5 ms·
This was bad. Notice how little time the driver has to react. At 8:05, everything is going well. Straight road, no obstacles ahead. At 8:06, the car has veered
by Animats 5y ago
This was bad. Notice how little time the driver has to react. At 8:05, everything is going well. Straight road, no obstacles ahead. At 8:06, the car has veered into opposing traffic. So the driver had about 1 second to react to Tesla's mistakes.
Now look at 2:51 .. 2:54, where the driver is distracted from the road for 3 seconds while operating the touchscreen interface. If the operator had been using the touchscreen in the same way at 8:06, there would have been a crash.
This demonstrates a few things:
* One fixed forward facing camera is not enough in rainy conditions at night. Humans will move their head a little in that situation to disambiguate raindrops and windshield dirt from distant lights.
* The system seems to identify oncoming vehicles at night by recognizing two headlights. If reflections or rain on the windshield or additional lights confuse that pattern, the oncoming vehicle is not recognized.
* Failure to recognize an obstacle seems to be treated as a no-obstacle condition.
- jakogut 5y ago> One forward facing camera is not enough in rainy conditions at night. Indeed, I wonder if that single camera is even binocular, or if they're using something like motion parallax to compute depth? The obvious problem with a single camera is that if it's degraded by dirt, debris, water, etc. you have no other input to fall back on. > The system seems to identify oncoming vehicles at night by recognizing two headlights. This seems untenable. I often see drivers with a headlight out, or even more commonly, driving at dusk or even night with their headlights completely off. Also, what about motorcycles?
- disillusioned 5y agoThere are three forward-facing cameras, each with a different depth of field, which I would _hope_ it can use as binocular vision, but this still doesn't solve for this exact problem when looking sideways! The single B-pillar-mounted cam, in my mind, cannot POSSIBLY be capable of, say, looking around a bush at an intersection of a side street connecting to a large, fast arterial road. Again, humans move their heads around the bush, they'll creep forward and then _lean_ forward to get a view around it, without having to extend the nose of the vehicle into the perpendicular traffic. The car simply does not have the sensors to be able to replicate this functionality. It has a single camera in the B-pillar for perpendicular vision. That's it. In a position fixed BEHIND THE DRIVER'S HEAD. I cannot fathom how that will ever work for these cases.
- Sohcahtoa82 5y ago> * Failure to recognize an obstacle seems to be treated as a no-obstacle condition. I'm not sure how else this would work. Do you mean the system may see that there's an obstacle, but doesn't know what it is, so it ignores it? If that's the case, then fixing it is nearly an impossibility. Certainly you wouldn't want to slam the brakes for a plastic bag floating in the wind, but if every obstacle is treated the same, that's what you'll end up doing. But if you try to build a system that can make a decision on every kind of obstacle, it's an extremely exhaustive list.
- michaelmrose 5y agoWe saw a similar behavior in the self driving car that hit the person crossing the road at night in Arizona. It first recognized the obstacle far enough away to safely avoid hitting the person but it effectively couldn't decide what was in front of it or indeed if something was in front of it at all. Presumably because it spent a large portion of the time in what we would describe in a human being as a state of mild confusion it didn't slow down or react in such instances and it struck the person it had recognized from a substantial distance going 40mph and killed them. Same as this car would have killed its driver. Regulators shouldn't allow a car on the public roads that might cross the center line and murder a family who didn't get a say in the other drivers choice of vehicle even if said car on average kills fewer people because if we demand better we'll get it. There is too much money to be made for the avenue to be ignored. It seems to me that superior instrumentation could tell the difference between a plastic bag in the wind. It should be required until they can prove they can do it like a human being on vision alone.
- kaba0 5y ago> even if said car on average kills fewer people That is only based on butchered up statistics. You would get very good statistics with a goddamn robot vacuum on a motorway, because it is a relatively uneventful driving environment. Guess where people will take over the wheel? In dangerous situations, basically self-filtering any negatives from the statistics. Very convenient.
- 5y ago
- KptMarchewa 5y agoThey claim to have three forward facing cameras.
- Animats 5y agoThey claim to have three forward facing cameras. The forward-facing cameras are all in one module at the rear view mirror location. They just have different fields of view.[1] So they don't get any multiple point of view or stereo benefits. [1] https://themotordigest.com/how-many-cameras-does-a-tesla-have/#camera-2-3-and-4-forward-cameras https://themotordigest.com/how-many-cameras-does-a-tesla-hav...
- disdi 5y ago>At 8:05, everything is going well. Straight road, no obstacles ahead. At 8:06, the car has veered into opposing traffic. I am not sure even if the incoming car was detected. Looking at dashboard screen, it appears after driver took control.
- HWR_14 5y ago> Notice how little time the driver has to react. At 8:05, everything is going well. Straight road, no obstacles ahead. At 8:06, the car has veered into opposing traffic. So the driver had about 1 second to react to Tesla's mistakes. Also note the feedback to react. The car did something unexpected that pulled the wheel from his hands. Would the driver have reacted as quickly to the car continuing in the same path when suddenly the motion needed to change?