4 ms·
You've got to wonder why it never went anywhere. Economics is probably the answer, but it doesn't seem satisfying. If it can extract useful work from merely wa
by jiggawatts 4y ago
You've got to wonder why it never went anywhere. Economics is probably the answer, but it doesn't seem satisfying.
If it can extract useful work from merely warm water, it would seem like the ideal thing to maximise the overall thermal efficiency of a large power plant.
- tedunangst 4y agoWhy bother with a big mechanical contraption like this when you can simply stick the leads of a thermocouple in two cups of water?
- VBprogrammer 4y agoDoing so efficiently is the challenge. Thermoelectric generators have very low efficiency of 5-8%. They don't extract a meaningful amount of extra energy.
- beambot 4y agoSeebeck generation is indeed inefficient.... But for low temperature deltas, Carnot efficiency already implies pretty low theoretical efficiency limits.
- mannykannot 4y agoTrue, but this means that the ROI for any method of recovering energy from any process' waste heat plunges as the temperature differential drops.
- VBprogrammer 4y agoYeah, it annoys me that so little infrastructure is built with no attempt to make use of the low grade waste heat. Imagine if thermal power plants were built alongside vegetable growing greenhouses etc.
- extrapickles 4y agoIf the thermal plant uses clean fuel (eg: gas fired) the CO2 in the exhaust would be useful for the greenhouse as well.
- bjelkeman-again 4y agoMany Dutch greenhouses have a CHP power plant, where the heat goes to the greenhouse, the CO2 to the plants and the power to the lamps or to the electricity network. They are swapping the heating to ground heat pumps and the electricity to renewables, so not sure where the CO2 comes from in the future other than of course a higher ambient level.
- genewitch 4y agotake the part of the plants that isn't used for anything else and ferment it with yeast. Free CO2. I'm not sure how old this trick is, as i used it a decade and a half ago with 2-3 liter bottles with holes drilled in the caps and a bubbler to remove solids to provide CO2 for a heavily planted aquarium bootstrap. My theory here is that running all the stems, stalks, and roots that you don't use from stuff like annual food crops through a wood chipper or something should macerate the cell walls enough to allow the yeast to feast, at least.
- DeathArrow 4y agoI think that a Sterling engine would be more efficient.
- pas 4y ago> You've got to wonder why it never went anywhere material fatigue. basically the nitinol springs/belts/strips eventually breaks. so it's a high maintenance low-efficiency (hard to scale) system compared to regular steam turbines. ... though of course the latter is in development for ~250 years, so it has a bit of a head start.
- api 4y agoWonder if you could get anywhere revisiting this with modern materials science? Materials have come a really long way in the past 60+ years.
- pas 4y agothe wikipedia page for nitinol is fascinating! so it seems like very much part of modern materials science. (and I'd guess bimetals are standard in many heat-related engineering applications, nitinol is just special because of how fast it changes shape, and because it's an alloy not 2 pieces of metal stuck together.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nickel_titanium#Biocompatible_and_biomedical_applications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nickel_titanium#Biocompatible_...
- fennecfoxen 4y agoIt’s not the 250 year head start that gets you. It’s the temperature differential.
- jkqwzsoo 4y agoI think the ultimate answer (for all kinds of waste heat recovery, or "heat economizer" technology) is that waste heat streams simply don't contain enough energy to invest in recovering (otherwise, we'd probably deploy ORCs everywhere). This device seems more useful for generating mechanical motion at the point of use, rather than generating electrical power. I'm envisioning solar and hydro-powered pumping systems that operate in remote environments, like the third engineer interviewed in the video. He proposed that the engine could be used to pump water solely due to the temperature difference between the pumped fluid and the air. Another interesting thing would be to run the system in reverse to turn mechanical energy into a hot and cold fluid. I haven't thought it through deeply, but it seems superficially similar to elastic band refrigerators[0,1]. [0] https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.aax6182 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.aax6182 [1] https://www.science.org/content/article/fridge-made-rubber-band-twisted-elastic-fibers-could-cool-your-food https://www.science.org/content/article/fridge-made-rubber-b...
- credit_guy 4y agoNothing can beat the efficiency of the Carnot engine. That's one of the equivalent ways of stating the Second Law of Thermodynamics [1]. Just like you can't create a perpetual motion machine, you can't extract more energy from warm water than a Carnot engine. And the efficiency of the Carnot engine is 1-T_cold/T_hot, both temperatures expresssed in Kelvin. Room temperature water is 300K (that's by convention, this translates in 27 C or 80 F). Let's say warm water is at 333K (that's more like scalding hot, at 60 C or 140 F). The Carnot engine efficiency is then going to be 1 - 300/333 = 10%. So, not engine can exceed 10% efficiency when using scalding hot water, for merely warm water it's probably going to be 5% or less. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_law_of_thermodynamics#Carnot's_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_law_of_thermodynamics#C...