16 ms·
Teach your kids bridge, not poker
- paulcole 4y agoTeach your kids anything but Hacker News.
- pstuart 4y agoI'll take your comment at face value (ignoring the dis on a site that is engaging enough for you to participate ;-) HN is a treasure trove of interesting ideas and adventures. Of course it's not perfect but nothing is. In the peanut gallery of this particular article I've learned about several games worth exploring to play with my kids.
- paulcole 4y agoThat’s like saying the beehive I poke with a stick is engaging enough for me to participate with. Sentiment isn’t wrong but you’re not quite there.
- v-erne 4y agoIs this some personal vendetta against HN :) ? I strongly believe that this HN thingy is one of the best things that I came across in the internet. Maybe I had bad luck but after slashdot, reddit and dig have gone down the drains this is a real godsend.
- Group_B 4y agoTeach your kids Blackjack, not Bridge
- glitchc 4y agoBlackjack and Euchre are two of my favourites.
- ufo 4y agoIn first grade, we were taught how to count to 10 using a modified version of blackjack that added up to 10, instead of up to 21. Turns out that it is still fun enough for 6 year olds if you remove the gambling aspect.
- ghaff 4y agoWhen I was visiting Las Vegas way too frequently about 5 years or so ago, I decided to memorize at least a simple version of what you should do with various hands. I think I played a bit one trip--lost a small amount of money. But decided I didn't really like it. I find it can be fun as a social thing but playing "right" is pretty much about memorizing a table.
- anikan_vader 4y agoMany casinos will let you bring a standard strategy card with you, because it’s still a negative expected value game for the player.
- mgaunard 4y agoI'd rather teach them a game that's actually good instead, like Tarot or Belote (which are both similar to Bridge, and not associated with 70+ people)
- aloisdg 4y ago5-players Tarot is awesome.
- mgaunard 4y ago4 players is the official one and is considered more of a challenge.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI hear Euchre and Spades are also good.
- Avshalom 4y agoThere was thread about spades a while back https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28358391 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28358391
- cbfrench 4y agoEuchre is delightful. I now live in the Midwest, where seemingly everyone knows how to play, so it’s always easy to pull out a deck of cards when people come over. It moves fast and involves just enough strategy to maintain interest while also being social. Edit: Also, if you’re into spades, I’d also recommend Rook. It has many of the same mechanics, but the bidding is somewhat more nuanced. (Although I’d suggest getting a used Rook deck because the modern ones are very cheaply made.)
- pclmulqdq 4y agoOne time, when I interned at a trading firm, I visited the Chicago office, and I was pleasantly surprised that they had Euchre games every Friday. The rules are really easy to learn and there isn't as much strategic depth as bridge, but it's a great social bidding-and-trick-taking game. Since everyone knows how to play, it's a lot of fun.
- butwhywhyoh 4y agoTeach your kids not to write follow-up articles to things found on Hacker News to gain internet points
- 4c3shi 4y agoInteresting take, maybe I'll write about that.
- c0balt 4y agoPost referred to in the article (you might want to read it yourself before reading this post): Teach your kids poker, not chess https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31435034 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31435034
- Hayvok 4y agoThis reminded me of an article in WSJ a few years ago that “Bridge is the ultimate war game”. > Great bridge players are great liars—as are brilliant military leaders and diplomats and politicians. > No board game can replicate the conditions of the battlefield or the maneuvers of geostrategy, for one simple reason: All of the pieces are visible on the table. The linked article talks about these ideas in more depth and compares bridge to other games like poker, chess, and go. Makes me want to give it a go, for sure. https://www.wsj.com/articles/bridgenot-chessis-the-ultimate-war-game-1431899680 https://www.wsj.com/articles/bridgenot-chessis-the-ultimate-...
- bombcar 4y agoIt’s not true that all board war games are perfect knowledge - things like Napoleon at Marengo have army markers that face the player so the other player doesn’t know what the strength is (could even be a blank as a feint). Various other war games implement different forms of fog of war that can be quite strategic. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/15839/bonaparte-marengo https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/15839/bonaparte-marengo
- brobinson 4y ago> No board game can replicate the conditions of the battlefield or the maneuvers of geostrategy, for one simple reason: All of the pieces are visible on the table. Uh, Kriegsspiel chess? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kriegspiel_(chess) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kriegspiel_(chess) Maybe a combination of Chess960 + Kriegsspiel would be even better...
- cbfrench 4y agoI was a weird kid and taught myself the rules to a ton of card games as a kid, including bridge. (Except I was an only child who lived out in the country and never really had anyone to play with. Again, weird kid.) The problem is that knowing the rules of bridge don’t really translate into understanding the intricacies of the bidding strategy, and I’ve never found anyone else who wanted to learn it (my wife has, understandably, never been particularly receptive to picking it up). And it’s not like there are other millennial couples out there eager to learn bridge, lol. I’m trying to make the canasta renaissance happen. It works well as a two- or four-hand game, and it’s social while also demanding some skill in the play. Bezique is another favorite.
- bombcar 4y agoWe had a pretty effective group of bridge players at college — and the bidding is certainly a decent obstacle. However, if you’re just playing for fun and at least one person knows the basics of a decent bidding set (American Standard is usually fine) you can just ask openly - thinks like “do you have more than 13 points? A major suit with at least five points and five cards?” And if bridge is a bridge to far you can play whisk or bid whisk as an intro.
- bmacho 4y agoOr you can try minibridge, it at least has official rules.
- cbfrench 4y agoI might give it another shot. There’s a bridge club in the area that might be worth looking into. And whist is great. I inflicted that on my friends at Scout camp one summer, and they ended up actually enjoying it. I need to refresh myself on bid whist.
- Nick87633 4y agoMy wife and I have had some fun games of German whist
- shadowofneptune 4y ago
- Xeoncross 4y agoTeach your kids
- HideousKojima 4y agoIn my family we grew up playing a lot of cribbage. Makes it easy to spot number combinations that add up to 15, not sure what other practical skills it might give.
- klyrs 4y agoTeach your kids brainfuck, not BASIC
- jvvw 4y agoTwo player games do have an advantage as you only need two of you. Finding other children to play with is a huge advantage too and lots of schools have chess clubs, so I understand it's popularity. It's hard if you are much better at a game than your children. Magic The Gathering works well because they can genuinely beat us, but you need a keen player as a parent really. There is also the age issue. I think Go is a more interesting game than chess but the scoring is a little hard to teach and it hasn't captured my children's interest as much as chess. Backgammon is interesting - been wondering about teaching it to my children as a counterpoint to chess. Not sure if mine (9 and 11) are quite ready for all the bidding conventions in bridge but working up to it with whist. Poker is very educational I think - I learned lots from playing it - but not really sure whether it would work as a family game.
- cesaref 4y agoDefinitely give backgammon a try with them. It's very easy to pick up the basics, I reckon any 9 and 11 year old will pick it up in an hour, if you avoid the doubling die and just play games out. A few evenings of this and before you know it they'll be playing tavla with a lovely turkish tea on the side and will be learning some farsi for common rolls. What's not to like?
- User23 4y agoBackgammon is a game I wish I’d picked up young. Anything that lasts that long is worth a look. Edit: I meant lasts that long in the sense of being played for the past 5 millennia. I didn’t mean the duration of a game.
- ghaff 4y ago>Two player games do have an advantage as you only need two of you. While not to encourage being antisocial, chess also has very good computer programs to play against--and even provide instruction. I assume there are good consumer accessible Go programs these days too although I haven't looked for a while. It's nice to have as a backup and, in general, I find computer card games are less capable or have annoying blind spots that you can suss out after a while. For example, I've found that computer Hearts programs are pretty vulnerable to shooting the moon against them. Backgammon could be good--although I never really got into it. I suppose Checkers is another option but, of course, relatively simple. Although I'm even worse at Go than I am at Chess, I agree with you. Chess probably has at least an easier learning curve to get to some minimal level of competence.
- drewcoo 4y ago> it is very unusual to have imperfect information but no luck in a game Rock, paper, scissors. Stratego. Many, many others. But the author seems to miss that bridge is not one of those games. It has the dealing of cards. That's luck! Luck, randomness, is a type of imperfect information. What is that enemy Stratego piece, really? Is the cat in the box alive? Will the roulette wheel come up red? All imperfect information. There are just different mechanics a game designer can use to achieve imperfect information. So we may as well argue about whether dice games are better than card games or games with spinners. Moot. Here's an idea: teach your kids a favorite game. It's probably a favorite because it's challenging in some way. Great! Just make sure you all have fun.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoDuplicate bridge removes the luck: you play the hand you are given at a table, but you are scored against other pairs who have the same cards as you, not against the people you played with. It essentially removes the luck from the game. Rubber bridge and grandma's version of the game have a ton of luck, but duplicate has almost none. Stratego is also a great game, and I forgot about it! EDIT: If you want to play a 4-player "duplicate" bridge game, that is also possible by comparing to the par result, which is the best scoring contract that can be played for the hand.
- Someone 4y agoIt doesn’t remove all luck. You may be dealt cards that suit your bidding strategy better than that of your opponent or vice versa. Given the number of rounds played, that’s unlikely, though, unless one bidding strategy is truly better than the other.
- bombcar 4y agoEven rubber bridge is usually long enough to even out the luck - where the more skilled partnership will win the rubber most of the time. But the luck makes it fun even for the less skilled - as everyone can help them bid a slam if they get one. Four-player duplicate needs a fifth person to arrange the deck/hands.
- spekcular 4y agoI think the author makes some good points, and certainly I find this article more more compelling than the poker one. Trick-taking card games seem like a great choice for kids. However, when I looked into bridge specifically, the following things turned me off. 1) It requires a dedicated, long-term partner. If your partner isn't available, you can't play. "Pick up" bridge with strangers simply isn't feasible in the way that randomly matching teams on, e.g., an online FPS or tower defense games is. 2) The game is fundamentally broken by certain bidding strategies, which must be banned. 3) There's no way to prevent opponents from cheating by using out-of-game signals (e.g. timing of bids). This can even be done unintentionally. So fair play is always an open question. Perhaps someone who knows more can comment about whether I'm wrong?
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI am the author, and I have played bridge for a very long time: 1. Pick-up bridge is certainly possible, and you can walk into a club and find a partner. You have to be playing a "standard" bidding system with them, though. If you do this, expect to play a lot of Standard or 2/1 in America, ACOL in Britain, etc. 2. This is kind of true, except the strategies that are banned are mostly banned because people don't want to play against them. The ACBL is run by grandmas who want you to play bridge like a grandma, so they ban a lot of things. The world bridge federation is a lot more reasonable. The only truly game-breaking bidding systems were forcing-pass systems, and those are banned in order to preserve the diversity of the game (if not, everyone at a competitive level would have to use a forcing pass system). 3. I think this is correct, although cheaters do end up getting caught when their play deviates too much from "correct." Fantoni/Nunes ended up getting caught this way.
- bombcar 4y agoBridge anti-cheating is some of the most elaborate in the world: at the top level everything is sanitized to remove the possibility of information transfer. For local or friendly play it can be much more fun to openly discuss the hand as it’s being played, especially if one pair is much better at bridge than the other.
- 4y ago
- 4c3shi 4y agoA lot of these comments seem to miss the point: author isn't suggesting you teach your kids any game in particular, it's just a reply to an article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31435034 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31435034.
- grimgrin 4y agoI’m a big fan of climbing games as they require a consideration to the order you play your hand unlike most other games. Doesn’t hurt that your hands are large, a dozen or more cards I think of the best 2 player variant, Haggis. And Tichu (partnered). And Dou dizhu (2v1) Also referred to as shedding games
- jb3689 4y agoTichu is practically bridge plus poker. Win-win
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- beebeepka 4y agoI'd rather go with StarCraft or Quake. Never liked cards. Multiplayer games require all sorts of skills to be successful
- shadowofneptune 4y agoQuake has the same issue as Bridge where if you try to get into it now, all the other players have been playing for decades and will steamroll you.
- oblak 4y agoWell, that is certainly true. The current top player is like 40 and his aim surprisingly good. It's never happened with StarCraft, especially Brood War, though. Probably too taxing mechanically for anyone not spending 6 hours a day playing to compete at high level.
- shadowofneptune 4y agoStarcraft also took an absurdly long time to get a true sequel, while I'd imagine everyone but the die-hards moved on to Quake II and III.
- beebeepka 4y agoBrood War was still absolutely massive in Korea when SC2 was released. In fact, some of the most successful SC2 players went back to Brood War. It's crazy
- Overtonwindow 4y agoI suggest teaching your children whichever game will enable them to think for themselves.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- crux 4y agoTeach your kids Tarock, not Bridge. Ok, that phrasing is mostly just to keep the pattern going. But I do want to bring to light the fact that there are actually a larger class of games of the same sort as Bridge - imperfect information, high skill, with a body of strategy and discussion - than most Americans are aware of. I think it’s worth mentioning these for two reasons: 1. They’re really wonderful games! And they have deep cultural roots, which can be added delight for those of us who enjoy engaging with other cultures. 2. Bridge players can be kind of… dicks? That is, it’s unfortunate but true that the culture of Bridge can often be quite rigid and unfriendly. Especially to newcomers. As mentioned elsewhere, a surprising amount of Bridge has to do with the conventions encoded in the bidding, and if you don’t know those conventions you might feel rather lost, and your partner might get very annoyed at you. Luckily, there are other games in the world that are the ‘Bridge’ of their own countries of origin - deep, strategic, rewarding years of play and study - that the average English speaker has never heard of. I won’t go into too much detail but some highlights are: - Preferans, a straight-trick-taking game for three from Russia; - Skat, a point-trick-taking game from Germany; - Tarocchino, a point trick taking game played with a 62 card tarot deck from Bologna; - Koenigrufen, a point trick game played with a 54 card tarot deck from Austria; - Danish tarok, a point trick game played with a 78 card deck; - Vira, a straight trick taking game from Sweden; - a half dozen incredibly deep and challenging games from Hungary alone. Something in the water over there. In point of fact, Bridge is quite interesting, especially if you’re interested in the meta game of communicating through bidding conventions. I am not; there are other games out there that have really interesting features, lots of strategy, and a history dating back hundreds of years. Check them out! Because I’m an annoying evangelist for this sort of thing, I’ll make sure my email is in my profile in case you’d like to know more.
- 4ggr0 4y agoIn Switzerland a lot of people play Jass[0]. It's almost like a national sport. I can't play it, but it feels like I'm part of a minority. Jass games are even being broadcasted on national TV, it really is a huge part of our culture. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jass https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jass
- JoshTriplett 4y ago
- jdmoreira 4y agoWhen I read the poker article I too thought about bridge as a better alternative. I've never been deep into bridge even though I dabbled but I honestly believe that Magic The Gathering is the to the present what Bridge was to the past
- jdmoreira 4y agoalso the author main criticism about magic the gathering is around variance. Well… variance is good! It makes the game more interesting and welcoming to new players. Better players don't need to win 100%. Yes, even Finkel can lose a game of magic and that's good I think.
- pdm55 4y agoBridge can be played online. I practise my skills there against the robots. It takes constant practise to interpret the bidding and play, aiming to work out the cards that the other players hold. The most unusual aspect of bridge is that after the bidding finishes, one player (the dummy) puts their cards face up on the table. I don't know of any other card games where this happens. Chess works really well online. Your rating is quickly adjusted so that you are playing players of similar ability. Bridge has a longer learning curve. You need to go to lessons to learn a bidding system. Though, I do remember one night at a club where a young guy brought his classmate along to play. Their whole system was, "If I bid a suit, support my suit". Some (younger) bridge players stream their online games on Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/directory/game/Bridge/videos/all https://www.twitch.tv/directory/game/Bridge/videos/all
- sgjohnson 4y ago> People will play poker differently when they are playing for large amounts of money than when they are playing for small amounts of money: they are a lot more conservative when a lot of cash is on the line This is false. If your playing style changes with stakes, you shouldn’t be playing poker. And you want to play at a table where people do that, because it’s exploitable. The only bet sizing that matters in cash games is relative to the big blind. Your playstyle shouldn’t change if the big blind is $1 or $1000. Game theory doesn’t care about the absolute size of the bets, and you should always aim to play game theory optimal game. If game theory says the most optimal play is to make a 35 big blind bluff, you make the 35 big blind bluff whether it’s $35 or $35000 (unless you know something about the particular opponent). And if you can’t afford to lose the money when the stakes are higher, you shouldn’t be at that table.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nimih 4y ago> Your playstyle shouldn’t change if the big blind is $1 or $1000. Your playstyle might not change, but it certainly seems plausible that the average players' does. Anecdotally, even a $5 vs $20 buy-in seems to meaningfully change the character of house games I've hosted/attended (at least, when everyone attending is a broke college student).
- mechanical_bear 4y agoOk Phil Helmuth… “you’re playing the game wrong!”
- pclmulqdq 4y agoIt's well known that people shouldn't change playing style when playing at high stakes, but that they do (this is a classic Monty Hall style thing). The really interesting game theoretic thing is that it goes further than just being relative to big blinds (if you have an infinite bankroll): it's all relative to the size of the pot. When you should be making or calling a bet is determined only by the relative size of the bet and the pot, not the blinds. The blinds just provide a natural escalation of pot size from 0. Bankroll management comes into play with larger bets (at any stakes), and naturally affects pot odds decisions: if you have a $5,000 bankroll and you are facing a half-pot $1,000 bet, you should call that bet with a much tighter range than if you had a $20,000 bankroll. You can only afford to take so many coin flips. It is actually rational to be more conservative as bet sizes get closer to your bankroll size. This means that people should be playing stakes relative to the size of their bankroll, which they don't always do (the average $1/$2 player doesn't usually have 1/5th the bankroll of the average $5/$10 player in my experience, it's closer to 1/3rd). However, when the pot size is $0, people naturally treat the pot very differently than when it is even $1, since there are no bankroll considerations at all.
- cletus 4y agoIt's a shame that Bridge's popularity is waning because it is a very interesting and skilful game. It suffers from having a relatively high barrier to entry. A lot of comments here are from people who clearly have never played the game. In bidding there are 48 calls you can make (1-7 of each suit plus notrumps, X ie double, XX ie redouble and pass). The bids (1-7 of each suit and no trump) are ordered meaning once someone bids 2D you have to bid 2H or higher so you've lost the 1 bids and 2C). The two teams are interleaved and are trying to convey information to your partner but your opponents have access to that information too. It's kind of amazing how much information you can convey within this simple system. It's not even just about what bids were made but what bids weren't made. Bidding is a deep, deep topic. Additionally you can lie to your partner (within limits) and in competition play there are rules around what you can and can't do. This can confuse your opponents but will also confuse your partner (if it doesn't it's often ruled as "illegal information"). After all this and the opening lead the dummy hand is placed on the table. Every player can see it. The defending team has the auction to inform the defense. So it's not just a simple trick-taking game. The auction and the play are inextricably intertwined. The defenders can convey information to each other through which cards they play. The declarer can see this too but has less context on the meaning. In both the auction and the play Bayesian reasoning comes into play. What didn't happen? How does that affect the probability space? Building partnerships takes time although experienced players can sit down with a new player, agree on some fairly standard conventions (eg 2/1, upside down carding) and be at a reasonable point. But the high barrier to entry, fixed numbers of players and the reliance on partnerships make it a tough game to play casually.
- ghaff 4y ago>But the high barrier to entry, fixed numbers of players and the reliance on partnerships make it a tough game to play casually. At various times, I've played a lot of different games. And Bridge always seemed like one that was more of a commitment than I felt like making at a given moment.
- Buttons840 4y agoIt sounds like if two players on a team have a lot of experience playing together they probably develop an intuition of each other, and I would guess this is viewed as an important part of the most successful teams. It also sounds like if those two players attempted to codify a communication pattern, like "I will play cards this way, which means this" it would be ruled as illegal? It sounds like a game of cards, and game of communication, and a game about pushing the rules and the moderators, like me and my partner need to learn to communicate illegal information, but we cannot do so in a way that is detectable, and if we're people of integrity, we wont make communicating illegal information our explicit goal, but our practice together is always helping us be a little better at it, but we maintain deniability and integrity because we never explicitly planned it. Am I way off here? I'm guessing all these subtleties make online play difficult as well?
- jonnycomputer 4y agoTeach your Kids Many Different Games, Not Just One. Domain specific intelligence optimizes for particular games, but our kids will play lots of games all their lives, and they need to be able to play them reasonably well. And of course, I'm not really talking about games. I'm talking about situations with different rules. Sequential circuits are so much easier to imagine and discover when you start drawing them down as flows and transformations, inputs and outputs. If you thought that the only way to describe a circuit was as a simple Boolean expression, you'd have only been left with combinational circuits..
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sixo 4y agoGetting especially good at one thing is very good for a person.
- jonnycomputer 4y agoExpertise has its place, but it is not everything. Also expertise is not the only component to career success, and everything isn't about career success either.
- kelnos 4y agoIt can be, but there's also a good amount of risk and opportunity cost that comes with that. Maybe the thing you get especially good at turns out to be useless or low-paying (for a profession) or of limited fun, social potential, or replay value (for a game). I would much rather become a generalist and learn a bunch of things, and then do some limited, "shallow specialization" when the need and opportunity arises. But I think you're still more likely on average to be successful/happy with a more generalist/breadth approach.
- slothtrop 4y agoWell it's not zero sum. You can specialize in one thing but still dabble in others
- RheingoldRiver 4y ago(Former) kid who was actually taught bridge by my parents (at a very young age) here. I believe I found it very boring and never played and forgot the rules. The teaching of bridge to me was somewhat of a Christmas present to my grandfather, who deeply loved the game, and my parents enjoyed teaching me random skills (for example, I could name most state capitals before I knew what a state capital was). When my brother was old enough, my family played pinochle instead. Simpler ruleset, MUCH easier bidding, games could go much faster (since no help from parents was needed, for example). It was always "kids vs parents" so there would be no fights between us about who won more games. You need two standard decks of cards to make a pinochle deck but whatever, just buy two standard decks of cards and throw out 2-8. Pinochle is a great game for families of 4 with young kids who want to play cards together, I would definitely do that again.
- ALittleLight 4y agoI played Bridge almost entirely with my family members. Our level of expertise was "We read the instructions for Bridge off a pamphlet somewhere." We really enjoyed playing it. Once or twice we had the chance to play Bridge with someone who Played Bridge and it was much less fun. Suddenly, our bids meant stuff, communicated something, and/or were wrong somehow. I'm sure if I played a lot of Bridge it would be better to play it the mainstream way. But, if it is a game you only play a bit with family sometimes - I think it's more fun to just play how you feel it should be played.
- c22 4y agoTeach your kids to make up their own games.
- backtoyoujim 4y agoTeach your kids dressage not polo.
- llIIllIIllIIl 4y agoTeach your kids starcraft 2 wings of liberty specifically. What a bs.
- plank 4y agoAs someone who has played international checkers (the 10x10 board), chess, go and bridge (although only chess and bridge in a club) I can concur. Bridge has the analytical dimension (at least with duplicate bridge), and compared to e.g. Klaverjassen or Belotte, the rules are very simple. (There is some complexity in the bidding part of bridge, but bidding can be postponed in the initial stages when learning the game) Just as the rules for international checkers are easier then the rules of chess, it is much more difficult to play very well. (While in e.g. chess you have much usage of heuristics like a rook is better then a knight, these simple heuristics do not work as well in international checkers). As bridge also had the psychological dimension (trying to trick your opponent by faking a finesse), I agree it teaches life lessons that can help you further down the road. (Furthermore: while chess is often a game of two - the classical variant is two players playing one game in the evening on the chess club, hardly talking at all - bridge is a more social game. Personal bonus for me: chess means either success of failure, while with bridge you can play e.g. 28 games in one evening, and go away with those 3 beautiful hands you played while forgetting the 5 times you blundered). The only game I find more elegant is Go, but I find the time necessary to play a single game to long (and in the Western world there are not that many simple to find opponents).
- tasuki 4y ago> The only game I find more elegant is Go, but I find the time necessary to play a single game to long We have various board sizes! A 9x9 is quick, while still being interesting enough even to strong players. > (and in the Western world there are not that many simple to find opponents) Come on, you are on the internet ;) As for online play, OGS [0] is where the Westerners hang out, and GoQuest [1] is where the quick hassle-free 9x9 online play is: with 3 minutes per player, a game takes around 5 minutes. Also, at least in Europe, most major and not so major cities have some semblance of a go club or a semi-regular meetup. [0]: https://online-go.com/ https://online-go.com/ [1]: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=fm.wars.goquest https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=fm.wars.goques...
- pbmango 4y agoI think most of Bridge's barrier to entry is perception. Before I learned the basics and started playing with friends and family I had the understanding it was extremely complex, on the order of playing a new instrument. This turned out to not be the case and anyone with a basic grasp of cards, probability, and betting can figure it out. There is also the social perception that is a game older people play, specifically older women. Without fail when I suggest a game or someone to learn it they reference "Its what my grandma plays". This is driven more by just how popular cards used to be, bridge one of the most popular. Something on the order of 3 of 4 were in a regular card playing group mid century I remember reading. As that population retained the habit the average age of bridge player is now in their 70s whereas it used to be much lower.
- sdeep27 4y agoAuthor of original article (teach your kids poker, not chess) here - funny, it was seeing this rebuttal on the front page that made me realize there was a thread on mine! (linked in other comment here or in the article) One critique of this article is that bridge is most definitely a "luck" game as this article classifies it - any card game is nondeterministic, or stochastic. Also this author's use of symmetric and asymmetric is very different then my use. If you read my article to its conclusion, I believe both chess and poker (and bridge) offer tremendous value and encourage kids to play whatever - the main is that the nature of these lessons are tremendously different.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI wrote this rebuttal. Nice to meet you! Your definition of asymmetry focused on asymmetry of outcomes, which I believe is worth considering, but not the usual definition of "asymmetric" when talking about games. I also did attempt to define the luck/skill axis in a way that is non-intuitive, but I believe correct when talking about games in a technical sense: luck games have information hidden from all players, while skill games do not. In that sense, bridge is not a luck game. It is an unfair game because you can get screwed by how the cards are placed around the table, but the unfairness tends to even out as you play more hands.
- cortesoft 4y agoLuck tends to even out in all games that involve luck if you play long enough. Why is it different in bridge than in poker? Luck will even out in both.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoIt's not that different, if you can play enough rounds. Bridge and poker both give you that chance over a day. Magic the gathering, not so much. However, the luck element (by the human way of thinking about luck, not my definition) is much smaller for duplicate bridge than for poker. You can get legitimately screwed by finding the right contract and going down due to unusual opposing hands, but so will most of the rest of the field bidding your cards. _Only_ unskilled players will get a good result on that kind of hand, and they will give you back that advantage later. I guess you could say that the correlation between skill and score is negative on a few hands. A pro player on a cold streak will usually lose a few bucks in a cash game against new players, but a professional bridge player will beat the new players, guaranteed, even with the new players making "happy accidents."
- mpettitt 4y agoI have a 5yo and play a wide range of games with her. She has various "learning games" from Orchard Toys. She has some junior versions of various mainstream games (e.g. Scrabble, Dobble) and junior versions of more gamer type games (e.g. Ticket to Ride: First Journey, Catan Junior, Concept Kids). She's got some (ok, a lot) of Pokémon cards, including the Battle Academy sets which give 3 roughly balanced decks for about £20, which give a decent introduction to the game. She can also play various other gamer type games - Zooloreto, full size Ticket to Ride, Thunderbirds co-op game, Kingdomino, etc. Also have a 3yo who is awesome at Dragonimo and likes joining in with things like Uno. I'm pretty sure the key thing is to teach kids that games are supposed to be fun and that there are a lot of options. There are games on my shelves which I don't plan to introduce them to for a while yet, but mostly because they are a bit too dry (hard to get kids interested in some themes) or require a bit too much in the way of reading without your opponent helping, but I'm sure they'll get introduced eventually!
- contingencies 4y agoCheck out Sleeping Queens, which looks like it's all chance but is really excellent for sneaking in some simple integer maths practice. Virus! is also a great card game for younger kids. When you get there, outsourcing (adult) scrabble scoring to your kid is also a sneaky way to get some extra maths in.
- alfor 4y agoI just started with my kids on the recommendation in a book. In it they describe bridge as a game where people learn to put their attention toward other people instead of being toward self. He claimed that most of our psychological problems are caused by a self centered attitude as we are made to live and interact in a group setting not alone. We turned off Netflix and gaming and started to play bridge and play tunes together. So far, good changes.
- ddingus 4y agoNo way. Teach them both! No limit hold 'em skills are high value in my view. Having learned the game from my wife, who we found out has real talent, has had a positive impact on how I view and price risks and value. Currently, I have idea how to play bridge. I can learn with the young ones.
- jessenichols 4y agoTeach your kids whatever they're interested in, not X utility
- renewiltord 4y agoKids who learn polo probably have better outcomes than these. Also recommend golf at the country club. Bet these show better outcomes than all these nerd games.
- gweinberg 4y agoImperfect information games always have an element of chance, or "luck" if you prefer, because there is no important difference between rolling a die and guessing. It's not rare at all to have two ways of playing a hand which, based on the information available, are equally likely to make your bid but one works and the other doesn't.
- jedberg 4y ago> Unless you want to introduce gambling to your children, this fact alone disqualifies poker. Why wouldn't I? Gambling teaches math, probability, detecting deception, the sunk cost fallacy, sticking to a budget, dealing with disappointment, and if you win, generosity of sharing your win. Maybe I'm biased because growing up Jewish we learn gambling at a very young age (playing dreidel) but we're also using blackjack and poker with our kids to teach them all the things I said above.
- golemiprague 4y ago
- winnipeg 4y agoWe (the kids in our neighborhood) learned gambling at a young age. For some, this was associated with compulsive behaviors, criminal misconduct via mafia-associated illicit gambling rackets, and further organized criminal activities. Gambling is a vice. Where there is a vice, other vices exist. I agree with your comment primarily but suspect that the influence on life outcome of learning gambling at a young age is environmentally and culturally dependent.
- Rufhfhs3747rhe7 4y agoImpulsive gambling is a vice. Games with sufficient game theoretic aspects can also be excellent intellectual playgrounds for strategic planning in uncertain situations.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThere is a big benefit to learning about how to gamble well as a kid, but that is offset (in my opinion) by learning that it is good to gamble. It needs to be drilled into a good gambler's head that they should take good bets as long as their bankroll supports it but avoid bad bets. Most people who learn to play poker don't learn that. Incidentally, I believe that it is also good to teach teens about fine wines and spirits (to expand their palates) and how to drink in moderation and avoid hangovers (to help them in social situations). Many people who start drinking early also don't learn those lessons. Kids also pick up a lot from context, so if you teach your child to gamble using a dreidel on a holiday, it is a very different thing than teaching them to gamble with online poker (for example). It's very easy to learn the wrong lessons from games like poker and blackjack.
- mcdonje 4y agoI prefer go to chess.Each piece is the same. There is no hierarchy. The goal isn't to topple a king. The goal is to get more territory. It's easier to teach a child the rules, but it is more difficult to master because there are more possibilities of how the game can play out. Concepts involve influence, pacing, feinting, planning, etc.
- hitpointdrew 4y agoNo love for Whist?
- cbfrench 4y agoParty like it’s 1899. (Whist is great btw.)
- jb3689 4y agoTeach your kid a bunch of games and let them pick for themselves
- weatherlight 4y agoGo, teach your kids Go.
- otikik 4y agoMy kid learned Super Mario Maker 2 on his own and he doesn’t know how to read yet. He’ll be fine. You can stop telling me what to teach him now.
- zem 4y agoLouis Sachar's "The Card Turner" is a lovely novel about tournament bridge. Highly recommended.
- lupire 4y agoOP, please get a spellchecker.
- rapjr9 4y agoI think that games are a waste of time. All of them. They take time away from doing useful things, like creating art, loving, preparing, doing. I can see them as a form of meditation, a way of escape, a teaching, a change of perspective, if designed well, but ultimately, as they exist today, they are not getting anything done. The best games are thinking, trying, and doing. Those will challenge and teach you more than any game will.
- longtimegoogler 4y agoOne downside to Bridge is that it is a much less visual game than Go and Chess. Personally, that is what drew me to the other two games.
- jetsaint 4y agoteach your kids how to love themselves. it will be enough to have an awesome life. everything else will come if needed.
- ilikehurdles 4y agoWonderful advice.
- awsrocks 4y ago
- xiaodai 4y agowhat's next? Teach your kids LoL, not bridge
- kqr 4y agoHow do I learn bridge, if I have little time and nobody nearby to play with? I've long wanted to learn but could never figure out how to start.
- phasersout 4y agoRummy is a Bridge alternative without the need for teams.
- onion2k 4y agoI interviewed with an online Bridge startup last year. The pandemic stopped people meeting up to play, and playing online exploded. There are lots of sites where you can learn and practice now.
- kqr 4y agoCan you link to one or two good ones? I have no framework in which to evaluate the ones I find.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoTeach your kids Spades or Hearts, not Bridge. Because you want your kids to actually be able to interact socially with other people in their age group, and that's not happening if they know how to play Bridge but not the other games. I have never met another living person who has played bridge and let me know about it. Pedro? Yes. Hearts? Yes. Spades? Yes. Bourre? Yes. Poker? Of course. Hell, I'd teach them the rules of Blackjack first, because it's useful in busting myths regarding assumptions of probability.
- Weryj 4y agoWaiting for the next post, "Teach your kids chess, not bridge" To come full circle.
- nindalf 4y agoAnything that applies to these games, there are video games that do it better. Imperfect information games - StarCraft is a great example. Working well with team mates, sometimes really toxic ones, to achieve victory - Dota and LoL are good examples. Long collaboration - Minecraft, Factorio. Yeah we had to play chess for centuries when that’s all was available. We have better options now.
- moozilla 4y agoFor those interested in learning I found this to be a great introduction: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9GQGfdlNYyM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9GQGfdlNYyM
- amai 4y agoTeach your kids Hanabi, not bridge: https://www.deepmind.com/publications/the-hanabi-challenge-a-new-frontier-for-ai-research https://www.deepmind.com/publications/the-hanabi-challenge-a...
- FunnyBadger 4y ago