10 ms·
I don't understand exactly what you're complaining about. Has anyone ignored the cost of closing schools? My impression has always been that everyone has known
by mort96 4y ago
I don't understand exactly what you're complaining about. Has anyone ignored the cost of closing schools? My impression has always been that everyone has known about the high cost, but, well, millions more dead isn't exactly a small cost either.
I mean you may disagree with the choices which were made, but surely you have to recognize that it's a bit more complicated than what you're suggesting?
- mattcwilson 4y agoWould love to see the data you have showing that private schools that stayed open, or public schools that fought to stay open, contributed significantly to additional deaths, such that “millions more dead” would even be a fair comparison to the impact of schools choosing to go virtual instead.
- makeitdouble 4y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8266060/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8266060/ > Early evidence indicated that schools were low risk and children were unlikely to be very infectious, but it is becoming clear that children and youth can acquire and transmit COVID-19 in school settings and that transmission clusters and outbreaks can be large.
- mattcwilson 4y agoThanks! A little confused though, the protocols run here all assume the classroom stays in-person and just goes into different isolation measures. Most of the protocols (besides the baseline, do-nothing protocol) have some effect, but aren’t perfect. > None of the mitigation protocols we modeled, initiated by a positive test in a symptomatic individual, are able to prevent large transmission clusters unless the transmission rate is low (in which case large clusters do not occur in any case). Among the measures we modeled, only rapid universal monitoring (for example by regular, onsite, pooled testing) accomplished this prevention. But as it says there, prevention can be achieved by emphasizing frequent on-site testing (which is super consistent with what we know about avoiding spread events generally). > Without closing schools down entirely, if we want to prevent large clusters from occurring altogether, this leaves approaches to detect potential index cases before they show symptoms. Pooled testing, wastewater monitoring and airflow monitoring have all been proposed with this aim [42, 43]. We simulated introduced cases and resulting transmission under the baseline of no regular testing (with the same baseline as above, symptomatic individuals going home) and compared this to weekly or every three day testing or environmental monitoring covering all individuals in the class. The results for the total cluster size are shown in Fig 6. Regular pooled or otherwise universal testing dramatically reduces the sizes of even the most unfortunate clusters (infectious index, higher-risk room), for example from a median of 12 to a median size of 3 if the index is asymptomatic. But even with regular pooled or otherwise universal testing, testing in a matter of hours (e.g. onsite) has a substantially greater impact than testing at a centralized laboratory (if that takes 2 days including shipping time). This doesn’t seem like a strong argument in favor of virtual school?
- makeitdouble 4y agoAs I understand, the base premise of the research here is that remote schooling is the proven no-risk solution, and their goal is to evaluate other strategies that could somewhat keep contamination at manageable levels for in-person classrooms. It is in particular useful for cases where virtual schools are just not an option (on the top of my head, toddlers and lower age kids for instance. If their parents can't teach them for whatever reasons, in-person teaching will be critical to their development, and they can't wait 3 years that the dust settles) Now this study might have a lot more different political stuff going on, but I generally think the situation with kids is complicated and there is no one single solution to the learning problem. We'd need to adjust to a lot of cases.
- mattcwilson 4y ago“Remote schooling is the proven no-risk solution” - where are you getting that? The abstract you cited is talking about the harms of remote learning. The paper concludes that an effective testing regimen can, in fact, contain spread. This is the lesson we should take from this whole experience. This is the heart of why Japan and South Korea did so comparatively well during the pandemic: test, trace, and isolate. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7688188/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7688188/ https://bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12916-020-01791-8 https://bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s1291...
- croon 4y agoYou're arguing for data examining something that has happened, while all decisions regarding a new virus act on data only available prior. Acting from an assumption that an infectious disease spreads more if children from every family gather daily in crowded classrooms doesn't seem like an unreasonable one. I would also love more data on this, preferably before the next pandemic.
- fsdfdsfdsaafds 4y agoThe irony being that many kids then spent a lot of time with their grandparents, so that their parents could continue to hold down their jobs while schools were closed.
- wellpast 4y agoThis is a worrisome line of reasoning -- that you can't act to protect children until you have 'all the data' about this or that narrow threat vector.
- croon 4y agoIt's a worrisome dilemma, in which you are forced to reason. There is no win scenario, only varying degrees of unknown loss states.
- giantg2 4y agoAnd this highlights that you are not free to make that decision and reason for yourself- the government mandated what they thought is best.
- wellpast 4y agoFair. The concern, however, is when the state forces everyone to reason one particular way. The other concern is that arguing from a who has 'all the data' position is seriously fraught ... but the state and its mandates get underwritten when enough people embrace this fraught & simplistic mentality.
- mattcwilson 4y ago
- bigDinosaur 4y agoYes, people have stated that 'the kids will be fine' quite consistently. Also, all costs other than deaths have been underplayed by people in favour of lockdowns. Memory-holing this is literally insane (where insane = disconnected from reality). That's not to say that what was done wasn't the best of a suite of bad options. But I saw nothing but fairly extreme downplaying of the consequences of lockdowns from people who wanted long (the only effective) ones.
- ryanklee 4y agoI think you should clarify your sample. I'm a liberal, was in favor of school closings early, my daughter went to her first year of kindergarten remote, and I was very aware of the tradeoffs. People like Emily Oster have been excellent at raising concerns.
- yonaguska 4y agoYou were aware of the tradeoffs for your daughter. Were you aware of the tradeoffs for children in less fortunate situations? And while being aware, did you still support schools closing early? Do you stand by your support knowing the trauma it has inflicted now? The school closings have had catastrophic effects on children with poor home lives. School for me was a place to eat, and in middle school, even just showering when the gas or electricity had been cut at home. Many of these kids were dodging abusive relatives, gangs, and drugs by going to school. The more fortunate kids were lucky to drop high school in exchange for working to support their families. https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/breaking/ct-11-year-old-reports-sexual-abuse-20210108-rqax7xobanas5npruzoiaclu7i-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/breaking/ct-11-year-old-... https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/breaking/ct-online-sex-abuse-caught-charged-20201017-fepiggml2bcopkduhoaqmpcofi-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/breaking/ct-online-sex-a... https://www.wbez.org/stories/to-help-their-families-during-the-pandemic-chicago-teens-are-skipping-class-to-work/ba108579-4fc9-4dcb-b9fc-9ffc82e08c2e https://www.wbez.org/stories/to-help-their-families-during-t...
- ryanklee 4y ago
- endgame 4y agoNo, people really did pretend that. Here's one example that I remember: https://twitter.com/AmerAcadPeds/status/1425857041457942542 https://twitter.com/AmerAcadPeds/status/1425857041457942542 Obviously paediatrics is not the same as schooling, but I recall this sort of attitude being prevalent.
- mort96 4y agoWhat does that tweet show? Are you suggesting that children are "far, far behind in school" because teachers were masked, and not because schools were closed and classes were remote?
- endgame 4y agoI am claiming that institutions made counterintuitive claims (e.g., seeing only masked faces will not delay babies' speech development) based on no evidence. These claims were made to shore up support for various pandemic response policies, including masking, lockdowns, and remote schooling but have turned out to be false.
- nathanaldensr 4y agomillions more dead Prove it. You can't draw wild conclusions like that and get away with it. Hardly any children die from COVID-19, and the ones that do often had extreme comorbidities.
- spookthesunset 4y agoI've been called a selfish asshole who just wants to use school as a daycare when I said our school should be open. LOTS of people pulled the wool over their eyes and pretended that "kids are resilient" and "kids will be fine" when they closed schools for more than a full year. What we did to the young generation the last two years is awful.