a detailed understanding of video encoding and also understanding of human perception of video.
- samatman 4y agoI've seen drone metal videos where the video and audio could both be 90% steganography and I wouldn't know the difference.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoI'd expect you could store more data steganographically than the raw video data. You can probably do things like add frames that can't be decoded and so are skipped by a decoder; that effectively allows arbitrary added hidden data. That's maybe cheating. If you stipulate that you can't already have a copy of the unaltered file, and the data has to be extractable from a pixel copy of the rendered frames ... that becomes more interesting, I think.
- paranoidrobot 4y agoYoutube doesn't give you the raw video back, it does transcoding to their given standard bitrates/resolution sets. You'll notice this if someone has just uploaded a video to Youtube and the only version available for playback is some 360p/480p version for a few hours until Youtube gets around to processing higher bitrates. So whatever you're encoding has to survive that transcode process.
- robonerd 4y agoIf you put youtube-dlp on youtube as a video, make sure to use youtube-dlp to it up.
- cush 4y agoIt's one of those problems that resolves itself. The process of creating and using the files is prohibitively unusable and so many better solutions exist that YT doesn't need to worry about it