4 ms·
There are lots of stories lately about stolen NFTs. The podcast ReplyAll did an episode where they tracked down the current owner of a stolen NFT. He had sympat
by criddell 4y ago
There are lots of stories lately about stolen NFTs. The podcast ReplyAll did an episode where they tracked down the current owner of a stolen NFT. He had sympathy for the original owner but he had no intention of turning it over.
I don’t get why purchasing a stolen NFT is different than purchasing a stolen guitar from a pawn shop. Shouldn’t the previous owner be able to use the courts to demand the return of the item that was stolen from them?
Or is this just something that hasn’t been tested yet?
- omarhaneef 4y agoOne of the points of digital assets is that the code is the contract, so whatever the code says is what was agreed to. There can be no cheating (in theory) hence no need to resort to courts etc.
- antifa 4y agoAnd there is a chance that the courts will recognize law as law instead of code as law.
- uoaei 4y agoAnd that will expose the fundamental contradictions and hypocrisy of the crypto community writ large, if they accept that help from the legal system.
- plandis 4y agoWhen two or more parties sign a contract, it doesn’t necessarily mean that all the terms in that contract are enforceable.
- uoaei 4y agoThat's true if you are litigating the enforcement of the contract through traditional legal systems. Crypto enthusiasts want to be completely divorced from those.
- shkkmo 4y agoWhich is why the big players the smart contract that was exploited in this article just accepted the loss and moved on? Oh wait, the two largest losers here BOTH went to court independently. The cryotocurrency community supports the "code is law" talking point only until serious money is lost. Then they go the courts for redress under actual law, or they fork the blockchain.
- SamBam 4y agoThe courts haven't even determined whether anyone even "owns" an NFT, so no. -- For the downvotes, I'll add some further explanation: you have access to the keys in order to perform a sale of "your" NFT, but no US court (I am unsure of other countries) has yet ruled in a case that clarifies whether a person actually owns an NFT. For example, they have not ever ruled against someone who has "stolen" an NFT. Therefore, there is no case law that says whether a person legally "owns" an NFT. Don't just take my word for it: > Ultimately, an NFT owner has access to the underlying asset, but they may lack exclusive access to or control of the asset, let alone ownership of the asset or any intellectual property (IP). https://www.lawyer-monthly.com/2021/05/nfts-and-ip-law-who-owns-what/ https://www.lawyer-monthly.com/2021/05/nfts-and-ip-law-who-o...
- bombcar 4y agoThe whole point of an NFT is that the ownership is on the blockchain and guaranteed by said blockchain - if the courts can "force" return of the NFT than the NFT isn't actually synonymous with the ownership, and so then is kinda pointless.
- tomhallett 4y agoThis is why I struggle understanding the mainstream usecases for crypto. Will it forever be bound to the "only put in what you can afford to lose?" mindset? Or are people banking on another layered solution which has arbitration, disputes, clawbacks, etc - all built within the blockchain. (I remember EOS discussing something like this) Note: I understand that risk is present in any financial endeavor, but knowing that the courts can help you does de-risk the amount people will feel comfortable investing.
- colinmhayes 4y agoThere are 2 different issues here. Do courts physically have the ability to change the blockchain so that an NFT goes to a different wallet? No. Do courts have the ability to arrest someone when they ignore a court order to transfer an NFT? Yes. I don't think the courts really care about some pure intentioned "code is law" argument, because they tend to think law is law.
- tablespoon 4y ago> I don't think the courts really care about some pure intentioned "code is law" argument, because they tend to think law is law. "Code is law" is a mantra chanted by people in no position to make it so.
- criddell 4y agoKind of like sovereign citizens?
- oldgradstudent 4y agoWith the ledger being public, it could be very simple for courts and police to deal with it given the appropriate legislation. Mark the result of theft or other illegal transactions, and any subsequent transaction as dirty. Make any exchange, any vendor, any trader, and any user check with a government database before or immediately after receiving a payment, with penalties prescribed by law. You immediately limit stolen crypto to the black market.