3 ms·
> The thing that killed the momentum then is the same thing that still kills it - card transaction fees. If only there were some permissionless internet paymen
by sneak 5y ago
> The thing that killed the momentum then is the same thing that still kills it - card transaction fees.
If only there were some permissionless internet payments system that has near-zero fees and realtime settlement that works across borders and has frictionless setup.
The real problem is not the market or the technology, it's that the state wishes to surveil and ultimately exercise veto over all payments in society. Lightning payments solve this perfectly and could across the whole web but it's illegal in the US to "transmit money" without doing all sorts of market-killing, expensive customer intrusion and surveillance (and buying expensive licenses in every state).
There's nothing technically stopping a browser extension from letting you anonymously pay a penny per request or something in one click to pass a paywall. It's just the state's incessant hunger to want 100% transaction surveillance and veto.
- zozbot234 5y ago> near-zero fees and realtime settlement Yeah, I'm pretty sure that's not a thing. Bitcoin transactions can easily cost tens of dollars each, and Lightning balances are ultimately settled via Bitcoin.
- sneak 5y agoYou're incorrect. This is the reason Lightning exists and the problem it solves. Payment channels are a little complex so it's common for people to not understand them, but they do indeed solve this problem completely.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoThere are plenty of alternatives outside of BTC but lightning works. In EU there are also free and instant bank transfers. CC payments can be reversed though (which is a cons in my mind, I don't understand why merchants should lose the money by default in case of a dispute).
- SirSourdough 5y agoBecause the impact that a fraudulent seller has on an individual is generally going to be much higher than the impact a fraudulent buyer has on an entire business. Sellers can price in and insure themselves against fraud. The protections offered by CCs are that insurance for consumers.
- MacsHeadroom 5y agoSolana transactions cost thousands of a cent and settle in 30ms. Which, incidentally, is why it's the blockchain with the second highest number of users. Basically free and instant transactions enables seamless integration with the web.
- latchkey 5y ago... when it is working. [1] https://www.theblockcrypto.com/linked/144639/solana-restarted-after-seven-hour-outage-caused-by-surge-of-transactions https://www.theblockcrypto.com/linked/144639/solana-restarte... [2] https://u.today/solana-network-goes-offline-again-now-ddos-attack-may-be-reason https://u.today/solana-network-goes-offline-again-now-ddos-a...
- rglullis 5y agoIf it goes down for hours every month, it is not a blockchain.
- sneak 5y agoLast I looked, you can't run a solana p2p node behind NAT. Instant showstopper for me.
- doomroot 5y agoMy guess is you haven’t used bitcoin a while. You could easily get away with paying 1sat/vbyte (< $1 for a typical transaction) for over 2 years now. While the 2nd part of your statement is on the surface true, it misses the point. You can gets hundreds of thousands of transactions out of a channel without ever closing it. Batching on-chain transactions is now easier than ever so you can close and rebalance hundreds of channels cheaply. You can very easily do automatic swaps between onchain and lightning channel balances. You can be the counter party to either side of these transactions depending on if you need inbound or outbound channel liquidity. These transactions can also be easily batched allowing you to unlock liquidity where you need it for a fraction of the price of a single spend bitcoin transaction. There is still a long way to go to scale bitcoin to billions of users while keeping the blockchain accessible to all. For further interesting scaling solutions in the works checkout. - cross input signature aggregation: A way to super charge batching. - channel factories: a way for a lightning channel to be trustlessly owned by multiple parties. - MuSig: multisig that is indistinguishable from a single signer transaction. - federated chaumian mints: a way to do privacy preserving custodial wallets. - drive chains/space chains: a bitcoin merged mined side chain. - eltoo: new lightning channel upgrade that cuts the space complexity of channels from O(n) to O(1). - covenants congestion control: allows a sender to commit to spend while the receiver gets to choose when to receiver. Exchange withdrawals during high demand times while a customer can wait for a lower demand time to fully receive the coins. Happy to answer any questions on these.
- Stevvo 5y agoI highly recommend you go watch Rick Falkvinge's videos on Lightning Network. They are a little old, but everything in them stands true to this day.
- rchaud 5y agoI'd rather a link to a commercially available software that does this. If I'm a business considering alternative payment methods, I need a vendor's quote, not a lecture about how transaction settlement works.
- mschuster91 5y ago> The real problem is not the market or the technology, it's that the state wishes to surveil and ultimately exercise veto over all payments in society. With anything cryptocoin, everyone on the planet can now analyze where my money flows to and from. That's decidedly worse than governments which need court orders to do so.
- ur-whale 5y ago> With anything cryptocoin everyone on the planet can now analyze where my money flows to and from I don't believe this is correct for Monero, ZCash, and anything based on mimblewimble (BEAM, Grin).
- mschuster91 5y agoThe DHS has been able to track Monero since at least 2020 [1]. Basically, as long as you have an in and a likely out, governments can do statistic analysis to determine payment flows. [1] https://de.cointelegraph.com/news/privacy-coins-no-more-ciphertrace-files-patents-for-tracing-monero-transactions https://de.cointelegraph.com/news/privacy-coins-no-more-ciph...
- krageon 5y agoThis is a corporate piece essentially informed by the company itself outlining they can do so. Who knows if it is true? The fact of the matter is if your argument is going to be "Yeah, I'm pretty sure this is it" (which is what you are proposing), that is not proof. It's a strong hunch.
- yobbo 5y ago> If only there were some permissionless internet payments Card fees are consequences of their pricing decisions, not marginal cost of transactions. And, the reason they have "pricing power" is the size/market position of their networks. > browser extension from letting you anonymously pay a penny per request Of course, and there is no need for crypto currencies. Paypal could have implemented this for twenty years.
- alwayslikethis 5y agoI'm not sure how you would go about being anonymous if you already gave them all of your bank info and IDs. Monero is the only payment method I would consider to be most likely anonymous. It has very low transaction fees (<0.001%) and completes a translaction in about 20 minutes.
- fullstackchris 5y agoI don't want to be that guy... but I'm going to be that guy. Check out nano: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nano_(cryptocurrency) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nano_(cryptocurrency) Granted it is a cryptocurrency, but it is feeless and ~1 second confirmation. I too thought it sounded like magic when I first heard of it. Also, the browser extension you wish for exists, it's called Coil: https://coil.com/ https://coil.com/ but it simply doesn't have enough buy-in to work. The real problem with microtransactions has nothing to do about some bigwig execs or some deep state preventing it crap, it's simply that EVERYONE has to buy into it for it to work properly.
- sneak 5y agoWhat's to stop a sybil spam attack?
- puchatek 5y agoWhen it's not being spammed into a standstill, Solana is a potential candidate that could facilitate micropayments in a trustless fashion. I'm not completely sure but the new Solana Pay might be a step in that direction