4 ms·
Kahneman and Tversky are legends in psychology, but they didn't change the fundamental way we view ourselves. The notion of humans as super rational utility ma
by disgruntledphd2 15y ago
Kahneman and Tversky are legends in psychology, but they didn't change the fundamental way we view ourselves. The notion of humans as super rational utility maximisers was entirely an economic model, and it was that they attacked. It was well known (for over twenty years before their seminal 1974 science paper) that humans were poor at probability and utility judgments.
What they did do, was force the economic profession to face up (somewhat) to these issues, and their contribution to loss aversion and prospect theory more generally, is a significant advance.
That being said, their dual process models are about as predictive as those of Freud (which is to say, not at all). its currently a really active phase of research, so I suppose I can thank them for making it easier for me to get funding.
They also did not invent priming, though they made heavy use of it. Likewise framing effects were well known before them, going back at least to Asch 1951 study of conformity in judgements of line length.
To summate, Kahneman is an amazing scientist, but this reporter does not appear to know much about what he is talking about.
- benmathes 15y agoThat is a common theme with David Brooks. I'm not trying to be ad-hominem, just noticing a pattern.
- klbarry 15y agoWhat are the best books available on the subject of predicting human behavior, if you don't mind me asking? Advanced or technical are fine, scientific journals would be over my comprehension, I'm afraid.
- jasonshen 15y agoOne great book on behavioral economics that's based on a lot of research and experimental data is http://www.amazon.com/Judgment-Managerial-Decision-Making-Bazerman/dp/0471178071 http://www.amazon.com/Judgment-Managerial-Decision-Making-Ba... Came highly recommended from a Stanford professor and is one of the most "meaty" books on the topic.
- joelhaus 15y agoAnimal Spirits is probably a lighter read (it's still on my to-read list), but I've been impressed when hearing the author, Robert Shiller, speak: http://www.amazon.com/Animal-Spirits-Psychology-Economy-Capitalism/dp/0691142335/ http://www.amazon.com/Animal-Spirits-Psychology-Economy-Capi... Discussing animal spirits in various videos on youtube: http://www.youtube.com/results?search=Search&resnum=0&oi=spell&search_query=Robert+Shiller+Animal+Spirits http://www.youtube.com/results?search=Search&resnum=0...
- billswift 15y ago>humans as super rational utility maximisers Is not an economic model, it is a straw-man of the economic "model" which states that en masse and over time humans behave rationally where their interests are involved. (I put model above in quotes because even that is really only an aspect of how economics models human behavior.) As many "critics" of economics have pointed out, and as Surowiecki reported in The Wisdom of Crowds, the mass often make better decisions than an individual because, among other reasons, their errors tend to cancel out.