6 ms·
Ask HN: What would you do with $700 Billion?
This is basically the title on CNN's site right now, and I thought what a great question to ask you guys.
Me? It's got to be a lunar base. Always wanted one.
- einarvollset 18y agoI would sponsor a manned mission to Mars. It's roughly the same amount of money.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agomoney doesn't solve problems, smart people do. money is just a way of freeing smart people of distractions. and i think 70 billion in todays dollars is a lot more realistic than 700 billion. that said: 10 billion for space elevator research 10 billion for terraforming mars research 10 billion in scholarships available to anyone in the world as well as the money needed to pull strings to get the smartest kids into the best colleges. 10 billion for a clean water research 30 billion in free contraception/medical for every country.
- run4yourlives 18y agoI wouldn't do anything. You would, because I will own you.
- qqq 18y ago100 billion goes to speeding up immortality and cryonics research a lot. i don't want to die, and i'd rather you didn't die either. 10 million (or whatever) pays for aubrey de grey, and anyone he recommends, to be my advisors for using the 100 billion effectively.
- thebigshane 18y agoFind the 299 most influential people in the world and pay them 10m a year for twenty years to do my bidding. Hold on the last 2 billion for reserves in case they turn on me.
- thebigshane 18y agoI'm surprised no one has mentioned buying Microsoft or Apple and "open source"-ing them. That would be $300b if you buy them at market cap value.
- noodle 18y agoi'd probably take one or two billion and buy myself a giant island to live on and forever take care of my personal needs. and fly into space a few times, too. after that, i'd take the half of the remaining and invest it in technology and fields that i'd like to see improved (i.e. space travel, science, alternative energy, etc etc) i'd take the other half and invest/give it to more charitable devices (poverty relief & research, disease research, land preservation funds, etc etc) basically, try and make the world a better place.
- auntjemima 18y agoI'd take two billion too, set up the rest of the money as a trust to fund four specific areas: 1. get people in the developing world clean water, access to enough food, and healthcare 2. give people money to get themselves out of debt (with accountability) 3. lobby the US government for various tax (simplicity is needed), healthcare, and humanitarian laws 4. funding for major energy research results
- yan 18y agoTaking an entire giant island for one person would make the world a better place?
- pchristensen 18y agoGiving $698 billion to tech research and charity probably would.
- noodle 18y agowould you like me to say "i'd give it all up to charity"? i'd be lying if i said that, and so would anyone else. i've always wanted to live on an island, thanks for shitting on my dreams in a hypothetical thread :*-(
- yan 18y agoI was just sitting on my hypothetical high horse and giving you a hard time. Friends?
- rokhayakebe 18y agoRelease the hundreds of drugs some people will not approve because that will hurt their financial interest.
- sfamiliar 18y agogive $11,000 to each of the 62 million households in the u.s. making under $50,000. watch the ensuing chaos with glee.
- potatolicious 18y ago... Give $11,000 to each household making under $50,000, and you're in essence paying all of that towards households making over $50,000. Some people are poor because they're honestly down on their luck, and need a helping hand. The majority on the other hand are simply unemployable, or horrible with their finances. Give them a handout and the money will simply end up in richer people's hands. That's not helping them.
- nostrademons 18y agoHowever, if you gave $11K in seed capital to anyone making under $50k who has a viable plan for a business with the promise of a few hundred K more if they started showing traction, then you might shake things up a bit. ...wait, isn't that YCombinator?
- steveplace 18y agoI don't think the yC model would scale up to 700B. I think it would be a great experiment, though.
- MaysonL 18y agoGrameen bank?
- Retric 18y agoHey, I was working with a college degree for 3 years before I broke 50k. At the time I was investing 8% of my income and I was still eating out all the time etc. I think the bar for poor needs to be a little lower than 50k/year.
- 18y ago
- no_body 18y agoI would bootstrap the asteroid mining economy, invest in micro-terraforming and nano-technology so that each asteroid could become it's own self sufficient republic. Yay Anarchy !
- ph0rque 18y ago>...each asteroid could become it's own self sufficient republic. Yay Anarchy! That's not anarchy, since each republic would presumably have its own government.
- steveplace 18y agoA "Federation" if you will.
- ivankirigin 18y agoBuild a space elevator and start mining the asteroids. This involves a robot army that would need to be built as well. No, I'm not joking
- gambling8nt 18y ago$700 b is not nearly enough to make a space elevator with existing technology; you're off by about a factor of 1000. Of course, if you're willing to wait ten years for the cost to produce carbon nanotubes to drop...
- ivankirigin 18y agoActually my brother and a good friend recently attended a conference on the subject, and I'm not pulling numbers out of the air. Clearly there is room for dispute, but between 10B and 1000B is a most reasonable range. I also disagree in principle that anything could cost $700T dollars. Are you telling me that the whole of the US working for 50 years couldn't build it? Because US GDP is ~$14T. Also, you don't launch a company and next year make an elevator. There is a lot of tech to develop. You don't just sit on that tech. Materials made cheap enough to build a earth bound tether would have plenty of other applications. As would the automated or teleoperated construction robots. Also, the first elevator on the moon wouldn't require much innovation in materials at all. But I do have a very armchair understanding of the topic.
- gambling8nt 18y agoIn spring of 2005 I did a back of the envelope calculation on the total cost to produce the mass of carbon nanotubes needed for an elevator with cross-section of 1 cm^2 using the methods available then and got a result of about 1.25 quadrillion dollars--a sum truly large enough to be meaningless. It appears there have been several significant advances since then, including the revision of the intended cross-sectional area downward, and improvements in the production costs. And my estimate on costs was precisely in the vein of "next year make an elevator"--I do not doubt that there will be a space elevator long before the next 50 years pass, I merely doubt that $700b is sufficient that a feasible short term effort could be made. A lunar elevator, while a nice proof of concept for a terrestrial space elevator, has two major problems: (1) There isn't really a point; the moon's gravity well is too weak for it to be worth it to construct an elevator any time soon. (2) Getting the material there without an existing terrestrial space elevator (and possibly even with one) is a prohibitively expensive exercise. Research into the construction of a space elevator is a worthwhile pursuit likely to result in many useful technological advances. But $700b is not enough to construct one in the short term from existing technology, and is too much to be usefully applied to further research.
- jcapote 18y agoSuper Crack Party.
- Jasber 18y agoNation-wide high-speed wireless. Computers for schools. Spend the rest on paying down our debt.
- whacked_new 18y agoCreate an alternative, multi-tiered research funding organization and proceed to turn the education system upside down. In fact, $700b is more than enough to do this several times over, so the surplus will probably go to funding a century of other programs related to exploration, bioengineering, green technology, and other sustainable development projects. Seriously, what could it be other than this?
- potatolicious 18y agoAgreed. I would establish an organization that will essentially usurp the position of the NSF. It will be non-partisan, be free from political influence, and non-ideologically driven. It will be available to all academics everywhere. My brother is a researcher in evolutionary biology. I have seen how the Bush administration has been sabotaging funding into this area over the last few years. Science should be a free for all of ideas, not influenced by politics, religion, or anything else except good hard science.
- phr 18y agoIt's nice to talk about being non-partisan, non-political, non-ideological, etc., but it's a lot easier said than done. One way might be to fund a series of huge prizes for the company that first achieves one of your goals. I'd start with a couple billion to the first company to achieve sustainable low-cost access to low Earth orbit. I'd also hand out lesser amounts to p+B11 fusion projects (EMC2 and there's another one I can't remember right now), to fund their research, with maybe $5B to the first to get a 1GW commercial plant on-line.
- jrockway 18y agoIt will be non-partisan, be free from political influence, and non-ideologically driven. How much of the $700b will be left over after you've developed the sentient robots needed to staff this place? ;)
- staticshock 18y agoIt will be non-partisan, be free from political influence, and non-ideologically driven. Really? No bias? How about this: you'd be a sucker. People apply for grant money and are rejected because the grants are often terrible. Sure, sometimes good grants get rejected, but, overall, the review system is pretty functional. I don't know much about NSF in particular, but if they reviewed grant proposals and then gave out money without passing judgement on quality, they'd be wasting a whole lot of money. And you'd really have to remove all judgement if you wanted a system where all academics are equal. So, judgement is back. Now, tell me this: now that we're judging, can we really keep ideological bias out? You have to remember that grant money can pay salaries. If you give it out to anyone, people will abuse it. You make a valid point about the Bush administration, though.
- pavelludiq 18y agoI would start my own aircraft company, all my planes would have lisp based auto pilot AI's.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- kingkongrevenge 18y agoBuy off the government. Mostly dismantle it.
- gills 18y agoWhat will you do with the rest? If they pass this bill, apparently it costs less than $700B to buy them out...
- fallentimes 18y agoWorld's biggest gravity bong; it'd take the place of Ohio.
- tdavis 18y agoI can't imagine the logistics of such a thing, but it's intriguing enough that I'd visit home to try it!
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- kamme 18y agoI think I would buy an uninhabited island and make it a research facility where top scientists can work together and find a way to optimize solar power and batteries. If I have those I will start a production company that makes those inventions and sells them at the price (or below) it costs to make the goods so everyone can use them. I would also invest in agriculture in dry area's (africa for example). What I would NOT do is waste it on politics, that's why I want the uninhabited island. If you build a facility/production company with that goal there will be government regulations about it and as most of us know, they tend to screw things up and only care for their wallet. Also a part of that money will go to education and proper sports centers. I'm a bit overweight myself and I want people to know better then always go to McDonalds and have the option to do any sport they like, as it should be.
- drhowarddrfine 18y agoPut it in the bank.
- natch 18y agoA non-failing bank, I hope.
- gambling8nt 18y agoWith a $700b loan, it wouldn't exactly be failing any more...that's sort of the point of this whole exercise.
- schtog 18y agosurfing-equipment + house on hawaii ~ 6million$ baller-life-style-money: 10$million. my own scientific/tech projects, 1billion. rest i would donate to various scientifc rpoject sand charity.
- run4yourlives 18y agoDude, with ten million you'd barely be able to get off the damn island after a couple of years. Jets cost at least $50M.
- zitterbewegung 18y agoMaybe you should also invest in a spell checker...
- yaj 18y agoShift 3rd/4th world countries to 1st/2nd world.
- steveplace 18y agoRemember, 700B pays for around 400 space shuttles. Just to give a sense of scale.
- huhtenberg 18y agoBetter yet - 612B is what Pentagon is getting in 2009.
- rsheridan6 18y agoSpace shuttle demolition derby, then?
- qwph 18y ago400 space shuttles would be awesome :)
- timtrueman 18y agoI can see it now, synchronized space shuttles in the space olympics (http://www.hulu.com/watch/34464/saturday-night-live-digital-short-space-olympics http://www.hulu.com/watch/34464/saturday-night-live-digital-...)
- dkokelley 18y agoYeah I'd have to race them then.
- gambling8nt 18y agoOr, for other means of comparison, $700b is about: 87 next generation aircraft carriers (or about 155 current-generation aircraft carriers) 500 stealth bombers (or 5000 stealth fighters) 10 years of federal education spending in the US 1.1% of the worldwide annual GDP 2/5 of the combined net worth of the 100 wealthiest people (or, if you prefer, 12 times the net worth of Bill Gates, or about 1/6 of the combined net worth of the 1000 wealthiest people) 23 times the total annual income tax collected from the lower 50% of filers with positive adjusted gross income in 2006 (see http://www.taxfoundation.org/news/show/250.html http://www.taxfoundation.org/news/show/250.html)
- maxklein 18y agoA monocle, a cape and a vizier. Then I'll do whatever he tells me to do with it.
- dangoldin 18y agoI don't see how this is different than any of the other "Non Hacker News" stories yet this one gets approval. What's up?
- cstejerean 18y agothis is not a story, this is a legitimate question.
- graywh 18y agoLegitimate? That's debatable.
- run4yourlives 18y agoIt would be debatable if they weren't ready to put someone in this exact position.
- Retric 18y agoInvest 50 billion and spend each years profit trying to build a real working fusion power plant, (~1 new ITER style plant design per year pick the best one and build it every 5.) when that's working invest the 50billion in power plants and keep growing till all the worlds energy needs are met. I expect 20 - 30 years till first one works and then massive ramp up. 50 billion 3rd world sweat shops to jump start the worlds economy. 100 billion, retro fit a lane on all US highway's with electric grids / contacts so there is no need for battery systems and we can go electric now. I would start by targeting the commercial trucking industry and then move to cars. 1billion fun money for me. And I don't know about the rest.
- natch 18y agoSolar electric for, back of the envelope, maybe 1/3rd of the US total electricity supply. I'm not an electric power expert - maybe someone with actual expertise will correct me.
- davidw 18y agoIf you'll settle for Zimbabwe dollars, that shouldn't be too hard to arrange.
- thomasmallen 18y agoYou know what I would do if I had seven hundred million dollars? I would invest half of it in low risk mutual funds, and then take the other half over to my friend Asadura who works over in Securities...
- mtw 18y agoresearch in space travel, terraform Mars, build cheaper space shuttles
- jm4 18y agoTwo chicks at the same time. Seriously, I have no idea what I'd do with that amount of money. If I was completely selfish maybe I'd buy an island somewhere. I sure as hell wouldn't use it to bail out a bunch of failed businesses whose executives have been giving themselves multi-million dollar bonuses.
- jmtame 18y agolmfao... office space ftw
- samwise 18y agohehe I would invest it. I would buy most of wall street and wait for it to bounce back. Turn that 700b to 10 trillion.
- einarvollset 18y agoYeah cause you're gonna notice the difference between 700b and 10trillion..
- run4yourlives 18y agoAnd then what?
- yters 18y agoA person can do a lot for the world with 10 trillion.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- gtani 18y agoI would hire a team of 87,000 competent developers to develop better documentation for java, C#, javascript, python and ruby. Oh yeah, erlang, OCaml, F#, a few others.
- corentin 18y agoBuy a copy of "The mythical man-month" before.
- rsheridan6 18y agoI'd buy a sovereign country and break it up into city-states, and allow them to compete with each other as an experiment to see which policies and forms of government are the most effective. It would be kind of like Pokemon for social science geeks. You could have libertaritopia, commietopia, fascistopia, etc, and you'd get to see what happens. For motivational purposes, after 50 years I would have barbarian hordes burn and pillage the unsuccessful ones. If I couldn't find somebody to sell me a country I would build large offshore platforms or rafts that would fulfill the same function.
- run4yourlives 18y agoSpoiler Alert: Fascism wins unless they are lead by a retard.
- gambling8nt 18y agoSpoiler Alert: If you wait long enough, all fascist countries are eventually run by retards.
- metachor 18y agoprotip: It takes one to be led by one.
- gambling8nt 18y agoOn the contrary; an incompetent leader is easier to manipulate, and therefore more likely to be favored by whatever secondary powers arise as the fascist nation stagnates.
- boredguy8 18y agoDon't we already have a bunch of states competing with each other as an experiment to see what form is the most effective?
- huherto 18y ago
- earle 18y agoShort the dollar into capitulation :)
- floozyspeak 18y agoGo to war with IRAQ!
- boredguy8 18y agoInvest in the stock market.
- sdurkin 18y agoBuild nuclear power plants, and fund fusion research. Permanently end our addiction to oil.
- vaksel 18y agoBuild a huge space station...something that can be seen with bare eyes during daylight.
- bwag 18y agoBuild the world's largest super computer. Then ask it what the meaning of life is.
- qwph 18y ago"You aren't going to like it..."
- alex_c 18y agoYou should ask it: "Will mankind one day without the net expenditure of energy be able to restore the sun to its full youthfulness even after it had died of old age?" Long-term, that would be the most useful possible way to spend the money. (Source: http://www.multivax.com/last_question.html http://www.multivax.com/last_question.html)
- TweedHeads 18y agoLSC: "Life has no meaning, you have the choice of giving it one, or let others give it for you." BSOD
- Ben65 18y ago42
- froo 18y ago700B dollars... Well given the odds of me obtaining that amount of money is just shy of being pure fantasy, I figure the only real answer to this would be in the realm of fantasy too. So, 700B - here's my shopping list. Create Jurassic Park Army of Super Oompa Loompas - perhaps with bionic implants Moon based Laser "Defense" system Universal Optional Breast Enhancement Surgery Giant Robot of Doom Another Giant Robot (so the first one never feels lonely) Build an even bigger supercollider, just to scare the bejeezus out of the irrational people Terraform Mars Create a religion based around the works of Bruce Campbell I figure I'd get some change out of that list, so I'd buy a few people a couple beers. Next stupid question please!
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoCan I administer the breast enhancement program?
- neilk 18y agoIt would be pretty easy to knock off all water-borne diseases. Distribute existing technology to clean water where it's needed, or use that newfangled thing that Dean Kamen has. Bribe all genociding warmongers (e.g. in Sudan) into retirement. Pay for relocation and land redistribution of affected ethnic groups. Immunize all children in the USA. Then, with the other 600 billion, I guess you could throw an awesome party.
- jmtame 18y agoprobably start 700 seed fund firms
- dfranke 18y agoThat's ridiculous. You'd never come close to finding enough entrepreneurs to give the money to.
- mhb 18y agoHire 70 trillion people to draw me a $700 billion bill.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- apollo 18y agoDamn that's some fine resolution. Unfortunately if you want to hire unique people you'll have to wait for the earth's population to increase about 12,000 times its current size.
- gills 18y agoEnergy development (fusion and solar). Compact self-contained hydroponic gardens (think shipping container).
- geuis 18y agoA very large truck of cigarettes, enough to last my family for the rest of our lives. Then scream "I'm rich biatch!" and honk my truck's horn a couple times.
- elai 18y agoI would create a commercially viable, extremely useful version (versus just plastic doodads) of the self-replicating fabricator ( http://reprap.org http://reprap.org ), design a decent computer & solar cell that could be easily manufactured by this fabricator and is easy to make into a cluster system (and have semi decent performance). And create some fabrication programs that can manufacture buildings, farming equipment and other such essentials. Then I would fund a bunch of funding into cures for third world evils like malaria and such.
- timtrueman 18y agoMicrosoft just bought back stock with its cash. How about a down-payment on our national debt?
- ars 18y agoIt's fun to read these, but I feel compelled to point out that the 700 Billion is not going to be spent, but rather it's the amount the US is on the hook for. The last time the US did this they not only got all the money back, they even made a small profit. To join along: if I had the money I'd spend all of it on as many nuclear reactors, to generate electricity, as I could. I'd standardize the design to keep the costs as low as possible.
- jah 18y agoRest
- lallysingh 18y agoHookers and RAM. When I've got a good rate with a few of the girls, and my DIMM banks are filled, I'd probably start building a loyal robot army to help fight the evil ones that come with the inevitable robot apocalypse. Each of which, incidentally, will require RAM.
- beaudeal 18y agoprobably something like this: http://www.boston.com/news/nation/gallery/251007war_costs?pg=9 http://www.boston.com/news/nation/gallery/251007war_costs?pg... i mean, no more poverty and educating every child on earth for 7 years seems like a good idea...
- kolokonokos 18y agoDeath Star.
- UandIblog 18y agoI'd get a crew of volunteers together and torch the The World Bank & The International Monetary Fund.. just burn it to the ground. That might cost a couple hundred grand tops. With them out of the way it would be easy to implement a true Meritocracy in all governments. Presidents will get a paycheck on a sliding scale, the more wealth they are responsible for creating for their people, the better off they will do personally. I'd then use crowdsourcing to dictate what investments were made with the remaining 699 1/2 billion. We would then use the interest created by the these investments to fund all of the projects previously mentioned by the HackerNews Community. edit I'd make sure all of the employee's were out of the buildings, of course...
- tdavis 18y agoUse it to somehow dismantle all organized religion, probably. Likely the quickest way to save the world.
- gambling8nt 18y ago$700b is almost certainly insufficient to do this; the Catholic church has around 4 times this amount by itself (most of it is illiquid, though--a large fraction is in real estate).
- fallentimes 18y agoWhoa - are you serious? Are these documents public? I want to see them. What about the Deferred Liability on their balance sheet for "Child Molestation"?
- gambling8nt 18y agoThe problem with estimating the net worth of the Catholic church is that an overwhelmingly large fraction of its wealth is in buildings (the many churches it owns throughout the world), real estate (the land those churches are built on, plus the Vatican), and art. That said, this article (http://www.zenit.org/article-1900?l=english http://www.zenit.org/article-1900?l=english) gives some indication of the magnitude of their income/expenditures. Note: Most of the figures in the attached article are in lire, with a conversion rate of 2000 lire to 1$US--the annual in and outflow of the Catholic church is on the order of hundreds of millions of $US; it is only their total assets that are on the order of trillions.
- danw 18y agoTry and fix poverty, hunger, clean drinking water in a sustainable way.
- felipe 18y agoA few years ago I attended a talk by Prof. Jeffrey Sachs, professor at Columbia University who was commissioned by the UN to develop a program to end worldwide poverty with sustainable, long-term initiatives -- Note this is not the standard aid, but stuff like microcredit and micro-entrepreneurship. He traveled the world and came back with the price tag: $1 trillion. That is not to relief, but to END poverty worldwide.
- yters 18y agoWhat kind of guarantee did that have?
- whatusername 18y agoProbably a better one than anything that Paulson is giving!
- rms 18y agoSounds about right. This is something worth adding a trillion to the US Debt for.
- iamdave 18y agoProbably keep enough to retire on, and give the rest to my alma mater and have a football stadium named after me :)
- rms 18y agoCure cancer Cure HIV Eliminate hunger Eliminate thirst Take over Equatorial Guinea
- gambling8nt 18y agoThe only one of these you could afford for $700b is Equatorial Guinea... :P
- rms 18y ago1B is enough to take over Equatorial Guinea... the failed 2004 coup attempt was financed with a pathetic 20M. This says that the military budget of EG is 150M/year (http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/spending.htm http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/spending.htm) and I suspect that is a very high estimate. It would be easy to invest in modern pharmaceutical manufacturing plants in African nations with generous IP laws and then start making modern HIV medications available for practically nothing. Curing cancer is more of a crapshoot, but throwing several hundred billion at the problem would be a good start, if nothing else. Proper distribution of the money remaining could go a long way towards eliminating extreme poverty.
- raheemm 18y agobuild my own university - maybe university on a ship, no a university on a ship with its own navy, wait - a university on a ship with its own navy, its own private islands and a jet plane and a space shuttle. Damn, it got crazy so quickly!
- michaelneale 18y agoFree renewable energy. Probably geothermal. About 100bn on research to develop the system, the rest to roll it out.
- phr 18y agoHire a mercenary army to conquer some third world sh*t hole, then give it a modern infrastructure, education system, etc., and turn it into a capitalist/libertarian utopia. With some of the profits, I'd pick another country and iterate.
- dshfnc 18y agoI would buy massive amounts of gold and start a anonymous, secure digital currency backed by gold :)
- semblance2 18y agoSince it seems like defaulting mortgages are the cause of the situation, why not use the money to pay off those mortgages?. If it took $50,000 on average to save an individual mortgage, then you could rescue 14 million mortgages. Some would say that presents a moral hazard, but it seems like that cat is way out of the bag already.
- MaysonL 18y agoReplace the US auto fleet with Better Place cars http://www.betterplace.com/ http://www.betterplace.com/ .
- zandorg 18y agoLongevity. Hook me up with some new organs.
- tptacek 18y ago700 billion is 1400 times the operating budget of Harvard Medical. So I might do that a couple times.
- zitterbewegung 18y agoCreate a new space station and possibly try to go to mars.
- trapper 18y agoBuy microsoft and open source it. Buy google and open source it. Buy apple and open source it. Spend the rest on hookers and beer for all programmers.
- rainface 18y agoI would use it to pay back the loan from which it came.