5 ms·
It's so silly that modern phones (from all manufacturers, really) need these giant kits (or hacks like microwaving a jelly sock) just to replace the single part
by jeroenhd 5y ago
It's so silly that modern phones (from all manufacturers, really) need these giant kits (or hacks like microwaving a jelly sock) just to replace the single part that wears down.
I still have my first Android phone. It contains a battery you can pop out after removing the back cover. Replaceable batteries used to be the norm!
Now we need suction cups, hot air stations and professional guides to replace the part, because somehow those billion dollar geniuses chose to make their devices unrepairable.
This programme is mostly greenwashing but it's a step forward some other manufacturers still haven't taken. If Apple actually cared about repairing phones, they'd design better phones.
- IgorPartola 5y agoOn the other hand phones are now thing and waterproof. Not saying that replaceable batteries are bad but it’s not like this was an entirely arbitrary decision.
- londons_explore 5y agoThere are also a lot of laws and regulations about shipping and selling batteries that don't apply to devices with non-removable batteries.
- IgorPartola 5y agoNot to mention aftermarket batteries. Imagine someone putting a $5 battery off Wish into their $1000 iPhone and starting a fire.
- jeroenhd 5y agoThe Galaxy XCover 5 is waterproof (IP68) and has a replaceable battery. It's built for extreme conditions so it looks a little funky, but it's clearly possible to have both. Sure, gluing the battery into a closed container is a lot easier than developing novel waterproofing methods, but it's not impossible to do so.
- Gigachad 5y agoAlmost all consumers would prefer to take their phone in for a battery replacement than have it look weird. Considering a replacement is something you do maybe once while the form factor is something you will always be affected by.
- thescriptkiddie 5y agoI used to carry a spare battery with me and swap them in 10 seconds when the one in the phone died. Now I have to carry a much bulkier battery powered charger and USB cable that takes an hour to recharge the phone.
- Gigachad 5y agoThat stopped being an issue for most people a while ago. The latest gen phones last all day under reasonably heavy usage and charge within a few minutes on a wall charger.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoPower banks are pretty small these days. If you have magnetic inductive charging capabilities on your phone, you can even just snap them on and keep going. Otherwise, get a power bank that has a small cable built in.
- ghaff 5y agoI found the lack of swappable batteries somewhat irritating at first. But these days, for the relatively few times when I run low on juice I'd rather just use an external battery pack than carry a bulkier phone around all the time. And as you say, with inductive charging, there are pretty unobtrusive options.
- thescriptkiddie 4y agoMagnetic inductive charging has an efficiency of <50%, so now the battery has to be twice as big and your phone gets really hot in your pocket.
- razodactyl 5y agoIf a group of government scientists can deploy devices into the field with waterproof enclosures and replaceable battery banks - it makes me wonder if Apple could do it :P
- IgorPartola 5y agoGaskets are not 0 size. You can absolutely make a waterproof case. It’ll just be thicker.
- jackpeterfletch 5y agoI guess the question is should they be _made_ to do it. If someone comes along and creates a device that has those features, like we've seen with the Framework laptop, that's great. For the people that want that kind of device with that specific set of benefits and trade-offs that's awesome. Personally not my device though. my usage patterns means it makes more sense for me to take the more integrated solution, and just forego any upgrades all modularity for the life of the product.
- vvillena 5y agoThe first Motorola Defy was a comparable device to its competitors when it was released, and its big feature, being water-resistant, didn't make any compromises apart from rubber caps on the ports (not necessary in modern phones) and a better back cover with a manual latch. Sealing phones isn't needed at all. It's a decision driven by the market makers.
- lupire 5y agoThe Defy weight over 8oz, a huge compromise. It's too heavy for the average personn to handle comfortably.
- MerelyMortal 5y ago8 oz is 227 grams The iPhone 13 Pro Max is 8.46 ounces (240 grams) The iPhone 13 Pro is 7.19 ounces (204 grams) The Defy is only 11% heavier than the iPhone 13 Pro, and lighter than the iPhone 13 Pro Max. Doesn't seem like much of a compromise to me.
- vvillena 5y agoI'm talking about the first Defy, back in 2010. It weighted 118 gr (just over 4 oz), more or less the same as its competitors.
- ghaff 5y ago>extremely specialised tools which ensure every repair is perfect with little room for any human error. I'm not sure I see the problem. Apple is saying that this is the "right" way to do the repair. Alternatively, you can have them do it. You can also, although Apple won't endorse it, take it to a third-party, order a kit from iFixit, or otherwise do it yourself. Ford will also not endorse doing repairs yourself, using an independent mechanic, using parts from a junkyard, etc. but they don't generally prevent you from doing so.
- bogwog 5y agoThe issue with right to repair isn’t that phones are too hard to repair due to being thin/waterproof/etc. It’s that Apple’s business decisions and contracts with suppliers are designed to monopolize the repair process, so that third party repair shops can’t fix peoples’ phones without resorting to extreme measures (like buying blackmarket parts that were likely stolen from Apple factories by rogue employees). This repair program is trying really hard to frame it as: “look how risky and complicated it is to fix your own phone! Nobody actually wants to do this!”. Drawing attention away from the obvious alternative where people send their phone to an independent repair shop rather than do the repair themselves (and benefit from competitive pricing rather than Apple exorbitant ones) As an example, you can’t buy a replacement screen from this program unless you provide a valid IMEI. This means that a repair shop can’t possibly offer same day repairs since they can’t keep any screen in stock.
- londons_explore 5y agoYou could totally laser cut a hole in the back of an iphone to replace the battery. You might need to remake a few ribbon cables, but then you'd have yourself a removable battery. You could start a business that can cut the required hole, and then sell batteries that fit the hole with the case pre-glued on. (you'd replace a square of the back of the iPhone whenever you replaced the battery)
- ezconnect 5y agoThe battery has DRM now as stated on the article.
- chinathrow 5y agoThis shit has to stop.
- Gigachad 5y agoIt isn’t drm, a warning shows up on boot if the battery replacement was done unofficially. It has no functional impact on the device. The reasons behind it are pretty strong. A lot of repair stores use second hand, or fraudulent parts which damage the user experience. So for an owner getting a repair, if they don’t see warnings, they know the repair was done right. And as a buyer, you can tell the phone is using all official parts. It’s also likely used to ruin the resale value of stolen parts from the factories.
- skyeto 5y agoYou could surely still have this for non-genuine / used batteries, but here we have a genuine battery coming straight from Apple throwing that warning. Just let 3rd party repair shops buy them at a reasonable price and don't throw the warning if it's unused. Edit: and preferably let them buy the batteries in bulk, without having to have the phone on hand which just causes unnecessary delays.
- 5y ago
- devoutsalsa 5y agoYou're not wrong. I used to have a phone with a replaceable battery. I replaced the battery after a year. The next year I wanted a better phone anyway. I realized that the battery in my iPhone is replaceable. I just need to pay Apple to do it. It's still way cheaper than buying a new phone, and I benefit from the advantages of having a sealed phone. Within two weeks of buying my iPhone 12, I dropped it in a lake :)
- Gigachad 5y agoYou don’t need all this. A hair dryer and guitar pick and suction cup is all you need. Ifixit sells a very cheap kit that has everything you need. It’s quite easy and reasonable to do. Problem is apple insists that phones can only be touched with extremely specialised tools which ensure every repair is perfect with little room for any human error. And instead of loosening their requirements for self repair, they have taken the absurd approach here.
- 8organicbits 5y agoFor what it's worth, I've done maybe five Android screen repairs using the iFixit tools. One repair I messed up and the new screen broke almost immediately. The others looked good. Price wise, I wasn't able to find cheap replacement displays although my net cost is maybe still 70% the cost of going to an unofficial repair place. I'm not sure it was worth my time, or stress when moving tiny ribbon cables with tweezers. Going forward I think I'll just buy phones that have screens that don't die when dropped. I'm OK with a cracked screen, but the display needs to work.
- lupire 5y agoIs Apple going to sue you if you use a hair dryer, or merely decline to fix it for you for free when the battery expired after your 3yrar warranty anyway?
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> It's so silly that modern phones (from all manufacturers, really) need these giant kits People have been replacing iPhone batteries long before this kit was available as an option. 99% or more of iPhone owners have no desire to replace their own batteries. Suggesting that Apple compromise the design of the iPhone just to cater to the rare customer who wants to swap batteries isn’t a realistic suggestion and I’m kind of baffled that so many HN commenters can’t understand that much.
- srvmshr 5y ago> I still have my first Android phone. It contains a battery you can pop out after removing the back cover. Replaceable batteries used to be the norm! > If Apple actually cared about repairing phones, they'd design better phones. They do make excellent phones. No doubt about it. I think the end claim is tad contrived: If you (and millions similar) are willing to let go of IP68 dust & waterproofing, willing to work with cheaper melamine casing, and plastic screens, I am sure Apple will have no argument to back up its high ground of why they need specialist repair tools & services. What you desire is a state of the art smartphone, with gloss, finish & every working bell & whistle. What you demand for is a Nokia 3200 (which incidentally wasn't too behind in evolution). This protocol exists because the devices are sophisticated. And they ship this hulk with the assumption you are at Level 0. I can only imagine good faith on Apple if they empowered local technicians to handle such repairs instead of this elaborate stunt to prove their point on self-servicing. Repairability is much different topic from build sophistication. Lets not mix up these two. Apple's approach to prove its point is labored. What we probably eventually want is iOS devices to be easily serviceable by ourselves (if well equipped) or via locally available technicians, instead of entering their marbled ecosystem. Eventually we will reach some middle ground. But it is crucial to understand that self-repair isn't everyone's cup of tea and a corporation cannot keep a supply chain for the 1-5% customers who dabble with this hobby