7 ms·
The fact that Ukraine seems to have had, or had access to, uncannily accurate intelligence does seem to be the signature fact of this war. Arms without targeti
by dredmorbius 4y ago
The fact that Ukraine seems to have had, or had access to, uncannily accurate intelligence does seem to be the signature fact of this war.
Arms without targeting are at best areal suppression weapons. Russia's impressive-looking mobile rocket-launcher batteries appear formidable, but their effect seems largely to be producing a few seconds of terror over a few hectares of land.
Ukraine's ability to target individual generals with precision, to distract and destroy naval flagships, to down helicoptors, to drop munitions on or through tank hatches, to land artillery and rockets with precision on massed troops and materiel ... has been tremendously effective. The shot:kill ratios seem to be extremely high.
At the same time, the US has telegraphed Russian moves, plans, and force structures with precision as well.
What the state and source of this intelligence is varies. Part clearly comes from near-theatre sources such as the Poseidon, other AWACS assets, and probably other capabilities in Nato Europe, Turkey (itself both part of Europe and Nato, though notable for its position on the Black Sea and control of the Bosperous). Much all but certainly from satellite observations. And I'd suspect a considerable degree is based on signals intelligence.
Russia does not control those domains, and has been unable to establish clear control within them. This is unlike, say, any major US campaign of the past 30 years, whatever other concerns might have as to their legitimacy, with the exclusion of satellite capabilities. To date, Russia has not felt it has the ability to move against those intelligence assets. It certainly has the ability to do so should it choose, and a more general conflict might result in that. But for now, it is pinned down in a fishbowl.
Effect here though seems to be a combination of intelligence as to enemy position and operations, the ability to deliver force to specific points of need, invulnerability of observation posts, and a general popular support within the theatre of operations. As well as remarkable material support from outside entities.
This will be (and all but certainly is being) studied in war colleges and curricula for generations.
- XorNot 4y agoA very good reason Russia won't touch satellite assets is that most of the early warning systems are based on those: if your early warning system goes down, then you're exceptionally vulnerable to a first strike.
- watersb 4y agoEven worse: with the loss of early-warning satellite assets, you have to decide how to use (or not!) nuclear weapons with extremely noisy information.
- corrral 4y agoThe intel sharing arrangements (I wonder who's actually calling the shots—literally—for fire control purposes... every link in the chain slows things down, and they seem to be working very effectively, which implies few links indeed) seem to me to be clearly the most interesting and effective facet of this war. Pity we may never get the story of what's actually going on, because it seems to be a really remarkable effort.
- pjc50 4y agoThe impression I get is that the US feeds them satellite info on the general disposition of Russian forces, but the individual targeting seems to be done by drones, some of which are consumer-grade. They seem incredibly accurate. It seems unlikely that there is direct US involvement - the US doesn't want that and it would slow the Ukranians down. They seem to have their own networked fire control: https://en.defence-ua.com/events/digitization_of_ukrainian_army_capacities_of_hermes_c2_tactical_control_system-1649.html https://en.defence-ua.com/events/digitization_of_ukrainian_a... , and have said that Starlink was critical, after the Russian cyberattack bricked a lot of satellite terminals. They even have a local drone startup: https://interestingengineering.com/ukraines-combat-drone-the-punisher https://interestingengineering.com/ukraines-combat-drone-the...
- trhway 4y ago>the individual targeting seems to be done by drones, some of which are consumer-grade. They seem incredibly accurate. a very impressive example https://www.reddit.com/r/CombatFootage/comments/tttrzs/ukrainian_strikes_targeting_russian_armored/ https://www.reddit.com/r/CombatFootage/comments/tttrzs/ukrai... Wrt. original article - Moskva's air-defenses weren't upgraded during last modernization (completed 2020) due to budget. They upgraded its cruise missiles which got land attack capabilities though - that tells about Russian priorities. The old air-defenses - S-300 and OSA - had issues against such a low flying missiles like Neptunes (i.e. 2-4 meters) though AK-630 CIWS could have potentially shot down those missile if activated on time by the info from the main radar. There are also unconfirmed reports that a Bayraktar was hanging around and took away a lot of attention and probably took down the main S-300 radar antenna of the Moskva right before the attack. The Bayraktar also was doing the mid-course guidance of the missiles thus allowing to not use the main radar of the Neptune battery thus avoiding the battery position detection by Russia.
- throwaway0x7E6 4y ago>This is unlike, say, any major US campaign of the past 30 years because the US did not face a formidable adversary in the past 75 years in a war somewhat comparable with this one in terms of manpower and tech - the Korean War, the US had suffered heavy casualties and had only narrowly escaped a complete defeat
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoWhat do you mean by "comparable with this one in terms of manpower and tech"? South Korea and allied powers were significantly outmanned during the Korean War, and the idea that the US had any kind of decisive technology advantage in theatre is belied by the accounts of lack of US preparedness post WWII.
- throwaway0x7E6 4y agoyes, that's exactly why it's comparable
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoI guess I just have no idea what you're calling comparable. In this analogy, is the US Ukraine? Is North Korea Russia? What is the point you're trying to make?
- throwaway0x7E6 4y agoa numerically inferior force (the US / Russia) up against an adversary (North Korea + China / Ukraine) funded, armed with modern tech by a powerful entity (USSR / NATO) and the point I'm trying to make is that it is laughable to compare fighting a modern military to Iraq and Afghanistan
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoRussia is the numerically inferior force vs. Ukraine in this example? Uhm OK.
- elorant 4y agoJust a few weeks ago there was a US aircraft carrier in northern Aegean, just a few miles off the port of Alexandroupolis where there is a US naval base. It seemed odd that for such a low significance base the US would bring an aircraft carrier in the area, but my guess is that it was involved in some kind of operations in the Black Sea region.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoThe US moves carriers into trouble areas as a show of force. It’s like having having a bouncer’s attention at a bar. There’s a world of hurt waiting if you step out of line.
- dredmorbius 4y agoIt's not merely display. A CTG affords considerable intelligence, logistical, and rapid-response capabilities.
- pjc50 4y agoThey've been in the Med for a while: https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/news_191063.htm https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/news_191063.htm
- rjsw 4y ago> to drop munitions on or through tank hatches I don't think this is down to intelligence, it is just how the NATO anti-tank missiles are designed to work.
- dredmorbius 4y agoDrops are usually made through consumer-grade drones. Those drones have limited range, and need to be proximate to, and be able to rapidly find, targets. Which requires intel. At this point ... I lack specific information on where or how that intel is aquired. Some may be from surveillance-drone flights or getting lucky sending out individual drone-attack missions. I suspect more, however.
- rjsw 4y agoAre there figures available on how many Russian tanks have been destroyed by drones and how many by Javelin and NLAW?
- distances 4y agoTotally unreliable personal take of public tank busting videos: Stugna-P is the most common, then various drones dropping AT grenades. These two lead by a large margin, followed by Javelin and NLAW, and finally a scattering of others like Panzerfaust. I'm sure the reality could be something quite different.
- saiya-jin 4y agoConsidering I didn't find a single successful Switchblade drone video in 3 months (1 which missed quite a bit), I would say this output is heavily moderated and for good reasons. Ukrainians want to prop their technology for sales/morale (Stugna), US probably doesn't want to show off their latest technology marvel. The other option is, Switchblade drones are completely useless and thus unused by Ukraine. I don't believe that even if it may not be some wonder weapon to solve it all.
- hedora 4y ago> This is unlike, say, any major US campaign of the past 30 years This seems exactly like both Iraq wars, except that Sadam's troops might have had working encrypted radios. In the first war, massively undergunned (in terms of number of rounds of ammunition) US tanks would enter a battle, and 66% of them would immediately get stuck in a boot loop, or otherwise break down. The remaining ones would rapidly fire a dozen rounds or so a few miles in a dozen different directions, anihilating enemy equipment well before it had any hope of striking back. Then, logistics people would go out and fix the stranded tanks. It's pretty obvious that the targeting systems and supply lines were what held everything together during those campaigns. Ukraine has been dominating in those two dimensions as well (using US equipment and intelligence, in many cases).
- dredmorbius 4y agoSource on the tank boot-loop issues? First I've ever heard of that.
- wil421 4y agoNot according to a report to the Government Accountability Office about the Abrams and Bradley vehicles. However, the report does say the support and recover vehicles caused slowdowns. >During the war, the Abrams tank exhibited good reliability, lethality, sur- vivability, and mobility, but limited range, according to the observations of commanders, crews, maintenance personnel, and Army after action reports. Reported Army readiness rates for the Abrams were 90 percent or higher during the ground war-indicating a high availability to move, shoot, and communicate during combat.[1] [1]https://www.gao.gov/assets/nsiad-92-94.pdf https://www.gao.gov/assets/nsiad-92-94.pdf
- kmonsen 4y agoWhat I have wondered: let's say the US gives some predator drones to Ukraine, and then "trains" their military to use them. What is to stop the US from actually piloting these drones from Tampa or whatever, perhaps through a cable from Ukraine to Poland? Would be very hard to prove who were actually piloting them at any given time.
- daemoens 4y agoThe issue is that predator drones will be shot down almost immediately which makes it a non-starter. It flies high and slow which makes it extremely easy to attack. Even fighters on both sides have been flying extremely low due to both sides having an abundance of anti-air.
- concordDance 4y agoAre they any easier to shoot down than the Bayraktars?
- daemoens 4y agoThey are significantly larger and made of materials that are much easier to spot compared to Bayraktars. Predators were made with complete air superiority in mind.
- JohnBooty 4y agoWhat is to stop the US from actually piloting these drones Technically, probably nothing. Diplomatically? The risk of nuclear escalation or various WWIII-esque scenarios, because at that point you have the US military directly killing Russians. Assuming that the US (gulp) does not actually want WWIII, I can't see them flying the drones themselves unless they could somehow have 100% plausible deniability. Keep in mind that Ukranian facilities and perhaps the whole country itself could fall to Russia, and all secrets might then be revealed to the Russians. Or a single base could be captured. Or Russia may be able to spy/intercept/deduce this information.
- 4y ago
- Rapzid 4y agoUSA flaunting its intelligence from before the invasion to now has got to be the biggest flex of the past 30+ years on the world stage.