3 ms·
It wasn't a guaranteed 20% APY. APY for defi protocols are constantly in flux and change based off how much money it makes and how many people are providing liq
by charcircuit 5y ago
It wasn't a guaranteed 20% APY. APY for defi protocols are constantly in flux and change based off how much money it makes and how many people are providing liquidity. APY is typically calculated per block and is based off how much everyone made in that block. It doesn't mean that it will be able to keep up that rate for a year. For a time Anchor was able to make more than enough to pay out 20% APY and it built a fund to pay out when it didn't make enough. There wasn't enough demand for Anchor to support a 20% APY so they were lowering the target over time while the previous profit made up a portion of what was being paid out.
>Where would that money come from?
The money came from staking rewards from tokens people deposited as collateral and from interest on loans people took out against the collateral they deposited.
>it is just a Ponzi scheme
Anchor itself was not a Ponzi scheme. You could withdraw your investment at any time. Your money wasn't paying out other people's returns.
- codedokode 5y agoThank you for clarification, but I still don't get this part: > and from interest on loans people took out against the collateral they deposited To be able to pay out 20% interest rate on deposits you need to issue loans at higher rate. But who would take such a loan when they can go to a traditional bank? Furthermore, the borrower needs to provide a collateral. Money cannot appear out of nowhere. There should be somebody buying something, like products or services (not just cryptotokens). Or at least a reasonable expectation of someone buying them.
- charcircuit 5y ago>To be able to pay out 20% interest rate on deposits you need to issue loans at higher rate. No, as I mentioned part of that 20% comes from staking rewards. I also missed that there is also a small liquidation fee that contributes to what gets paid out. >But who would take such a loan when they can go to a traditional bank? Because you can instantly get the loan. Because you get paid in ANC for borrowing. This ANC can be sold to help offset the interest. 10% Anchor's protocol fees are used to buy ANC which is distributed to people staking ANC which incentivizes a demand for ANC. At times you would make more in the ANC rewards than what you had to pay in interest.
- mstipetic 5y agoYou are all insane, how is that not a Ponzi scheme
- charcircuit 5y agoBecause people were speculating on the growth of the project.
- mstipetic 5y agoWhy do you keep referring to them as projects, why not call them schemes which is much more apt
- charcircuit 5y agoA scheme is a plan. Saying just that trivializes the massive amount of work creating a community, creating websites, working on the distributed system itself, doing the marketing, creating smart contracts, getting the smart contracts auditted, setting up bug bounties, writing documentation, moderating the community, creating tools for visualizing the blockchain or other stats, creating various other dapps, etc. Pretty much everything worked on is open source too. You can find it on github. I don't go around calling Linux a scheme, or emacs a scheme, or blender a scheme.
- mstipetic 5y agoMadoff also did all those things. Every time I look into one of those “projects” it either depends on money coming in or other parts of the crypto system growing. Stop fucking lying to people, and especially don’t compare it to something like Linux. So much wasted effort for nothing
- charcircuit 5y ago>Every time I look into one of those “projects” it either depends on money coming in or other parts of the crypto system growing Can you please explain what you are talking about. There are a lot of different projects that are related to cryptocurrency. I think we are talking past each other. >Stop fucking lying to people What lie did I tell? I have been trying my best to explain how things work because I have been looking into how it functions over the past fwe days. >and especially don’t compare it to something like Linux I was just picking open source projects which have a community built around them.
- oefrha 5y ago> But who would take such a loan when they can go to a traditional bank? It’s not like people generally take out these loans to put into productive use. They put them into even riskier and scammier crypto get-rich-quick schemes.