9 ms·
Index funds officially overtake active managers
- nh23423fefe 5y agoEverytime one of these articles comes up, someone says, "but who will do price discovery, this is terrible" What's the argument that active managers aren't just rent seeking parasites lying about their roles? Why have active fees gone down if they provided value all along?
- pkulak 5y ago> but who will do price discovery, this is terrible Whoever actually believes they have more information than the market and is willing to stake their own money on the proposition. I'd guess that we need surprisingly few of those folks to keep the machinery humming.
- michaelt 5y ago> What's the argument that active managers aren't just rent seeking parasites lying about their roles? "That might be true of other active managers - not me though, this fund I manage has outperformed the market over the past 10 years."
- lvl102 5y agoPrice discovery just happens on a different pace mostly around earnings. But you’re still at the mercy of market makers which is a big problem on its own. We also have bonds/convertibles to help price securities.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oneoff786 5y agoIf everyone invests in the sp500 then the price of the sp500 will climb, guaranteed, because you know that next months paychecks will purchase more of it. You can’t really do anything about this even if you’re actively aware of this mechanism and think it’s fundamentally over valued. It’s like a decentralized Ponzi scheme
- gruez 5y agoWhat isn't a ponzi scheme these days? If you're passively investing in stocks, it's a ponzi because of the reason you outlined. However, if you're actively investing and bought a stock that's a little too popular (eg. tesla), then that's also a ponzi because "the company doesn't make a profit and the way people are making money is from new investors paying older investors". Hell, even if you only buy blue chip stocks with reliable earnings, some of your original complaint is still there (ie. people mindlessly buying it because they know it's reliable, new investors paying old investors).
- fartcannon 5y agoI cant tell if youre joking or not because I sorta do think it is all a scam. I think the stock market is a way to keep the sociopaths doing something less dangerous than continuous war and insurrection. Whether intentionally or not, I think that's it's primary value. It basically magnifies wealth discrepancy which is what the sociopaths want. The rest of us just try not to become poor by playing their games. Whenever everyone gets too close to fair, they invent a new game, or take the ball and go home. You know? I'm only sort of kidding. :D
- andsoitis 5y ago> Whenever everyone gets too close to fair, they invent a new game, or take the ball and go home. who is “they”?
- fartcannon 5y agoSociopaths
- legitster 5y agoWell, we've kind of known that the benefits of active management would be diminishingly small. In theory they could be working just as hard, but at this point they are being paid to clip coupons that aren't there.
- throw0101a 5y ago> Everytime one of these articles comes up, someone says, "but who will do price discovery, this is terrible" Note that this has been around since 1980: > The Grossman-Stiglitz Paradox is a paradox introduced by Sanford J. Grossman and Joseph Stiglitz in a joint publication in American Economic Review in 1980[1] that argues perfectly informationally efficient markets are an impossibility since, if prices perfectly reflected available information, there is no profit to gathering information, in which case there would be little reason to trade and markets would eventually collapse.[2] * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grossman-Stiglitz_Paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grossman-Stiglitz_Paradox Paper: * http://www.dklevine.com/archive/refs41908.pdf http://www.dklevine.com/archive/refs41908.pdf * https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=228054 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=228054 Price discovery happens at the edges: you probably don't need a lot activity for it. I think we're seeing a lot of the also-ran active managers (slowly) being weeded out, and the remainders will increasingly be those that actually manage to get things right every so often.
- ItsMonkk 5y agoThis isn't taking into account that there is really no such thing as 'passive'. In reality, passive investors are constantly either investing with their paycheck, or selling in retirement. They are the world's simplest active investors. If you put money into passive then the index buys. If you request money, the index sells. So what you need to track is the net flows. If the net flows are positive, and there is so little active left in the market that no matter what the active investors do the stock still has positive net flows, then active has no other option than to buy. This eventually leads to stocks having an infinite price as there is no downward force. On the other hand, if net flows are negative, then prices go to 0.
- im3w1l 5y agoThat's a passive failure mode I haven't seen before. To elaborate on what you said: Imagine an index, and an index fund tracking it. The index fund will own x% of every stock in the index. Someone buys the index fund, and the index fund now try to achieve x+epsilon% in every stock. But what if 100-x% of the stock is owned by diamond-hands hodlers, that wont sell at any price? The index fund bids higher and higher, and the sellers refuse to let their shares go, making the price reach ridiculous levels. The price reaching 0 seems less likely, as there will always be bargain hunters.
- jeffreyrogers 5y ago> What's the argument that active managers aren't just rent seeking parasites lying about their roles? That someone has to set prices and structurally index funds can't do that job. How are prices going to be set without active participants? You could do it by formula I guess, but that would be gamed by companies around earnings time and doesn't account for differences in industries or differences in corporate strategy. > Why have active fees gone down if they provided value all along? That's exactly what you would expect as more firms enter providing the same service. The same thing happens in every other market. More competition drives down margins.
- cyphar 5y agoIf markets stop being efficient at price discovery, why wouldn't active managers and hedge funds exploit that inefficiency? In other words, why are active managers and their supporters arguing that they aren't good at their job? (The answer is that they would exploit the inefficiency and the market would maintain efficient price discovery, but they'll get more business by fear-mongering around index funds.)
- LatteLazy 5y agoThe arguement in both cases is that if someone is doing something useful in a market (like price discovery) they'll be paid according to how useful they are. And if their pay exceeds the cost then they'll profit. If not then your guy (or girl, or other descriptor) isn't useful and you're paying them from your picket. But it's your job to check and move your money accordingly. And you'll be paid for doing so, and penalised for not doing so. If your active manager beats the index (in returns and risk) after fees then he is earning his keep both for you and the world in gen
- wsostt 5y agoYou’re not considering that a lot of active managers are helping clients define bespoke investment strategies that suit their assets and liabilities. They set a strategy, pick a benchmark, and invest. In some cases, a portion of those investments may be passive instruments and other portions may be research-driven asset allocation by the manager.
- m3nu 5y agoThat sounds like a financial adviser, not a manager of an active fund.
- SkipperCat 5y agoThere are actively managed funds that hold stocks, bonds and other instruments and constantly balance those ratio on a daily basis to give investors a steady state of returns (think 4% to 6%). A lot of folks who want fixed income returns instead of cap gains growth purchase these funds. Retirees and pension funds are big consumers of these product. This requires complex daily work and would be nearly impossible for a financial advisor to perform.
- 55555 5y agoCan you give any examples of these which can be bought via brokerage account?
- wsostt 5y agoNot OP, but I doubt it. These are individual mandates with mandatory minimums in the tens of millions of dollars for a small shop.
- SkipperCat 5y agoVanguard targeted retirement funds. VTTHX is their 2035 target fund. They are constantly readjusting their balance of stocks/bond/cash to meet a stable return in the year 2035. Virtus AZNAX is another fund that blends a bunch of financial instruments to achieve a targeted return. There's plenty others and they're all available from any retail brokerage firm.
- whimsicalism 5y agoPrice discovery can be left to the prop traders.
- blitzar 5y ago> "but who will do price discovery, this is terrible" - just rent seeking parasites lying about their roles I think you copied and pasted your rant from a different rant about finance as it really doesnt have anything to do with this.
- IMSAI8080 5y agoThere'll never be a shortage of people who think they can beat the market. Market beating is just such a compelling illusion. Also passive funds are not quite 100% passive. What does everyone do when they're broke? Stop investing. How about when times are good? Pile more into investments. There's also many different types of passive funds with slightly different biases. There's world passive funds (which have maybe 40% not in the S&P). There's passive funds that track other specific countries. There's ESG passive funds that avoid oil companies and such. There's passive that skips China. There's investor biases in there and prices being discovered all over.
- Invictus0 5y agoYes, Berkshire Hathaway and Renaissance are just figments of the imagination.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoHas BRK outperformed SP500 since 2009?
- IMSAI8080 5y agoNow throw in all the other active funds and average them out. Also Berkshire would not have been the better investment over the last decade. Can you guarantee me Berkshire will pull ahead before I retire?
- Invictus0 5y agoWhat a silly thing to stay. Let me just ignore that and explain why Berkshire works. It's possible to beat the market because it's possible to buy $1 for $0.95. That's the whole trick. It takes a lot of work, a lot of smart people, and you have to make big enough deals to cover the cost of paying the managers, but yes, these opportunities exist and they are abundant. The real mistake is thinking that the market is a bunch of random number generators with no rhyme or reason to it. But no, there are no guarantees--the SPY doesn't come with a guarantee either.
- andi999 5y agoPersonally, I dont think price discovery is the biggest problem, but no overseight of the board of directors. Etf do not actively vote (as far as i understand). So this opens up for management and minority owners to run the comopany badly (or even plunder it). This is a negative effect in the long run though.
- matthewowen 5y agoBlackRock absolutely votes. The concern is arguably the _opposite_: in the index model ownership is concentrated in a few large institutions with very broad diversification, which creates some odd incentives. Matt Levine has a bunch of articles touching on this topic.
- cromka 5y agoBut ultimately the indices are incentivized by the underlying companies' growth, as to make their customers happy, thus it is in their best interest to take sane votes?
- kwere 5y agothey vote , usually against all stewardship bogus they like to signal [0]. [0] https://shareaction.org/news/new-data-shows-scant-improvement-in-fund-managers-voting-on-esg-resolutions https://shareaction.org/news/new-data-shows-scant-improvemen...
- missedthecue 5y agoWouldn't fees go down as a result of more competition in the sector?
- jshaqaw 5y agoInterest to revisit such militant attitudes should the current crash of inflated bullshit techcos continue. Is your kids 529 plan on the S&P. Well congrats - you got to buy Tesla at the peak of Elon’s pump train just in time to be a ticket holder for his self-immolation show. Does your 401k hold small cap exposure to the Russell. Yippee you get to be the bag holder for a good chunk of the SPAC garbage VCs dumped into public markets based on things like projections that personal electric helicopter taxis would become ubiquitous in US urban markets by 2025. Passive investing got gamed by Silicon Valley and isn’t exactly what Bogle had in mind when he got started.
- sepiasaucer 5y agoI don’t understand what point you are trying to make. Specific stocks being bad investments is not an argument against passive investing. The whole point of index funds is to diversify your portfolio so you track the overall market, not any specific stock or group of stocks. If you are assuming you know which stocks/sectors are under or overvalued, then I guess active investing makes sense, but that seems like a flawed premise to start from.
- jshaqaw 5y agoYou aren’t tracking the whole market. An index is a subset. Even total market indices have weightings which embed biases. And the whole game has been reverse engineered by charlatans to dump crap into rivers of blind money. If think capital offerings aren’t designed explicitly to target index inclusion criteria then you aren’t in on the joke.
- cromka 5y ago> And the whole game has been reverse engineered by charlatans to dump crap into rivers of blind money. If think capital offerings aren’t designed explicitly to target index inclusion criteria then you aren’t in on the joke. This is an interesting and plausible take, just wondering if you have actual published resources on that or is it your personal, arguably justified hunch?
- FunnyBadger 5y agoThe market does price discovery if it's not program traded. What markets are doing is recording and publishing the results of auctions for the particular good as a time series of data. Indexes hide some of that but there's something far worse: HFT. The problem is that program trading and HFT has far more in common with the old Scientific American COREWAR game than it does with the fundamentals of price discovery. The buy/sell decisions are about gaming other players rather than discovering price. There are also nonlinear feedback loops with very short loop time constants created that are "nonconservative" in a physics sense and create instablity. The fact that hard limits are required to deal with flash crashes is a warning, not a solution!!
- jt2190 5y agoA clearer title (from the article) would be: Retail investors’ holdings in index funds exceeds active funds for the first time More specifically: > As of March 31, Morningstar says, retail investors had $8.53 trillion invested in index mutual funds, while $8.34 trillion worth of assets were invested in actively-managed funds.
- traceroute66 5y agoIts actually a very poorly written article, more clickbait than actually saying anything useful. Case in point, title says "active managers" ...but if you read the article its actually "actively managed funds". Which means that before we've started we're already deep into Apples & Oranges comparisons with "index funds" vs "actively managed funds". "Index funds" are simple, they track an index. (oversimplified, there are technicalities, but we'll leave it at that). "Actively managed funds" meanwhile have a defined remit, and each fund will have a different remit. They might be limited as to sectors, company size, market technicalities or anything else. It is also likely the case that there is less interest in "actively managed funds" because if you are in the market for "actively managed" then you may well be constructing your own portfolio of individual equities rather than just buying a fund. Furthermore, "index funds" can be used by money managers as part of a balanced portfolio. For example, they might pick individual equities in markets/sectors that they are familiar with, and then use index funds for broader geographical or other coverage. So in essence the Yahoo article is a waste of words and is doing everyone a disservice, including the index funds it seeks to promote.
- abirch 5y agoMost active funds are in fact mostly beta (indexed funds) with an exception of 5%. Most articles are worthless, but it's hard for media outlets to say that nothing meaningful happened in their sector today.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throw0101a 5y agoWilliam F. Sharpe published the very short (two pages) article "The Arithmetic of Active Management" in 1991: > Over any specified time period, the market return will be a weighted average of the returns on the securities within the market, using beginning market values as weights[3]. Each passive manager will obtain precisely the market return, before costs[4]. From this, it follows (as the night from the day) that the return on the average actively managed dollar must equal the market return. Why? Because the market return must equal a weighted average of the returns on the passive and active segments of the market. If the first two returns are the same, the third must be also. > This proves assertion number 1. Note that only simple principles of arithmetic were used in the process. To be sure, we have seriously belabored the obvious, but the ubiquity of statements such as those quoted earlier suggests that such labor is not in vain. > To prove assertion number 2, we need only rely on the fact that the costs of actively managing a given number of dollars will exceed those of passive management. Active managers must pay for more research and must pay more for trading. Security analysis (e.g. the graduates of prestigious business schools) must eat, and so must brokers, traders, specialists and other market-makers. > Because active and passive returns are equal before cost, and because active managers bear greater costs, it follows that the after-cost return from active management must be lower than that from passive management. * https://web.stanford.edu/~wfsharpe/art/active/active.htm https://web.stanford.edu/~wfsharpe/art/active/active.htm And on why picking a winning stock is so hard (first edition 1973): * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Random_Walk_Down_Wall_Street https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Random_Walk_Down_Wall_Street
- throwk8s 5y agoBut does it matter that the category of "active managers" achieves near-parity (after costs) with index funds if you're not able to maintain a running bet on the whole pool of active managers (i.e. you have to pick one or more specific managers)? For instance, if today's active managers always lose their asses to new active managers arriving tomorrow, then any active manager you actually give your money to today is going to do way worse than an index fund, not just somewhat worse due to costs. The set of active managers actually available at a given moment in time might be 100% long-term losers.
- dangus 5y agoI’ve been something of a Boglehead for a long time, but every few years or so I try to look up analysis of active funds to try and see if they’re starting to beat the market as a whole. I shouldn’t be surprised, but I can’t help always feeling a bit of surprise when the answer always ends up being “nope, only 10-20% of active managers are beating the market.” So, if you’re going for actively managed funds, you’ve got a pretty low chance of actually picking a good one. It’s no wonder index funds have now become the majority. I have to admit that I don’t know enough about how the financial markets work to know what would happen if 100% of investors went with passive funds. How would that even work? Is that even possible?
- bombcar 5y agoBogle himself talks about a bigger danger than price discovery etc - when all companies are owned by index funds effectively nobody owns them - and so they’ll be run by the managers for the managers. http://johncbogle.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/niri-6-03.pdf http://johncbogle.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/n... It’s likely that we need to actually take ownership and not just let everything go as it goes forward.
- Consultant32452 5y agoIn effect, they are owned by Vanguard, Blackrock, Fidelity, etc. Those firms buy the shares with your money, then those firms pick the boards of the companies they bought with your money. So basically the boards of a hand full of the big investment firms own and run every publicly traded company.
- tryptophan 5y agoI dont understand why congress doesnt just mandate that voting rights go to the ultimate owner in index funds, no the management firm. Would be a pretty simple fix.
- Consultant32452 5y ago
- terabytest 5y agoAll the things I’ve read about passive funds have pointed in the same general direction. I can completely buy the reasoning but I worry I’m missing part of the point, which brings me to my question. In a scenario where passive funds are the best investment vehicle when looking at long term returns, what’s the role of buying and/or trading individual stocks? Are there cases in which you’d prefer stocks over funds? I’ve got some Netflix, Microsoft and Apple stock which I plan to keep for the long term. I could never figure out if that money would’ve been better spent as a fund purchase. What trips me up is stocks tend to lead to bigger earnings (when things go right) and companies like Apple are almost certainly going to remain valuable for a long time. What am I missing? Edit: this has been a recurring theme in discussions I’ve had with my dad (who’s a financial advisor, ironically). I’ve pointed out to him that passive funds seem better but he keeps wanting to put my money into stocks, active funds or sometimes narrow, low(er) cost managed funds (e.g. biomedicine and robotics stuff).
- doovd 5y ago> what’s the role of buying and/or trading individual stocks? Loads of reasons to do so: 1. You might have enough alpha to beat the returns of an index. 2.You prefer a more market neutral strategy and construct your own basket, maintaining it over various timescales. The fact is that most of these reasons don't apply to your average retail investor though.
- terabytest 5y agoWould you be willing to go into more detail about those two reasons? I feel I don’t have enough experience to understand the reasoning underlying them.
- ironSkillet 5y agoI can try to provide some additional information: 1. If you have a view of current market dynamics that you think many other investors have wrong, it can be profitable to go long/short an individual stock. E.g. you have some data suggesting that company XYZ is going to have a great quarter relative to market expectations, and buy some of the stock. Hedge funds do this all the time, with mixed success. 2. Some investors don't want to be exposed to the up/down trends in the overall market, and would prefer an investing strategy whose return/risk profile is independent of the general market. You can do this by creating long/short portfolios in individual sectors/stocks. For example, if you are long stock A, short stock B, you can make money if the market rises or falls, as long as you were right about the relative performance of each stock. In a rising market, you would make money if stock A gained more than stock B. In a falling market, you would make money if stock A lost less than stock B.
- hendzen 5y agomy personal theory is that active management can still produce market-beating returns but the good active managers will rapidly grow their capital base to huge levels where they don't need much outside investment. On the other hand - now we have a situation where most investment savings by individual investors are tracking passive indexes. But if everyone is indexing - what determines the relative weight of each stock in the index? The answer is active investors. But with an increasingly smaller field of increasingly skilled investors (with more discretionary capital), we end up with the valuations of companies (and thus how societal time is allocated) competitively determined by a fierce prediction competition between the top active managers (Renaissance, DE Shaw, Citadel, etc).
- qznc 5y agoI guess the big question how much active management is good. According to the article for funds it is now roughly 50%. I believe even 10% is plenty for market efficiency.
- JudgePenitent 5y agoHow do you arrive at 10%?
- elromulous 5y agoI was under the impression the relative weights are (often) simply proportional to their market cap. Afaict that's how that works for the sp500 at least.
- hendzen 5y agoExactly, the relative weights are often proportional to the market cap. So if I invest $1M in the S&P that doesn't actually change the relative weights of the stocks in the index (mostly), since the impact on all of the underlying stock market caps should be roughly even as more money flows in to the stocks with higher market cap and smaller sums flow in to the stocks with lower market cap. So in the case that say Meta's metaverse initiatives suddenly start taking off with the general population, it will take active investors to invest more in FB to increase FB's marketcap relative to the other stocks in the index so that passive investors are "correctly" allocating to stocks in proportion to their earnings potential. Obviously there are some caveats here. Passive investors still have to choose an index to invest in, and inflows in to one narrow index (i.e. QQQ) will affect the weights of particular stocks in broader indexes. But the point stands that the relative marketcap ranking between stocks in the index is not affected much by in/outflows in to a particular index, and in some sense indexes are outsourcing their stock picking to active investors that actually try to accurately value individual stocks on an absolute and relative basis.
- westurner 5y agoIndex fund: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Index_fund https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Index_fund > Comparison of index funds with index ETFs: In the United States, mutual funds price their assets by their current value every business day, usually at 4:00 p.m. Eastern time, when the New York Stock Exchange closes for the day. [40] Index ETFs, in contrast, are priced during normal trading hours, usually 9:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Eastern time. Index ETFs are also sometimes weighted by revenue rather than market capitalization. [41] Survivorship bias > Examples > In business, finance, and economics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias
- drawingthesun 5y agoI thought this was always true?
- melony 5y agoAre there index funds that are similar to hedge funds? I am looking for indices that generate returns that are uncorrelated to general market performance. Because that's what the hedge in hedge funds mean.
- sideshowb 5y agoSome people use a emerging markets index for that, it's at least a little uncorrelated to western performance
- shneefLeopard 5y agoYes and no. There are products that track hedge fund performance [0]. But ultimately these reflect active investment decisions, while a proper index fund does not [0] https://etfdb.com/etfdb-category/hedge-fund/ https://etfdb.com/etfdb-category/hedge-fund/
- sprash 5y agoThis is a macro phenomenon and will stop soon since the central bank has stopped printing money. Since 2008 major Central Banks are actively buying bonds in droves which companies use to buy back their stock and as a result increase prices of their stock. The passive strategy will not work anymore now because companies with high capital costs will get hammered.
- gitfan86 5y agoActive managers make way more money selling their fund and increasing deposits than actually beating the market. So they will do things like promote "downside protection", claiming that their returns will be close to Russel 2000, but 90% less likely to go down by 2x more than the Russel 2000 in any year. Which is bullshit because anyone could put 80% of their money in Russel 2000 and 10% in cash and 10% in gold and get the same guarantee without paying anyone for it.
- melony 5y agoCash and gold are not the risk free rate.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Cash and gold are not the risk free rate In finance jargon, “cash” is typically taken to mean “cash and cash equivalents,” i.e. money market assets.
- anonu 5y agoThe financial markets are a fantastic ecosystem. There are all types of players out there: short-term vs long-term, high-frequency vs low-frequency, technical chart readers, fundamentals, macro, hedgers, punters, speculators, 401k managers, retirees, r/wsb, retail, institutional. For as long as there have been markets, there are people who think they can beat them. So active management isn't going anywhere and it certainly wont disappear. There will certainly be a time when the active managers win out over passive. On a related note: I have this particular view that most active managers inside trade. (Look at Steve Cohen, SAC/Point72 - the insider trading was rampant, and I assume that if it was this prevalent and the largest most sophisticated of funds - then its probably pretty pervasive). I think the SEC's continuous crackdown on systematic insider trading is partly responsible for the long decline of active management.
- MuffinFlavored 5y agois technical chart reading real? does it really yield any results?
- spiralx 4y agoAs someone that once implemented close to 100 different indicators for a real-time stock chart AFAIK there is no evidence that technical analysis is particularly useful. In the short-term markets are lead by sentiment and in the long-term by fundamentals, neither of which are really captured by indicators.
- FunnyBadger 5y agoI thought this was shown to be true in terms of expected ROI more than 25 years ago - it was talked about in my MBA program.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 5y agoAside from costs, index funds may have outperformed because their share of the overtall pie has risen. If you consider an index fund to be an asset on its own, the price of that asset rises as more people invest in it. As a result, equities that are underrepresented in indices decrease on average, while those that are overrepresented - increase. We see evidence of this in the fact that equities tend to fall shortly after being removed from key indexes. So index funds outperform because their share increases, and their share increases because they outperform. Classic bubble equation.
- known 5y ago