7 ms·
Deep inside ARM's new Intel killer
- jws 15y agoThis is the A7 mentioned yesterday. The article is worth a peek if only for the two contrasted CPU instruction diagrams showing the difference in complexity and the graph of performance versus power for the two chips. It all makes sense when you see those.
- sounds 15y agoI enjoyed reading Ars Technica's take on this a while back, entitled "All this has happened before: NVIDIA 3.0, ARM, and the fate of x86" http://arstechnica.com/business/news/2011/02/nvidia-30-and-the-riscification-of-x86.ars http://arstechnica.com/business/news/2011/02/nvidia-30-and-t... Predictions of x86's imminent demise are, well, wrong. But so too, prediciting arm's destruction at the hands of intel... not likely. There's lots of market for both companies. They have different origins, different goals, and different areas of expertise.
- ChuckMcM 15y agoArs had a better take on it, but that is to be expected. I was reminded of how MIPS used to be the best selling ISA but that was because it was in HP and Lexmark printers so tons were sold and nobody realized it. The tablet/smartphone markets have really pushed ARM into a position where the shear number of implementations justifies the time and effort to build better software. The helps the architecture achieve better tool parity and that is something that is vital for its longevity.
- rbanffy 15y ago> because it was in HP and Lexmark printers And game console. PS1, PS2 and N64, IIRC, were MIPS boxes.
- Symmetry 15y agoOn the other hand, this will probably head of MIPS's attempts to encroach on ARM's markets.
- sounds 15y agoI'd really like to know if MIPS is actually competitive at the same performance-per-watt levels as ARM. As I understand it, MIPS is easy to license and cheap to build, so when cost is the biggest factor you go with MIPS. That's nothing to sneeze at. The way I see it ARM dominates in phones and tablets because these devices do much more than, say, a wireless router.
- salem 15y agoARM, especially ARM-thumb mode, is the gold standard for instructions/watt. That's why it's in phones since way back. I don't see MIPS challenging that.
- rbanffy 15y ago> They have different origins, different goals, and different areas of expertise. The greatest threat against Intel is the decreasing importance of the PC and the increasing importance of tablets, überphones and other non-Intel-based devices. Intel is common on desktops because the most popular OS for desktops runs on nothing but an x86 and on servers largely because what we call a server these days is just a (sometimes exquisitely) well built PC with rack mounting rails that has to be a PC because a very popular server OS can't run on anything that's not an x86 PC. So, as x86's vanish from desks, there will be less reason to run desktop-derived OSs on servers and less reason to run them on x86 servers. With Windows 8 there is even less reason to have x86's in the remaining desktops, users being able to opt for more power-efficient ARM engines. I am not sure whether Windows Server 8 will support ARM-based servers, but, if they do, I expect the x86 to become a legacy platform.
- sounds 15y agoI'll chime in on the "Post-PC Era" buzzword ... but only with a disclaimer: I don't buy it. Intel wants to grow their market, so they're investing in UMPCs and MIDs. I think it's pretty telling they aren't in any phones (yet). They're going to try that in 2012. Ok. "Post PC?" I don't buy it. PCs may change to ARM, but there will always be IT, science, engineering, data visualization, education, ... -- stuff that might work on a phone or a tablet, but the keyboard is a "killer app." I actually see the two markets as symbiotic. Only in corner cases can you find people who prefer a smartphone over a PC, or vice versa. It looks like mainstream applications benefit from having both.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoThe "Post PC" era is coming, have little doubt of that. However, it'll be more of a phase transition than a cataclysm. Mostly it'll come down to different form factors, different operating systems, and different UIs. And yes, ultimately the markets will be even more symbiotic than they are today.
- sounds 15y agoIf symbiotic, then not "Post PC." I don't buy it. Maybe I need to phrase it as a question: Why would you get rid of your PC once you have more form factors, more OS's, and more UIs? Especially, why would you get rid of your _keyboard_?
- InclinedPlane 15y agoI don't know quite why every recent competitive relationship in tech has been portrayed as an imminent existential battle, but it's an annoying trend.
- mturmon 15y agoIt sucks. I think it's as simple as: page views. Reduce the news to something as simple as possible, give people a side to cheer for. Who would have imagined that tech would turn in to a spectator sport?
- jseliger 15y agoBecause tech writers need something to write about, and rises and falls are more exciting that coexistence. I got tired of reading endless "PCs are dying, so run out and buy more stuff!!!11" articles and decided to write a response to them: http://jseliger.com/2011/10/09/desktop-pcs-arent-going-anywhere-despite-the-growth-of-phones-and-tablets%e2%80%94because-theyre-cheap/ http://jseliger.com/2011/10/09/desktop-pcs-arent-going-anywh... that's applies to the analogous situation you bring up.
- ippisl 15y agoAccording to the article , intel's strength is in per thread performance.But most of today's heavy applications enjoy multi-thread performance: Multi-user servers, Heavy math applications and other applications written with today's better multi-programming tools. So that means selling a lot less chips. But that bad for intel's business model , and get worse with moore's law(they gotta sell double number of transistors). Now about demise: it's hard to tell because it depends minimum sales intel needs to sustain it's business model, But intel are trying to counteract that with several interesting moves: 1. An integrated pc platform strategy: CPU+GPU integration , chipsets with better integration with their flash modules(z86 chipset), buying an anti-virus software. This way they can get more money and have more control on the pc market. This may compensate them on decreasing volumes. And hurt GPU manufacturers along the way. 2. Finding new sources for chip manufacturing r&d investments: Manufacturing flash, letting non-competing companies manufacture chips using intel fabs. 3. trying hard to compete on the multi-core performance game: letting old code(c++/fortran, etc) run faster on a 64-core intel platfrom might be more appealing than needing to import that code to a GPU.Working on parallel development tools also helps there.
- corysama 15y agoHere's ARM's whitepaper that the article links and summarizes: http://www.arm.com/files/downloads/big.LITTLE_Final.pdf http://www.arm.com/files/downloads/big.LITTLE_Final.pdf
- cpeterso 15y agoI'm curious to see how the Linux process scheduler will load balance processes will be tweaked to use the big dog and little dog processors. IO-bound processes could be migrated to the little dog and CPU-bound processes to the big dog.
- salem 15y agoFrom the description, it seemed like there is a mode to handle this transparently in hardware
- ZeroGravitas 15y agoI believe the OS can, optionally, make these decisions itself if it wants to.
- bitwize 15y ago"big.LITTLE processing". Funniest name since Blast Processing. I imagine little Sackboys running around my smartphone, carrying bits of soft polyester data.
- brintoul 15y agoAnd the UltraSPARC T1 is totally gonna take them out in the server space! ... right..?
- 6ren 15y agoThis is our inability to use multi-core. From the performance graph (http://regmedia.co.uk/2011/10/20/arm_performance.jpg http://regmedia.co.uk/2011/10/20/arm_performance.jpg), two A7s would have the same raw processing power as one A15 - at less than half the power. The problem is we can't utilize that raw power effectively. So, instead, this awful, inelegant, stupid design is probably the absolute best we can do at the moment. People claim that functional programming's immutability solves this problem. But it's interesting that while Erlang, one of the most effective multi-processor languages, is functional, it doesn't use that for multi-core: instead, it uses a shared-nothing architecture (like smalltalk) which is independent of the fp paradigm; and STM (Software Transactional Memory). The second interesting thing is that incredible rewards are available today for a solution (and have been for a while) - so where are the fp solutions? Why haven't they taken over, or had substantial success - or, at least, appeared? Multi-core is a hard problem. Silicon is cheap but we don't know how to use it (excepting GPUs/CUDA). I think this will not be solved with any existing methods (including 50-year old fp). Instead, it will require a complete reframing of the question, from the silicon-up. That is, it won't even look like a programming language - or a computer. It's hard to overstate the rewards for solving this.</provocativerant>
- flazzarino 15y agoThere exists a non-intuitive asymmetry in the nature of systems like multi-core. Do four 10mph car crashes do the same damage as one 40mph crash? If it can be properly coordinated. If you can coordinate it, how much does the coordination cost? At worst you only have the power of one 10mph crash, often at best too. Programming for multi-core can a hard problem but the problem doesn't always lie in our abilities, many times it's computationally impossible. To play games and video is a must right? We want the most from our battery right? A fact of the situation is that high power activities are many times mutually exclusive from low power activities right? So what is awful, inelegant or stupid about the design? The asymmetry? There is asymmetry of the interaction? Should you cary around a dumb-phone, a gameboy, and a video player? Maybe more elegant, but it sure is more awful. P.S. Don't talk about FP son ;)
- Someone 15y ago
- cjenkins 15y agoI've always thought it strange to think that ARM (or any other CPU design) company could take out Intel. Worst case in the ARM scenario, Intel buys a company with an ARM license and is still a step ahead on process and fab technology. To boot, increased mobile device usage (even on ARM) is probably good overall for Intel as it helps drive demand for the servers powering the services those devices consume.
- Andys 15y agoARM chips are priced an order of magnitude lower than Intel's chips. Their process advantage would only last one generation because the fat profit margins aren't there to pay for the next one. If ARM kills Intel, its because cheap chips are finally "good enough" for nearly all purposes.
- dstein 15y agoIntel already bought and then sold an ARM licensee: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XScale http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XScale