10 ms·
Lavender's Game: Silexan for Anxiety
- amelius 5y agoI tried the exact same product as mentioned in the article, and used it for several months. But for me it only worked as a way to reduce depression. For anxiety it did little to nothing. Your mileage may vary, of course.
- tmountain 5y agoIsn’t reducing depression a pretty impactful outcome? Given the prevalence, it seems like that’s a big deal.
- amelius 5y agoYes, but for me certain foods already helped to reduce depression. The effect could be highly specific to me.
- mise_en_place 5y agoThat is interesting. Out of curiosity did those foods have a lot of PUFAs? More MUFAs? Saturated fats?
- amelius 5y agoSardines, vitamin c, walnuts, green olives. And oddly, drinks containing aspartame.
- marcinreal 5y agoI've been learning about adrenal health the past few days, and those happen to be foods that are great for overworked adrenals (which can cause anxiety and depression). Something to look into. Lavender is also a classic remedy for the adrenals.
- mise_en_place 5y agoI’m on a cut cycle and I just love kalamata, green, and black olives. I’ll have to try sardines, they seem like an excellent protein source.
- UncleOxidant 5y agoA naturopath prescribed lavender oil for my anxiety early on in the pandemic. I think it might have helped a little, but it wasn't a game changer. But she only had me taking 1 80mg pill per day. I'm going to get some of the recommended brand and try 160mg/day as suggested in the article.
- tga 5y agoEdit: not directly relevant to Silexan, but I'm not surprised that the lavender oil didn't work, especially if it came from a naturopath. The Massachusetts Medical Society states, "Naturopathic practices are unchanged by research and remain a large assortment of erroneous and potentially dangerous claims mixed with a sprinkling of non-controversial dietary and lifestyle advice." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturopathy#Evidence_basis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturopathy#Evidence_basis
- hash872 5y agoSeems like a non-sequitur in response to his specific statement- OP isn't endorsing naturopathy (nor am I), the discussion is about the specific efficacy of silexan. The linked article is a meta-analysis of silexan by a board-certified psychiatrist. No one here is pro-naturopathy. If silexan isn't effective, surely you can prove that empirically and without resort to an argument from authority. If a naturopath says drinking water is good for you too, that doesn't mean that specific claim is wrong because naturopathy is pseudoscience (which it is). We're evaluating silexan here. Larger discussion is that a lot of modern medicine is not based on well-replicated studies, either
- vorpalhex 5y agoLavender oil != Silexan
- UncleOxidant 5y agoSure, I get that. I'm pretty skeptical of a lot of stuff that goes on in naturopathy, but the best doc I've ever had was a naturopath (not the doc I mentioned above, unfortunately, I'm still looking for a replacement for that best doc) - why do I say he was the best? 1) he wasn't into the woo-woo stuff - he'd present papers on efficacy. So if I were talking to him about a specific issue he'd quickly look things up on his laptop "I was just reading a paper on this the other day, here let's take a look..." 2) he'd actually take time to listen - appointments were at least 45 minutes. Sometimes 1 hour. All the MD's I've been to since seem to be in a huge rush - you're lucky to be in there for 10 minutes (not the fault of the MDs, likely, more the fault of our healthcare system) 3) he taught complementary medicine to MD students at a local Medical School so he wasn't anti-MD as some NDs are. He was well aware of the limits of naturopathy and didn't hesitate to send me to a specialist when needed. 4) Very comprehensive blood tests. I haven't had an MD who tested for so much. And just because some parameter was in the normal range he didn't necessarily consider that everything was ok. He'd say stuff like "this is considered the normal range [for this parameter] but it's right on the edge of normal, we need to look into this further... (or we need to keep a watch on this)" 5) he thought like an engineer - most doctors aren't great at troubleshooting, in my experience. This guy was a good troubleshooter. He got me through some digestive issues that I'd been dealing with for a long time because nobody else seemed to dig into it like he did. Unfortunately he retired a few years back - because of his reputation he was in huge demand and I think he just kind of burned out. In the years since I haven't found a replacement doctor that I've been happy with (either MD or ND).
- prophesi 5y agoThe Amazon referral link is suspicious, but I don't know anything about the author and they may very well be an unbiased critic simply trying to make some additional income from their blog.
- jdpigeon 5y agoThis is Scott Alexander, previously from Slate Star Codex. He's highly respected as a blogger about psychiatry
- yewenjie 5y agoand also an influential figure in the Effective Altruism/ LessWrong communities. Interestingly enough, he also wrote a really enjoyable and clever fiction novel. https://unsongbook.com/ https://unsongbook.com/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rrose 5y agoim not going to tell you you're wrong for respecting him, but i feel this comment is only telling half the story. He's very well respected in the "rationalist" community, but he and that community are pretty controversial and definitely not universally respected
- civilian 5y agoIf anyone is curious about the controversy, here's the NYTimes piece on Scott Alexander: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/13/technology/slate-star-codex-rationalists.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/13/technology/slate-star-cod... It's a decent article, and the few attempts at pearl-clutching fall pretty flat. My only gripe with rationalists is that they suck at running their own conference, CFAR. (:
- 0x_rs 5y agoIf somebody's interested, I would strongly suggest checking out both sides of the dispute and not only that, as the NYT story caused quite some ruckus at the time. https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/06/22/nyt-is-threatening-my-safety-by-revealing-my-real-name-so-i-am-deleting-the-blog/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/06/22/nyt-is-threatening-my-... https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/statement-on-new-york-times-article?s=r https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/statement-on-new-york-...
- symlinkk 5y agoNone of this shit works. If it did it would be called medicine.
- strbean 5y agoThere are numerous studies supporting it's efficacy, but none that are really independent and conflict-free. This is the start of how something starts to be called medicine.
- op00to 5y agoYet we have "medicine" that you can buy that in fact is not at all effective (Phenylephrine, for example).
- nkozyra 5y agoA long tail from the ephedra plant, once similarly an unregulated supplement that absolutely does stuff.
- dllthomas 5y agoIf you're unfamiliar, see https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/uselessness-phenylephrine https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/uselessness-phenyl.... Where do you think Derek goes wrong?
- Tao332 5y ago
- colechristensen 5y agoBe cautious, lavender has compounds that interfere with hormones. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/03/180318144856.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/03/180318144856.h...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 01100011 5y agoI believe mint and licorice root have similar issues.
- UncleOxidant 5y agoIt would be surprising if it was effective and had absolutely 0 side effects.
- AceJohnny2 5y agoStarting with references to a Daily Mail interview and a podcast (even if from a purportedly reputable source) doesn't exactly fill me with confidence. The Daily Mail is gutter-level tabloid trash. If anything, it's a pretty strong anti-reference.
- howmayiannoyyou 5y agoAnyone suffering from Restless Leg Syndrome, big caution. This drug, like SSRIs, can make the condition worse and/or trigger it.
- newobj 5y agoSource? (Asking, not accusing) Counter-point? https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4733501/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4733501/
- beagle3 5y agoWill use this comment to say: Anyone suffering from Restless Leg Syndrome, some people report that iron supplement helps, some people report that flush niacin (pure vitamin B3 in primal form; NOT inositol hexanicotinate, NOT nicotinamide, NOT slow release) help. Be careful with advice on the internet (for all you know, I'm a dog). Iron overload is harmful. Niacin may cause a "flush" which is transient, but feels like your skin is sunburned for 20-30 minutes. Do your own research about amounts etc. Consult a medical professional if you don't feel qualified to do your own research. This is not medical advice, just some random info. (Though, it helped me a lot)
- manmal 5y agoStart with 100mg Niacin or less. I can report that 500mg might induce an urge to go to the ER.
- earleybird 5y agoMy regime is 100mg first thing in the morning resulting in minor flushing 20-30 after taking. Throughout the day, 500mg at a time with often no flushing, staying at or under 2000 mg total for the day. It's very effective at managing my cholesterol and seems to improve joint inflamation. I'll do this for 3 months then stop for a month to 6 weeks.
- beagle3 5y ago
- ddlutz 5y agoMy doctor suggested I take this last year for my GAD. I've been taking it since September, and it's definitely been a huge change for me. Previously, I was really "on edge" and would get panic attacks semi regularly. I haven't had a full panic attack since starting to take in, and day to day I feel much more like I'm able to function like a regular person instead of always having that "on edge" feeling. I guess it's possible it could be a placebo? Previously I was on lexapro for a while, and that didn't seem to be as effective as this, and had some side effects.
- guerrilla 5y agoHow long do you think it took to start working?
- ddlutz 5y agoIt took a couple weeks for me because I started with taking one daily at night, didn't notice much benefit, then took two per dr. recommendation. After that noticed benefit pretty quickly. One thing I did not expect which the article mentions is the "burps that taste like lavender". It was quite unexpected for me but I personally quite like them. I think my stomach might have gotten used to the lavender though because I would get them ever single time I took them for the first few weeks, and now it's maybe once a week some minor burp.
- MacsHeadroom 5y agoAbout a decade ago I acquired some lavender extract which looked something like cannabis extract. I can confirm that it was sedating and obviously anxiolytic, both vaporized and dissolved in hot water. Vaporized the effect is instant and lasts only perhaps 20 minutes. Notably, it was not euphoric like some benzodiazepines can be. So I would say recreational/"abuse" potential was virtually non-existent for me personally. Qualitatively I would describe the experience as a mental and physical shift towards moderate relaxation, not unlike the feeling after a brief shoulder rub.
- arisAlexis 5y agoExamine.com says it may be anticholinergic (that would explain some properties). If it's the case then it's not very good for longterm use, it may make you demented
- rhexs 5y agoI suppose the downside here is that lavender reduces testosterone. Then again I’m sure chronic anxiety and stress do as well.
- jaqalopes 5y agoI have bigtime anxiety so I ordered some of this stuff after reading this blog post a couple days ago. I took my first dose this morning, and I gotta say it really does feel like it helped. Obviously this could be placebo effect so I will reserve full judgment until I've taken it for a few weeks at least, but having tried all sorts of stuff for anxiety—both prescriptions and supplements—I can say it's not typical for something to work right away the lavender seemed to. Very promising!
- tibbon 5y agoI’ve found beta blockers at low doses help quite a bit with low grade anxiety. I’m prescribed them for other reasons, but they do seem to be another class of drugs that can help for anxiety just a bit.