6 ms·
It's interesting that shopping carts that you have to insert a coin into still seem to be uncommon in the US. They were the obvious way to incentivise people t
by eru 5y ago
It's interesting that shopping carts that you have to insert a coin into still seem to be uncommon in the US. They were the obvious way to incentivise people to bring the carts back in Germany.
(And not necessarily the same people who shopped with them. People who find an abandoned shopping cart in the parking lot would often bring it back to the store to get at the coin.)
- zdragnar 5y agoThe only place in the US that I have seen them is at Aldi
- eru 5y agoAnd that's because they are extremely German.
- zdragnar 5y agoYeah, I probably should have clarified that for anyone who isn't familiar. It's a German grocery chain that also operates in the US.
- bombcar 5y agoAnd even Aldi here has to station a guy to give you a cart and collect those in the parking lot, mainly because people often don’t have the quarter to get one. It’s a cute idea but I’m not sure it’s practical in the long run.
- zdragnar 5y agoI wonder if this is regional or specific to your location. I've been to several (and have frequently shopped at two) and they've never had a person staffing the carts. It has been practical for a long time, but you may be right in that they'll have a hard time with the younger generations that transition to being cashless.
- robonerd 5y agoRelying on the honor system may be less effective, but I prefer it anyway because it feels a whole lot less demeaning. No quarter is essentially the store saying 'We trust you to do the right thing' whereas the quarter says 'betcha we can make you behave with a quarter' Also, stray shopping carts left in the lot really doesn't seem like a big problem worth solving to me. The lots all have cart returns scattered throughout them, so you're never very far from one, and the vast majority of people use them.
- eru 5y agoI was more thinking of carts strewn throughout the city. But, I guess, American supermarkets are not anywhere near the cities.
- robonerd 5y agoAll three of the grocery stores I shop at are in the city. All three of them have honor system cart returns, and I've never seen a stray cart in my neighborhood. Even the homeless seem to leave the carts alone, or at least stash them where they won't be seen.
- jarenmf 5y agoDuring the pandemic many stores in Germany left all the carts unlocked and it seems that some of them didn't go back to the old system. So probably they've realized it's a silly thing to do and maybe it actually bring more customers if you left the carts unlocked. I actually used to chose stores that don't require a coin to unlock the carts.
- 13of40 5y agoExactly this. Also, for example, no security cameras at Trader Joe's and no scales in the self checkout at Whole Foods. I'm a grownup, you don't need forcing functions to make me behave like one.
- DangitBobby 5y agoI prefer the pragmatic approach of assuming (not without evidence) that people won't behave without incentive. I'm much more annoyed by carts all over the parking lot than I am by temporarily putting a coin in a slot. And I like the happy side effect of not seeing miserable teenagers in vests tasked with collecting rogue carts on cold nights.
- fredley 5y agoUS doesn't have high enough denomination coins to make it work I imagine.
- kube-system 5y agoIt works at Aldi in the US. The incentive is not so much that I can’t afford throwing away 25 cents, but it’s that, the next time I shop at Aldi, I need a quarter to get a cart.
- eru 5y agoYes. But: the quarter doesn't have to work on you. It just has to work on someone. Ie you can essentially contract out bringing the cart back for a quarter of a dollar.
- jimmaswell 5y agoHow many people even have coins in their car anymore, much less in their pocket? I have a small supply of coins in my car just in case but I imagine a lot of people haven't touched a coin or bill in years.
- Doxin 4y agoI, and a fair few number of people I know, carry a specific cart-coin in their pocket.
- amelius 5y agoProbably because in the US it is not so easy to walk away with a cart and take it any further than the parking lot. It also wouldn't make much sense. In Germany, you could theoretically walk your cart a few blocks to your home, then leave it on the street.
- raverbashing 5y agoA lot of places have an invisible perimeter for shopping carts https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-QKcprQD0zc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-QKcprQD0zc
- morelisp 5y agoWe have an Oma in our apartment who brings a cart back periodically, keeps it at the bike rack, and walks it back to the store the next day she goes shopping.
- jokethrowaway 5y ago1-2 eur for a cart is not a bad deal. I saw plenty of supermarkets with carts asking for coin having their cart stolen and abandoned across town. I think it's mainly linked with whether you have juvenile "gangs" fooling around or not
- hereforphone 5y agoOn the list of ways to judge the quality of a society, people putting carts back where they belong is up there with using turn signals.
- eru 5y agoAnd Germans by and large put the coins back. They just use a Euro coin to help with that social institution. Most people could totally afford to lose a Euro, but it's The Right Thing to do to bring the cart back. Similar to how when you are working as a programmer, it's good for not to break 'master'. You could rely completely on an honour system, or you could have an automated merge-check. In most places, the merge-check can be arbitrarily easy to bypass, but programmers would still by and large abide it.