11 ms·
Unofficial firmware upgrade for Dyson V6/V7 vacuum battery management system
- c7DJTLrn 4y agoGood man, I hate Dyson shit so much. It's all overpriced rubbish. Whenever I see their hand-dryers in a public bathroom I just use paper towels instead because they tend to blow stagnant water and particles in your face.
- Xcelerate 4y agoAre they that bad? I’ve been interested in buying a cordless vacuum, and the Dyson ones seem to top all the review lists (e.g. Wirecutter). What are some good alternatives?
- bruce343434 4y agoI have a corded dyson that doesn't use those dust bags, but it sucks (but not in the way a vacuum is supposed to). It's squeaky plastic and feels rough/wrong on the ground.
- dontlaugh 4y agoUnfortunately, they make the best cordless vacuum. I have one and it's very good, but I couldn't say it was good value.
- rbinv 4y agoI love their cordless vacuums. Mine's approaching 6 years with no issues whatsoever. My previous (corded) Dyson vacuum also works perfectly to this day, bought in 2006 and used at least every other day (because dogs) for 10 years. It fell down the stairs a couple of times, too. Really robust in my experience. The cordless one does not quite match the suction, but it's so much more convenient and sufficient nonetheless.
- deepsun 4y agoI own both Dyson and Samsung, and I'd say they're pretty equal, but Samsung is much quieter.
- ChrisRR 4y agoNo they're not that bad. The jets are pointed downwards Dyson aren't awful but they're definitely overpriced.
- Lio 4y agoI have one of the cordless vacs. It works well at being a cordless, the size is great and it's easy to handle but... It's made of really cheap plastic and has cracked in a few places. Being bagless is good in that I can see what it's collected but bad in that when come to empty it the dust I'm allergic to goes everywhere. (If only someone would invent a bag to keep the dust in eh?).
- nikau 4y agoThey are good in certain circumstances, but they use a few tricks, eg. there is no battery meter on the V6 to avoid range anxiety, so it will just die without warning and flash a LED vs having a battery gauge. The suction is also pretty poor, however it makes up for it by having a roller in the vacuum head which picks up the dirt. If you have anyone in the house with long hair its almost unusable as the roller will be clogged up after a single vacuum. A traditional vacuum with better suction and no roller wont have this issue. On the plus side they are light and manoeuvrable, and the wall mount means you always keep it charged.
- nsteel 4y agoI agree with all of this. I've had mine 5 years now, the battery life was never greatand unsurprisingly it's not getting any better... Would I'd buy another? Probably not. I heard Shark is supposed to be pretty good.
- sithadmin 4y agoShark's cordless vacs are pretty mediocre. Especially poor battery life. Tossed mine in favor for a Roborock that is only marginally more expensive, but far better in basically every way (run time, suction power, accessories, ease of cleaning).
- nsteel 4y agoI've never heard of Roborock and cant find much availability in Europe which might explain the one price I did find. Shame, the Dyson won't cut it once I move to a bigger place.
- sirfz 4y agoI got a Black & Decker cordless vacuum and it works great. Great battery (~60-90m runtime on full charge) which is also easily swappable (same batteries as their drills) with decent suction, build quality feels good too. It's almost 3x cheaper than the Dyson so really great value
- unfoldedCravat 4y agoNot really relevant to cordless ones but I know Dyson removed their pre-motor filter on their latest corded vacuums. If the dust chamber is too full excess dust is blown through the motor and then stopped from coming out into the air by a post motor filter. This will lead to premature motor failure over time. The Dyson 'bagless' idea is a bit of a sham. Yes they work, but they don't work that well. They don't make as much suction as their bagged competitors so they cheat and use smaller orifices to increase suction instead of by having a larger motor or alternative design. Then in order to have 'like new' performance all the time you have to continually wash (which doesn't really clean well enough) or replace filters. Some people love them but they don't make sense to me. If I'm emptying my vacuum I'm going to empty it into a bag anyway so I may as well use a bagged vacuum that works more consistently and doesn't throw dust everywhere.
- mr-debil 4y agoI love bagless, it is perfect for my use case. I have Huskies and fill up the canister multiple times per vacuuming of the house. The majority of my vacuuming is just picking up hair, not dirt. I'd fill bags up so quickly, and I've yet to find one that is replaceable as quick as a bagless canister can be emptied. It's not a sham, different use cases call for different things.
- d3ckard 4y agoI have a V8, my wife loves it and I appreciate it as well. We have a large apartment, so we prefer cordless solutions. Dyson has a decent battery and enough of sucking force to be useful. Personally can recommend. It also cleans super easily, with one lever.
- karavelov 4y agoMiele - more expensive than Dyson though.
- slowmotiony 4y agoI use a Tineco one - twice as cheap as the Dyson and it works great for years now.
- xiphias2 4y agoI guess people just like complaining, it works great, especially used together with a robotic vacuum cleaner for the easy locations. I just got some food on the floor an hour ago, I would have been lazy to get a wired vacuum cleaner there, but with Dyson wireless it was really easy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yardie 4y agoI have the Dyson V10. And I got it much cheaper by buying refurb and coupon stacking for <$200. I think they were the first to get the cordless vacuum formfactor right. There are many alternatives now that are significantly cheaper. And if I wasn't able to purchase mine at the price I did I probably would have considered them.
- jonfw 4y agoI have a tineco cordless vacuum which I think is incredibly well built, I bought it because it topped the Consumer Reports leaderboard at the time I was looking for one
- jalk 4y agoDon't know how good it is, but I'm considering a Bosch universalvac 18 since it uses the same batteries as a bunch of their cordless tools and garden products (18V) which I already have a couple of
- sithadmin 4y agoRoborock cordless vacuums are fantastic. Have an H7 and have nothing but praise for effectiveness and versatility.
- 1-more 4y agoI had a Dyson. I lost it in a breakup. I got a Shark. I figured any cordless stick vacuum is gonna get me what I want. The Shark is nowhere near as good. I found a Dyson on the street. It runs circles around the Shark. It's no contest. It makes it so easy to vacuum without all the ceremony of vacuuming from the past.
- grishka 4y agoI always ignore the hand dryers regardless of the brand if there are paper towels.
- Fnoord 4y agoI grew up with a Miele vacuum cleaner (my parents were all about Miele). Only disadvantage is they last so long that newer hardware is potentially more energy efficient. I don't get the point of wireless vacuum cleaner except autonomic ones and in niches where you don't have electricity (like an area where the electricity is often down). Having recently owned some different brands (Samsung, Beko) which broke down got us back te Miele again.
- Shaanie 4y agoHave you ever used a wireless vacuum? It may sound stupid, but it saves significant time and effort over a conventional vacuum; taking the clunky vacuum out, plugging it in, unplugging it and putting it back means it takes (much) more than twice as long to do spot vacuuming. Personally I'm never going back to a corded vacuum if I can avoid it.
- PetitPrince 4y agoThis! The friction to use a cordless vacuum is very low compared to a corded one. And consequently, vacuuming change from being a chore that's done once few weeks for a an hour to some short 5-10 minutes burst every few days.
- wlesieutre 4y agoNot even mentioning the cord management? You just vacuum where you want to vacuum and don’t have to drag a cord behind you and throw it around to keep it out of the way of being run over.
- mr-debil 4y agoThey're talking Miele, which most likely means canister vacuums. The two of you have very different mentality / approaches to vacuuming...and that's totally OK.
- Gigachad 4y agoI switched from a Dyson corded vacuum to a Samsung battery powered one and it’s amazing. I’ll never go back to wired vacuums. My parents have a Dyson battery powered one and it is garbage.
- tjpnz 4y agoI tend to use paper towels too. Electric hand-dryers promote the build-up of bacteria given how microbial life prefers warm places and how often people will walk away before their hands are properly dry.
- oxplot 4y ago> I hate Dyson shit so much I've been using Dyson products since 2005. Happy to shine some light on why people pay for it voluntarily :)
- _joel 4y agoAgreed, they're absolute garbage compared to similar offerings now.
- oxplot 4y ago> Whenever I see their hand-dryers in a public bathroom I just use paper towels Removing and replacing paper towels with hand dryers in public bathrooms has been an unfortunately shortsighted move that's been copied without much thought. Hands aren't the only thing that get wet in a public bathroom. You may wash your face, you may be removing stuff off your clothing, and countless other uses that a hand dryer alone can't accommodate.
- samatman 4y agoAerosolizing whatever might happen to be stuck to someone's hands is pretty irresponsible all by itself.
- orev 4y agoBy the time you make it to the drying step, whatever that stuff is, should have already been removed by the soap, water, and scrubbing.
- foundart 4y agoI don’t think it’s safe to assume that people are doing that good of a job on the wash step.
- ssl232 4y agoAnd even if they did, many (most?) bathrooms have doors that open inwards, so you have to touch the same bare metal that they (and every other previous user) also touched... and I'm yet to be convinced by the usual argument that it's for fire safety.
- samatman 4y agoThanks Mom. Seriously, if paper napkins and no Dyson Aerosol-Your-Skin-Cells-9000 means I don't have to think about the sanitary habits of my fellow citizens, that would be reason enough to stop installing them. They also scream like a banshee and don't dry your hands. I happen to also wear a beard, perhaps you can see why having only the Scream And Don't Dry My Hands Machine available would be unsatisfactory.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoI'm not exactly sure how they could blow stagnant water in your face, unless you have some extreme sanitation problems.
- jSherz 4y agoHas anyone had success with aftermarket battery packs for these vacuums? eBay is full of questionable quality options and my vacuum lasts all of 3 minutes.
- jakedata 4y agoI have obtained a couple of dead-battery Dyson vacuums in recent years. Aftermarket replacement batteries are available and so far, so good. The ones I installed offer somewhat increased capacity over the originals and performance is as good as I would expect. Of course aftermarket lithium ion battery packs are a crapshoot at best, so I stuck with ones that published at least plausible capacities and had a reasonable number of good/non-fake reviews. Given the price and lack of availability of OEM packs I'd say go for it.
- ggm 4y agoYes. I bought an aftermarket v6 battery with increased maH over the original, but with no 3 stage blue led charge level indicator (just one led) but it definitely lasts longer.
- djaychela 4y agoI bought one for my girlfriend's Dyson (v6, I think) - which had terrible battery life from day one, and got worse over time. She was very dubious about it, but it worked a lot better than even when the Dyson was new. Still not great, but better than before. Eventually I persuaded her that a Henry was the way forward. She bought it and now knows what I mean - I have one as a "garage/DIY" one and another as the house vacuum. There's a reason why professional cleaners in the UK use them!
- bluGill 4y agoYes, Dyson was out of stock, when the battery in my V8 died so I felt forced to buy an aftermarket just to use it. More amp hours than the OEM (or so they claim), and so far working great. The filters that came with it don't fit as well as the OEM ones though, they are falling off when I hold the vacuum wrong.
- atombender 4y ago
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>It only requires 6 resistors that cost $0.00371 each, or 2.2 cents in total for six. Dyson did not install these resistors I knew that cost cutting in consumer electronics was bad, but I didn't know it was THAT bad, especially for a premium brand like Dyson. And that's coming from someone within the industry.
- elaus 4y agoIt's not only cutting costs, it could also increase sales of replacement batteries I guess? Not assuming that is the reason, but it certainly seems like a "positive" side effect for manufacturers.
- TrueSlacker0 4y agoThe battery on both of mine went out quickly after purchase and Dyson sent replacements at their cost.
- dtx1 4y agoIt's not cost cutting. It's planned obsolencense! No Battery Engineer in their right mind would save a few cents on a balancing circuit. It's such a standard, it's like saving buying a car and the tank is sealed shut with gasoline inside.
- longcat 4y agoLegislation on e-waste, serviceability is extremely important to prevent this kind of preventable waste.
- akino_germany 4y agoCould you add the resistors to the V6 board and enable the balancing?
- throwaway2037 4y agoI assume the project name prefix "FU" is a hint! Ahem, I meant: "firmware upgrade". (See also: Google moonshot money from self-driving project)
- sebazzz 4y agoWell this firmware actually doesn't implement rebalancing. Therefore I don't understand the point of the resistors.
- tinfever 4y agoUnfortunately I haven't implemented cell balancing in the firmware. This is for a few reasons: On the V6 batteries, you could theoretically install the missing resistors and handle the rest in software, but the balancing would be very slow since it would also have to go through a 1K resistor Dyson included on the other side of the internal balancing MOSFETs. On the V7 and up models, they actually shorted the internal balancing MOSFETs of the ISL94208 on the PCB so you'd have to cut the very fine traces here and then solder on balancing resistors. I think you could actually just place a short in place of the balancing resistors because of the 1K resistor already in circuit. All said, I figured that of the limited number of people willing to take apart their battery, buy a programming tool, and install my firmware, there would be even few willing to make those very delicate modifications. And anyone willing to do all that probably already owns a bench power supply they could use to rebalance their battery pack manually. I'd initially planned on adding cell balancing until I saw that the ISL94208 balancing connections where shorted together on the PCB. That's something that just can't be fixed in software. Maybe one day I'll add balancing to one battery, just to show it can be done.
- jamescun 4y agoI bought a Dyson V7, and the battery life even from new is atrocious. On a full charge, unable to cover my very modest London flat, and of course, it cannot be used while charging. I even fitted a larger aftermarket battery. Still awkward to use. Eventually I gave up, and bought a corded Henry from Numatic. I cannot recommend a cordless Dyson for anything except light dust busting.
- batushka3 4y agoCorded vacum for residential is such a thing of a past, can't believe genuine people fallback to cords over dysons... I use V8 and V11, wonderfull machines. I like V8 more because it light and nimble.
- _joel 4y agothey're not, I have a v11 and it attrocioius. Constantly needs maintenenance for really light loads, plus James Dyson is a shark.
- GeorgeRichard 4y agoHackaday has an interesting article about this: https://hackaday.com/2022/05/23/fighting-back-against-dodgy-dyson-batteries/ https://hackaday.com/2022/05/23/fighting-back-against-dodgy-...
- millerm 4y agoWell damn, I literally replaced my battery after the 32 red blinks of death a couple weeks ago. I don’t have the old one anymore either. Grr. This would’ve been a fun alternative.
- alhirzel 4y agoThese little vacuums really suck! Seriously though, I didn't realize how impactful having a good vacuum would be. There are probably other-brand equivalents that cost less, but refurbished the Dyson handhelds aren't bad on price. The accessories are intuitive and "just work". I'm glad I didn't bawk at it when my fiancee wanted to buy it. And really cool to see more hardware mods getting attention on HN!
- _joel 4y agoI wouldn't touch a Dyson again with a bargepole. It constantly breaks and needs lots of maintenance, they have programmed obsolescence and James Dyson himself is an absolute scoundrel (Brexit, Singapore move, Tax, Ventilators etc.)
- syntaxing 4y agoI own an older gen (v5?) and I absolutely love it. I haven’t had the battery issue other have. I grew up with vacuuming being part of my chores. We used to have this super heavy bagged Hoover built in the 90s, and I remember how extremely difficult it was to lug it around and keeping track of the wires. Changing to a Refurb Dyson for like $200 was mindblowing and worth the 5 year+ investment.
- robohydrate 4y agoBought a refurb Dyson cordless V7 on a whim - Didn't want to spend full price because this is the first cordless bagless vac I've owned and I wanted to test the waters. It's been going strong 2+ years, total game changer - will not go back to bagged/corded. Once this thing dies I'm buying the newest one.
- thomaslord 4y agoI haven't used the slightly older models, but it may be worth sticking with them because it's possible to adapt them to use a standard 20v tool battery (I've specifically seen this done for the V8). Meanwhile on the V10 I have, batteries cost $130, can't be hot-swapped easily, and use a higher voltage that makes the 20v tool battery modification impractical. I planned to replace (and upgrade) the cells on the refurbished model I bought because the battery has been subpar since I received it, but so far I haven't managed to get past the abnormally-tricky plastic clips.
- mdrzn 4y agoI've been using a V12 for a year or so and it's incredibly easy and pleasurable to use. Huge battery, rarely I use it for more than 40% of its full charge, on full speed. Plus all the quick swap accessories make it a no brainer. I consider it the Apple of vacuums.
- subhro 4y agoI have got both a corded and cordless Dyson vacuum. For my high pile carpeted floors, I find that the battery powered one just does not have sufficient power even though the brush design is better than the corded one. In general, I have come to hate battery powered stuff including laptops, power tools and cars because they just dont pack enough raw power for my needs.
- alex_duf 4y agoWhich electric car doesn't pack enough raw power for your needs, and what are your needs if I may ask?
- subhro 4y agoWas able to get a Model S my friend bought in 2021 into limp mode when I took it to track after 3 laps. I believe the battery overheated after the 3rd lap. In the mean time, my STi was driving in circles for the next 20 or so laps.
- alex_duf 4y agooh, fair enough then I was asking because I wondered what sort of use case would electric cars not fulfil properly, and although not perfect they're getting pretty good. I can live with electric cars struggling on a track, it feels niche enough.
- FridayoLeary 4y ago>Here's why: 1.Series battery cells in a battery pack inevitably become imbalanced. This is extremely common and why cell balancing was invented. 2.Dyson uses a very nice ISL94208 battery management IC that includes cell balancing. It only requires 6 resistors that cost $0.00371 each, or 2.2 cents in total for six. 3.Dyson did not install these resistors. (They even designed the V6 board, PCB 61462, to support them. They just left them out.) 4.Rather than letting an unbalanced pack naturally result in lower usable capacity, when the cells go moderately (300mV) out of balance (by design, see step 3) Dyson programmed the battery to stop working...permanently. It will give you the 32 red blinks of death and will not charge or discharge again. It could not be fixed. Until now.
- gnyman 4y agoIf you want a cordless vacuum designed for repairabilty, there is a new company called Lupe which is trying https://lupetechnology.com/ https://lupetechnology.com/ Vacuum wars were impressed at least https://youtu.be/rFbkGM9Lm18 https://youtu.be/rFbkGM9Lm18 No idea about battery balancing in them though, maybe I need to open it and try to find out. My gut feeling is that they wouldn't save out on a few resistors.
- kingcharles 4y agoThank you for this. I'm shopping for a vac right now and this looks better than all the competition (Dyson, Samsung etc). What I wanted more than anything was a vacuum with easily available spares because vacs are one thing that tends to wear out and break more than any other appliance. I just hope Lupe does well and doesn't go out of business, otherwise there won't be any more spares.
- esaym 4y agoInteresting that it uses a PIC processor. I had an American Standard (Trane) heatpump installed at my current house. I noticed once winter came that the defrost cycles just didn't seem to be working right. They are supposed to be "on demand" but were occurring at every 30 minutes of accumulated runtime once outside temps dropped below 32 degrees. Noticed the defrost controller board had a PIC processor on it... Got the pickit3 rom flasher/reader and was able to read the rom. It didn't have any code protection thankfully. I ran the exported hex through gputils to disassemble it, and then ran it in the mplab simulator. I could tell it was hand written assembly. It used hardcoded values in some areas to set the program counter (vs just using goto and lables) so that made modifying the code harder (since you would need to then find all these hard coded values and offset them). Long story short, the fireware was indeed full of bugs. It is possible that these controller boards haven't been working right for the last 10+ years. I managed to add a few lines of code to bypass some initial values when the board is first powered up, and that fixed the issues. It is indeed an "on demand" defrost controller now. I'm still slowly writing a blog post about it but probably won't get more time to publish for a few months. But I guess the point is, after messing with this, there seems to be an entire world of embedded firmwares that are just riddled with bugs and will never be fixed.
- schemescape 4y agoWere the hard-coded addresses just an artifact of disassembling from binary format? I’d love to see this blog post, if you end up having time to write it! Can you share a link to your blog? I didn’t see it in your profile.
- esaym 4y agogputils did an amazing job on the disassembling! There are labels, gotos and functions all laid out. Hardcoded and calculated values were added to the PC in many places like: "addwf PCL, F" In that case, add W register into PCL, and store value into PCL. Trane had the original patent for computer controlled defrost: https://patents.google.com/patent/US4573326A/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US4573326A/en In the first image you'll see a chart with different temperature "bin" factors. In one place in the code, the temperature offset from 32 degrees (freezing) is added to a hardcoded value and the PC then jumps into a certain spot in a lookup table. The values in that lookup table help determine at what "DT" (delta temp between outdoor coil and outdoor ambient) a defrost should initiate. In another location, a hardcoded value is added to the PC along with a loop counter.... On loop 1 through the code, jump to this location, on loop 2 jump to this location, etc. Kind of a strange way to code, but after buying different revisions on ebay of this board going all the way back to the early 2000's, and on top of the patent being from 1985, perhaps this was the norm in the 80's and mid 90's.
- ghostly_s 4y agoMisleading project description. Very much further down the page: > Cell balancing is not implemented. I know this is ironic, but because the cell balancing resistors aren't installed and Dyson used 1K resistors for the VCELL# connections, even if you shorted out the connections where the cell balancing resistors would go, which most people aren't going to do (and you'd have to cut some very fine traces on the V7 BMS PCBs), the cell balancing would be extremely slow through the 1K resistors. So I guess the only use of this currently is reviving a dead battery pack.
- tinfever 4y agoI really wanted to add cell balancing but the PCBs are designed in way that it would require hardware modifications that I thought very few people would actually do, especially on the V7 models and up. I was also pretty burned out on this project by the end. I did add a way for you to at least monitor the cell balance level via LED blink codes so you know when the cells need to be manually rebalanced. You are correct that in the end, this project doesn't provide a ton of extra utility. Especially since another user from the EEVblog forum thread, dvd4me, found the EEPROM values you can reset to clear the permanent lockout on the original firmware.
- ghostly_s 4y agoThat's perfectly fine, I would just suggest re-writing your intro so it doesn't imply this project (currently) provides that.
- sebazzz 4y agoWhat is the point of the firmware? It does not implement cell balancing, and no instructions are there to solder resistors to actually allow cell rebalancing.
- cronix 4y ago> 4. Rather than letting an unbalanced pack naturally result in lower usable capacity, when the cells go moderately (300mV) out of balance (by design, see step 3) Dyson programmed the battery to stop working...permanently. It will give you the 32 red blinks of death and will not charge or discharge again. It could not be fixed. Until now. > By using this firmware, your battery pack will not become unusable if the cells become imbalanced, you will just have reduced battery capacity as usual.
- sebazzz 4y agoWell, perhaps it is a bad idea to let unprotected lithium batteries get out of balance.
- turtlebits 4y agoUnpopular opinion, but it looks like Dyson is trying to be as safe as possible (mitigating any chances of fire) by disabling the pack. Unbalanced packs can result in overcharging. Maybe it would have cost too much to provide a better BMS or charger, or just wanted to eliminate a risk factor.
- newman314 4y agoI happened to see a recent video where there apparently are adapters to utilize power tool batteries for these Dyson. https://www.amazon.com/s?k=dyson+battery+adapter https://www.amazon.com/s?k=dyson+battery+adapter I suppose they work mostly like the Power Wheels hacks but have no personal experience with the vacuum variant. YMMV.
- bredren 4y agoThis is cool but I haven’t had a problem w blinking red lights on the v6 animal. I’ve replaced the original w some random one from Amazon, because it wouldn’t last as long. (Choosing from the many generics was not easy reviews are seem very uneven) Maybe BMS could make it last longer in charge behavior similar to iPhone? I’m more interested in a guide on how to replace the red bristles in the long vac head. Also +1 on the dyson v6, it changed how I clean. Have not tried the cheap knock offs but anything w o a cord is the way to go.
- tinfever 4y agoAuthor here. I'm honored to see someone actually posted this on HN. :) I purchase my Dyson V7 as an official refurb and the battery went in to lockout a few months after the short refurb warranty expired. Thus prompting the project. The vacuum is pretty handy for my small apartment, and when I bought it, I wanted something that had decent reviews and was from a real company, not just some Amazon seller with a bunch of random characters for a name. I still like the vacuum, I just wish Dyson hadn't designed it to fail. I think there are two issues here: 1) The left out the cell balancing circuitry which is pretty standard for battery packs. 2) They designed their firmware to go in to permanent lockout when the cells go to far out of balance (300mV). For the sake of discussion, I've heard interesting two arguments on why they might have disabled cell balancing: 1) Cell balancing could be a weak point on the ISL94208 IC they used, so they could have disabled cell balancing to actually increase overall reliability. We'd never know for sure, but I could see this being plausible. This is from someone on the EEVblog thread (https://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/fu-dyson-bms-an-(unofficial)-firmware-upgrade-for-dyson-v6v7-vacuum-bms/ https://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/fu-dyson-bms-an-(unof...) 2) Cell balancing isn't actually useful because a poor battery cell will plummet in voltage under load anyways due to the higher ESR in the poor cell. At least, that was my interpretation of their argument after translating it from Russian to English in a comment on the YouTube video. While I see their point, especially in the vacuum's turbo mode which draws 17A vs the usual 3A, I think there would still be some usable capacity to be gained by balancing the cells even if one did have a much higher ESR.
- pabs3 4y agoHackaday featured your project, figured I should post the project as well as their article. https://hackaday.com/2022/05/23/fighting-back-against-dodgy-dyson-batteries/ https://hackaday.com/2022/05/23/fighting-back-against-dodgy-... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31487401 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31487401
- retSava 4y agoMeta: I interpreted the "FU-Dyson..." in the project as "F*uck you Dyson", not "Firmware upgrade", did I make the right interpretation? :) Also, this resembles why I'm very reluctant to buying an e-scooter in Sweden since basically all the ones available here are rebranded OEM Alibaba scooters with poor/fake battery implementations, so when it fails you'll be standing there with no way to get back on the saddle again. Even the Swedish-branded Vessla scooters were rebranded OEMs from Alibaba, with minor cosmetic changes and a hefty premium. After a while the batteries turned out to be of poor quality, and after their v2, they quit that vertical entirely. Looking forward to Segway launching their e-scooters in Sweden, at least I know it's a reputable brand standing behind it and can honor warranties etc. I want something quite small that I can have in the apartment (theft and vandalism otherwise), and can use to scoot my kid to school with.
- Saris 4y agoLeaving out cell balancing is a perfect example of planned obsolescence to drive people to buy more batteries.