10 ms·
What Happened to Tagging? (2019)
- PaulHoule 5y agoAdd enough tags and then you have a gawdawful mess and you need tags to organize your tags.
- coffeeblack 5y agoDoesn’t that always happen? Some people will push the tools so far that they lose all their initial usefulness.
- WalterGR 5y agoI’ve always thought that Gmail’s hierarchical tagging (‘folders’) is a great solution to the organization problem.
- pc9 5y agoSame. I've making and remaking a bookmarking/notetaking site for my personal use over the years, and this is the solution I landed on. They look like and can be organized like folders, but you can quickly add items to multiple folders. I think it's working well for me so far.
- WalterGR 5y agoThat’s awesome. Just this past week I’ve started looking for a Chrome extension that does the same.
- bbkane 5y agoI think this is a great use case for some algorithm to help you combine tags ( by recognizing synonyms/plurals, text summarization, crowd-spurcing, something else?). Then it could keep you "on the rails" when tagging and periodically ask if you want to combine tags that seem similar.
- foerbert 5y agoPerhaps, but after even just a few relatively short attempts to start organizing some of my files with tags I don't think this would be sufficient. I found the meaning of tags frequently started to drift. What I cared about and why just wasn't that consistent. Never mind being consistent with hair-splitting judgement calls in categorization. And the more you tag, the more difficult it is to fix. Either you retag everything to fit the new standard or you accept that trying to retrieve things by tag will return some weird set defined by the intersection of your changing definition over time and the time at which you applied the tag. I don't doubt a more structured and principled approach would help, but I found it just ended up soaking up tons of time, and thought, without actually providing much back.
- m3kw9 5y agoApple notes tag is pretty awful.
- CharlesW 5y agoHow so? https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT212507 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT212507
- jkmcf 5y agoOTOH, Federico Viticci (MacStories) just switched to using reminders and tags with smart lists. I haven't attempted this yet, but I think the gist is reminders/notes requires tags in order to get smart folders. https://club.macstories.net/posts/going-all-in-with-reminders-tags-and-smart-lists https://club.macstories.net/posts/going-all-in-with-reminder...
- seunosewa 5y agoI loved del.icio.us. It was a core part of my browsing experience. Any useful link I stumbled upon got tagged and saved. The popular links were very useful, too. Then it got sold to people who couldn't figure out how to make money off it without ruining it. I still miss the functionality of being able to quickly find every interesting webpage I've ever seen (using tags). A way to supply that functionality in the modern world would be a visited pages search feature on Google or Chrome. Or a search feature for the content of pages I've bookmarked.
- wincy 5y agoWhy couldn't such a thing be a local browser extension or similar?
- flir 5y ago> A way to supply that functionality in the modern world would be a visited pages search feature on Google or Chrome I've been wondering about a plugin that does that. Maybe built over this? https://lunrjs.com/ https://lunrjs.com/ I am ABSOLUTELY CERTAIN this does not yet exist. (Easier to type that last sentence than actually Google for it).
- tlavoie 5y agoPinboard (https://pinboard.in/ https://pinboard.in/) is still a thing, and the developer bought the deli.icio.us domain too I think. In any case, it has at least replicated the del.icio.us functionality, and then added more, such as archiving page contents. The tags are still there too, and it prompts with other users' tags when you add a bookmark. Oh, and an API, which is very useful for programmatic use of the data once saved.
- panic 5y agoPinboard doesn’t have the social features that del.icio.us had—you can’t see the list of others who bookmarked a link, for example.
- kordlessagain 5y ago
- tiffanyh 5y agoTagging never died. “Tags” became known as “Labels”. Labels are core functionality of Gmail, GitHub Issues, and more today.
- asplake 5y agoKilled (at least for me) by browser history (and then the web of course) being so easily searchable
- 7fYZ7mJh3RNKNaG 5y agoAlthough that might have been the case some time ago, nowadays browser history is definitely not easily searchable unless you only need results from the last 90 days. Chrome purges them after that, and Firefox has a similar limit.
- johnny22 5y agoI just have my history config set to: Firefox will "remember history" and my history goes back to 2019 when i started this new firefox profile.
- andybak 5y agoObligatory: https://people.well.com/user/doctorow/metacrap.htm https://people.well.com/user/doctorow/metacrap.htm
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 5y agoThanks, that's a vastly better article than the submitted one. I'd read it before, it's well worth revisiting.
- japhyr 5y agoBuilding an effective tagging system can be much harder than people realize. I once worked on a tagging system for a collection of math problems. I thought I could code a simple tagging model, and let users tag their own math problems, and it would become much easier to find the problems you're most interested in. Then I realized that tags like algebra 1, Algebra 1, Algebra I, Alg I, and all other variations should mean the same thing. So I started to develop a closed set of tags. That led to a fascinating rabbit hole about taxonomies that I don't even remember how to speak about clearly at this point. That project is still a work in progress, and it's left me with immense respect for people who build well-structured systems that involve tagging.
- NicoJuicy 5y agoI just used synonyms and a tag hierarchy ( nested sets). Works pretty well.
- japhyr 5y agoI ended up building out a hierarchy as well. But figuring out the structure of that hierarchy was not trivial at all. How does the name of a repeatable class (Algebra 1) fit with the name of a specific class (Algebra 1 Fall 2020 Section 2)? How does that relate to an area of math like algebra, geometry, number theory? How does that relate to things like context (ie problems about Minecraft, Lego, Physics, etc.) I developed a closed system of tags, and then gave people the ability to define aliases.
- cratermoon 5y agoclosed system and aliases are good. Taxonomies, not so much. See https://oc.ac.ge/file.php/16/_1_Shirky_2005_Ontology_is_Overrated.pdf https://oc.ac.ge/file.php/16/_1_Shirky_2005_Ontology_is_Over... and http://www.dlib.org/dlib/january06/guy/01guy.html http://www.dlib.org/dlib/january06/guy/01guy.html
- mgdlbp 5y agoTwo impressive site-wide systems I've seen are the categories of Wikimedia Commons (multimedia) and tags of Archive of Our Own (fanfiction). The Commons guideline[0] elucidates its system and interesting ontological theory well. It's scope is extremely broad, aiming to simultaneously include any possibly useful categorization scheme,[1] and overall is a fairly freeform (ideally) directed acyclic graph. Variations are handled with redirects and disambiguation pages in a typical wiki manner, with the limitation that individual category uses must have the canonical name. Ao3, in contrast, has a schema of sorts, and synonyms are made equivalent during resolution (its tags FAQ[2] is also an interesting read). I tried to write a more thorough comment but also struggled with being coherent. Thus, some ideas, only briefly: - At an even higher level, the web itself and the overlapping userbases/communities ('intersectionality', without the discrimination--the original set-theory kind?) of individual sites can also be considered a way of organizing content - Thus, analogously: Search engines replaced directories and webrings as algorithms did tags. The present SEO meta, though... - Generalizing from Commons, all Wikimedia wikis (Wikipedia, etc.) have parallel category structures, only less developed due to the greater reliance on links. So do most wikis in general, though Wikimedia also unifies categorization and structured data with Wikidata. From there are knowledge graphs and databases in general, wrapping back around to Google trying to determine the Knowledge Graph item that each query refers to. [0] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Categories https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Categories [1] all the typical keying on depicted people, things, times, and places, plus the ways that we categorize those. Niches from 'horizontal bicolor blue and white flags' to 'Luxembourgish pronunciation by gender', 'trams on route 709', 'ships with 6 funnels'. There's a tool (now called vCat) to visualize categories, some outputs here: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Wikimedia_catgraphs https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Wikimedia_catgra... [2] https://archiveofourown.org/faq/tags https://archiveofourown.org/faq/tags Edit: specific examples
- achairapart 5y agoFor sometime there were also "machine tags", basically a triple tag invented (I think) at Flickr[0]. It was an interesting concept, you could automate relationships between different contexts, for example between Flickr and Last.fm[1]. I used it for a while, then I always wondered why nothing similar has ever emerged, maybe because after the first wave of "social sharing" excitement of web 2.0, every walled garden has basically double locked their gates. And this is maybe what happened to tagging in general. [0]: http://tagaholic.me/2009/03/26/what-are-machine-tags.html http://tagaholic.me/2009/03/26/what-are-machine-tags.html [1]: https://code.flickr.net/2008/08/28/machine-tags-lastfm-and-rocknroll/ https://code.flickr.net/2008/08/28/machine-tags-lastfm-and-r...
- pyinstallwoes 5y agoI’m not sure I’m following, how is the machine tag format setting up automatic relationships and contexts? How is it helpful and how might you see it being effective today? Edit: only saw the first link. Seems second link breaks it down but can’t review it yet. Got pulled away. Thanks!
- bastawhiz 5y agoThe concept of machine tags is the core premise of RDF. RDF is essentially the standardized way of describing relationships in a structured way (in XML). In fact, an early version of RSS was based on RDF (RSS 0.9 stood for "RDF site summary). One of the downsides is that it's pretty hard for "average" folks to produce these feeds. There's a steep learning curve for modeling the relationships. Getting other sites to agree on a format, use it, and maintain it without breaking compatibility was hard.
- joshu 5y agoMachine tags aren't tags at all. Not all metadata is tagging.
- cratermoon 5y agoCurated tags, including canonizing one variation of a tag and making all the others with the same meaning synonyms: https://archiveofourown.org/wrangling_guidelines/16 https://archiveofourown.org/wrangling_guidelines/16 Of course, where a single word has two or more meanings, synonyms don't make sense, so go with Wikipedia-style disambiguation. Also be aware if your community has specialized jargon, uses multiple human languages, patois, creole, dialects, or pidgin. Allow multi-word tags, but settle on a single casing/separation and enforce it: camelCase, snake_case, and kebab-case are some choices. Prefer plurals "landscapes" over singulars "landscape". See also https://web.archive.org/web/20050426210018/http://ideant.typepad.com/ideant/2005/04/tag_literacy.html https://web.archive.org/web/20050426210018/http://ideant.typ...
- caseyross 5y agoBesides what the article goes into about auto-curation of social feeds reducing self-curation, the counterintuitive answer is that decentralized tagging requires strong centralization to work. You need: - agreement on what should be and what should not be tagged in a given domain - standardized terminology (no multiple variants of tags) - consistent grammar and formatting across all tags - software support for tag editing that makes it easy to adhere to established tagging rules - mechanisms to explain tagging rules to new users, at scale - mechanisms to punish malicious/spam tagging (e.g. user history/reputation + bans) Usually, all of these conditions together are only found in highly niche and specialized forums that care a lot about the quality of their content. While most large social platforms today do have some kind of tagging system (e.g. hash tags on Twitter/Instagram), the usefulness of these systems is generally limited due to the inherent difficulties of co-ordinating so many diverse users who have varying interests.
- porker 5y ago> Usually, all of these conditions together are only found in highly niche and specialized forums that care a lot about the quality of their content. Ooh do any of these still exist? If you know of any I'd love the links to look at how they're doing. I was an inveterate tagger, debating taxonomies and ontologies late into the night (I have now forgotten the difference between the two!) and tried to run a curated forum. Eventually I gave up for most of the reasons you highlight - but mainly because I realised no one was as OCD about classification as I was. In another life I would have run and catalogued a university library.
- b3morales 5y agoStack Overflow exhibits (or exhibited) all the points that parent mentioned. If you look at [the discussion of tags on the Meta site][0], and especially what's called ["burnination"][1] you'll see these issues being hashed out over time. To sustain a tagging system like that it takes dedicated and invested individuals, and the corollary of that is that such people tend to generate a lot of discussion. [0]:https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/tags https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/tags [1]:https://meta.stackoverflow.com/tags/burninate-request/info https://meta.stackoverflow.com/tags/burninate-request/info
- woojoo666 5y agoI don't think tags died, they just evolved to more user friendly forms. For example, Reddit is basically tags. You post something to one subreddit, or cross-post it to another, and other users who are subscribed will all see it. Perhaps the UX was the main issue in those early days
- jimz 5y agoAlso, reddit, due to the way it encourages specific niche subreddits to proliferate, inadvertently also showcases, albeit from the tag side instead of the tagged-content side, one use-case where community tagging is both necessary and canonical tags are inconsistent or nonexistent, which is the vast arena of porn, which involves attempts to categorize massive amounts of content that are frequently lacking in tags or tagged minimalistically or even erroneously by studios, and also, can involve specific preferences that aren't necessarily even considered as something that needs to be tagged until someone starts a subreddit on some really obscure aspect of a clip and then, suddenly it turns out there's a community and demand for such a tag. Some automated tagging solutions do work on some aspects of the tag deficiencies - performers using different stage names, for example. However, just as obscenity is defined on a "I'll know it when I see it" basis, individual and perhaps previously unnamed categorizations pop up frequently enough that there's no realistic way to anticipate every future community tag that may come about. There's also inconsistencies as to how currently-used tags are defined, and even in the generally more centralized and almost over-specific niches of the industry in Japan, with consistent and unique product codes for reference, you still don't get a single consistent studio tag system, even for their domestic mainstream market. And language certainly factors into all this, as well as culture. It's already evident that some tags translate and some simply don't, either because there is no word for it in the other language, or the categorization loses some aspect of cultural significance in the translation process that makes it end result valid but also nonsensical. Some degree of community curation to augment even a relatively consistent, centralized, and comprehensive canonical source. There are a few projects on Github that are hashing out compatible systems for at least the English language (and it appears that projects in Korean and Chinese exist too, also on Github). This is definitely an arena that is organic, disorganized, and even if in the future can mostly be automated, will always have room for community curation, and is actually actively being worked out and evolving in real time. Tags, or community curation at large, will likely persist as content, the market, culture, CV/classification tech, and mores change as time goes on. Definitely not dying.
- stareatgoats 5y agoTagging requires mental energy and some level of abstraction prowess - and might still be misleading. Social media is geared towards making the user expend as little mental energy as possible - and then organize the information they provide anyway for the advertisers using behavioral patterns or some variant of AI. This is probably considered by the industry to provide more reliable information - its like the difference between asking people to explain ethical behavior compared to recording what people actually do in reality. So, we have a "tagging" model driven by advertising needs, that discourages our own need to tag (intellectually categorize) the content we consume. Instead of moving forwards, towards a more accurate tagging system that supports reflection and concept organization, it seems to me (in my pessimistic moments) that we are moving backwards into an online world where the only ones that know what we are doing are the machines.
- karaterobot 5y agoRight around the time the author was celebrating Tagsgiving, I was in Library School, and tagging was a hot topic around those parts. The consensus there was: "this is great and all, but there's a reason we have controlled vocabularies and classification systems. We'll see, we'll see." I was all in on the possibilities for "folksonomies" and user tagging. However I have to admit that I have not seen many examples of where uncontrolled tagging was all that useful at scale. To organize information, you need experts, with training, time, and a reason to get it right. Or, you can do it with an arbitrarily sophisticated, mostly theoretical ML system. But neither of these solutions benefit from having user tags.
- tandav 5y agoAll you need is links. Tags are just links to pages which don't exists. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30915520 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30915520
- dredmorbius 5y agoIf that's the approach you want to take, tags are links to a set of pages you've specifically defined, whether they exist or not being largely irrelevant. The term in library science is a controlled vocabulary. Search allows a document (or its author(s)) to define itself. A controlled vocabulary allows another party --- yourself or a third party --- to define a set of terms which describe the contents. There are various reasons why you might not want the document's author themselves to rule over such terms as "brilliant", "fascist", or the like. Some degree of distance may be required. Authors are also famously unreliable narrators.
- dahdum 5y agoI’m not sure tags died, TikTok certainly seems to be built around tags and it has over a billion monthly users. They are also key to Instagram discovery but feel a little less important there, though I don’t care much for that platform and could be wrong.
- adventured 5y agoTagging has enormous labor costs associated with it and people don't want to do it. Creation, accuracy confirmation, maintenance/updates, removal. Your users do not want to do work, and they certainly do not want to do your work for you. They're tired, they want to relax, do not make them work.
- B1FF_PSUVM 5y agoAlso, what happened to the "semantic web"? (what, you cynical person, are you insinuating a profit-addled industry would stoop to misleading tags? oh, ye of little faith ...)
- joshu 5y agoMy time to shine, I guess. When I invented tagging it was as personal curation process, it was designed for people to recall things back to themselves later. It was an organizational schema. It has mostly disappeared. What we have now is mostly tagging so OTHER people can find it. Which leads to all sorts of bad incentives. Nobody really built collaborative tagging but it needs a bunch more support than hashtag-this and hashtag-that to really work. For example, we showed people tags that they have used before so they were gently pushed to reuse tags for more organizational cohesiveness.
- dyogenez 5y agoHey, and thanks for bringing the concept of tagging to the world! The idea that tags were meant for the individual makes a lot of sense. That’s how I used delicious. It was like my bookmarks folder, but links could be in multiple folders. When it comes to collaborative tagging, are there any successful examples that you’ve seen? Or sites you feel are using tags in interesting or surprisingly useful ways?
- marban 5y agoI was on a call with Science to potentially take over delicious but the momentum was super low back then and IIRC 99% of it was porn. Should have taken that poison pill in hindsight.
- aaron695 5y ago
- closedloop129 5y ago>Nobody really built collaborative tagging Why don't you build it now, or at least finance somebody who does? Is it too risky to build because the big social networks will copy it and thus destroy any successful exit?
- user_7832 5y agoThank you for making the concept of tags! Even though it's not perfect, I'm sure you've probably saved anywhere between thousands to perhaps millions of man hours globally (if not more)! That is an achievement very few people can claim.
- pronlover723 5y agoTagging doesn't work because there is an incentive to falsely tag to sell stuff. Tag sites with ads for cat products as "dog", "bird", "groceries", "boots", "cars" on the off chance that you'll get your ad for cat products in front of some random customer's eye balls. It's exactly the same incentive as spam email. It takes zero effort, costs nothing, and if you get 1 hit in a million you still make a profit. You can see this issue in play easily on soundcloud where people will tag their music with whatever tags they think will get their tracks played. You can also see it on all the porn sites where people re-upload porn with ads inserted or overlayed for their pay-for-porn site and then tag the porn with whatever they think will get click throughs. you might claim with enough tags you'll be able to tell the accurate tags from the inaccurate tags but I've seen no evidence that that actually works. My guess is it's partly that the only people who have an incentive to tag are the content creators (or content re-uploaders) and they have no incentive to follow any rules. Further, Agreeing on tags is nearly impossible. Consider "man" vs "woman" and all the political discussion around that. There's a conflict between those that want the tag for their identity, and those that want the tag to be useful for filtering. As much as I respect people's identities it's more useful for filtering if I can search for "brunette" and only see brunettes. And, if you find some other tag to use for the filtering then it's only a matter of time before someone demands they be identified with that new tag.
- HKH2 5y agoUsers are not given enough power to penalize bad actors. What do you expect? I suspect if tags were implemented properly, companies would make less money.
- smcnally 5y ago> You can see this issue in play easily on soundcloud where people will tag their music with whatever tags they think will get their tracks played. When a Lo-Fi Chillwave stream also includes Grindcore Death Metal tracks, it’s an especially annoying taxonomy misapplication. Most tag spam is less obvious to people, but still makes for dirty data.
- TylerE 5y agoSeems like this would be easily countered by weighting each tag by something like log(n tags) or something. Basically have just a few tags? They count a lot. Have a bazillion? They count next to zero
- polote 5y agoPeople who tell you that social tagging doesn't work would have tell you that Wikipedia can't work. Social tagging can probably work but we haven't found a way yet
- krick 5y agoThat's really shallow. A nostalgia dive, not an analysis. It isn't that "tagging worked, but now it doesn't", it just never really worked for her usecases, and it still does for usecases it can be used for. Maybe I would be more sympathetic, because I also feel that "it was better back then" (who doesn't?), if it wasn't for people like her using phrases "exploring Web 2.0" and so obviously not understanding what really happened. And what really happened is this. A bunch of somewhat similar people (a tiny group, really — compared to the population of the world, anyway) were playing a cute tabletop game of "Web 2.0" at the table set up out in the open fields, pretending they are eager for more people to join. But they weren't exploring this game, weren't really thinking about all the nuances and implication its rules had, and weren't actually preparing for more people to join, instead they implicitly agreed to use their own impromptu simplified version of the rules, which wasn't that hard to do for this tiny group of likely-minded people. And this naturally broke when more people and corporations and governments joined the game, and started playing it being limited only by the actual rules of the game, which are akin to the laws of physics in that they really have to be explored and have an immense number of implications. So, what role does tagging have in all of this? What is its true nature? Sadly, its true nature is "a hack", an artificial construct that gives you a one-inch leeway to barely slide across your problem. The problem is that it's a bit too hard to search for content using natural language descriptions of the content, because there is a lot of content, and there are a lot of words in human languages, and they all intertwine in all sorts of ways, and people use the same words to mean something else than what you meant, and they might use some other synonymous words to describe what you meant, and so on. It is alright as long as there is a hundred of people and thousands of posts, and it's all text without pictures, but when it grows it becomes just unmanageable and the full-text search doesn't work anymore. And you have no ideas how to approach it other than full-text search. So you agree to use simplified version of language in addition to the original language to mark what your content really is about, so that its a bit less ambiguous and you can continue to use full-text search on all of the contents of the internet. That gives you just enough leeway to reduce the number of search results to something manageable and you are happy. And you can even automatically feed the search results to your RSS. And 15 years later, when it all grows more still, and the simplified tagging-language gets more complex and more abused (or underused) so that full-text search doesn't work for everyone again, so people stop using your tagging-language because it doesn't help them any more than the original content, so it's useless and unnecessary and they switch to other approaches to find content. Which are also imperfect, by the way, but at least they are actually another approaches, not just some hacks on top of full-text search. The real lesson here is: "tagging doesn't work out in the open fields; use it in small communities with curated content, like, for example, a blogging channel of your own, so that your readers can find your other posts on the same subject". And (surprise!) people do use it for that quite successfully.