13 ms·
Great to see the project moving along, but it's been a persistent feeling of mine that FOSS is starting to get left behind in the dust. The design space has bee
by Gigachad 5y ago
Great to see the project moving along, but it's been a persistent feeling of mine that FOSS is starting to get left behind in the dust. The design space has been very rapidly moving towards online, live collaboration tools like Figma, Sketch, Adobe XD, etc and FOSS just has no answer for this market. Even a lot of the big name proprietary tools are finding themselves becoming rapidly obsolete in a world where people want to IM a link and just have it reflect the latest version rather than attaching files back and forth.
It's not even clear how FOSS would even work in this market or how it would benefit the user when it would be hosted all on someone else's server with self hosting diminishing the ease of collaboration.
- ur-whale 5y ago> FOSS just has no answer for this market And thank god for that. Users literally hate the Adobe model, but aren't given a choice. Please remember what the 'F' in FOSS stands for. Hint: it's not about money.
- Gigachad 5y agoUsers are given a choice. There are mountains of alternatives to adobe products. But they keep paying for the adobe one because it’s the best. And it’s the best because people keep paying their monthly subscriptions to fund it. They might complain but at the end of the day they are very happy to pay adobe for the best in class tools.
- WillAdams 5y agoThe industry keeps paying because of the sunk costs of legacy files and content, and the fact that Adobe also makes RIPs for imagesetters so the expectation is that it will all be compatible and work together.
- jotm 5y agoThat's not exactly a FOSS problem, though. Nothing stops an open source project from offering the same collaborative features as proprietary solutions. It just seems that people who work on FOSS value privacy, ownership and freedom more than braindead ease of use and monetization.
- Gigachad 5y agoThat seems to be an unfair dismissal of these products. The vast majority of everything built with these tools will be public facing. Marketing designs, UI design, etc. Design is a very collaborative process, especially with remote work which has made having everyone see and edit the same thing at once critical. It's not "braindead" to work in a team, its a requirement. I really want to see FOSS succeed but its hard to see how the open source benefits translate over to this kind of software where you no longer run the software locally and consistency is needed so others have the same version of the tool as you.
- likeclockwork 5y agoI'm not they but I think they meant that the collaborative aspects of SaaS products emerge from the requirement to be as rentable as possible. There are some open source movers in this space too: https://penpot.app/ https://penpot.app/
- koshersalt 5y agoI don’t think IMing a link is the main competition so much as “is there an companion app” For the hobbyist/small business though these regular desktop tools are still a godsend
- gerdesj 5y ago"FOSS is starting to get left behind in the dust" What does your TV or car boot? Design space ... what do you use day to day - I'd love to see your blog/show piece?
- Gigachad 5y agoI'm not talking about low level infrastructure, but the user facing software. Offline desktop tools have rapidly started to become obsolete. Products like Office had to scramble to pivot because Google Docs was replacing them. Its been a while now since I have been emailed an actual office file instead of being sent a link to the live version. A while ago it was common for Photoshop or illustrator to be used for UI designs and then it would be thrown over the wall to you as a PNG which you had to make sure you had the latest version of. These days everywhere I have worked has used a tool like Adobe XD, Figma, Sketch, and gives out a link which is always up to date, which you can fiddle with, write comments on, etc. The market is rapidly shifting and I'm just not sure how FOSS is going to stay relevant in this space.
- vikingerik 5y agoWhy can't FOSS do this, though? There's no reason Inkscape couldn't work the same way, where a document lives in the cloud and users pass around links to it. It does require someone to maintain and pay for the cloud hosting. That shouldn't be unsolvable; that's not really any fundamentally different than hosting a download site for traditional FOSS. Donation-supported FOSS can work.
- Gigachad 5y agoIt requires a total redesign of the app and architecture. Being able to live stream edits in and conflict resolution. But I think the biggest barrier is most FOSS enthusiasts consider web apps and collaboration to be anti user malware.
- tadfisher 5y agoSounds like there's a need for: 1. A generic CRDT library, preferably in C or something that exposes a C interface. This is probably very hard or even impossible, depending on how much must be abstracted and how much work the developer must do to express edits in terms of the CRDT. 2. A P2P backend for said library for streaming edits. 3. A networked data store, maybe as-a-service, for versioning and persistence. 2 and 3 might even be made transparent to non-CRDT-aware applications through FUSE, but that's not a hard requirement.
- efortis 5y agoGood employees find ways to collaborate no matter what. That’s to say that real-time collaboration is a luxury feature. Also, many projects have only one designer. Not to mention, it’s rare to find designers that work in tandem. Also, from a dev perspective having designs updates without some process is undesirable.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"That’s to say that real-time collaboration is a luxury feature." So were toilets once upon a time. I am not a fan of webapps, but this line of argument doesn't hold water
- efortis 5y agoI rather have a toilet than saving two clicks. —- real-time collab is not exclusive to webapps.
- Gigachad 5y ago>real-time collab is not exclusive to webapps. Sure, but once you make the effort required to build a real time app, there are vanishingly few reasons why not to have it as a web app. Some of them provide a desktop app as well but they all provide a web app. As a designer, you can just send a link to your design to anyone, end users, clients, developers, managers. And they just click it and it shows up and works. No need for installing software, setting up accounts, etc. A lot of these web apps are actually C++ and then compiled to web assembly so they are quite fast.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- esrauch 5y agoDo you use source control or do you email zips with the source files between you and the other developers? The collaboration here is exactly the same as that distinction in workflows. It's obviously not just "two clicks", it's "Text copy 2 final final alt reviewed.doc" and then you get a new person email their suggested updates to you as "Text copy 2 final 2.doc" and you have to somehow merge those suggestions in with the head version. With Word at least there's the ability to do suggestions rather than direct edits to let you collaborate against nonsynced docs at all, but with Inkscape when that happens you'll literally just get a different svg and you can't actually merge at all, instead you'd need to conceptually understand what edits were made and then make them again manually to the "head" version, which is completely redundant work.
- jka 5y agoHave you had a chance to try Penpot ( https://penpot.app/ https://penpot.app/ )?
- Gigachad 5y agoI hadn't seen this one before. This looks like exactly what is needed.
- hectormalot 5y agoWanted to share Penpot as well. It worked surprisingly well for my use case. Ecosystem is limited unfortunately, eg hard to find someone on fiverr to deliver penpot files instead of figma
- zelphirkalt 5y agoHm, I don't think online tools are that far ahead. If I look at the horrible experience, which is Google docs or MS Office 365, especially their word processing parts, they lack behind soooo much compared to a tool like Libreoffice. You cannot even properly use styles and, if I got a few $currency for every silly bug I encountered in those online half-assed tools, I would probably work half time only. If that experience is anything to go by for the design space, then I would rather work offline and without collaboration, than having to worry about my whole document getting completely messed up by some silly bug.
- foxes 5y agoIn contrast to your anecdote, I have never had issues with Google docs. It has always just worked, reasonably clean interface. I'm not sure what elaborate styling you need, but it seems serviceable for when you need a basic document which I imagine is most peoples use case. Also the collaboration is actually very useful. The same reason I use overleaf as an interface for a lot of my LaTeX projects. I can quickly share and get updates, they just have to open their browser instead of download pdf > open it in their pdf viewer > make comments > send it back etc. The web interface is great for people that do not use git etc.
- nerdponx 5y agoG Docs is fine but very basic. Great for sharing and collaboration, not great for exercising precise control over the document.
- foxes 5y agoI don’t know what precise control you need over the document in the use case served by Google docs.
- aikinai 5y agoThat’s exactly the problem; Google Docs’ use case is only “share a basic document and collaborate on the words.” It’s not capable of creating precise or maintainable documents (e.g. no styles as others have mentioned), which is a very common need that it’s adjacent enough to that lots of people use it for and then it fails.
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoSandstorm.io tries to make collaborative web apps work easily with sharing for non-technical users, though we haven't solved getting people a server easily, or more crucially, convincing people to buy a server to do things they can do for free with ads. Unfortunately, the problem is companies powered by ad revenue have a lot more money to throw at usability than FOSS folks do.
- Gigachad 5y agoAll of these apps and products I mentioned do not have ads, they are paid for directly. Users/businesses do want to pay for software, but when they do pay, they want it to just work seamlessly. No one wants to set up and maintain a server.
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoI mean, ultimately the answer there is... pay someone to run your open source server for you. But since the OSI hates SSPL and the like, the actual open source developers are disadvantaged in running such a service compared to someone who just downloads it and hosts it. A huge issue is that the gatekeepers of "open source" don't believe making it financially viable is something they need to address. So it's gonna end up being the best we can do in our spare time for the love of progress.
- cxr 5y ago> we haven't solved getting people a server easily It doesn't help that Sandstorm focuses on apps that are architected with a devops-heavy mindset. Many apps don't really need anything more complicated than PUT and DELETE (no POST special handling required), esp. since they're already doing so much on the client, anyway. This really calls for an auth-protected document store more than it does what Sandstorm tries to provide; the difficulties of "getting people a server" probably starts with assuming/insisting that that's what you need to do in the first place. Those kinds of architectures are only necessary when you really do need some way to offload computation to a remote, high-availability machine, but things like online image and document editors aren't that. (Even then, what you really want for that is some sort of mobile code architecture that lets you squirt lightweight payloads at some sort of fleet of faceless workers, preferably in the same/similar form to the kind of code that you write for doing useful work on the client...)
- digisign 5y agoSorry your use case isn't being met, but it's hardly the point of inkscape to become a saas. The typical use is, "I need to draw something on my PC."
- gopiandcode 5y agoYep, exactly. It's absolutely insane we've now reached for a point where when people see a standalone, working, polished piece of software that respects your freedom, they somehow feel that it is "inferior" because it doesn't take away your rights. I, for one, am glad that Free/Libre software like inkscape continues to be heading strong, and find that it far outpaces any of the proprietary malware SAAS applications out there.
- dash2 5y agoIt's not insane. People want to know whether free software package X is a good alternative to the proprietary version. If it isn't, the fact that it's "good enough on its merits" is irrelevant. If they don't think proprietary software is intrinsically evil, then the free/proprietary distinction is irrelevant to them too. In what way do you find Inkscape to outpace e.g. Figma? That would be interesting to hear.
- sfriedr 5y agoThe free/proprietary distinction is only irrelevant for small-ish projects, on the order of a few months, where "good" is a one-dimensional measure in terms of features the application has: The risk of the software maintaining company being bankrupt in this timespan is low. A typical mid-level employee at a company might be very happy with such tools, especially because they are usually new & shiny too. Now imagine you are part of a team that wants to solve BIG problem, over a LONG timescale. Suddenly the picture becomes more nuanced as software features aren't the only thing that matters anymore. Would you really want to make the success of your project dependent on a third-party software company whose objectives aren't aligned with yours and that can take the tools you use away from you on a whim? FOSS makes a very strong point there. The interface may not make you cry and melt your eyes with shiny buttons, but you can be sure that years down the road the software will still be there and you can read your old files no matter what, as the file formats are open. You can depend on the software, and,.more importantly, you can assess and proactively mitigate the failure modes in advance! (E.g. the tex files from the 90s that you can find on some researchers website can still be compiled today; I imagine the entire research community would be significantly hindered if they would have to deal with the zoo of formats of proprietary software, rtf, doc, docx etc. In this sense FOSS can even act as the catalyst for establishing a standard, as is the case for tex files in domains of science.) Though I agree that for image editing specifically, typically projects are probably not longer than you few months, so in this you case I imagine you could go without issues with the flow of new and proprietary software.
- teleforce 5y agoI really think that the future is Local-First software and FOSS can greatly benefit from the new paradigm [1]. With Local-First software the cloud is just the natural extension for backup and collaboration (real-time or offline) not the sole repository for the data. [1]Local-first software You own your data, in spite of the cloud: https://www.inkandswitch.com/local-first/ https://www.inkandswitch.com/local-first/
- makeitdouble 5y agoThe concept looks fine, but was there resistance from users to have local apps talk to cloud resources in the first place ? It looks to me like it’s just describing the situation from a few years ago, but as a pre-packaged concept. I understand the current situation as a result from evolving business models, that lead to better profits when the control is taken away from the user and they have to get into subscriptions for continuous use. Basically the Adobe CS story. This manifesto doesn’t touch the business aspect at all, so I’m not sure what to take from it.
- teleforce 5y agoCoincidentally, currently there are ongoing discussions on how to utilize Git outside of the software engineering field. In particular, this is small anecdotal case study on how a calendar booking/rental system can work with Git [1]. For me this is a wonderful example of application for Local-First software albeit a simple one. [1]Ask HN: Why hasn't Git been adopted outside of software engineering? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31408544 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31408544
- throwaway290 5y agoOnce you have your centralized cloud service integrated, you have ongoing support costs so you must charge subscription instead of letting your users fully own the software. The only acceptable paradigm in my view is local-first with P2P collaboration options.
- redox99 5y agoI don't agree that this thing about moving to the browser is currently relevant outside of the drawing software like figma and equivalents. I don't see NLE, 3D suites, DAWs and many more moving anytime soon to the browser. Maybe photo editors like photoshop? But even that isn't there yet. And to be honest the only FOSS content creation software that actually competes at the professional level (i.e not just simple edits) with proprietary tools is Blender: As in, would people use this software, if all the (currently proprietary) alternatives were also FOSS? But inkscape doesn't need to compete. So I don't think it's getting left behind in the dust. I'm sure too that most inkscape users would much rather have a lot other improvements, than moving to the web.
- easrng 5y agoI would still use inkscape, it's way faster and lighter and though it crashes sometimes, it doesn't corrupt files like Illustrator. It also has (IMO) a simpler interface that's somewhat more discoverable than Illustrator but not by much.
- jjoonathan 5y ago> it's way faster Does Inkscape have GPU rendering yet or does it still slog down on anything more complicated than a minimalist icon?
- easrng 5y agoI think it does software rendering and there's some tearing while you zoom but it opens much faster and is more responsive than Illustrator.
- philipswood 5y agoHave you had a look at Penpot? https://penpot.app/ https://penpot.app/ From the same team as Taiga: https://www.taiga.io/ https://www.taiga.io/
- randomsearch 5y agoSome people speculate whether the rise of SaaS is a response to FOSS, which made it difficult to monetise software development. I’ve certainly begun to question my previous automatic assumption that FOSS is a good thing in the long term. The good news for FOSS is that hosting costs just keep getting cheaper, so providing free SaaS is increasingly feasible. There’s also the “third way” of FOSS with a hosted option available. Wordpress is a good example of that. If deploying such projects on the cloud eventually becomes trivial, then you could imagine a FOSS desktop in the future might have a cloud component (or be entirely remotely hosted). That might sound odd, but consider you still need to buy hardware to run your FOSS on, so renting that hardware instead isn’t a great leap.
- Mordisquitos 5y agoWordpress is an example of that for the simple reason that it is a CMS, which by its very nature implies it works in a server-client fashion. Of course Wordpress can be run as SaaS or self-hosted–it is software that needs to be hosted to serve its purpose. On the other hand, editing vector graphics has no intrinsic need to be hosted. Just because a cloud-based FOSS desktop in the future could be imagined doesn't make it a reasonable idea. What would be the point, other than massively increasing complexity and points of failure in terms of reliability and security?
- randomsearch 5y agoLots of points, but the most obvious one is with SaaS you can deploy a single version of software, which makes it orders off magnitude less difficult to maintain.
- Mordisquitos 5y agoI don't understand that argument. I sometimes use Inkscape but I never have more than a single version deployed on my device. Also, I don't think I'm putting any pressure on the maintainers if I were to insist on never updating from an older version. Snarkiness aside, being able to "deploy a single version of software" is itself incompatible with the ability to self-host, making it a moot point for FOSS (let alone for FOSS that has no practical reason to be SaaS in the first place).
- thefz 5y ago> The design space has been very rapidly moving towards online I think the opposite will eventually be true, a browser is no space for complex documents. > Even a lot of the big name proprietary tools are finding themselves becoming rapidly obsolete in a world where people want to IM a link and just have it reflect the latest version rather than attaching files back and forth. O365 has worked like this for years and it works well.
- aembleton 5y ago> a browser is no space for complex documents. Why not? What UX paradigms can you do in a desktop that can't be done in a browser?
- aliswe 5y agoVirtually all FOSS projects grind to a halt with regards to basic features as soon as they gain traction. The old userbase wants to keep the UX, others want to revamp, yet others want some other kind of pivot. The real pivot window is before you gain traction, unfortunately.
- Gigachad 5y agoThis seems accurate. Reminds me of libre office which has a settings page to pick between 5 different toolbar UIs. I have got to the point where I don’t want to be customising my toolbar. I just want the default one and I want the default one to be the best UI. While the default on LO hasn’t progressed in 20 years.
- las_balas_tres 5y agoDo you ever think a project like Blender will end up like this. I don't think there is anything remotely similar to it online and I doubt there ever will be.
- Gigachad 5y agoI think it will when the web becomes powerful and efficient enough to run such a tool in the browser. I don't think its there yet but I'd expect it will be eventually.
- victornomad 5y agoDo you know Penpot? https://penpot.app https://penpot.app Its like, sketch/figma online, collaborative and open source. Its not at the same level of Figma but its pretty good!
- GiovanniP 5y ago> The design space has been very rapidly moving towards online, live collaboration tools TeXmacs has an online collaboration tool, although as far as I know it is still experimental :-)
- pibechorro 5y agoI avoid all of what you mentioned like the plauge.
- thebeardisred 5y agoOne thing to look at (which I'm very intrigued by) is https://graphite.rs https://graphite.rs As a proof of concept about the possibility of a design tool with the potential to share information in this way it's intriguing. I'll also add that a major pain point of FL/OSS tools for me is that so many of them HEAVILY depend on local file descriptors which makes remote storage access a PITA.
- prokoudine 5y ago> The design space has been very rapidly moving towards online, live collaboration tools like Figma, Sketch, Adobe XD, etc and FOSS just has no answer for this market. Oh, but it does: https://penpot.app/ https://penpot.app/