5 ms·
WHO is meeting this week to vote on amendments to international health regulations, https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-far-reaching-us-proposals-to-amend-the-internat
by walterbell 4y ago
WHO is meeting this week to vote on amendments to international health regulations, https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-far-reaching-us-proposals-to-amend-the-international-health-regulations-at-the-upcoming-75th-world-health-assembly-a-call-for-attention/ https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-far-reaching-us-proposals-to-am...
> proposed US amendments to Article 12 IHR will both considerably extend the executive powers of the WHO Director-General to declare global emergency-like situations and centralise this power further by removing the need to consult and find agreement with the respective state party ... Articles 9 and 10 IHR moreover strengthen WHO’s powers to assess alleged global health risks by relying on information received outside official channels, giving the respective states only 24 hours to verify such information.
> ... if WHO’s powers are extended in this way, is there a need to also answer the question quis custodiet ipsos custodes (who guards the guards?), and to thus set up mechanisms ensuring that WHO complies with its obligations under the IHR and its Constitution, as well as its responsibilities for human rights deriving from customary international human rights law?
WHO's Intergovernmental Negotiating Body (INB) site has videos from their April 2022 meeting: https://inb.who.int https://inb.who.int
- no-dr-onboard 4y ago> and centralise this power further by removing the need to consult and find agreement with the respective state party This is discomforting. Genuinely curious how anyone would see this as anything more than a power grab.
- WalterGR 4y agoIs it intended to remove politics from science?
- at-fates-hands 4y agoBy replacing it with unilateral power? Yeah, what could go wrong with that?
- nix23 4y ago1984 but instead of televisions with pee-bottles and blood-tests ;))
- fragsworth 4y agoThe WHO is not really "powerful" like a nation is, as they do not have a military or enforcement arm, and they do not pass laws. All they can do is decide how their funds get spent. They are granted all these "powers" to spend their funds by the participating states. Furthermore, they are restricted to spending it on things that promote world health. The worst they can do is squander the money, which isn't even all that much. Compare this to people like Jeff Bezos who have vastly more money, 100% centralized, and effectively no restrictions on how they spend it. Whether you should be concerned about that is up for argument, but by contrast, any concerns about the WHO are pretty absurd.
- no-dr-onboard 4y ago> The WHO is not really "powerful" like a nation is, as they do not have a military or enforcement arm, and they do not pass laws. True, but a majority of policy makers and talking heads (that influence and approve laws) carry out their deeds under the guise of "Well, the WHO says so". Consider how frequently the "appeal to authority" tactic was used during the pandemic. This isn't entirely without consequence.
- runarberg 4y agoBut still consider the relativity here. The risk of a malicious WHO is insignificant next to the risk of rich industrialists like Jeff Bezos. Very wealthy and powerful entities like Jeff Bezos do lobby and influence governments and media on a totally different scale then international organizations such as WHO. And more often then not these industrialists do succeed in bending policy to their favor at the cost of everyone else. Maybe this isn’t without consequence, but relatively speaking the risk of negative consequences are next to nothing.
- TimTheTinker 4y ago> centralise this power That's the part I take issue with. Any time power becomes centralized (including during emergency situations) it leads to loss of individual freedoms, and often increased anthropogenic (=human-caused) suffering.
- new_stranger 4y agoIf you were wealthier you would understand the importance of centralized power /s
- TimTheTinker 4y agoThere's a big difference between centralized power and coordinated action facilitated by wise leadership. The latter does not require the former, contrary to what some people might say -- those who wish to hold unfettered power, or those who wish to be ruled over by one holding such power.
- new_stranger 4y agoThe issue is you and I know this, but they don't
- slickrick216 4y agoOr the opposite.
- maxbond 4y agoETA: I made this comment before the author clarified they were being sarcastic. I'd propose that if you made more of an effort to be empathetic with people who lack access to wealth and privilege, you'd understand better the criticisms of centralizing power and power structures in general. "You don't understand because you can't see my perspective" goes any which way, and so is not an argument. If their are artifacts of your perspective that we need to form a full and coherent view - then share them with us. If you're just looking to be patronizing and dismissive because you only value a certain perspective - then please reconsider.
- leemelone 4y ago
- codefreeordie 4y ago
- taylorius 4y ago
- codefreeordie 4y agoor whatever they decide to push next when people stop being afraid of this one
- taylorius 4y agoTake a look at what "simulations" the usual globalist suspects are running at their conferences. Both Covid and Monkeypox were the subject of such simulations in the years before they emerged as "OMG we're so ill prepared" pandemics.
- Datagenerator 4y agoView the report here: https://www.nti.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/NTI_Paper_BIO-TTX_Final.pdf https://www.nti.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/NTI_Paper_BIO...
- codefreeordie 4y agoThat report presents clearly the reasons why entities like the CDC must be eliminated. They declare the need for the ability to have a single unaccountable bureaucrat with the ability to permanently lock down the entire planet or to take any other freedom-destroying action on a "no regrets" basis. At the first sign of a "threat", real or imagined, it's purge the commoners and don't ask questions later. They have demonstrated that it is unsafe for freedom to have such entities.
- outworlder 4y ago> And what do you know, just in time for them to gain unopposable, unaccountable ability to lock down the entire world whenever they want Who benefits from 'lockdowns'? The economy slows down, workers stop working and lining up powerful people's pockets. Tourism plummets, supply chains gets disrupted. It's not profitable. Even a war brings profits. Lockdowns don't. Mind you, most countries didn't experience any lockdowns at all. Not every organization is conspiring against you. If anything, the media was regularly pushing to reopen business even as hospitals struggle.
- thedrbrian 4y agoFascinating look at their new proposal https://twitter.com/criticalsway/status/1526464386386345984 https://twitter.com/criticalsway/status/1526464386386345984 https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1526464386386345984.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1526464386386345984.html
- walterbell 4y agoThanks for posting this plain-english summary.
- adrianmonk 4y ago> WHO is meeting this week This seems off topic. The article is about monkeypox. The WHO meeting is about regulations. Yes, they are both public health issues, but that's about as close of a connection as there is.