3 ms·
Not enough, actually. The American Civil War was the first big war where railroads and telegraph lines allowed coordinated operations over a large area, and mac
by Animats 5y ago
Not enough, actually. The American Civil War was the first big war where railroads and telegraph lines allowed coordinated operations over a large area, and machine guns and repeating rifles allowed killing large numbers of advancing troops. Grant got this; he wrote "War is Progressive", meaning that there was progress through technology. This was a radical idea in military thinking at the time. Most European military leaders didn't get that until WWI. They were still trying mass charges. Which, against machine guns, absolutely does not work.
- bee_rider 5y agoIt also featured a little bit of trench warfare. I imagine the European observers who saw that were like "Huh, definitely not important, let's not come up with strategies to counter this sort of thing" and then forgot about it for the next 50 years or so.
- isk517 5y agoI mean, it had been 50 years, it wasn't like there had been another war fought 10 years prior that also devolved into trench warfare that they completely failed to learn anything from.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bilbo0s 5y agoIn fairness, I think people thought the Eastern and Southern armies fought in a "civilized" manner. It's just that the Western armies and Western generals came in, and they fought in a significantly different fashion. You can call the West of the Union more "modern". Or "pragmatic". Or maybe "barbaric" is the right word. No one wanted to be seen as being "Barbaric". Except Western armies, who really didn't care what people thought about them. (At least, not as much as they cared about their orders.)
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoI just can't see how that can be true - 'we're going to murder you all, but we're going to do it with good manners because otherwise people will think we're bad'?? It seems way more likely to be 'cargo cult' type learning where something worked for centuries and so got formalised and taught rigidly? Any good sources on this, it must have been covered on AskHistorians!?
- inglor_cz 5y agoThe missing ingredient that prevented the ACW from turning into static trench warfare similar to the later Western Front was probably barbed wire, which was only patented in 1867.
- refurb 5y agoPresumably also the rate of fire of WW1 weapons. While the ACW had Gatling guns and canons, the rate of fire during WW1 far exceeded anything seen before. The only protection was a trench
- jcranmer 5y ago> The American Civil War was the first big war where railroads and telegraph lines allowed coordinated operations over a large area, and machine guns and repeating rifles allowed killing large numbers of advancing troops. Hi, the Crimean War would like to remind you that it existed.
- missedthecue 5y agoIn which American Civil War battles did machine guns play a meaningful role?