6 ms·
> The interesting idea behind crypto once was to have a totally different system. the problem with this idea is that this idea of a "different" system is just
by chii 4y ago
> The interesting idea behind crypto once was to have a totally different system.
the problem with this idea is that this idea of a "different" system is just merely going to evolve back into what we have today. The fundamental needs of a financial system doesn't change much, and what we have today is fit for purpose (mostly - there's efficiency to be had and red tape to cut).
- OtomotO 4y agoIt is until you're on a list, for whatever reason. When states and countries can just block your access to your bank accounts, because you're on the other side of interests, it gets...Interesting With a decentralised approach, such actions would've needed to be implemented in the real world, not merely by the flick of a virtual lever.
- Nursie 4y agoWhat’s truly decentralised? Miners are increasingly centralised and can effectively block/ignore transactions if they like. They may conceivably end up compelled to blacklist certain wallets, as some exchanges already do. And that’s before we get to stuff like Luna, where the decentralised authorities took the centralised action of halting the chain entirely
- eudoxus 4y agoI'm curious what makes this a centralized action? Many independent (decentralized?) entities debated and used social consensus to come to the decision to halt the chain to isolate further potential damage. Like them or hate them, I'm intrigued where the centralized line in the sand was crossed
- Nursie 4y agoA relatively small group of powerful people shut the chain down. This was not a consensus action amongst token holders, network users or any other group, their consent was not required. Power is held by this group of (130?) people, it seems pretty centralised to me, basically an oligarchy.
- cuteboy19 4y agoIt's so decentralised that Mr. Kwon can just turn off the blockchain when he wants to!
- eudoxus 4y agoIf we're going to shit on crypto, can we at least be accurate in our statements. The validators of the Terra chain halted it. There's no switch that Kwon as an individual can flip.
- adhesive_wombat 4y agoCould the company not just issue a hundred trillion dollars of it in a day and sink the currency if they wanted to (or were forced into it). There's no built-in way to verify that minted Tether can be verified to be backed. If there were, firstly there'd be no questions about the backing at all, it's all public on the blockchain, and second, it would revolutionary and actually useful to have a smart contract that can track real assets and not let them vanish from under it.
- LittlePeter 4y agoHow were multiple validators coordinated to switch the chain off? When we say Putin can press the red button obviously we don't mean a physical red button pressed by Putin himself. But he is the one coordinating.
- eudoxus 4y agoThere's many channels/groups where the validators coordinate and communicate for all kinds of chain related activities, tasks, upgrades, etc. Actually, the Putin analogy is basically exactly what happens. Putin pushed the "red button" and everything else is a direct consequence. That's not how it works with validator based PoS chains. Absolutely Kwon can "suggest" to do something, but has no omnipotent influence or control unlike your Putin analogy. Validators are absolutely free to discuss, debate, and agree to whatever they think is best. Additionally, the validators in the active set with this power are put there mostly by the community of token holders.
- mindwok 4y agoDoes this really matter though? Is it any different to drug lord having a tonne of dirty cash they can’t use anywhere because all the useful places you could put it want nothing to do with you? Watching from the sidelines, the Crypto world seems to just be morphing into the normal financial world.
- exdsq 4y ago> Watching from the sidelines, the Crypto world seems to just be morphing into the normal financial world. Say this is true, how amazing would that be for countries without existing banking infrastructure to easily access it?
- closedloop129 4y agoCan't they already use WeChat and AliPay?
- exdsq 4y agoHow do you do that without a bank account?
- chii 4y agothis is already being done via mobile phones. Crypto doesn't solve the problem of being unbanked. In fact, the requirement that you need good internet speed for crypto to run locally means it's even harder for a place without infrastructure to participate.
- searchableguy 4y agoIn India, everyone has a phone even if they do not have a roof, bank account, proper 3 meals a day, etc. Bank accounts also require minimum balance, address and identity proof which is hard to get for some, local branch is necessary to open an account due to regulation and quality can vary wildly even for urban centres. > In fact, the requirement that you need good internet speed for crypto to run locally means it's even harder for a place without infrastructure to participate. Internet costs less than $2 for monthly unlimited data. You can find 300-500 Mbps broadband in small towns of country where you won't find roads or basic hospitals.
- katcher 4y agoLike you're on a list for starting a genocide.
- hestefisk 4y agoThose lists can come in quite handy when you need to deal with people like Russian oligarchs …
- lupire 4y agoAnd with dissidents. But not so handy if you are an oligarch (or a dissident)
- outside1234 4y agoWe need the lists for drug dealers and oligarchs. There are lists for a reason.
- paganel 4y agoThere are also political dissidents in there. See Canada.
- chx 4y ago> mostly - there's efficiency to be had and red tape to cut and Open Banking has been working on this steadily in many countries.
- Jommi 4y agoCan you show me any tangible results of open banking? I used to work in the space and it was a shitshow of bureaucracy that never went anywhere. Ethereum IS ALREADY an ecosystem of programmable money APIs, and it works TODAY.
- chx 4y agoWorks is an interesting choice of word. https://twitter.com/qrs/status/1395784294451265536 https://twitter.com/qrs/status/1395784294451265536 > Smart contracts should be considered self-funded bug-bounty platforms.
- Jommi 4y agoYou share a link to a tweet with a phot of an ATM. What is your point? What do you think it true anti-fragility in a system? Something that is built form the ground-up in a regulatory too-big-to-fail environment, or something that starts from the wilderness, gets beaten down multiple times, yet grows back up stronger than before. That is true antifragility.
- chx 4y agoI quoted the point. The hubris of Ethereum where software bugs result in the loss of money is just astounding. While obviously banking software can have bugs as well, the regulations make the consequences much, much less severe. With Ethereum, one bug, money is gone and you are done for. And as we learned, often the money is gone to North Korea. That's what hubris and cryptobros brought upon us: they made a funnel of savings of poor people caught in the hype tsunami to North Korea of all places. https://web3isgoinggreat.com/ https://web3isgoinggreat.com/ https://www.cnn.com/2022/04/14/politics/fbi-north-korea-hackers-crypto/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2022/04/14/politics/fbi-north-korea-hack...
- KaiserPro 4y ago> there's efficiency to be had and red tape to cut Depends. In the USA, yes, your banking system is utterly shite, despite the supposedly numerous volume of different banks who are supposedly able to innovate and compete. But. that red tape is there to prevent a bank from collapsing. Its been imposed as a reaction to numerous financial crises. There loads of rules that govern how much money a bank can loan, and how much they have to have on hand and in what classes they need to store deposits in. A bank can be wildly profitable if it doesn't care too much who it lends to. Riskier debts yield much greater interest. The problem is, as soon as confidence takes a knock, the entire bank collapses because the value they claim they have is not backed by any kind of liquid asset. This is the same with crypto. A stable coin is wildly profitable when people are pouring cash into it. but all it takes is a small wobble, people rushing to convert the "coin" into another asset class, and the whole thing crashes. This might be because they really don't have enough reserves to cover the withdrawl, or it was fraud. They aren't regulated, so we'll probably not know.
- Paradigma11 4y agoIn my opinion crypto (i am talking about PoS with smart contracts) is about having a decentralized open source/standards cloud for financial services/ transactions. That opens up many possibilities but everything has been completely drowned out by VCs starting defi ponzi schemes and other shenanigans.
- the_snooze 4y agoThe problem is that there's adverse selection going on here: people who aren't running ponzi schemes and other shenanigans are generally content with the regular banking system, so scammers are disproportionally present in the crypto world. Given that environment, it's mostly risk and little benefit for legit users in crypto. The killer app for decentralized finance so far is sidestepping laws. No wonder it's a den of snakes.
- salawat 4y agoPoS is centralizing by it's very nature.
- Paradigma11 4y agoShow me. There are PoS chains running for a few years, so this should be observable.
- lupire 4y agoCrtyptoc is digital cash (not necessarily all of digital money), with all the benfits and risks that digital provides. It's like converting your office paperwork to digital. Highly efficient, but you might get hacked or lose your keys and lose it all at once.