5 ms·
Any guesses what the long term consequences might be? I have a hard time imagining anything more dire than the immediate consequences of social isolation during
by criddell 4y ago
Any guesses what the long term consequences might be? I have a hard time imagining anything more dire than the immediate consequences of social isolation during the pandemic.
In other words, I think the kids that make it through are going to be okay.
- usrn 4y agoI spent high school in the woods home schooled and only socialized at church. So did all my siblings and a number of people I met at college. We all turned out fine.
- winphone1974 4y agoVery few people ever self identify as "not fine" so along with being a single data point yours is pretty biased
- ryanbrunner 4y agoI think home schooling and large-class remote schooling are quite a bit different. We home schooled our kids for the 2020 / 2021 school year, while most other kids spent the majority of the year in remote learning. Our kids are doing great academically, while there's definitely some struggles among some of the other kids. This is another factor increasing inequality, by the way - we were exceptionally privileged to be able to have work schedules able to handle this, and a nanny who could watch our kids while we worked. Most parents wouldn't be able to do that.
- Auracle 4y agoChances are if you can afford a nanny you’re intelligent enough to teach your children well and the kids are intelligent enough to do well fairly independently. Most people that home school…not so much, in my experience.
- howling 4y agoStandard application of selection bias. People that don't "turn up just fine" don't go to college or browse HN.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nemo44x 4y agoI would imagine home schooling and socializing around something like your church will give you better odds of turning out fine. Putting your kids in public spaces exposes them to kids from all sorts of negative background that can influence your kids greatly. In essence, you want to keep your kids away from bad kids which are a function of bad parents with bad values. Note that this is often relative. You may find the church to be full of people with bad values. Likewise, someone who is religious may not want their kids to socialize with kids that have parents that encourage things like transgenderism in pre-teen kids.
- t-3 4y agoNot sure what browsing HN has to do with anything. I turned out really badly and still browse HN. It's not like there's a gatekeeper, it's just a tech-focused message board. Nobody asked me if I went to college when I signed up.
- jl6 4y agoGreater inequality, because wealthy parents can do more to compensate for schooling inadequacies than poor parents can.
- JohnDeHope 4y ago
- goldfeld 4y agoOh you've no idea how catastrophic cascading effects over generations of parenting will be, but it's all fitting to a plan you know, the pandemic was just a means. The words religious and fascism come to mind, also Greg Egan's and others' sci-fi. In other news Politicians Are Far, Far Advanced In Their Schemes. Ed.: it may sound as if I'm calling out a major conspiracy and centralized but that's far from it, I'm just saying bad actors will increasingly have their way and bad intents will group themselves and plan out the short term ahead, step by step of public degradation. But that's been happening since the first fall and destruction of Babylon anyway.
- taeric 4y agoProbably not much, is my gut. Catching up on relevant academic items is easier than we typically acknowledge. Is why those kids that were reading at an early age are typically not that ahead in a few years. Not that this should be dismissed. But I hazard it is not a panic item.
- mattmcknight 4y ago> why those kids that were reading at an early age are typically not that ahead in a few years. That's often because they are dropped in a single pace system, where they are forced to sit with kids learning the alphabet, wasting valuable time, getting bored.
- taeric 4y agoCertainly possible. My priors speak otherwise, though. Just seeing my own kids accelerate in reading at different ages makes me think early success is as indicative of kid's abilities as it is executive impact. Certainly not zero. But mostly overstated.
- jdmichal 4y agoSometimes I'm really surprised that people have such a hard time extrapolating from their own experiences learning to children and school. Individuals will tend to learn things at their own pace. Individuals will tend to learn different things at different paces. Example: I despised history in school. The only subject I ever scored less than a B in during a quarter. I discovered it was mostly just down to how it was being taught, as a series of factual but mostly disjointed events. I found that I enjoy learning about history, as long as I'm understanding the complex causation and linking between those different events. Example: I've hired people that had zero experience in one of our programming languages. They typically end up completing their first PR in that language within a month or two -- with assistance, of course. People tend to pick things up pretty fast when it's part of their job expectations. (I always make it clear during interviewing and the hiring process that such an expectation would be present.) Example: My son didn't begin to talk until after his third birthday. Now he is almost entirely caught up, with only minor speech issues.
- JohnDeHope 4y agoI'm curious which is worse, social isolation, or mass consumption of video media. I bet Netflix is worse. The social isolation was bad, no question. But during the early school lockdowns I saw first hand what 12+ hours a day of modern TV does to a person's brain in a short period of time. It's nothing like what TV was like in the 80s when I was a kid. The social isolation gets a lot of air time. I'd guess it's not the worst thing the lock downs did to kids. I bet the loss of education and the overdose of TV are in the top two.
- Cerium 4y agoMy parents are teachers and talk about mass consumption of internet media as the largest negative effect of the pandemic on children. Many of them are serious addicts, high school students acting like children at just the thought of their video games and YouTube access missing for minutes.
- corrral 4y agoAnecdotal, but my friends who are teachers report a marked decline in student reading ability (vs. even just 20 years ago) in middle and higher grades. The main problem seems to be that kids have trouble parsing sentences that aren't very simple and short, with the result that most of the students—including "advanced" students in accelerated classes—have trouble following the basic narrative, let alone anything deeper, of works that weren't regarded as difficult when they were written. I don't mean Shakespeare or Paradise Lost or something, but works aimed at younger readers from as recently as the late 20th century. They lose track of what's going on by the end of a sentence having more than a small number of clauses. This trend pre-dates the lockdowns. Web-induced changes in reading behavior is my #1 suspect for the culprit, though I'm also suspicious of the YA book genre—I have an unconfirmed hunch that, as it's risen to prominence, it's also chased more and more "palatable", if you will, writing styles, in the name of greater sales.
- zarzavat 4y agoI realize this is not what you intended, but I have learned more (as an adult) from YouTube than I ever did at school. A bad teacher in adolescence can ruin an individual’s appreciation of a subject. Today’s kids are blessed with the best teachers in the world, only a few taps away. There’s nothing intrinsically wrong with video content. But perhaps the recommendation algorithms need to be tweaked so that these websites have more social responsibility towards younger users.
- dncornholio 4y agoMy guess is a lot of people will blame covid for their failings out of their own. This will be the harshest consequence I think; people playing victim. [edit] I think it's already happening, but with parents. My kid is not a bad learner, it's because of covid!
- DoughnutHole 4y agoThe effects will probably be small but measurable on average, with significantly worse effects on poorer kids or kids that were already struggling to begin with. The closest example to something like this happening is probably major teacher strikes. Kids in Argentina during the teachers strikes of the 1980s lost an average of 88 days of primary education and today make about 3% less per year than you would expect given their age.[0] This effect largely comes from lower income groups being less likely than usual to achieve higher levels of education and being more likely to be unemployed. [0]: https://www.cedlas.econo.unlp.edu.ar/wp/wp-content/uploads/doc_cedlas217.pdf https://www.cedlas.econo.unlp.edu.ar/wp/wp-content/uploads/d...
- dehrmann 4y agoBased on TFA's numbers, 88 days seems close enough on the academic scale. Social is probably worse (kids probably played with their friends while teachers were striking), and that's also a big component of earnings. I'd guess 6% less earnings, though it'll really depend on how old they were in 2020. It also exacerbates inequality. The interesting question is whether there's a 20-year block with lower performance, or there are spikes at certain points. I imagine anyone starting professional work out of college in 2020 is effectively a year behind by now. Someone who started in 2015, not so much. I'm not sure if something similar applies to school.
- spookthesunset 4y agoThey'll have lost a bunch of "firsts". First date, first kiss, graduation, prom, dances, you name it. We stole it from them.