3 ms·
> The biggest economic misunderstanding of my childhood was that people got rich from high salaries. Though there are some exceptions—entertainers for example —
by amelius 5y ago
> The biggest economic misunderstanding of my childhood was that people got rich from high salaries. Though there are some exceptions—entertainers for example —almost no one in the history of the Forbes list has gotten there with a salary.
The problem with owning things is that it is usually zero-sum. A thing can only owned by one person. This means that owning things reduces the opportunities of other people.
And here is also the biggest problem with the entire article: if everybody applied this advice, would everybody be successful? Probably not.
Perhaps I'm overly cynical, but I think a better title would be: "how to rig the system to your advantage".
- pmichaud 5y agoIt’s only zero sum if there is only a preset amount of things to own, but in fact you can own something that never existed before you owned it.
- karpierz 5y agoThe wealth of the world per capita grows at an exponential, but fixed rate (~3%, plus or minus). I don't think there's a way to get around that, so that 3% is zero-sum. You can argue that the rate that our productivity can grow yearly is unbounded, but I have yet to see evidence.
- samatman 5y agoYou can only describe a growing system as zero-sum by abusing the definition of the term.
- karpierz 5y agoWhy? Zero-sum just refers to the allocation of a bounded quantity; growth is a quantity. If the derivative of a value is bounded, then the delta of that value over time is bounded. If one new oil well is discovered every year, then you can say that who own that growth is zero-sum. You can also say that the amount anyone can increase their wealth via oil wells by is zero-sum. Sum over the growth of capital over the year, and you find that the allocation of the ownership of growth is also zero-sum. And so are the proceeds of that yearly growth. If your claim that the growth of the world's productivity on a yearly basis is unbounded, then sure, zero-sum isn't an applicable term. If your claim is that you can generate growth without hampering the growth of others; that's true to a point. Someone needs to sweep the floors and take out the trash. You can make robots do it, but those robots need to be made and maintained by someone. Someone needs to make food as you do it. Someone is on "robot design duty" and someone is on "farming duty". The person on "farming duty" can't stop without someone coming in to replace them. But I haven't been able to see any evidence of that claim being true.
- belter 5y agoIt's a zero sum because the persons and financial resources buying what you have to sell is a finite number. If they buy from me they probably wont buy from you. This is independent of the relative merits of the products we are both selling. Maybe I forced my products to be shown in the major television channels, because I also own the television channels and you dont.
- solveit 5y agoNew persons are born every day and financial resources are a bookkeeping tool. If I make something new and you make something new then we can trade our products and we both gained without anyone losing out. It is not true to say the world is zero-sum.
- belter 5y agoThe Federal Reserve who controls the M1 supply would like a word with you.:-) There is a limited amount of goods and services you can sell to the inhabitants of a planet with a population of 7.7 Billion. What if the planet would have only a population of 7? Each person owning one of the 7 continents? Let's say the persons owning Africa and the person owning North America, due to some meteorological disaster, and unfortunate investments, had to sell their respective continents to the hotshot owning Europe? If the money supply is infinite, then has no value. Now from the finite money supply in the world who is going to gain the most?
- thethimble 5y agoYou’re being downvoted because you're conflating two concepts that are related but not the same: the money supply and economic output (GDP). Economic output is non-zero sum. Consumption/production scales up and down elastically. The money supply is adjusted independently in order to drive “ideal” output growth while maintaining “ideal” inflation levels.
- belter 5y agoThanks for replying. I appreciate it. But you fail to note the creation of a market happens by destroying another. Amazon vs Book Shops, Uber vs Taxis, Cars vs Faster Horses, Netflix vs Theater Industry and DVD Rentals.[2] There is a limit of resources and economic output per year, the ones owning the more productive processes will get a progressive bigger share of the output. More and more, lots of activities are zero-sum and the long term is a complete zero-sum. [3] It's not a view from mainstream economists, because many do not want to be seen as heirs to Karl Marx ( an Economist let's not forget, not a politician). It's also a discourse popular from a certain political current, that spouses the "we can all benefit mantra". I prefer to use Constrain Theory [1], and be reminded that if somebody creates a more efficient Amazon, faster, cheaper, better then Amazon will not prosper. If somebody opens a new service, or creates a new product, there will less disposable income from the customers of this product to shop at Amazon. Reminds me of a story, normally told with several variations so my details are not exact. When Henry Ford II toured some factory, he taunted some workers with the fact increased Robotic Automation would make Ford less dependent on the workers. The workers replied asking Ford how many cars he was expecting the Robots would buy? [1] "Exponential Economist Meets Finite Physicist": https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist/ https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist... [2] "Capitalism: A zero-sum game": https://www.business-standard.com/article/markets/capitalism-a-zero-sum-game-110050700073_1.html https://www.business-standard.com/article/markets/capitalism... [3] "The Zero-Sum Economy": https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/zero-sum-economy-fuels-high-inequality-by-adair-turner-2018-08?barrier=accesspaylog https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/zero-sum-econom...
- DantesKite 5y agoIf that was true, GDP would never increase and we’d all still be eating raw fish in caves, the average total of everybody’s net worth being a few dates and some shiny sticks. > if everybody applied this advice, would everybody be successful? He literally says it would not work for everyone as it requires a baseline level of success already achieved.
- dahart 5y ago> The problem with owning things is that it is usually zero-sum. Can you give some examples? Certainly this is party true with real-estate in some large cities, but there are lots of places where land is available and real-estate isn’t yet zero-sum. I’m having a hard time seeing other examples, so I’m wondering why you said “usually”. I would assume that Sam is also referring to software, where ownership means owning all parts of production, or means owning the rights to IP & creative work. In the software startup and in the creative art sense, I don’t think ownership is zero-sum at all. Ownership there is more about having control over the income and expenses of all parts of your business, and avoid rental traps. In general, this does seem like good sound advice to me. > Perhaps I’m overly cynical but I think a better title would be: “how to rig the system to your advantage”. That does seem a bit cynical when the majority of points were things like ‘work really hard’ and ‘believe in yourself’ and ‘think independently’. It’s hard to even find something I would consider ‘rigging the system’ - like owning things and having a network are the only two, but those are pretty generic and more centered on what I should do more than affecting the system. Not that there’s anything wrong with being cynical. ;) We can’t all be billionaires, and using the Forbes list as the example of success is questionable and gives real reason to be cynical. I’m wondering what your list of how to be successful looks like, and what makes it different?
- samatman 5y ago> owning things is that it is usually zero-sum The only thing I can think of to which this applies is collectables. Land? No. There is an aspect of land ownership which is zero sum, but if all you want is land, it's always for sale, and the value of a given plot can be improved with labor and investment. The land the Empire State Building sits on would be very valuable just sitting on Manhattan Island, but is even more valuable with an iconic skyscraper on it. Businesses? Absolutely not, they can be created for modest amounts of money at any time. "Real capital" like equipment? Clearly not, every purchase is presumably profitable to the seller, meaning they get enough money to make another one for the next customer in line.
- WalterBright 5y ago> would everybody be successful? Probably not. Yes, everyone can be successful. It is not zero-sum. Someone else's success is not at your expense. Though there are some endeavors that are deliberately set up to be zero-sum. Like the Olympics. Only the fastest wins a gold. But note that this is a completely artificial constraint. Real life in a free market society is not like that at all.