6 ms·
The Fed's $2.7T mortgage problem
- unchocked 5y agoGiven that there's nothing forcing the Fed to unload these mortgages, the option of putting them on the market (thus driving commercial mortgage rates higher) seems like a policy lever that will be good to have, cooling real estate inflation selectively separate from the federal funds rate.
- readthenotes1 5y agoDriving rates higher won't cool inflation except by raising prices - which is inflation. They want to stifle the demand so as to match supply better, but when it's a supply shock and the United States is short something like 3 million houses, it seems a fairly punitive and misguided way to approach solving the problem.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> rates higher won't cool inflation except by raising prices - which is inflation Rates rising drives prices down. Of the mortgages on their books. And of the homes collateralizing them.
- ZoomerCretin 5y agoYou're on an island with five chairs. There are four people. Everyone has a chair. Add six people. There are now five chairs and ten people. How can you manipulate the prices of chairs such that all ten people can have their own chair? Artificially lowering the prices of chairs does not solve the underlying issue: There are not enough chairs for everyone that needs one. By treating housing price surges as excessive demand (raising mortgage rates), you lower demand not only for _existing_ homes, but also for creating new homes. If your goal is to ensure that housing prices always go up and affordability/homelessness go in wrong direction, the Federal Reserve's policy is very effective. They're wrong to prematurely kill demand before it can cause new housing construction to increase, fixing the underlying issue of not enough supply.
- medvezhenok 5y agoYou're missing the people who have multiple chairs and are sitting on chairs hoping that price goes up who would be incentivized to sell (look at supply coming online as mortgage rates rise - and any similar pattern - i.e. 2018). Price always going up makes chairs attractive to hold, which results in misallocation of chairs - ideally you want them to go to whoever wants chairs the most, not whoever grabbed a chair first. Yes, the best answer is to make more chairs, but that is not something that the FED has much control over (it's federal/state/local zoning policy and regulation which prevent more supply). The question the FED can address is not "how can we make sure everyone has a chair", but rather "how do we make sure that the existing chairs go to the people that need chairs the most"
- amanj41 5y agoYeah, not really sure what the original commenter was on about... The price of money itself is higher when rates go up, so prices of goods and assets must go down to compensate for reduced demand
- realce 5y agoIs this what you would do if you wanted certain classes of people to capitulate on their "American Dream" and turn it into "at least I can rent a house from Goldman Sachs" for some reason?
- kodah 5y agoThis is already happening in the Bay Area (more or less)
- kodah 5y agoThere's another option that the fed isn't considering: let Congress find a way to force businesses out of congested areas where houses aren't and won't be available any time soon. There's also financially incentivising remote work and providing incentives to move away from major cities. There's still a supply shortage in building homes to deal with, but that'd at least solve a problem for a good chunk of folks.
- ZoomerCretin 5y agoThis doesn't fix the underlying problem. The vast majority of local governments make it very expensive or outright impossible to add significant amounts of housing via zoning and density bans. Pushing businesses into other areas will simply drive up housing prices in other markets, not to mention accelerate suburban climate arson. The solution is to remove tariffs on imported wood to make new housing cheaper and to punish municipalities with racial segregationist-era housing/zoning policies.
- kodah 5y agoI live in the Bay Area. Where are you going to add houses here that aren't protected land? Zoning isn't even a thing here; I live right behind a Denny's. Some of your assumptions seem vastly off. There are places like Mountain View that don't allow building above four stories, which is crap, but stuffing people into towering buildings where they're not allowed to own the thing they're living in or immediately priced out of it (which serves as an investment) doesn't solve the housing crisis. Edit: I had a bit of a snarky reply, and I apologize if you read that. I pay a little over $3.5k for a house (that allows a big dog); if I lose this place I'll pay over $4k in rent per month and that number goes up by the month. I'm being forced to come into an office, which requires me to live near by. If I can't live near by, then I have to accept a lower paying job. Do you see the complexity of this issue?
- eftychis 5y agoYeah I also don't buy the approach and commentary. Rates need to go up sure, but not with this much funfare. Killing the patient in the process to keep inflation in check makes little sense. And then there is the demand elasticity. How many people here are going stop using gas to go to work or stop eating to push prices down? Similarly with the baby formula -- where they suggested throwing money at the problem of lacking formulas: there is just not enough at retail for people to buy, doesn't matter how much money you have. What is the Federal Reserve going to do: tell babies to not eat? This is misguided politic theatrics, that causes even more panic and over consuming due to panic, which leads to further stress and supply issues.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI read the article twice an I don't understand the challenge posed by leaving the mortgages on the balance sheet. I don't think that the fed has wo worry about freeing up the capital to relocate because they printed it into existence in the first place. They also don't want to do more QE because the market is already overheated.
- anm89 5y agoIf they can't kill inflation by killing equity markets and bonds the last target left is the housing market. So if you believe that their true goal is to kill inflation at this point, which I more or less do, than the thing the Fed feels like it needs to do is to target housing prices directly and their best lever for that is the MBS on the balance sheet.
- kmonsen 5y agoBut if the inflation is not due to overconsumption in the US, but about global problems with supply side issues on the front and China in lockdown not helping at all, how does it make sense to cause a housing crash? I certainly think the fed should stop to build the bubble, but it should also not go all in and crash everything.
- unnamed76ri 5y agoInflation’s main cause is printing trillions of dollars in unbacked currency. The Trump admin and now the Biden admin are very fond of doing so for the sake of short term political advantage.
- kmonsen 5y agoWhy does Norway that didn't print money have similar inflation in that case?
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> how does it make sense to cause a housing crash? Less housing demand presumably means less home construction and renovation, which eases the strain on supply-chain limited resources. Lower home prices also reduce the amount of equity sellers, or HELOC borrowers, can spend on NFTs or whatever [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_effect
- jjoonathan 5y agoProblem? No, it's working as designed: as a plausibly deniable mechanism to print trillions for rich people. Meanwhile, inflation will be blamed on the billions printed for poor people. "Balance sheet that never rolls off" is very much in the same genre as "loan that is actually a grant" and "financing tax cuts with debt."
- konfusinomicon 5y agoI dabble in news sources from both sides of the aisle and I've not heard the opinion that inflation is a result of poor people, only that its the result of a perfect storm of the pandemic and an unjust war halfway across the world, which mostly makes sense... who is blaming the poor?
- __john 5y agoEveryone knows inflation is because of the stimmies. edit: /s
- ZoomerCretin 5y agoOften what everyone knows to be true and what is actually true are distinct.
- stusmall 5y agoI guess "everyone" is wrong. The huge influx of money is part of it but the current inflation doesn't have just one cause. There is a huge spike in energy costs partially from the war in Ukraine, partially from a decrease in production by the prices cratering in 2020 and partially from an increase in demand. There are huge supply chain problems everywhere. Massive labor shortages. I'm sure I'm missing some others. This isn't a simple problem with a simple cause.
- themitigating 5y agoThat doesn't mean it's right and most people haven't researched this they are just told it by the media
- candiddevmike 5y agoThe recession in 2008 was never really fixed, we just kicked the can down the road.
- upupandup 5y agowhat does this mean exactly? We can't raise the rates anymore without substantial structural shift in our economy? Such as the end of ridiculous earnings-to-price multiples?
- candiddevmike 5y agoPretty much, to me I think the problems facing the US economy entirely revolve around wealth inequality and require significant, painful policy measures to fix.
- anm89 5y agoWe took a crisis of bank and consumer balance sheets and relocated it to the government balance sheet by artificially generating liquidity backed by government liabilities. We didn't change many of the underlying mechanics (if you believe that the mbs rating schemes and bad mortgages were a symptom and not a cause which I do, we did fix those things) The problems with a debt crisis at the sovereign level is there is only one can left to kick and that's the inflation can. The government says they don't want inflation but if it comes down to real solvency issues, they are going to give in to inflation, if the choice is between that and defaulting. We basically have been playing a liquidity shuffling game since the first tech bubble.
- user3939382 5y agoThe Fed will curb inflation with high rates that slow down the entire economy and drive up unemployment, which is exactly what they're doing.
- phil21 5y ago"Too Big to Fail" was introduced into our vocabulary. I think beyond that it's too many words to really get into?
- javert 5y agoKind of a silly article. When the Fed sells enough bonds, interest rates go up. It doesn't matter if they sell mortgage-backed securities or something else. Selling these does not effect the housing market any differently from the Fed selling some other bond.
- anm89 5y agoDead wrong. Selling MBS affects the incentives of mortgage initiators in a vastly different way than selling Bonds. It's a direct pipeline to affecting bottom line mortgage rates for consumers as opposed to a highly indirect one. When bottom line mortgage rates for consumers go up, the housing market is affected directly and immediately.
- javert 5y agoI don't see why that would be the case. Enlighten me. If the market will pay yield X for a long-term bond of a certain duration, banks can make money by offering mortgages for X plus some margin. The Fed selling MBSs should just depress yields in general.
- lvl102 5y agoThe Fed is compounding its mistakes of not stopping QE last year by pulling forward QT in order to fight inflation that is outside of its control (Ukraine and China).
- harambae 5y agoInflation was out of control before the (most recent) Ukraine war
- anm89 5y agoI was talking about this with a friend today. I think if the Fed announced they were selling agency MBS as part of their QT program we would see a paradigm shift in markets. Like limit down kind of days. I think that's what the punch bowl being taken away truly looks like. And if the S&P down 35% doesn't get inflation down, then I think that's probably next on the list.
- m348e912 5y agoJust curious, how does the Fed selling Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae/Ginny Mae mortgage backed securities cause a shift in the markets? What's the likelihood the Fed would actually do something like that?
- anm89 5y agoIt's basically trying to kill housing demand via interest rates. Selling MBS is a much more direct effect on mortgage rates than something like the fed funds rate
- camnora 5y agoAn increase of MBS offered on the market will cause mortgage rates to rise because there's too many loans for sale and not enough buyers. Buyers will demand higher and higher rates to make it worth their while.
- m348e912 5y agoSomeone/something has to be buying the MBSs today, wouldn't selling them on the market just increase potential buyers? Sorry that I'm not following.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> it will incur big financial losses that reduce the funds the central bank returns to the Treasury...expect officials to face tough questions from Capitol Hill to explain why they've lost billions of dollars on behalf of the American people This isn't how it works. No doubt, some will try to spin it that way. But the Fed balance sheet's gains and losses are an accounting artefact. (It will always make money when lowering rates. It will always lose money when raising them. This is close to mathematical fact.) The Fed can't go broke. Its operating metrics are inflation and unemployment. > the selling would likely push mortgage rates up further, at a time the housing industry is already starting to groan under the pressure of rising rates This is the real issue. But it's why we have an independent central bank. Nobody likes rate rises. It's why economies with weak institutions wind up hyper inflating. (No, we're not.)
- redisman 5y agoThe housing market is in a mega bubble. Why exactly does it need support to push it even further into madness?
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThe bigger the bubble the harder it pops. The harder it pops the more damage it does. The more damage it does the better it is for those who didn't buy into the madness. And I say this as a homeowner.
- riskneutral 5y agoIt would be ironic if a second housing bubble collapse causes a second financial crisis. It's entirely possible. It could start outside the US, in other Western countries where real estate prices have reached completely insane levels. In Canada, if there was a housing "bubble pop" then it would be catastrophic for the entire economy and financial system. It would not really be better even for those who didn't buy into the madness, unless they've been sitting on a hoard cash the whole time and buy at the right time. Most people never had the cash to buy into the madness, and if the music stops then they lose their job and a significant portion of their investment savings and are probably unable to take advantage of the opportunity. The rich always get richer, and the poor always get poorer, even in a financial crisis.
- dvt 5y ago> The Fed's pandemic actions fueled a housing boom. As it tries to withdraw that support, it could be bad news for housing — and the Fed's standing on Capitol Hill. I think this article is a bit of a nothingburger. Of course QT has the opposite effect of QE, that's the entire point. The 2020 housing boom will not blow up like in 2008 because today's mortgage backed securities are much more stable than the C-tier CDOs of yester-year, as long as the labor market is doing well (which it seems like it is[1]) and folks can afford their mortgages. Of course house prices may deflate (~20%?) purely out of demand for such high prices decreasing, but imo it's unlikely we will see mortgages go underwater, and therefore the Fed doesn't really have a problem on their hands. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/06/business/economy/jobs-report-april-2022.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/06/business/economy/jobs-rep...
- philwelch 5y ago> as long as the labor market is doing well Which is indeed the last shoe that has yet to drop in the current recession.
- aidenn0 5y agoIf housing prices deflate more than 20%, nearly everyone who bought a house with 20% down in the past 2 years will be underwater, no?
- dvt 5y agoIf we assume that the home-owners have been building equity in their homes for the past 2 years, no, they would be at 0 + equity. This of course stings a little, but still not underwater or filing for bankruptcy.
- aidenn0 5y agoI meant to say much more than 20%; you don't build a whole lot of equity in the first years of a 30 year mortgage due to the amortization schedule.
- 5y ago
- kart23 5y ago"The Fed's pandemic actions fueled a housing boom. As it tries to withdraw that support, it could be bad news for housing" How is this bad news? Housing is incredibly expensive relative to the average American's salary. Yeah it sucks for people that bought a house recently, but in the long term, it is absolutely a good thing.
- harambae 5y agoThis is how I see it as well. If clean drinking water doubled in price in 2 years would the same people go on CNBC and praise the gains in the "strong water market"?
- omgJustTest 5y agoA hot topic! NYF announcement over two weeks ago. https://www.newyorkfed.org/markets/opolicy/operating_policy_220504 https://www.newyorkfed.org/markets/opolicy/operating_policy_...
- cs702 5y agoI'd be more concerned about the other ~$6.3T of holdings in the Fed's ~$9T balance sheet.[a] The Fed has publicly announced it will allow its bond holdings to mature, to the tune of ~$90B/month, without recycling the proceeds back into treasury and agency-sponsored mortgage-backed bonds. Given that all treasury bonds that mature and most mortgage bonds paid off via home sales are refinanced, private investors -- that is, mutual funds, ETFs, pension plans, individuals, etc. -- will have to buy an additional ~$90B of bonds every month, give or take, going forward. That's $1T/year that private investors must find to buy treasury and agency bonds newly issued to refinance old ones. Without a doubt, this will have a large, persistent effect on treasury yields and credit spreads. [a] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=PlId https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=PlId
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> $1T/year that private investors must find to buy newly issued treasury and agency bonds Yes. > this will have a large, persistent effect on treasury yields and credit spreads That's the point.
- cs702 5y agoYup. You and I are 100% in agreement. :-(
- camnora 5y ago> If the Fed sells mortgage securities that pay low rates at a time when prevailing rates are much higher, it will incur big financial losses that reduce the funds the central bank returns to the Treasury. Why does this reduce the amount of funds to the treasury? The losses are on the Feds balance sheet. My understanding is that the Treasury is not involved here, but the article hints at them being affected. Is it implying that treasury yields will rocket higher??? > In that scenario, expect officials to face tough questions from Capitol Hill to explain why they've lost billions of dollars on behalf of the American people. If the Fed takes a loss, doesn't this mean that base money supply increases? Sure it will be drawing liquidity out of the system, but in the long run, it will leave more money in the system compared to where they started with QE.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Why does this reduce the amount of funds to the treasury? It's an accounting thing [1]. When the Fed makes a profit, it remits it to the Treasury [2]. (I believe this is an anachronism from the gold standard days, but not sure.) [1] https://www.stlouisfed.org/on-the-economy/2018/september/fed-payments-treasury-rising-interest-rates https://www.stlouisfed.org/on-the-economy/2018/september/fed... [2] https://www.wsj.com/articles/fed-sent-88-5-billion-in-profits-to-u-s-treasury-in-2020-11610384401 https://www.wsj.com/articles/fed-sent-88-5-billion-in-profit...
- camnora 5y agoOh neat, TIL. Thanks