18 ms·
What does being "behind" even mean? The dirty truth of the US educational "system" is that there is no system. Different school districts offer vastly different
by lapcat 4y ago
What does being "behind" even mean? The dirty truth of the US educational "system" is that there is no system. Different school districts offer vastly different levels of education, depending mainly on wealth (i.e., the property tax base, because schools are locally funded). When I was a kid, my family moved from one city to another within the same state, and suddenly I was way behind in my new school, especially in math, simply because my new school moved at a significantly faster pace and had higher expectations of students. But I eventually caught up, and it was fine. So I suspect that this problem is vastly overstated.
It's not like the US educational system was doing a great job before the pandemic. I used to teach in college, and a lot of student were not properly prepared. We rely a lot on "social promotion", where mere age and time spent in seats is taken as the standard for educational level.
- endisneigh 4y ago> So I suspect that this problem is vastly overstated. > It's not like the US educational system was doing a great job before the pandemic. I used to teach in college, and a lot of student were not properly prepared. Huh? So you think the problem of being behind is overstated, but observed many students not being properly prepared yourself when you taught?
- lapcat 4y ago> Huh? There's a typo: it should have said "a lot of students". Not sure whether that was the confusion here.
- endisneigh 4y agoYou're saying that you taught and felt people were not properly prepared, but also believe people are not behind?
- lapcat 4y agoWhat I'm saying is that there's no uniformity. Incoming college freshman are mostly the same age, but their preparation for college varies dramatically, depending largely on where they came from. At any given age, many US students are "behind" their peers, because they're not all receiving the same education.
- endisneigh 4y agoThat doesn't mean they're not behind, though? If anything it just means most students are behind. It's strange you say that the problem is overstated but also say that you encountered many kids yourself who were not prepared.
- lapcat 4y ago> That doesn't mean they're not behind, though? As I asked originally, what does "behind" even mean? It seems to depend crucially on a schedule and expectations. This is why I mentioned social promotion, where students move up in grade simply because a year has passed. The pandemic has certainly messed up the standard academic schedule, without a doubt. But so what? Are kids irreparably harmed because the standard academic schedule was messed up? I don't think so. Kids were already moving at different educational paces before the pandemic. I'm not saying it's good that educational quality differs by school district. But this is a socioeconomic problem. There's no "natural human" educational system that the pandemic messed up. When you compare US kids with, say, the great English philosopher John Stuart Mill, we're all way behind. As a kid, J.S. Mill was the beneficiary of an educational experiment almost without equal in history. He was taught Greek at the age of three! Who gets that?
- endisneigh 4y agoThe article showed standardized test performance went down, which is what it means by behind. You seem to be ranting about something irrelevant. The authors never claimed kids were irreparably damaged. Your take is just so bizarre.
- 4y ago
- balefrost 4y agoIf you read the article, it specifically points to remote learning as the thing that put students behind. I think the commenter believes that the negative effect of remote learning is overstated relative to other factors.
- endisneigh 4y agothe commenter didn't even mention remote at all tho
- balefrost 4y agoI think it's fair to assume, in the discussion of an article, that all the discussion is related to said article.
- jdmichal 4y agoGrice's maxim of relation: Be relevant. https://psychology.fandom.com/wiki/Gricean_maxims#Maxim_of_Relation https://psychology.fandom.com/wiki/Gricean_maxims#Maxim_of_R...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- giantg2 4y ago"i.e., the property tax base, because schools are locally funded" Not exactly. Most states and the federal government adjust funding to send it to the schools that need it most. https://www.commonwealthfoundation.org/research/school-funding-myth-busters/ https://www.commonwealthfoundation.org/research/school-fundi...
- Steltek 4y ago"Most states" qualifier supports the claim that funding varies widely from state to state and town to town. State and Federal funding grants alone are not going to sustain a school district. Also, your link is basically a charter school industry propo campaign. Hardly unbiased when talking about public schools.
- giantg2 4y agoIt's possible there could be bias. Do you have a source that states otherwise? Do you have any resaon/explaination to suspect the numbers in the pertianate table to be biased? '"Most states" qualifier supports the claim that funding varies widely from state to state and town to town.' Of course funding will vary to some degree - as does cost of living. This is especially true depending on the state, but it is not based on local wealth (as the original claim states). The point is that the troupe that districts collecting less property tax are providing poor education because of it are mostly false. The funding levels are mostly adjusted to be similar to other districts based on the needs-based funding of higher levels of government. Are there some states that underfunded the entire system? Probably. The example of Pennsylvania shows that it is one of the highest funded states, with some of the highest paid teachers, has relatively evenly distributed funds, and it still has districts that underperformed. This isn't a funding issue, and continuing to look at it like one is doing a disservice to those students. There are other factors that drive success more than property tax funding. Things like two parent households, and societal/parental expectations.
- bradlys 4y agoAs someone who went to a very poor school district - I can tell you that what the state and federal government has sent in the past is not sufficient. My school district was only 4-days a week. It has not changed since I left to the best of my knowledge. Four days. We couldn’t even afford five days a week. There were other effects to this besides four day weeks but I’m giving a good sound byte here.
- Allower 4y ago
- annyeonghada 4y agoIf someone start a Physics degree without knowing how to add fraction is it the duty of a university professor to correct such deficiencies? >Just stop acting like its someone else's problem to solve. It is a problem for all the precedent teachers that let pass someone so unprepared.
- beej71 4y agoUsually a teacher has a specific class they are teaching, and the material has certain published prerequisites. Lots of times the students don't meet those. I would argue against the assertion that it's that teacher's job to catch them up.
- 015UUZn8aEvW 4y ago>Different school districts offer vastly different levels of education, depending mainly on wealth The data show that causation mostly flows in the opposite direction. The main determinant of whether a school is "good" is the average academic ability of the students who attend the school. And that, statistically speaking, is largely a function of race and income. Policy interventions based on the idea that school quality determines student performance have consistently failed to show significant results. These interventions include local and regional busing. Putting lower-achieving students in close physical proximity to higher-achieving students doesn't make much of a long-term difference.
- lapcat 4y ago> These interventions include local and regional busing. Busing raises a host of problems that are independent of school quality. I can only offer my anecdotal experience here, but I was able to thrive in my new school, after I caught up. My inherent ability didn't change simply by moving, but more was given to me and more expected of me after I moved. But I wasn't bused in, I lived in the same neighborhoods as my friends and peers.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoThe article you're commenting on mentions several interventions with significant benefit: "High-dosage tutoring—which educators define as involving a trained tutor working with one to four students at a time, three times a week for a whole year—is one of the few interventions with a demonstrated benefit that comes close, producing an average gain equivalent to 19 weeks of instruction." "One option is voluntary summer school, which, according to prior research, has yielded about five weeks of instructional gain per student. Another option is an extra period each day of instruction in core subjects. A double dose of math over the course of an entire school year has been shown to produce gains equivalent to about 10 weeks of in-person instruction, although the evidence on reading is weaker." https://fordhaminstitute.org/national/commentary/5-lessons-education-policy-newly-minted-nobel-laureates https://fordhaminstitute.org/national/commentary/5-lessons-e... lists a few more studies that consistently show the opposite of what you claimed. School quality matters, and more schooling matters.
- markvdb 4y ago> What does being "behind" even mean? In my case as a guitar teacher, I see two patterns: - Students with less support at home or natural feeling for guitar are about a year behind where they would normally be after four years of studying. - My most motivated, talented and best supported students are on schedule or slightly ahead.
- jeffbee 4y agoThanks for mentioning music. It baffles me that anyone would be blind to the idea that children could be "behind" when so much of childhood development involves muscle strength and dexterity that must be practiced. This goes for many musical instruments as well as the voice, all athletics, penmanship, verbal articulation, and so much more.
- lapcat 4y agoIs this actually a problem for music though? Who are the future professional musicians? "My most motivated, talented and best supported students are on schedule or slightly ahead." So it's not clear that we're losing any potential virtuosos here. If a generation of amateur musicians end up being a little less proficient in music, that's unfortunate, but hardly worth panicking, I think. I personally started playing guitar, and tennis, too late in life to become a professional. This had nothing to do with the pandemic. But I can still enjoy them as an amateur.
- jeffbee 4y agoI'm not really thinking of the health of the professional music class here, I'm thinking of the mental and social well-being of a generation of people who may never be even moderately proficient at music.
- lapcat 4y agoThe guitar teacher said some students are "about a year behind where they would normally be after four years of studying". That seems a lot less extreme than "never be even moderately proficient at music".
- tejohnso 4y ago> What does being "behind" even mean? Or matter? Is extending parental dependency the problem? If someone starts college at 20 instead of 18 they are likely at home longer. But a lot of people aren't leaving home for college anyway, or they return home after college whether they graduate or not. If a bunch of kids start high school at 16 instead of 14 is it going to cause serious problems? It seems to me the only issues would be those that we create by our own expectations.
- jdmichal 4y agoThere would be huge capacity problems associated with combining entire years of students. Many teachers, classrooms, and entire schools are already on the edge of overcapacity.
- dncornholio 4y agoAbsolutely. If everyone is behind, are you?
- Jensson 4y agoIf everyone is behind then society is behind. It isn't a problem for society if one kid is behind, but it starts to be a problem when millions of kids are behind.
- guidoism 4y agoI would like to bring up the question again of “compared to what?” Are the metrics: 1. Based on university entrance (in which case you need to recourse and ask the same questions of that) or 2. Based on some pragmatic list of things that will help the child become a good part of society or 3. Completely arbitrary.
- leksak 4y agoYou don't imagine being two years older than the majority of your classmates at that time is going to have immediate effects on their social life at that time or that employers in the future will note that they graduated later in life and thus pass them over for a different candidate?
- ekianjo 4y ago> But I eventually caught up, and it was fine. So I suspect that this problem is vastly overstated. Alternative explanation: you are acting like there is no problem based on anecdotal evidence that is irrelevant to the current situation - At the same time there might be a very serious one as quite a few kids basically have missed proper school for about 2 years. Let's not even try to pretend that lockdowns have no negative effects at all.
- lapcat 4y ago> At the same time there might be a very serious one as quite a few kids basically have missed proper school for about 2 years. Let's not even try to pretend that lockdowns have no negative effects at all. I'm not saying there are no negative effects. What I would say is this: even before the pandemic, many students were not sufficiently "challenged". They were already moving more slowly than they could have moved. It's possible for them to catch up. They could have caught up with other kids before the pandemic too, if put in the right situation. Time spent sitting in seats is not education, by itself. How that time is used is just as important, and we often squander that time, even when there's not a public health crisis.
- diputsmonro 4y agoUnless you think that every single child was previously slacking off and is capable of effectively working double time without getting overwhelmed, then it's still a problem to be concerned about.
- lapcat 4y ago> Unless you think that every single child was previously slacking off and is capable of effectively working double time without getting overwhelmed I actually do think this. "John Stuart was educated by his father, with the advice and assistance of Jeremy Bentham and Francis Place. He was given an extremely rigorous upbringing, and was deliberately shielded from association with children his own age other than his siblings. His father, a follower of Bentham and an adherent of associationism, had as his explicit aim to create a genius intellect that would carry on the cause of utilitarianism and its implementation after he and Bentham had died." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Stuart_Mill#Biography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Stuart_Mill#Biography I realize that this is not financially realistic for application to every child. But the gap between how far we could push children and how far we do push children is often massive. We've always been "ok" with leaving many children behind.
- User23 4y agoHome schooling is quantifiably far superior to public schooling, pretty much independent of socioeconomic status[1]. As one would expect, the education level of parents did affect the results. For example, home-school students of parents without college degrees scored, on average, at the 83rd percentile for the core subjects. When one parent had a college degree, those students scored at the 86th percentile, and when both parents had a college degree, those students scored at the 90th percentile. There was virtually no difference, however, between the scores of students whose parents were certified teachers and those who were not. It amuses me that apparently certified teachers are no better at teaching than any other concerned parent. In fact, a concerned parent will wildly outperform a school teacher. This ought to be unsurprising to anyone who is aware of the mind-boggling two standard deviation improvement tutoring provides. A home-school is essentially a tutoring arrangement. [1] https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2009/aug/30/home-schooling-outstanding-results-national-tests/ https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2009/aug/30/home-school...
- lapcat 4y ago> In fact, a concerned parent will wildly outperform a school teacher. A parent teaches maybe 2 students per day. A school teacher teaches maybe 200 students per day. It's an unfair comparison.
- pjkundert 4y agoI'm struggling to find the purpose of this reply. Do you believe that saying "no fair!" invalidates the superior outcomes for home-schooled children? If billions of dollars of state funding and the teachers' aggregate decades of university education can't overcome this obstacle (which did not seem to be a problem when children in one-room schoolhouses routinely used to learn Latin), I'm wondering what other advantages anti-home-schooler central planners need, in order to force their sub-par solution on parents? I know I'm being ... obtuse. But, seriously -- if it takes 1 or 2 hours a day to "keep up" with the standard curriculum in grade school, and "schooled" students are sent home with 1 or 2 hours of homework, after they attend "school" all day -- what is the purpose of sending kids to these institutions? :)
- magicink81 4y agoThe schooling system is designed to fail the expectations of those who think its purpose is to educate people, and succeed in full-filling other purposes. If you're curious about what those other purposes might be, I recommend reading the books of John Taylor Gatto [1]. Also, the School Sucks Project [2] is a great source of knowledge about the history of schooling, as well as education solutions and alternatives to schooling. They have just launched a re-broadcast of the essential 50 episodes (of their over a decade of 800 episodes) that covers the full spectrum of the relevant topics. [1] https://www.amazon.com/John-Taylor-Gatto/e/B001K7S0AE%3Fref=dbs_a_mng_rwt_scns_share https://www.amazon.com/John-Taylor-Gatto/e/B001K7S0AE%3Fref=... [2] https://schoolsucksproject.com https://schoolsucksproject.com